Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you keep that you’d inherited 10k a secret from your husband?

612 replies

MoonBaby1 · 21/03/2021 17:57

In a generally happy, good relationship?
I have and it feels a bit weird but also really freeing. It’s been a tough few years money wise but we’re both in a position where we’re earning and working.

We both contribute to the household bills about 2/3 him and 1/3 me (I’m still part time as youngest is 2 yrs) and he’s in charge of all food and drink bills.

Just having this money up my sleeve has been very freeing. I’m not going mad but I bought the dc some strawberries and ribena from the shop and he saw me disposing of the rubbish in the outside bins with raised eyebrows. I want to sneak some other bits bought on amazon (socks, some chocolate and a scarf) into the house but feel guilty. If I own up he won’t condone this kind of spending and will insist it gets saved. I just want to enjoy about £500 over the year on little things and save the rest. AIBU?

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 23/03/2021 12:44

But it's nice that the cut off point for extravagance for so many is shellfish rather than extra fruit

I doubt many experience the guilt of finding some coins down the back of the sofa/chairs and using it to by ice cream for the kids rather than put it in the gas/electricity meter.

blackcurrantjam · 23/03/2021 12:36

BillMasen
Yes for a man too. In fact often they do, much to the woman's suprise on divorce. Women are disproportionately affected economically by childbearing, caring and so on so yes, independent savings are a good idea.
Ideally this would actually all be transparent and above board and part of mutually agreed financial planning but unfortunately in cases where this is not the case, I think a security account for a woman is not a bad plan. And yes if a man is sacrificing career for childcare etc in a marriage, depending on the set up a small security fund would be a good idea too.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/03/2021 12:27

If OP had posted In addition to working FT whilst DH is part time due to child care, I do all the shopping (because frankly i'm better at it!). Money is REALLY tight, even with his recent pay rise its still tight. If he tells me, i'll put some own brand treats on, but that's all we can afford. So I come home and he's hiding rubbish in the bin - expensive fruit and sugary pop for the kids from the local shop which is SO expensive. I don't even know how he paid for it, we have that little money left over. aibu to worry he's put in on the credit card again or he's dipped into the kids meagre savings? He didn't mention it, just looked sheepish and walked off. i wonder what the answers would be?

Tell him if he wants to spend money like that he should work full time? He's a cocklodging CF? He's financially abusive if he's got secret money he's keeping from you?

DH's unclue died recently. He'd said before that he expected to get some inheritance but he's never mentioned. I mentioned it to my Mom and she said maybe he'd kept it aside as his "Fuck Off Fund". Is this ok?
Def LTB responses!!

Chanjer · 23/03/2021 12:23

Had a little chuckle when a pp said "it's not like you're sneaking them lobsters"

That's pretty much it. I personally couldn't imagine not being able to afford a lobster anytime I want, that pp must be on some hard times indeed, but I accept that I'm excessively privileged and don't assume that of everyone.

By the way I can't afford lobsters but you get my point

But it's nice that the cut off point for extravagance for so many is shellfish rather than extra fruit

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 23/03/2021 12:21

Having a budget is definitely controlling. No. Not necessarily. It’s controlling if one partner exerts decision making and control upon the other
It’s sensible and prudent to have a budget and grasp of ones finances. Having a budget is eminently sensible. Too many people waft by with an inadequate grasp of finances, credit cards,or finances

timeisnotaline · 23/03/2021 12:17

I think there are a few insightful comments on budgeting when money is truly tight. It’s not controlling to want to be able to pay your family’s bills. It might be the dh has gone a little too far but that experience does stick with you, and you want to protect against ever feeling like that again. hopefully, they can talk and agree.

BigFatLiar · 23/03/2021 12:14

[quote HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee]@Chanjer I think there’s a fundamentally deep chasm between them regard finances and their respective behaviours
I expect her husband feels exasperated by it also probably reticent and reluctant However I think his behaviour is controlling[/quote]
Having a budget is definitely controlling.

He should get rid of the budget and stop being so controlling perhaps he can celebrate his new financial freedom by buying himself some beer and whisky on the next shop.

I'd be totally beyond a raised eyebrow if after struggling together to get out a financial hole I found my partner had started sneakily spending again money we couldn't afford (he doesn't know she has the cash). I'd feel betrayed and that it had all been for nothing. For all we know he may be wanting to splash the cash on treats for the kids as well.

QuestionEverythingOrBeASheep · 23/03/2021 12:12

@MoonBaby1

We’ve really had a hard couple of years and he’s better at the food shop than me. He’d let me put some cheap chocolate on the Aldi list but buying anything from a village shop is frowned upon.
There seems to a control issue here. I'm sure you're aware of it. It does not sound healthy but I feel there may be a few more issues in the relationship, not mentioned here. I could be wrong of course.
HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 23/03/2021 12:09

Mn is tone deaf when it comes to poverty. The daily grind of poverty
A Complete inability to imagine the impact of a limited budget. As exhibited by protestations that one simply must have Ribena & strawberries

Only time mn claims to be thrifty is the one chicken feeds 15 people threads (inc making risotto,soup,a roast,sandwiches) on those threads people are positively bragging about their thrift

Chanjer · 23/03/2021 12:09

And there's people here pointing out that its man bashing and I don't really think it's that, or care, it's just a crazy lack of imagination

Probably a good sign for the countries state in general that so many people find this hard to imagine

SleepingStandingUp · 23/03/2021 12:06

@RavingAnnie

I wouldn't but my husband wouldn't question me if I wanted to buy socks, strawberries and Ribera. That seems controlling tbh.
how much disposable income do you have each month? how much is your food budget?
Chanjer · 23/03/2021 11:59

Fucking hell not eBay Grin *on what

Chanjer · 23/03/2021 11:58

My actual view on it is she should spend it on eBay she wants, if she wants to do that. I think inherited money should be separate from family money and it should be spent in accordance with what would have pleased the person who left it to you.

I just find it pretty amazing that people can't grasp that there are people in the UK to whom a fiver makes a big difference and that if that is your situation then yes it's unreasonable to spend money you can't afford

People making it sound like the DH have denied the children a balanced diet are projecting. The kitchen may be amply stocked with fresh fruit and vegetables that were budgeted for and already bought. It is possible for a few quid to be an extravagance not a bloody right

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 23/03/2021 11:50

@Chanjer I think there’s a fundamentally deep chasm between them regard finances and their respective behaviours
I expect her husband feels exasperated by it also probably reticent and reluctant However I think his behaviour is controlling

hahaohno · 23/03/2021 11:49

Op do you actually see the bills and outgoings and income? Why do you say he's better at the food shop? What do you kids eat if you're not allowed to buy fruit?

BigFatLiar · 23/03/2021 11:47

@Chanjer

Can that reluctance and reticence ever be, in your opinion, a justified feeling on behalf of the spender?
If she knows they're struggling (which she does) and also feels that the spend is actually an extravagance yet goes ahead and spends.
Chanjer · 23/03/2021 11:40

I can think of approximately 10,002 reasons that the OP might not want to tell her DH

Many other people who don't credit the OPs assessment of her own situation seem to be ignoring the 10,001 other possible reasons

BigFatLiar · 23/03/2021 11:36

@AryaStarkWolf

I don't know if you could call it a good and happy relationship if you feel like you need to hide 10 grand just so you can buy chocolate :/
I don't think she's all that happy. I think she resents being skint.

She was going to save most (which she believes is what her husband would do) but was also going to put some money aside to spend. She didn't even raise this with her husband so he hasn't had the chance to say it was a good or bad idea.

It doesn't bode well that she's buying stuff and sneaking it in while they're struggling. I'd be worried about what else she was buying and not saying.

Things may have started to look up for them but that doesn't necessarily mean blow the budget, it may take time for the benefits to filter through.

As you say not a great marriage when your hiding money from your partner and not a great marriage when you feel you can't trust your partner to stick to budget when you're struggling financially.

Chanjer · 23/03/2021 11:36

Can that reluctance and reticence ever be, in your opinion, a justified feeling on behalf of the spender?

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 23/03/2021 11:28

This thread has 2 camps. ⬅️That’s an inaccurate & superficial summation

It’s ok to be prudent and have good financial management
It’s not ok to be controlling and have another adult in a state of reluctance & reticence

Suzi888 · 23/03/2021 11:23

In your position YANBU.

AryaStarkWolf · 23/03/2021 11:22

I don't know if you could call it a good and happy relationship if you feel like you need to hide 10 grand just so you can buy chocolate :/

BillMasen · 23/03/2021 11:16

This thread has 2 camps

Those that understand there may be times when strict budgeting is needed, it’s not necessarily controlling, op could be seen as a bit frivolous and they understand the husbands reaction to what looked like op spending what they haven’t got.

And those who either have never known a tight budget and the concept doesn’t compute, or who must blame the man!

Birdcloud · 23/03/2021 11:15

What was the decision please?

BillMasen · 23/03/2021 11:12

@JanetPisahypocriticalC but they can’t well afford them. That’s the bloody point. I know people don’t read or understand threads but the op specifically says they’re on the breadline!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread