Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you keep that you’d inherited 10k a secret from your husband?

612 replies

MoonBaby1 · 21/03/2021 17:57

In a generally happy, good relationship?
I have and it feels a bit weird but also really freeing. It’s been a tough few years money wise but we’re both in a position where we’re earning and working.

We both contribute to the household bills about 2/3 him and 1/3 me (I’m still part time as youngest is 2 yrs) and he’s in charge of all food and drink bills.

Just having this money up my sleeve has been very freeing. I’m not going mad but I bought the dc some strawberries and ribena from the shop and he saw me disposing of the rubbish in the outside bins with raised eyebrows. I want to sneak some other bits bought on amazon (socks, some chocolate and a scarf) into the house but feel guilty. If I own up he won’t condone this kind of spending and will insist it gets saved. I just want to enjoy about £500 over the year on little things and save the rest. AIBU?

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 25/03/2021 07:54

@DreamingofDalyan what you describe is deceitful and totally unacceptable in a relationship, trust is fundamental. However the idea of suggesting to her that its alright for her to be deceitful and hide money away is wrong, it works both ways. They either trust each other or they don't. What came out from the post was she'd bought extras, been spotted and feels guilty, OH hasn't raised it, she just feels guilty because she knows he knows she's spending money she doesn't have. Perhaps she has form for hidden spending and running up debts and he has to find a way to pay them, who knows. If she'd simply said at the outset it may have saved him a lot of worry about where the money was coming from.

BigFatLiar · 25/03/2021 07:40

@Pumpkinstace

We were on the breadline once. We were close to getting evicted. I couldn't sleep with anxiety about it and was pregnant at the time.

My husband had £300 hidden away and didn't tell me.

One of the reasons I'm divorcing him.

They're skint and she has 10k stashed away

Time for him to divorce her?

DreamingofDalyan · 25/03/2021 04:00

Me now would say yes..keep it a secret and try and stash more away than he doesnt know about. As someone who is about to get divorced after 28 years.
When I got married I was in love trusted my husband obviously but very bloody stupidly let him control majority of finances as he was partner in accounting firm. I worked and gave him 1k a month towards mortgage bills etc. When I had our first child I left work in the hope that I would return when they started school. Well then 2nd child came along. I ended up staying at home until the youngest was 10. My husband did not want me to go back but by this stage he financially controlled everything. I got paid a weekly allowance for coffee. No matter what I said or did made no difference.
I then made enquiries and got my job back and loved having my own money. Wont go into it here but realised I wanted out.
I have since found out that my ex had been moving money out of joint account since we got married. Money I had inheritanted 20k he insisted he put in joint account...gone and I found out that the home we have lived in for 28 years that I thought was almost clear isnt ours. He changed mortgage to interest only without my knowledge and has paid no capital.
I am still in house with youngest but will need to sell it in 2 years to pay bank back. No equity in house as needs a lot of work which he refused to do. All that money that he has hidden and I have no idea where it is. My life is not exactly how I imagined it so now I would always advise any women to protect herself and stash some away. When you are in love its hard to think that you could ever be in a rubbish situation. If your marriage ends and if you haven't got one of the nice ones you could find your life upside down.
I know im cynical now but I thought I had the most amazing man ever. Kind honest caring...but what ive found out. Now I don't believe any man would tell their wife everything not at all and women are deluded if they think they do.
The money was given to you but from the sound of your description your husband is controlling about money and it will only get worse. I see a lot of myself in your story and all I can say is you have my sympathy x

Pumpkinstace · 25/03/2021 02:14

We were on the breadline once. We were close to getting evicted. I couldn't sleep with anxiety about it and was pregnant at the time.

My husband had £300 hidden away and didn't tell me.

One of the reasons I'm divorcing him.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/03/2021 01:55

think it appropriate for her to have enough money or the authority to decide to buy socks and strawberries well he's seen her with them and didn't ask where the money had come from or of she stole them so she clearly has access to money that he's aware of, they're just not meant to be spending it on treats.

BigFatLiar · 24/03/2021 21:39

Honestly, the fact that both op and her husband do not think it appropriate for her to have enough money or the authority to decide to buy socks and strawberries for her children speaks volumes.

@terrimom I don't think its the appropriateness of it that's the problem its that they simply don't have the money. (Well she does now but she hadn't told him and has let him believe that she's spending money they don't have). If she had said they needed socks or wanted strawberries the it could have been budgeted for. Perhaps you think its fine to let your partner believe you're running up debts. He's controlling the shopping budget because she thinks he's better at it and as they're strapped for cash someone has to keep an eye on it. By not telling him she has the cash and still spending it leaves him with he additional stress of worrying about where is it coming from.

terrimom · 24/03/2021 20:42

Honestly, the fact that both op and her husband do not think it appropriate for her to have enough money or the authority to decide to buy socks and strawberries for her children speaks volumes. Would any husband allow a wife to control the finances to that extent? And would it be considered healthy? Do you have access to any money of your own in the monthly budget? or do 100% of your earnings go to an account that only he controls the spending of? Is it his money is his money and your money is his money or is the money and spending decisions equally decided? It genuinely sounds terribly one sided if you are hiding fruit as an "unapproved" expense! It can be hard to see how inappropriate someone's behavior is when you are the one being controlled. Controlling individuals usually get that control in little steps like not allowing shopping for fruit and socks or not allowing any independent decisions about spending or what to do with your earnings or telling you they make better financial decisions so they will be in control. They will undermine your confidence in your ability to have autonomy in the relationship and in financial matters that should be shared decisions and you will start to agree and think that they are right to control everything. I would take a look and ask for an outside opinion of the entire relationship not just this one event.

billy1966 · 24/03/2021 09:47

In a relationship like that, definitely.

IM0GEN · 24/03/2021 09:47

@Candleabra

Your husband raises eyebrows at the children eating strawberries? Please don't fritter away you inheritance on perfectly reasonable household expenses. You may need it to escape your awful husband.
This.
WishICouldThinkOfAGoodName · 24/03/2021 09:46

Based on what you’ve said your husband sounds financially controlling and mean, therefore I’d definitely keep it a secret. Hell, I’d keep it a secret anyway, but I don’t think there’s anything wrong with having a little secret emergency fund.

BigFatLiar · 24/03/2021 08:53

@butterpuffed

Well, OP said on Sunday she thinks she'll tell him but not updated since then so maybe it's sorted.
Would be nice to know (nosey), perhaps just a wind up (I suspect much of MN is)
BigFatLiar · 24/03/2021 08:51

@Snog

Do you think he has secret money too?
Perhaps that's why things are so tight, they're both so busy building secret savings in case they need to split that they can't afford to live.
butterpuffed · 24/03/2021 08:09

Well, OP said on Sunday she thinks she'll tell him but not updated since then so maybe it's sorted.

Snog · 24/03/2021 08:08

Do you think he has secret money too?

WisnaeMe · 23/03/2021 23:29

OP already told her Husband about her inheritance 🌺

user1471538283 · 23/03/2021 21:01

Having an ex who spent everything and left us with nothing I would keep it but either in your own account or the children's. I would imagine your DH would be upset if he's struggling to manage and you've got £10k though

requitalissima · 23/03/2021 20:33

Of course keep it a secret. You'll never know what life brings, always important to have access to little cash.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/03/2021 20:11

@Nettie1964

Get out now. If you can't buy strawberries and chocolate without him bei g pissed off. I understand he might be nervous ad finacially insecure but that's how control starts. I know that was me. Normal people dont do this. If you spent it on excessive alcohol or scratch card maybe. Do you really want someone telling you what to buy or eat for your whole life? You could tell him and then see how he reacts. My partner made a list of how much I owed him!
Dear AIBU, came home and found DH hiding food rubbish in the bin, stuff he'd brought from the local expensive corner shop. He knows how tight money is and I buy everything we need on a v small budget. Aibu to wonder what else he's spending our tiny savings pot on?
Nettie1964 · 23/03/2021 20:02

Get out now. If you can't buy strawberries and chocolate without him bei g pissed off. I understand he might be nervous ad finacially insecure but that's how control starts. I know that was me. Normal people dont do this. If you spent it on excessive alcohol or scratch card maybe. Do you really want someone telling you what to buy or eat for your whole life? You could tell him and then see how he reacts. My partner made a list of how much I owed him!

grannieali · 23/03/2021 17:29

You should put your windfall or most of it, in an investment account and forfet about it until the invitable rainy day arrives.This is your personal FFF.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/03/2021 14:18

but buying fruit or the occasional Ribena for the children is not profligacy if every penny is accounted for because that's how they're keeping a balanced diet on the table and a roof over their heads then yes, extra expensive fruit and expensive pop IS. They're not saving up for a holiday to Hawai, op said they're on the breadline. And suddenly she's sneaking food into the bin and God knows what else. He's probably worried she's got a credit card or is dipping into the kids piggy banks!

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 23/03/2021 14:18

budgeting is important but buying fruit or the occasional Ribena for the children is not profligacy
You’re so missing the point. If as op says you’re on breadline every penny counts
Tesco Ribena £2.00 compared to the Value brand cordial 40p
£1.6 difference
That £1.6 could buy 20 fish fingers and tin of beans
So whilst for most folk when you’re solvent £2 is no big deal, literally every penny matters when you’re skint
The Ribena is comparatively costly

Growltiger22 · 23/03/2021 14:00

It all depends on the husband. If mine was as controlling as yours sounds, the inheritance would make a good basis for an escape fund. I understand that budgeting is important but buying fruit or the occasional Ribena for the children is not profligacy. Good luck.

Birdcloud · 23/03/2021 13:21

OP, a very useful message

Barcodes · 23/03/2021 12:58

@SleepingStandingUp

If OP had posted In addition to working FT whilst DH is part time due to child care, I do all the shopping (because frankly i'm better at it!). Money is REALLY tight, even with his recent pay rise its still tight. If he tells me, i'll put some own brand treats on, but that's all we can afford. So I come home and he's hiding rubbish in the bin - expensive fruit and sugary pop for the kids from the local shop which is SO expensive. I don't even know how he paid for it, we have that little money left over. aibu to worry he's put in on the credit card again or he's dipped into the kids meagre savings? He didn't mention it, just looked sheepish and walked off. i wonder what the answers would be?

Tell him if he wants to spend money like that he should work full time? He's a cocklodging CF? He's financially abusive if he's got secret money he's keeping from you?

DH's unclue died recently. He'd said before that he expected to get some inheritance but he's never mentioned. I mentioned it to my Mom and she said maybe he'd kept it aside as his "Fuck Off Fund". Is this ok?
Def LTB responses!!

Exactly this. Of course what OP's currently doing eg wanting to buy stuff on amazon, buying things from an expensive corner shop isnt BU. However if he isnt aware that this isnt coming from the tightly controlled budget, and thinks she is spending money that they dont have of course he going to react to the situation as he sees it rather than the truth thats been hidden from him.

Back in the times when we had a tightly controlled budget, i would have definately been side eying a partner if i noticed they were spending more money on clothes, having parcels delivered that didnt fit within the budget. When you have a budget someone spending more in one area takes it out of another area, which is fine if there is enough to go roundbut not if you are worried that an extra amazon parcel might be the difference between paying your gas bill or not.

Equally i would be annoyed if DP hid the fact they came into enough money that could have a positive impact on us as a family, eg being able to have a holiday, go on days out, put towards home savings (eg for a sofa!) or simply build up an emergency fund. I would be even more annoyed if in the process of hiding it from me they had to use it on small purchases to fly under the radar, and it frittered away thus i found out we might have had money that we need now, or have needed in the past but its now gone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread