Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you keep that you’d inherited 10k a secret from your husband?

612 replies

MoonBaby1 · 21/03/2021 17:57

In a generally happy, good relationship?
I have and it feels a bit weird but also really freeing. It’s been a tough few years money wise but we’re both in a position where we’re earning and working.

We both contribute to the household bills about 2/3 him and 1/3 me (I’m still part time as youngest is 2 yrs) and he’s in charge of all food and drink bills.

Just having this money up my sleeve has been very freeing. I’m not going mad but I bought the dc some strawberries and ribena from the shop and he saw me disposing of the rubbish in the outside bins with raised eyebrows. I want to sneak some other bits bought on amazon (socks, some chocolate and a scarf) into the house but feel guilty. If I own up he won’t condone this kind of spending and will insist it gets saved. I just want to enjoy about £500 over the year on little things and save the rest. AIBU?

OP posts:
IWantT0BreakFree · 21/03/2021 22:19

Also, it's pissing me off a bit tbh because I DID grow up with a financially abusive father and it feels very belittling to have people clutching at straws to label this guy when the reality of financial abuse can be so destructive and harmful. It's an insult to OP's DH and it's an insult to genuine FA victims.

IWantT0BreakFree · 21/03/2021 22:18

I absolutely agree. But that really doesn’t seem to be what’s happening here. OP has said she wants to have £500 out of £10,000 to spend on little treats for the whole family, not just herself, over the course of a year. And save the rest.

The fact she didn’t initially feel she could talk to her DH and agree this with him - knowing they can afford it because they suddenly have £10,000 more than they thought they had - is what’s worrying.

It sounds to me as though DH is the more financially responsible partner. She didn't want to tell him because she knows he would want to save it. If they've been through an extremely tough time financially, and are even now still on the breadline, then they probably do NEED that £10k as their financial buffer in case of any unexpected expenses or a change in circumstances. Maybe that's what happened in the past to plunge them into the financial difficulty that they are still experiencing.

I think it sounds like OP knows the money should be saved or used productively really, that she knows her DH is the more financially responsible partner and would insist on saving it (for everybody's benefit), and she just wants to enjoy the feeling of having some cash for once. I get that, by the way. I've been there. I know when you're hard up you just want to enjoy the little treats, but that's not how to lift yourself out of a financial mess.

I don't think he sounds in the least bit abusive and I think people are massively reaching. He just sounds like he's worried sick about keeping his family afloat.

BigFatLiar · 21/03/2021 22:18

Even if they can't actually afford it? It may not be wildly extravagant to buy strawberries (or any other little treats) but if you're struggling it is an issue.

If people are struggling to pay the rent and heating on benefits would we say don't worry about the fags and booze a little treat is fine?

Perhaps if things are on the up it may be time to lighten up but he may be worried about starting to overspend.

MrsCBY · 21/03/2021 22:07

In fact, there's a definite case to argue that actually it's financially abusive to spend family money on luxuries beyond what you can afford, potentially plunging the other partner into debt and destitution with you.

I absolutely agree. But that really doesn’t seem to be what’s happening here. OP has said she wants to have £500 out of £10,000 to spend on little treats for the whole family, not just herself, over the course of a year. And save the rest.

The fact she didn’t initially feel she could talk to her DH and agree this with him - knowing they can afford it because they suddenly have £10,000 more than they thought they had - is what’s worrying.

As is this: we’ve become fragmented due to finances and my not contributing 50/50 which I managed to do with one child.

That sounds like he feels or you both feel that you’re only entitled to joint financial control with him if you’re contributing exactly the same as him financially. Even though the reason you’re not in a position to contribute the same is because you've been looking after your joint children. Really worrying.

I think I’ll tell him but regain some control by insisting that £500 goes towards making this year easier than the one before.

I hope you do. And I hope you make sure he acknowledges how valuable to the family your non-financial contribution is, and how it’s your earning potential that’s taken a hit to bring up the children that are his as well, and that you shouldn’t be penalised or denied the right to equal say on fundamental financial decisions because of that.

ChewtonRoad · 21/03/2021 22:07

MoonBaby1, how old are you? Do you have a pension or any money put aside for your future?

I was taught "look after yourself as no one else will" and that's been true whether single or when married (now divorced).

Every woman needs running away money even when there's nothing to run from or to at the moment. If you've got nothing in savings then £5000 or £7500 is a good start towards ensuring you don't spend the last 30 years of your life on the breadline.

You inherited £10,000 and you need to decide what to do with it. You may decide to tell your husband you inherited £2000 and you'd like to spend a little on treats right now but are willing to save the rest for something specific ... or you may tell him you inherited £1000. Or not tell him at all.

If you have no savings or pension then consider talking to a financial advisor about what you could do with £5000 to ensure your better future, then decide.

hulahooper2 · 21/03/2021 22:05

Yabu, he sounds very controlling , you should be able to buy those treats out of normal household money , it’s not as if you are being wildly extravagant

IWantT0BreakFree · 21/03/2021 21:46

But he is financially and emotionally abusive if he expects you to live by his rules. If you don’t have an equal say in deciding how family money should be spent. If he’s the “adult” in charge and you’re the “child” being told what you can and can’t do.

What would be your suggestion if a family is on the breadline and one partner is spending money that the family simply doesn't have on luxuries? Should the other partner just accept the impact on their joint finances lest they be seen as "abusive"? I think it's unfair to label this man as an abuser when he wouldn't have to disapprove of OP's spending if she was either A) financially responsible and living within their means or B) honest with him about a significant financial windfall.

In fact, there's a definite case to argue that actually it's financially abusive to spend family money on luxuries beyond what you can afford, potentially plunging the other partner into debt and destitution with you. (Not really aiming that last bit at you, OP. I don't think it sounds like you intend to blow thousands and rack up debts. Just trying to demonstrate the ridiculousness of the "abuser" claims).

Babyroobs · 21/03/2021 21:45

@Candleabra

Your husband raises eyebrows at the children eating strawberries? Please don't fritter away you inheritance on perfectly reasonable household expenses. You may need it to escape your awful husband.
This.
RootyT00t · 21/03/2021 21:43

@iolaus

I haven't told mine I inherited £5000 - if he asked if I had inherited anything I'd tell him

He'd want us to do something with it - I'd rather have it (or most of it) as a safety net in case of a big expediture needed

Statements like this, ie you letting on you aren't lying because he didn't ask , don't make it any less deceitful.
thumpingrug · 21/03/2021 21:37

You are not in a good relationship and you know it. You have kept the money secret because you need an escape option. His behaviour is seriously controlling.

ReceptacleForTheRespectable · 21/03/2021 21:31

@Mrgrinch

The issue is that it appears to be the DH who dictates how their money is spent. IMO, both partners should have a joint say in what the priorities are when it comes to family finances. No one should ever have to sneak about with Ribena bottles or fruit wrappers.

With respect, there could be a good reason for that. If he's had to go as far as that then the OP could be spending beyond their means. Not that hard to imagine when they're on the breadline but she thinks it's a good idea to spend £500 on chocolate and strawberries?

That's fair. That's why I think the way forward is for then to have a frank conversation about how best to use it to benefit them all as a family.
MichelleScarn · 21/03/2021 21:31

@Ladderclimber

Could people please RTFT where the OP admits that they’re on the breadline and that her husband budgets for food extremely carefully because they need to?
Ah but that doesn't let the righteous 'LTB take all you can!' have their airtime, why read when you can automatically do that?
hansgrueber · 21/03/2021 21:31

I thought that within a marriage MN considered money to be 'family money', or is that only when men have it and we're back in MN hypocrisyland?

MrsCBY · 21/03/2021 21:30

@MoonBaby1

The thing is, he’s not financially abusive. He’s just bog standard tight Grin. Totally un materialistic which I admire and doesn’t buy himself new stuff either if he can help it.
But he is financially and emotionally abusive if he expects you to live by his rules. If you don’t have an equal say in deciding how family money should be spent. If he’s the “adult” in charge and you’re the “child” being told what you can and can’t do.
IWantT0BreakFree · 21/03/2021 21:29

I’d be buying something from the village shop deliberately every single day and leaving the wrapper on the side in the kitchen. Everytime he raised an eyebrow I would say “the more of a problem you have with this then the more things I’m going to buy to deliberately annoy you so I suggest you get over it”

Such great advice to a person whose family are currently on the breadline, and whose husband is simply expecting the other adult to also behave financially responsibly and not spend money they don't have (or he doesn't know they have). Fucking hell. It's so obvious that some of you have never been poor.

sanfranfibber · 21/03/2021 21:22

Honestly if I was your husband and I found this out I would leave you.

A hard few years financially struggling to the point he has to limit tropical fruit buying and you're hoarding £10k? You're not his partner

Ladderclimber · 21/03/2021 21:13

Could people please RTFT where the OP admits that they’re on the breadline and that her husband budgets for food extremely carefully because they need to?

HerMammy · 21/03/2021 21:12

@Mrgrinch
It was £500 a year, £10pw on socks, chocolate and fruit, hardly frivolous spending.

Thewiseoneincognito · 21/03/2021 21:08

So.much.weirdness

Biscuit9224 · 21/03/2021 21:07

That does not sound like a healthy relationship op. Hiding wrappers?! He begrudges you buying strawberries and Ribena?! Is he controlling? I don’t blame you for not wanting to tell him about the inheritance op.

In this house everything is shared. It isn’t 1/3 me or 2/3 dp. Everything we earn together is simply ‘ours’. If I was to inherit money I wouldn’t have a problem with dp knowing fully about it.

But I would say in your cause YANBU for wanting to keep it to yourself. Sneaking things into the house is not normal. Dp is always saying I need to stop splurging but I’ve never felt the need to hide things at all!

I spend a little of the inheritance for a few treats but keep the rest in a savings account only you have access too. Just in case you really need it one day!

Mrgrinch · 21/03/2021 21:04

The issue is that it appears to be the DH who dictates how their money is spent. IMO, both partners should have a joint say in what the priorities are when it comes to family finances. No one should ever have to sneak about with Ribena bottles or fruit wrappers.

With respect, there could be a good reason for that. If he's had to go as far as that then the OP could be spending beyond their means. Not that hard to imagine when they're on the breadline but she thinks it's a good idea to spend £500 on chocolate and strawberries?

BackforGood · 21/03/2021 21:04

Currently only 53% of voters think YABU.

Can you imagine if this had started with the OP saying she'd just found out that her dh had won £10K, and hidden it away rather than sharing the good fortune with him, and the family Hmm

TooManyDinosaurs1 · 21/03/2021 21:03

Wow sneaking around buying chocolate, fruit and socks? That isn't normal behaviour. Unless you are destitute and on your last 20p each month I'm not quite sure why those things would be forbidden? Are you wanting to keep the money secret so you can leave him? If so fine, but in a happy marriage I wouldn't be sneaking around buying myself chocolates or hiding money from my husband personally. It doesn't sound healthy.

ReceptacleForTheRespectable · 21/03/2021 20:58

@HerMammy

He’d let me put some cheap chocolate on the Aldi list but buying anything from a village shop is frowned upon what a miserable existence, unless you’re incredibly hard up, he’s beyond tight,if he’s raising eyebrows at strawberries.
The OP has said they are hard up.

The issue is that it appears to be the DH who dictates how their money is spent. IMO, both partners should have a joint say in what the priorities are when it comes to family finances. No one should ever have to sneak about with Ribena bottles or fruit wrappers.

blackcat86 · 21/03/2021 20:57

We need an MN misogyny klaxon!