Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you should not allow your dog to chase squirrels?

208 replies

lillypond75 · 01/04/2021 20:38

Because it causes distress to a wild animal! I said to my friend to put their dog on a lead and she looked at me like I was mad. Apparently it's fine as their dog is unlikely to catch it, but that's hardly the point imo.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 02/04/2021 07:35

You’re arguing about one animal being prevented from doing what nature intended in order that another animal can do... what nature intended!
Dogs weren’t born wearing collar and leads. They are massively over bred, under exercised, left in isolation for hours on end. If a dog is found roaming the streets it’s locked up or worse, put down. If squirrels can be allowed to live their best lives free from being chased by dogs, then dogs should also be allowed to live their best lives and not be tethered to a lead.
Let’s hear it for dogs! I

InTheNightWeWillWish · 02/04/2021 07:33

I personally find the whole red squirrels- no way, grey squirrels- crack on mentality very disturbing. To the squirrels it makes no difference, they feel the same pain and emotions regardless of colour.

Grey squirrels are an invasive, non-native species. They are not suitable for our ecosystem, which is why they have almost eradicated our native red squirrels and can do untold damage to trees. You can get non-native species that are not invasive but when a non-native species takes over the balance in the ecosystem it can have devastating effects. Including for other wildlife. Not every critter should be protected just because it feels pain. Invasive non-native species pose a massive risk to biodiversity and habitat loss.

In rivers we had the white clawed crayfish which is a rare U.K. species. There are a number of non-native invasive crayfish, including the American signal crayfish which is the one having the biggest impact on white clawed crayfish populations. American signal crayfish eat young white clawed crayfish if they are in the same space, they also carry plague and infect the older populations of crayfish. In large quantities, American signal crayfish can burrow into the banks of the river causing sedimentation of the river, collapse of the river bank. This will then have negative effects on all other river ecology - invertebrates, fish, voles. The American signal crayfish does not care about the pain it causes white clawed crayfish or the devastation it can cause on the system as a whole. There are so many invasive non-native species impacting our environment.

picknmix1984 · 02/04/2021 07:19

I presume you mean all types of squirrels. I'm not fussed with grey squirrels but she's too old to catch them now. Reds I would never let her chase.

AvocadosBeforeMortgages · 02/04/2021 07:04

[quote CuthbertDibbleandGrubb]@AvocadosBeforeMortgages whilst I agree with you about grey squirrels and they are the only species I would advocate a cull of, I don't think dogs should be encouraged or condoned to chase after them. There are other animals a dog could then be chasing and frightening, so its a matter of good training not to be chasing things.[/quote]
In my local urban park, what other animals are there?

Pigeons, seagulls, waterfowl - he has no interest
Hedgehogs - we occasionally see them in the summer at dusk but he's avoided them like the plague after discovering that sniffing one in an investigative manner and discovering spikes hurt his nose
Foxes - I presume, based on the turds, but we've never seen one
Rats - but no one would whine about those being killed either.

I can assure you that this is no haven for rare furry wildlife. It's full of students and 20-somethings drinking and having picnics. Sometimes there are used needles. A rural idyll it ain't.

CuthbertDibbleandGrubb · 02/04/2021 06:55

@AvocadosBeforeMortgages whilst I agree with you about grey squirrels and they are the only species I would advocate a cull of, I don't think dogs should be encouraged or condoned to chase after them. There are other animals a dog could then be chasing and frightening, so its a matter of good training not to be chasing things.

AvocadosBeforeMortgages · 02/04/2021 06:27

Grey squirrels are vermin - an invasive species. I let DDog chase them in the local park - he's a terrier and so hard wired to chase anything small and furry.

Despite having a top speed of 24 miles an hour (when slightly younger, yes, we measured!) he's never caught one because he has no technique and I suspect he slightly slows down when he gets a bit too close because he doesn't really want to catch one, he just likes the thrill of the chase. Even the particularly thick squirrel that doubled back on itself avoided his jaws.

The worst he's ever actually achieved is interrupting a pair of Chinese tourists who were trying to take pictures of the bushy tailed rats.

No way I'd let him off lead near livestock though, and there's no ground nesting birds in our park. It's so urban that the skills required to walk there are basically dodging picnics and learning not to eat litter, not avoiding wildlife.

SmeleanorSmellstrop · 02/04/2021 00:15

Instead of complaining to your friends, why not do something productive and set up a counselling group for those poor traumatised squirrels to work through their emotions post-being chased?? And then afterwards maybe set up another for all the dogs that feel they've lost their sense of purpose from not being allowed to chase squirrels?

firedog · 02/04/2021 00:09

Bells. On collar. If squirrels still don't run away then ...

Itsamess8456 · 01/04/2021 23:59

I have that dog 😩

My dog is usually incredibly well behaved, sloppy and sleepy. However, if she sees a squirrel-it's as if she has taken squirrel amphetamine.

She was off lead (has good recall) in a woodland area and caught 2 squirrels in approx 6 mins. I was beyond shocked. I did keep her on a lead for a while but then bought a huge load bell for her collar and that stopped any squirrel catching.

I went out last week with her and she emerged from the bushes with another squirrel.

The groundsman was chatting with me when we saw her and he was really encouraging of her catching them! He said they were overrun with grey squirrels and they were causing loads of damage.

I don't think I can go through the trauma as I can still hear the squirrel death squeaks in my sleep.

She is back on the lead now

NoSquirrels · 01/04/2021 23:36

@N51BU

Sounds like there's a lot of very irresponsible dog owners on here with dogs that are not under control in public. No wonder I've seen so many posts about sheep being attacked
My dog has a particular squirrel bark - she’s obsessed by squirrels.

She’s indifferent to sheep. I keep her on lead around livestock just in case, though.

She’s a friend to cats, and bored by birds.

A rat, mouse, vole or other small furry would be very exciting.

A sheep and a squirrel are not at all alike.

Newfluff · 01/04/2021 23:07

[quote Bluebird2021]**@Newfluff* This is 'whataboutery' the behaviour in other situations does not justify behaviour in a different one*

pfffttt....i'm right though....and you don't like that so you try and brush it off as a made up word designed to TRY and shut people up.TRY[/quote]
Crack on and justify it how you want

Bluebird2021 · 01/04/2021 23:03

I've always kept my dog on a lead, even out on remote walks.

this thread has encouraged me to start thinking about a bit of off lead walking...or squirrel chasing...doubt he would catch one. Need to double check on recall first then its game on!

Bluebird2021 · 01/04/2021 23:00

@Newfluff This is 'whataboutery' the behaviour in other situations does not justify behaviour in a different one

pfffttt....i'm right though....and you don't like that so you try and brush it off as a made up word designed to TRY and shut people up.TRY

JackieTheFart · 01/04/2021 22:52

Owners should have control of their dogs for sure, but surely it's instinct for a prey animal to chase a rodent?

Stellaris22 · 01/04/2021 22:51

Owners of dogs that chase the odd squirrel (natural behaviour) are not the same as owners who allow their dogs to attack livestock.

Most owners know their dogs and wouldn't let them harm wildlife or be uncontrollable around livestock.

Squirrels are vermin, and I see no difference between them and rats.

I wouldn't own a cat because I couldn't control it killing wild birds, but most people are fine with that while being outspoken about dogs natural prey drive.

Fastforwardtospring · 01/04/2021 22:50

Ha, try telling this to DDog, she’s on constant squirrel surveillance in our garden, she’ll never catch one, not unless she realises she needs to be more stealth and not make a bloody racket barking as she chases them. TBF the squirrels do not learn, they’re back within the hour.

firedog · 01/04/2021 22:40

OP. Some dogs like labs will almost always dive into a stream. Instinct and breed. My dog wouldn't go near.
Some dogs scavenge food or bins or picnics. My dog will sniff around but wouldn't do anything else.
Some dogs would snatch food from strangers. My dog won't.
Ive not trained this; it's his breed.
He will however chase or hunt the scent of a rat or fox or squirrel for hours if allowed.
Viewing dogs as fully domestic is misleading. They are trained animals.

Respectmyauthoritah · 01/04/2021 22:39

I let my idiot Spaniel chase them because he's far more likely to do damage to himself than the squirrel. If I had a dog that could possible catch and kill a squirrel then I'd be far more cautious.

To all the posters saying they don't let their children chase pigeons, how do you feel about seagulls? The gulls where I live are like a street gang and terrorise pedestrians and business owners on a regular basis. I'd let the dc chase them if they felt brave enough.

Iremembertheelderlykoreanlady · 01/04/2021 22:38

Grey squirrels are vermin.

Would you have the same issue with a dog chasing rats?

My dog chases squirrels. Has never caught one and no I really don't care about the "distress" it causes. See previous vermin comment

sunflowersandbuttercups · 01/04/2021 22:37

But dogs and cats are domestic animals so how can they be part of the food chain or order of nature?

Because evolution.

They still have their instincts even though they live in nice warm houses with humans.

Branleuse · 01/04/2021 22:37

I dont think they should be encouraged to chase, i think predatory behaviour should be discouraged in a pet, but if it doesnt catch it then i dont think its a big deal.

Stellaris22 · 01/04/2021 22:33

@N51BU I think you are getting confused about the difference between livestock and vermin.

Chasing squirrels (which are quick and agile) is not the same as attacking livestock. I don't think dogs should be off lead around livestock, but spying the odd squirrel on a walk is different.

moochingtothepub · 01/04/2021 22:32

My dog regularly catches them but doesn't hurt them, it's instinct - he doesn't chase anything else

firedog · 01/04/2021 22:32

[quote lillypond75]@firedog

But dogs and cats are domestic animals so how can they be part of the food chain or order of nature?

Dogs are supposed to be under control by law. Cats not so much. How is a dog that attacks a squirrel and cannot he recalled by owner under control?

The wild bird on the other hand is total different imo. [/quote]
No. They are domesticated animals. Not domestic animals. Dogs didn't start by living in centrally heated semis with cosy beds and warm coats and food every 13 hours in a nice bowl. They can be trained to a great degree. BUT
They are still animals. With animal instincts.

Elai1978 · 01/04/2021 22:29

Hunting animals with dogs is illegal in England (and probably the UK)

Not entirely, it’s legal to hunt rabbits and rats using dogs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread