Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you keep that you’d inherited 10k a secret from your husband?

612 replies

MoonBaby1 · 21/03/2021 17:57

In a generally happy, good relationship?
I have and it feels a bit weird but also really freeing. It’s been a tough few years money wise but we’re both in a position where we’re earning and working.

We both contribute to the household bills about 2/3 him and 1/3 me (I’m still part time as youngest is 2 yrs) and he’s in charge of all food and drink bills.

Just having this money up my sleeve has been very freeing. I’m not going mad but I bought the dc some strawberries and ribena from the shop and he saw me disposing of the rubbish in the outside bins with raised eyebrows. I want to sneak some other bits bought on amazon (socks, some chocolate and a scarf) into the house but feel guilty. If I own up he won’t condone this kind of spending and will insist it gets saved. I just want to enjoy about £500 over the year on little things and save the rest. AIBU?

OP posts:
PersonaNonGarter · 22/03/2021 22:20

Do not tell him about the money.

sansou · 22/03/2021 22:14

Tell your DH & assuming there are no debts to pay off : -
1 - Spend £500 - £1K on whatever.
2 - Max YOUR pension contributions for this tax year.
3 - Remainder, if any, in a S & S ISA.
So, basically, you're investing 90% of it and you can still access the funds in your ISA in an emergency. You don't need professional advice to invest a sum less than £10K - there's plenty of internet finance articles advising just that as we approach a new tax year.

BigFatLiar · 22/03/2021 21:38

From the OP's posts....

We’re on the breadline. We don’t own a house and we do have to watch money.
They are luxuries at the moment and I worry it makes a mockery of his careful Aldi planning. I’m not a saint in this and neither is he.

Also she is going to tell him.

As he didn't know she had the extra cash, if he did see her dump the rubbish then from his view she was spending money they didn't have/couldn't afford.
No doubt for many Mumsnetters its abuse to expect your partner to stick to budget and not spend 'extras'. The children are also his so I'm sure getting extras would be something he'd like but instead he focuses on the rent and food.

Perhaps budgets are a waste of time for most, if you haven't got the cash stick it on the credit card.

He may be a bit strict with controls, better that than too lax unless you don't mind the debt. I think what worried OP was in the phrase 'I worry it makes a mockery of his careful Aldi planning' - not that he was financially abusive but that he'd think she was just taking the piss and not taking their financial situation seriously.

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 22/03/2021 21:28

Im also confused as you say he contributes 2/3 to bills and you 1/3 is that all your wages both of you put in just to cover bills or are you both left with some spending money after this ?

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 22/03/2021 21:26

Though to add we aren't rich but my dh wouldn't see strawberries for the kids as extravagant and are a staple in the fridge and socks the same ( obviously not in the fridge )

donewithitalltodayandxmas · 22/03/2021 21:23

Yes you should tell him
He shouldn't get to tell you what you spend it on ? But the again he is putting more in the pot than you at the moment but guess thats due to childcare
In my house we would have no secrets and we would discuss best way to spend to benefit out family

NoodleDoodle24 · 22/03/2021 21:15

No one knows the OPs circumstances. What if she is entirely frivolous and husband is keeping them out of debt? Yes it seems extreme but she seems comfortable in that he’s being super sensible.

I don’t think it’s a normal situation though. If there’s a specific goal to save for fair enough, if not then you need to have a word. I would maybe disclose 3k and keep the rest back!

caringcarer · 22/03/2021 21:12

He sounds very controlli g. The children can't have fruit and you.cant have docks? Does he expect you to walk around barefoot? You know it is madness OP. When my dh inherited a few thousand from his gran he told me and I asked what he would spend it on. He put it towards a new car as his old one was unreliable. I.inherited £26.8k from my Mum. I gave my 3 adult children £1k each, took DH for nice meal and put rest towards a btl. The income generated is put.inyo family money. Later this year I.will get lump sum on pension when I have 60th birthday. I am planning on taking DH to Australia to see Boxing Day Ash's cricket, Covid allowing travel. DH would never stop me buying fruit for children and activly.encoursgrs me to spend money on new clothes and stuff for myself as I don't buy much clothing. I feel I have enough clothes but If I wanted any I would just buy it. Fruit would be purchased routinely with shopping. I would pick.up.sockd either on Amazon or before Covid on high street. In your position I would be saving £8 k as FOF and spend £20 per week on fruit and Rubens for kids and a few treats for family. Once your 2 year old is at school I would.be going back.yo.work to get.own money.

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 22/03/2021 21:11

If you have to hide buying strawberries, socks and ribena no, I’d keep it hidden.

BillMasen · 22/03/2021 21:11

@suggestionsplease1

You're in a marriage, you have to work together as a team, not against each other which seems to be what you may on the verge of doing.

I think OH is getting a hard time considering the sheer lack of information posters have - there could be a lot of debts that need paid off, OP might have had a £5 a day coffee and sweets from the shop habit - £150 a month, which was making life really hard on a very low income etc etc. Granted that is pure speculation, but so is the speculation about the OH!

If I was busting a gut trying to get my family out of debt and to a better place and my OH decided to conceal something that might help us get to that position I'd be very disappointed - and that old cliche that gets trotted out on mumsnet - if the sexes were reversed what would people think then?

Wife trying hard to get her family finances back on track, she's presently breadwinner, her and her husband both aware that he's a bit frivolous and have mutually decided that she takes care of things like shopping as she can get it in within budget so they can plan for nice things in the future. He gets a lump sum and squirrels it away, moaning to his friends that his wife always raises an eyebrow when he gets something a bit frivolous so he has to keep it secret....that would be a ltb for a lot of posters I reckon.

The fact that someone feels guilty or knows their partner will raise an eyebrow doesn't inherently mean it is an abusive or controlling situation, although is some circumstances it can certainly help build the picture if that is going on. However sometimes it can also be an indication that a partner knows their OH is trying really hard to get the family financial situation in order and they're holding back a sum to themselves that might help with those larger financial goals. That would make a lot of people feel guilty too.

This is mumsnet though. It must be his fault, even if there’s incomplete information you must assume that.
Mother87 · 22/03/2021 21:03

Sounds like financial control/abuse as others have said - the 'covert' behaviour you feel you've had to use to hide everyday items from him, shouldn't be acceptible to you. You'll be needing that money towards your escape - but i've always been a believer in having 'fook-off' money IF at all possible...

tiredmum2468 · 22/03/2021 21:01

You probably need it for an escape fund if he doesn't like you buying ribena and strawberries!

Twoforthree · 22/03/2021 21:00

@Calmdown14

Your husband's attitude depends on how tight money actually is. If the food budget is £50 and going over that puts you into an overdraft then raising an eyebrow over spending a fiver of it on two items is totally understandable. If you have hundreds left over each month perhaps not. I can't really see how if you plan to save £9500 your husband can really object but will this actually be the case or do you have form for frittering? Personally I think if the tables were turned and it was an OP trying to eek out a food budget every week and to then found out the husband had a secret 10k the responses would be very different
If he's really got the families best interests at heart and money is as tight as you say, then telling him and insisting on the £500 for luxuries is a good compromise. He might actually be really pleased with this, as the other £9,500 will take a huge weight off his shoulders and he'll enjoy the extra treats more because of the back up money.

If he still moans, you ready do have a dh/marriage problem.

Yourcatisnotsorry · 22/03/2021 20:55

Everything about this is U. Either massive back story or he is incredibly controlling and your relationship is unhealthy. ‘Normal’ couples don’t hide inheritances from each other.

Chanjer · 22/03/2021 20:49

MiddleclassNet trundles on Hmm

cuparfull · 22/03/2021 20:45

I do feel many people on here have no idea of what having a really HARD time financially means.
It is not having access to overdrafts, not having a credit card as a fallback. Not having a credit history. Paying for day to day items in cash. Only ever buying cheap clothes or 2nd hand clothes. Its knowing where every penny is going....
It's dire having to mentally account for each and every penny spent to ensure never buying beyond what is NEEDED.
Having been in similar situation for a period it's just awful and if one partner is keeping the financial records/keeping it all together and its incumbent on both partners to cooperate in spending as little as possible.
We only hear one side of the story but it takes cooperation to drag yourselves out of the mire... painful experience from the 2008 financial crash!

waitingpatientlyforspring · 22/03/2021 20:33

I never would as we share all money. However my dh would never begrudge me buying any of those things.

Eowyn78 · 22/03/2021 20:30

@MoonBaby1

The thing is, he’s not financially abusive. He’s just bog standard tight Grin. Totally un materialistic which I admire and doesn’t buy himself new stuff either if he can help it.
Is he Northern? I was married to a Northerner and he was tight too. But then he found money for us to go on holidays etc. I'm a terrible spendaholic so I did trust him to make good financial decisions, which he did for the family. If this is the case it may be worth having that chat with him, telling him about the inheritance and deciding together what is the best thing to do. Investing it may be a good idea.
numberoneson · 22/03/2021 20:30

I'd never have hidden any inheritance from my late husband, but then I had every reason to adore, admire and trust him implicitly and he was the most generous-spirited person I ever knew. But I chose YANBU because your husband, despite you saying you had a tough two years financially, sounds like a controlling a-hole. If he's policing your shopping, then something's NOT " a generally happy, good relationship".

Fluffmum · 22/03/2021 20:13

I wouldn’t tell anyone to be honest.

Folklore9074 · 22/03/2021 19:57

I wouldn't keep it a secret but at the same time it would be my inheritance to do what I wanted with. I wouldn't feel I needed to put it in a joint account or report on what I was going to do with it in any way.

Sounds really odd to me that you'd be 'sneaking' fruit and drinks for your children. Perhaps you need a bit more frankness around money in your relationship.

Lanique · 22/03/2021 19:56

Of course I wouldn't want to hide it from dh. I was delighted to pay a very sizeable inheritance sum into our shared mortgage recently. I have kept 10 percent of it aside for myself to invest, he knows this and has no problem with it. But then I'm given free rein with our joint, and my own, finances.

hedgehoginthebag · 22/03/2021 19:52

I have no problem hiding my money from the hubster. Or hiding purchases. Its kind of a bit of a game between us. Especially when we downsized the house recently. Its amazing what you can shove under the bed ha ha

m0therofdragons · 22/03/2021 19:51

I can’t imagine being with a man who didn’t buy me my favourite chocolate and only allowed cheap stuff. I give my dc more choice than that. Even in the days money was tight no one would control my access to money that much.

When I inherited money I paid for a conservatory, car and bought myself a laptop. But my dh is lovely and I’m happy to share.

scubadive · 22/03/2021 19:45

Your marriage is a problem, why would he make you save it. Why dies he get to decide?

Is it because he’s the higher earner so he has the power? What about your unpaid work?

How on earth do you need to hide buying strawberries, ribena, socks and chocolate. What sort of dictatorship do you live under? What sort of budget do you normally have to manage on? Are you really so financially stretched?

The fact that you feel the need to hide you inheritance should set alarm bells ringing. This is not a healthy relationship.

Swipe left for the next trending thread