Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you keep that you’d inherited 10k a secret from your husband?

612 replies

MoonBaby1 · 21/03/2021 17:57

In a generally happy, good relationship?
I have and it feels a bit weird but also really freeing. It’s been a tough few years money wise but we’re both in a position where we’re earning and working.

We both contribute to the household bills about 2/3 him and 1/3 me (I’m still part time as youngest is 2 yrs) and he’s in charge of all food and drink bills.

Just having this money up my sleeve has been very freeing. I’m not going mad but I bought the dc some strawberries and ribena from the shop and he saw me disposing of the rubbish in the outside bins with raised eyebrows. I want to sneak some other bits bought on amazon (socks, some chocolate and a scarf) into the house but feel guilty. If I own up he won’t condone this kind of spending and will insist it gets saved. I just want to enjoy about £500 over the year on little things and save the rest. AIBU?

OP posts:
ChelleMum85 · 22/03/2021 19:43

@MoonBaby1

We’ve really had a hard couple of years and he’s better at the food shop than me. He’d let me put some cheap chocolate on the Aldi list but buying anything from a village shop is frowned upon.
Are you aware that this behaviour is financial abuse and it's illegal?

If you're not allowed to buy food or drink without permission, you're in a controlling, abusive relationship.

I think you need to seek help from CAB, Family and Friends...possibly Women's Aide, too.

wusbanker · 22/03/2021 19:33

What's the point you paying for strawberries out of your secret money and letting him see the rubbish? He'll just assume he's paid for it so he may as well have Confused

silverbubbles · 22/03/2021 19:32

If you are not telling us that the reason you husband keeps such a close eye on your spending is because you have run up debt and money burns a hole in your pocket or that you are in debt then YABU.

If this is not the case then he sounds like a real kill joy and you should keep the money for yourself.

He is bound to find out though - then what will happen?

QuornSausagesAreTheDevilsPenis · 22/03/2021 19:27

@MoonBaby1

In a generally happy, good relationship? I have and it feels a bit weird but also really freeing. It’s been a tough few years money wise but we’re both in a position where we’re earning and working.

We both contribute to the household bills about 2/3 him and 1/3 me (I’m still part time as youngest is 2 yrs) and he’s in charge of all food and drink bills.

Just having this money up my sleeve has been very freeing. I’m not going mad but I bought the dc some strawberries and ribena from the shop and he saw me disposing of the rubbish in the outside bins with raised eyebrows. I want to sneak some other bits bought on amazon (socks, some chocolate and a scarf) into the house but feel guilty. If I own up he won’t condone this kind of spending and will insist it gets saved. I just want to enjoy about £500 over the year on little things and save the rest. AIBU?

That you have to keep the little things like Ribena and socks secret does not say to me you have a "generally good relationship". I wouldn't even consider hiding this from my husband and would be disappointed to say the very least if he kept it from me.

I'll read the rest of your posts now op.

JackieTheFart · 22/03/2021 19:21

For £10k I might not tell him, because that would clear about half the personal debt we have (all in my name as I’ve been the only one working for a long time). But I wouldn’t be squirrelling it like you are.

I probably would though and he’d agree to pay stuff off. He’s generally amenable to my money ideas.

suggestionsplease1 · 22/03/2021 19:17

You're in a marriage, you have to work together as a team, not against each other which seems to be what you may on the verge of doing.

I think OH is getting a hard time considering the sheer lack of information posters have - there could be a lot of debts that need paid off, OP might have had a £5 a day coffee and sweets from the shop habit - £150 a month, which was making life really hard on a very low income etc etc. Granted that is pure speculation, but so is the speculation about the OH!

If I was busting a gut trying to get my family out of debt and to a better place and my OH decided to conceal something that might help us get to that position I'd be very disappointed - and that old cliche that gets trotted out on mumsnet - if the sexes were reversed what would people think then?

Wife trying hard to get her family finances back on track, she's presently breadwinner, her and her husband both aware that he's a bit frivolous and have mutually decided that she takes care of things like shopping as she can get it in within budget so they can plan for nice things in the future. He gets a lump sum and squirrels it away, moaning to his friends that his wife always raises an eyebrow when he gets something a bit frivolous so he has to keep it secret....that would be a ltb for a lot of posters I reckon.

The fact that someone feels guilty or knows their partner will raise an eyebrow doesn't inherently mean it is an abusive or controlling situation, although is some circumstances it can certainly help build the picture if that is going on. However sometimes it can also be an indication that a partner knows their OH is trying really hard to get the family financial situation in order and they're holding back a sum to themselves that might help with those larger financial goals. That would make a lot of people feel guilty too.

BigFatLiar · 22/03/2021 19:16

You are obviously being made to feel guilt for buying stuff so you are then hiding it.

Theres no indication she's being made to feel guilty just that she obviously does feel guilty.
Nothing to say that he wouldn't be fine with it, She presumed he'd be annoyed without actually giving him the chance to express an opinion.

BatleyTownswomensGuild · 22/03/2021 19:14

None of this sounds healthy to me. I can't believe you are fretting about buying Ribena!

In answer to your question, I wouldn't hesitate to tell my husband. We are very open with each other when it comes to money. Our marriage is a partnership.

Everydayyoungmum · 22/03/2021 19:11

My nan use to say that you should keep an account with "run away" money in, that your partner/ husband, doesn't about. That way if for whatever reason you need to pack everything and leave you can. Just food for thought.

I personally would take out what you feel appropriate and put it into a bank account. I would then tell him that you inherited the money.
If you don't want to give him any then don't, thats up to you it your money.

BigFatLiar · 22/03/2021 19:11

on the other hand, they're on the breadline and she's buying secret treats for herself and the kids when they're barely covering basics

His job to cover the basics.
She's the fun mum he's the controlling bad dad.

Time they swapped roles.

singledadstu · 22/03/2021 19:11

It doesn’t sound right to me personally. I would have been gutted if my late wife had hid money from me as I never hid it from her .. two way street .
However, I don’t like the fact you seem worried about spending on treats etc . It doesn’t sound like you’ve got equal footing

hbcrfvr · 22/03/2021 19:10

This is a difficult one. I think the biggest issue here first and foremost is why would anyone need to 'hide' money from their partner? You are obviously being made to feel guilt for buying stuff so you are then hiding it. Thats not healthy. Even if one partner brings in more than the other you are a unit and both earners for the household. To stop one or the other from making 'judgement' about who spends what, why don't you decide on a monthly budget for each of you so you can buy stuff you want without asking him then you both have some freedom to make buying decisions that you individually want to make...good luck it sounds like you need to press 'reset' on the way you work your money out together instead of gong down the slippery slope of deceit xx

jbee1979 · 22/03/2021 19:09

I can't vote, because I want to say you aren't being unreasonable - but I don't know why you're skint. I also am skint, so no judgement! I budget our money really carefully, and my husband saves what he can. We're skint because child, childcare, loss of earnings when I went part time, family bereavement and a really bad job decision on my behalf. It won't be this way forever. If we were skint because either of us had been frivolous with money, that would be the decider. If we're both managing as a family and separately, I'd tell him but squirrel it away for a deposit for a house. If he was bad with money, I'd keep it to myself, buy some shoes and put the rest away as an escape fund should it be necessary. If I was bad with money, I'd pay off my secret debt, and give him the rest for the family savings. I'd be really annoyed if he was the one who inherited and I was choosing between food for us or shoes for the child, because £500 over the next 12 months is £40 a month that could help us both sleep better ❤️

Youmakemewannashout · 22/03/2021 19:08

I find it quite sad that you don’t want to share your good fortune with your husband. If the tables were turned would he let you know? Maybe it’s time to re-evaluate the ‘my money/ his money’ aspect of your partnership and instead consider that you chose to be together so should work as a team.

BigFatLiar · 22/03/2021 19:07

If things are back on the up you should take over the budget as he's got you through the tough times and now you can be seen as the good guy with the extras.

I think he also needs an escape fund as if things don't stay on the up then you may be buying the little extras that lead to debt and after struggling he may want out if that happens.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/03/2021 19:05

however i do agfree that you're lack of a voice is worrying - you aren't obliged to do as you're told like one of the kids. if you want to save 9.5k and enjoy the rest, it isn't his place to permit you

SleepingStandingUp · 22/03/2021 19:03

@Lifestyleinlondon88

I’d say you were unreasonable until you said he raised his eyebrows at strawberries - now I can see why you’ve done it. Have fun OP!
on the other hand, they're on the breadline and she's buying secret treats for herself and the kids when they're barely covering basics
LowlandLucky · 22/03/2021 19:03

Don't you have an escape fund ? If you don't you need to keep the money secret.

Izzy24 · 22/03/2021 19:03

Our finances are completely separate. We share bills apart from one thing which I pay as it is totally non-essential. I would expect we would each keep the inheritance but probably tell the other and maybe treat to a holiday or whatever with part of it.

But we don’t have any children. I think in your situation this makes a huge difference because your finances are already shared.

The problem, as others have said, is your lack of voice.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/03/2021 19:01

If you have both 0 free money at the end to the extent that he's raising eyebrows over fruit and a drink then you stowing 10k to spend on you and the kids does not suggest a healthy dynamic.

If you want an escape fund, then tell him you inherited 5k. Suggest you spend a few £200 each on replacing essentials where needed, put some into savings and use a small set budget for treats occasionally.

sobby · 22/03/2021 18:57

"He let you "

We’ve really had a hard couple of years and he’s better at the food shop than me. He’d let me put some cheap chocolate on the Aldi list but buying anything from a village shop is frowned upon.

sobby · 22/03/2021 18:55

'"He let you "?

Overcastcloudy · 22/03/2021 18:53

If you value your marriage, you will not keep the £10k secret. You may not value it over your financial freedom - that may well be the right choice for you.

He MAY be controlling. I would hope that you two came up with the 'Aldi budget' together and that you both agreed to stick to it until X time had passed or X amount had been saved or repaid.

At the moment, you are buying treats and he has no idea how. He thinks that you are breaking the budget that you both agreed to. (At least I hope you did.) I think he has a right to be irritated about that.

The only line that worried me was, He's better at the food shopping. Huh? What do you mean? It's not rocket science; it's a food shop. Would you spend more? Is that justified and financially sound? Do you disagree with his budget? It's your home and your money, too (because you are married and in this together). The budget for food needs to be agreed together, not imposed.

You both need to reconnect about finances.

theirishDH · 22/03/2021 18:49

Please consider whether it is a sign of other issues in the relationship. It sounds extremely unhealthy that you are hiding things from him. I would suggest that you consider getting relationship counselling.

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 22/03/2021 18:49

@ionlyasked

I think I would keep it secret, if my husband was so controlling. My mother always used to say you should have some money of your own stashed away. She called it your running away money
Sage advice that I agree with Every woman should have her own money, just in case money None of this we or family money guff. Your own stash. I was also given same advice and yes I have separate finances and just in case money There’s no we, no nonsense about being a family with shared finances. There’s no me in we