Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you should not allow your dog to chase squirrels?

208 replies

lillypond75 · 01/04/2021 20:38

Because it causes distress to a wild animal! I said to my friend to put their dog on a lead and she looked at me like I was mad. Apparently it's fine as their dog is unlikely to catch it, but that's hardly the point imo.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Winterscomingagain · 13/11/2022 19:10

The dog is out of control in that situation and that's obviously a huge danger. She also shouldn't expect the dog will never catch it as my large tabby cat has killed several grey squirrels. Will her dog react in the same way to a cat?
There are quite a lot of mink around a local pond now and dog owners have had to be warned about how dangerous they can be.

Podlesterong · 13/11/2022 18:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

mrspharm · 14/03/2022 16:27

A child is a savage until a responsible owner("parent")tames it and brings it under control. Do not use the excuse that a dog can't be controlled.KEEP THEM ON SHORT LEADS AT ALL TIMES IN PUBLIC SPACES!!The sight of a dog catching a squirrel in a public place is totally unacceptable and would traumatise most people as well as being a despicable and cruel act.

PresentingPercy · 03/04/2021 14:54

I’ve had several. Rarely did they get a bird. Over 25 years of ownership. The male cats really couldn’t be bothered. The one female cat we had did catch mice and shrews and one day, yes, a squirrel. We don’t have cats now and our dog died 18 months ago. He caught a chicken that had escaped and was on our road. Ditto a duck. And the odd pheasant and rabbit. But we live in the countryside and all of these are plentiful. The duck survived and went back to the pond. Foxes got all the ducks in the end. As they would if they found a chicken wandering about.

poppycat10 · 03/04/2021 14:13

I'm always surprised by all the claims that cats kill birds. Birds can fly. Cats cannot. Cats are well fed by their owners.

When I see a cat watching the birds I just think "dream on mate".

They may get the odd injured bird, but in general I think most birds are killed by other birds. Or, in my locality, by flying into windows.

Disclaimer: I've never had a cat.

PresentingPercy · 03/04/2021 14:03

What would you do with a rat in your house?

PresentingPercy · 03/04/2021 14:02

It’s a squirrel though. Not a human being!

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 03/04/2021 10:51

@IDreamOfLogCabins

I saw a dog catch and kill one too - owner wasn't bothered in the slightest Confused
Same as a lot of the people on this thread about all the wildlife their cats have killed, then...

Most seem to be pissed off about the mess caused by all the blood and guts, but not bothered about the distress caused to the animal (because that's 'just what cats do').

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3213297-to-be-pissed-off-with-my-cat

PresentingPercy · 03/04/2021 10:30

I’ve owned male cats who were incapable of catching anything. My dog wasn’t bothered about squirrels. However we need a cull of squirrels. Sadly most people don’t understand how to protect our broadleaved woodlands. They are damaged by an over population of squirrels. So there has to be action. Most dogs are fine.

Inthevirtualwaitingroom · 03/04/2021 08:43

the squirrel runs up a tree!
game over

sunflowersandbuttercups · 03/04/2021 08:42

@IDreamOfLogCabins

I saw a dog catch and kill one too - owner wasn't bothered in the slightest Confused
Why would you want the owner to be bothered? Dogs are prey animals - it's normal.

You don't see this level of hysteria emotion around cats who kill birds and mice for fun.

LST · 03/04/2021 08:36

@Stellaris22

I have yet to see any threads that harass cat owners in the same way as dog owners. If people have an issue with animals being killed why isn't the hate being directed there? Or is it ok for cat owners to allow their pets to regularly (and successfully) hunt wildlife?
You are kidding? Have you never seen a cat shit thread? Most dog bashing threads turn into 'but cats though' as well!
Stellaris22 · 03/04/2021 08:32

I have yet to see any threads that harass cat owners in the same way as dog owners. If people have an issue with animals being killed why isn't the hate being directed there? Or is it ok for cat owners to allow their pets to regularly (and successfully) hunt wildlife?

noblegreenk · 03/04/2021 00:32

My old dog used to chase squirrels but she wasn't very fast so it didn't worry me. I now have a greyhound and if she saw a squirrel when off lead she would stand a good chance of catching it! This is one reason I don't let her off lead at parks.

IDreamOfLogCabins · 03/04/2021 00:16

I saw a dog catch and kill one too - owner wasn't bothered in the slightest Confused

BlueSkyBlinking · 03/04/2021 00:03

Lots of beef on this squirrel thread.

I’m mostly amused by the poster who thinks every single mumsnetter lives on the English coastal path. Stopped reading about p.4.

My dog (also a lurcher) caught a squirrel once, to my horror. I don’t like them chasing anything because the prey drive isn’t great to encourage. Anyway, the squirrel squeaked, and my dog seemed to get a sudden flash of empathy and dropped it gently. She still chases them but never seriously. It looks more like mutual banter, tbh.

Elsiebear90 · 02/04/2021 23:30

What is it with MN and people expecting dogs to be like robots? It’s an animal, it can be trained, but you cannot completely eradicate all of its natural instincts or restrict its behaviour (never allowing them off lead presumably even in your back garden) to prevent this ever happening. To try and do so would be cruel.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 02/04/2021 23:08

@Kerravon34

I have a beagle too! I refer you to the two posts where I put links which tell you, in great detail, how to train a dog with a strong prey hunting instinct. This is your responsibility. Educate yourself.
But why would you get a beagle and then train it not to do what it's been bred for thousand of years do so?

It seems utterly ridiculous to me Hmm

SkedaddIe · 02/04/2021 23:07

@Kerravon34 what on earth are you talking about? Your post is a long strawman argument. The wild dogs you described are essentially abandoned and neglected domesticated animals, 'real wild dogs' are still called wolves. And there are plenty of species of other undomesticated Canis which are happy in the wild such as jackals and coyotes. And what's telling is that those animals mostly avoid humans.... Foxes, rats, and pigeons are animals that actually like to share our habitats with us.

And you topped it off with the classic 'other countries' comment. Lol... ofc... why not throw in a bit of hand wringing xenophobia to top off the self righteousness.

I think people keep pets because they're unwilling or incapable of interacting with other humans or the wilderness. Yes we've done it for thousands of years but that doesn't magically make it 'right'

I eat meat so I'm far from perfect, but I'd never do the mental gymnastics of pretending a chicken had a better life to make me feel better about it being on my plate. It tastes good and that is all.

People don't keep pets for the good of the animals and 'nature' we do it for the good of people and that is all.

Stellaris22 · 02/04/2021 21:52

The squirrels we encounter are not scared in the slightest, they seem to get great enjoyment from mocking and taunting my dog. They regularly sit on a branch just to annoy her.

They are vermin and an invasive species that cause damage.

Stellaris22 · 02/04/2021 21:49

I have a basset and there's no way I would train her to not have a hunting instinct, to me that is quite cruel to force a dog to act against its natural instincts and what it's been bred to do.

That doesn't mean she isn't well trained, and it's completely different to dogs that attack livestock.

She's never killed anything in her life, as opposed to cats that kill and injure wild birds and mammals. Do we harass cat owners the same way dog owners get treated? Should we force all cats to stay indoors so they can't be natural predators?

Kerravon34 · 02/04/2021 21:42

I have a beagle too! I refer you to the two posts where I put links which tell you, in great detail, how to train a dog with a strong prey hunting instinct. This is your responsibility. Educate yourself.

Kerravon34 · 02/04/2021 21:40

@SkedaddIe

Are people really surprised that a carnivorous animal has carnivorous instincts. Domesticating animals full stop is morally wrong.

A few squirrels getting chased up trees is the very thin edge of that wedge.

Think about living near a pack of undomesticated, wild dogs. Would it be pleasant? Would the dogs be as happy as pet dogs? Have you much experience of genuinely wild dogs? They would be getting run over on the roads, seen as a menace. Think about never putting a lead on a dog,, never any commands, unless you live miles from a road, it won’t be pretty. The squirrels I have seen killed are not just chased up trees, they are ripped apart. You can hear them scream. Even if just scared, they become disorientated and they abandon their dreys and the baby’s die a slow cruel death.Also, as I said your dog can die from diseases carried by the squirrel and can receive serious injury. . Humans cannot catch these diseases. It’s about protecting the dog. Would you let your dog run wild and be hit by a car? If we left dogs to live in the wild and never used a lead or commands, this would happen non stop. That’s morally wrong in my book. I volunteer for an animal charity and these animals benefit hugely by being domesticated. The sheep we rescue are constantly harassed by the same bad owners dogs. A dog with a strong prey instinct sees absolutely no difference between a lamb and a rodent or a pet cat. It’s the owners responsibility to train their dog. As to the idea that training dogs is morally wrong, have you visited a country where the dogs are left to be wild? Dogs enjoy human companionship, and being domesticated as they have done for thousands of years. They are intelligent and hugely enjoy being trained. They become bored otherwise.
Robin233 · 02/04/2021 21:31

My brothers dog got one - it killed it.

sunflowersandbuttercups · 02/04/2021 21:20

I love my dog and I would never let him terrorise and attack a squirrel. I have seen them torn apart by dogs while the owner does nothing. I trained my dog, so I don’t believe you can’t stop them.

I have a beagle. How do you propose you train a hunting hound not to hunt?

Swipe left for the next trending thread