Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you should not allow your dog to chase squirrels?

208 replies

lillypond75 · 01/04/2021 20:38

Because it causes distress to a wild animal! I said to my friend to put their dog on a lead and she looked at me like I was mad. Apparently it's fine as their dog is unlikely to catch it, but that's hardly the point imo.

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 02/04/2021 13:49

The thing is they appear from no-where and the dog starts chasing them. You can't keep a dog on the lead all the time just in case a squirrel appears surely ?

MaryLennoxsScowl · 02/04/2021 13:44

I used to have a dog that killed crows and rats but not sheep, chickens or cats, so the idea that a dog that chases squirrels is a danger to all livestock is just wrong. If that dog can tell the difference between a crow and a chicken then any dog can tell the difference between a squirrel and a sheep. And, despite what some particularly hysterical posters on the thread about the seal were arguing, none of them confuse squirrels/seals with children either.

XenoBitch · 02/04/2021 13:24

My greyhound has caught two squirrels in her almost 11 years, but I don't encourage it. I can only think that they were old/poorly for a dog to catch them.

Susie477 · 02/04/2021 13:20

Grey squirrels are absolutely fair game. They are an invasive species which have displaced native red squirrels. Our ex-lurcher used to love chasing the little buggers. He didn’t catch many, as he never quite mastered climbing trees, bless him. Grin

sunflowersandbuttercups · 02/04/2021 13:15

However I can guarentee there are thousands more dead squirells as a result of cars.Every single day I drive past roadkill on my way to favourite dog walks.Squashed squirrels,flattened badgers,eviscerated hedgehogs.Carnage caused by humans and their cars

Well, exactly. This morning my beagle didn't kill anything, but I live rurally and can't go a day without seeing a squashed squirrel, fox, rabbit, badger, pheasant, bird or deer on the roads.

Humans do FAR more damage than any dog will ever do.

Alsohuman · 02/04/2021 13:13

@MissyB1

Dogs will be dogs. My dog like most has zero chance of catching one. I’m not keeping her on the lead all the time just in case she sees a squirrel.
Same. She hasn’t got a hope in hell of catching one and the squirrel isn’t too traumatised to sit up a tree thumbing its nose at her.
LibertyMole · 02/04/2021 13:12

Most people don’t live in the countryside and exercise their dogs in parks or similar. All this ground nesting birds stuff is not relevant to most dog owners because they don’t go to those places.

Part of what dogs do is catch vermin. If I owned a terrier, part of the point would be to catch vermin. All the people objecting to it, would you just let mice or rats live in your house?

Snugglepiggy · 02/04/2021 13:09

It's all getting a bit bonkers out there with the anti dog brigade now.Our have great recall.But are never allowed of lead anywhere near livestock.However in the depths of woods yes they do go off lead.And occasionally get excited and dash after a grey squirrel.Fat chance of ever catching one though .They are generally far to quick and wily.
However I can guarentee there are thousands more dead squirells as a result of cars.Every single day I drive past roadkill on my way to favourite dog walks.Squashed squirrels,flattened badgers,eviscerated hedgehogs.Carnage caused by humans and their cars.That sickens me far more tbh.

Shinyletsbebadguys · 02/04/2021 13:01

Grin This reminds me of a park nearby us where its a well known off lead (and on) area for dogs. Its pretty much always been and everywhere else has a tacit agreement to stay on lead which mostly people respect.

This particular park has lots of trees in which reside the bolshiest pack of squirrels that take great pleasure in playing games with the dogs. I swear if squirrels laugh they spend most of the time winding the dogs up and then laughing themselves silly.

The most common is to jump down and sit in one of the clearings and wait until 2 or 3 dogs start to chase then they promptly run up a tree and sit on one of the lower branches watching the dogs gather below. I swear I saw a squirrel giggling when a boxer and a spaniel ran into each other trying to get the squirrel.

I don't allow ddog to chase anything (partly because she would come off worse....worst guard dog in the whole world and partly because frankly it would encourage DC to do the same and no pigeon or squirrel needs to deal with 5 year old DS2 barrelling towards them yelling that he wants to hug them he says hug he means headlock )

I don't think dogs should be encouraged but frankly I've never seen a squirrel that can't thoroughly look after themselves.

My DM has maintained for years the squirrels are up to something....the older I get the more I think she may be onto somethingGrin sinister furry beggers.

Stellaris22 · 02/04/2021 12:55

Mines a basset, and it is so interesting to see all that breeding display itself in their behaviour.

Once she's seen a squirrel in a tree it is incredibly difficult to get her attention away from that squirrel. She also does the typical basset behaviour (again, part of the breed) and will loudly bark at the squirrel.

In all honesty I wouldn't even try to train her not to, it's her breed and wouldn't be right.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 02/04/2021 12:51

I was reminded of this thread this morning.

I was out with my dog in the woods - he was on a lead as there are fields with sheep/newborn lambs surrounding the woodland. He spotted a squirrel and it honestly took me two minutes of searching to find what he was looking at!

He was frozen, staring. He was on lead so I wasn't worried about him dashing off, but I called him, shouted, whistled and encouraged him with food and he didn't move, turn his head or look at me once. All his focus was on that squirrel and if he'd been off the lead he'd have been off and gone and there'd have been NOTHING I could do about it.

He's a beagle and he's been bred to hunt. It's what they do. All the training in the world can't undo thousands of years of breeding and evolution.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 02/04/2021 12:51

That was meant to be Grin, not Gin....

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 02/04/2021 12:50

@Elai1978

Despite having a top speed of 24 miles an hour (when slightly younger, yes, we measured!) he's never caught one because he has no technique

You need a sighthound of some description, fastest ones are good for 45mph and can spot a rabbit sized animal at half a mile. Unless the squirrel has a nearby tree it’s screwed. Ours is rarely off lead as generally their recall is not great and non-existent if the aforementioned small furry appears. On the plus side we never, ever, get cats in our garden - they’re not suicidal.

We have a sighthound - greyhound x whippet x saluki. Adores chasing cats, but squirrels trigger some kind of existential crisis and she just freezes and starts shaking like a leaf Gin It's not fear, I think it's more like total overload due to having insufficient brain capacity for all the feelings.
vdbfamily · 02/04/2021 12:50

We have a rescue dog (Podenco) and they are bred to chase rabbits. We walk him on lead as if he sees a rabbit he will be gone, but he is allowed free access to our garden and parents garden and had caught 3 squirrels in the time we have had him. He is now 13 so the squirrels are likely to outwit him. I love animals but would see squirrels in same category as rats and can't get too distressed at a dead one occasionally. The one I found in his bed with him one day had no visible injuries so I assume probably died of fright or a quick broken neck.

VeganVeal · 02/04/2021 12:41

Grey squirrels are vermin and destroy the woodland. The forestry commission were paying people to cull them, wasnt very successful so are now looking at contraception methods instead. Unlikely a dog would catch a squirrel, however we found it useful to have one around to finish off any ones that werent a clean kill when my uncle used to manage local woodland

www.airgunmagazine.co.uk/news/potential-for-airgunners-to-earn-s-from-squirrel-culling/

Wingedharpy · 02/04/2021 12:34

I don't have a dog but I do have a husband with a long brush and a gift for making hissing noises as squirrels hang on his bird feeders, enjoying the buffet.

I've never trained him in recall and I'm not willing to keep him on a lead.
He's getting on a bit now and I think he needs the exercise.

Stellaris22 · 02/04/2021 11:49

With mine (scent hound) the squirrels are wise to her, and if anything, get immense enjoyment out of tormenting my dog.

They'll jump down pretty much in front of her (while she's watching them) and run towards the nearest tree while she chases and barks.

I have no sympathy for squirrels, they know what they can get away with.

AvocadosBeforeMortgages · 02/04/2021 10:17

@Elai1978

Despite having a top speed of 24 miles an hour (when slightly younger, yes, we measured!) he's never caught one because he has no technique

You need a sighthound of some description, fastest ones are good for 45mph and can spot a rabbit sized animal at half a mile. Unless the squirrel has a nearby tree it’s screwed. Ours is rarely off lead as generally their recall is not great and non-existent if the aforementioned small furry appears. On the plus side we never, ever, get cats in our garden - they’re not suicidal.

I should have mentioned that he's a Jack Russell cross with very short legs! He makes the most of what he's got Grin

One of the neighbourhood cats was once found in the garden early one morning - a scene reminiscent of Wacky Races ensued as the cat ricocheted around the garden (high walls) with DDog in hot pursuit. Eventually the cat realised that there's a gap by the gate it could fit through but DDog can't.

It's been spotted skulking along the walls a couple of times, but hasn't been stupid enough to enter the garden itself again.

Elai1978 · 02/04/2021 10:06

Despite having a top speed of 24 miles an hour (when slightly younger, yes, we measured!) he's never caught one because he has no technique

You need a sighthound of some description, fastest ones are good for 45mph and can spot a rabbit sized animal at half a mile. Unless the squirrel has a nearby tree it’s screwed. Ours is rarely off lead as generally their recall is not great and non-existent if the aforementioned small furry appears. On the plus side we never, ever, get cats in our garden - they’re not suicidal.

LakieLady · 02/04/2021 08:42

@BlatheringOn

Poppycat: "dream on, they've no chance of catching them".

You've obviously never owned a lurcher! That's why I have to make lots of noise to warn the squirrels.

Or a whippet. I was out walking with a friend and his whippet suddenly took off like a bullet and leaped at the trunk of a tree.

We thought the dog had gone mad until she turned round and we saw the squirrel in her mouth. She was so quick that he didn't even have time to call her.

She then appeared to decide she was actually a gundog, came back and presented him with the aforementioned squirrel, now an ex-squirrel. She was the sweetest-tempered dog in all other respects, but hugely quick and efficient when it came to rabbits. I don't think she ever got another squirrel though.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 02/04/2021 08:30

I don't think dogs should be encouraged or condoned to chase after them. There are other animals a dog could then be chasing and frightening, so its a matter of good training not to be chasing things.

You can't train the instinct out of a dog. Yes, dogs should be trained in good recall but it's never going to be foolproof - because they're living beings, not robots.

GrumpyMiddleAgedWoman · 02/04/2021 07:55

What @InTheNightWeWillWish said.

I'd never encourage my dogs to chase squirrels, but they have caught a few over the years (one was in the middle of the path as we rounded a corner and the elderly dog, who is well past chasing anything, nabbed it). I don't get too distraught: as PP have said, grey squirrels do a lot of damage and have driven out native reds, as well as infecting them with a disease that kills them (but not the greys).

Invasive species are a massive problem.

JeffTheOracle · 02/04/2021 07:53

My dog loves chasing things so I let her. She likes to make the birds fly off the playing field I walk her on. She loves chasing squirrels and I wouldn't be that fussed if she caught one. I would actively encourage her to kill rats if they were in my garden for example. Filthy creatures. She's a terrier, it's what she's been bred for and as long as she finished them off herself I wouldn't care.

People asking how you tell the difference between red or grey squirrels - unless you live in a very few select areas of the UK you won't see a red because the greys have driven them out. They are invasive vermin

She will never ever have the opportunity to chase livestock - always on lead without exception if it's even remotely possible livestock could be present

CuthbertDibbleandGrubb · 02/04/2021 07:42

@InTheNightWeWillWish in wanting to see the end of grey squirrels I do not advocate anything other than a humane cull. I do want to see gin traps, disease or other methods of reducing the numbers of grey squirrels.

@AvocadosBeforeMortgages I had made no presumption about your local park, common or place a dog is walked and my comments apply in all places dogs go, I suggest.

AvocadosBeforeMortgages · 02/04/2021 07:38

@Soontobe60

You’re arguing about one animal being prevented from doing what nature intended in order that another animal can do... what nature intended! Dogs weren’t born wearing collar and leads. They are massively over bred, under exercised, left in isolation for hours on end. If a dog is found roaming the streets it’s locked up or worse, put down. If squirrels can be allowed to live their best lives free from being chased by dogs, then dogs should also be allowed to live their best lives and not be tethered to a lead. Let’s hear it for dogs! I
A vegan once told me that keeping pets was a form of slavery.

I pointed out to her that I kept trying to set the 'slave' free at the park each day, but he keeps following me home again.

Perhaps the dog has Stockholm syndrome?

Swipe left for the next trending thread