Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you keep that you’d inherited 10k a secret from your husband?

612 replies

MoonBaby1 · 21/03/2021 17:57

In a generally happy, good relationship?
I have and it feels a bit weird but also really freeing. It’s been a tough few years money wise but we’re both in a position where we’re earning and working.

We both contribute to the household bills about 2/3 him and 1/3 me (I’m still part time as youngest is 2 yrs) and he’s in charge of all food and drink bills.

Just having this money up my sleeve has been very freeing. I’m not going mad but I bought the dc some strawberries and ribena from the shop and he saw me disposing of the rubbish in the outside bins with raised eyebrows. I want to sneak some other bits bought on amazon (socks, some chocolate and a scarf) into the house but feel guilty. If I own up he won’t condone this kind of spending and will insist it gets saved. I just want to enjoy about £500 over the year on little things and save the rest. AIBU?

OP posts:
midnightstar66 · 22/03/2021 06:58

I think a lot of posters here are struggling to understand that for some families strawberry's and individual sugary drinks are a luxury.

I'm not, I'm very much in that camp but I'd still never hide it if I did it. A tub of strawberries in the long run will not hugely hamper a deposit for a house. Everyone needs the occasional treat even if it knocks £3 off the weeks budget for more sensible things

harknesswitch · 22/03/2021 06:57

I'd be really upset if my dh inherited 10k and chose not to tell me. Especially if he spent £500 on himself, that's really quite selfish.

Re the food shop and your contribution, I think you just need tit are more control over it. There's nothing wrong with the odd treat from the shop, so you need to start asserting yourself. You bring money into the family and take care of the dc.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 22/03/2021 06:53

Depends on the husband .

Circumlocutious · 22/03/2021 06:50

@MessAllOver

I think you need to have a chat with him. It sounds like things have been extremely tight but are getting better. So you need to agree a small budget with him for treats for the children and personal spending so you're not always having to watch your pennies.

Though I'd be tempted to keep the £10k secret and put it into savings. Once you have children, relationships often become subject to power imbalances when one of you earns less and it's good to have an "exit fund" so you don't feel trapped. It doesn't sound like your DH is financially abusive, only very frugal, but it is possible for the one to tip into the other and before you know it, you're forbidden to have a coffee out with friends or buy a present for a birthday party. And that's no way to live.

Isn’t it better for them to buy a house?
Circumlocutious · 22/03/2021 06:48

@IWantT0BreakFree

I’d be buying something from the village shop deliberately every single day and leaving the wrapper on the side in the kitchen. Everytime he raised an eyebrow I would say “the more of a problem you have with this then the more things I’m going to buy to deliberately annoy you so I suggest you get over it”

Such great advice to a person whose family are currently on the breadline, and whose husband is simply expecting the other adult to also behave financially responsibly and not spend money they don't have (or he doesn't know they have). Fucking hell. It's so obvious that some of you have never been poor.

Absolutely. The responses on here are absurd. ‘What a miserable way to live’ - welcome to the real fucking world.

Before clarifying that they were ‘on the breadline’, OP had mentioned multiple times that they had a difficult few years financially. That they were looking to improve their situation. We know they’re looking to save for a deposit and that this is OP’s husband priority. We don’t know if they have debts or other costs. Many people do have a very strict Aldi shop that they don’t stray from, in order to keep costs low. In fact this is #1 on the list of food budgeting advice if you’re struggling.

Buying stuff impulsively from the village shop is a lovely treat for many, but if you’re on a ridiculously tight budget then it can absolutely detail everything.

dishydishemup · 22/03/2021 06:43

I would tell him it's £5k inheritance and keep £5k as your secret fund. You never know when you might need it.

Either that or you decide how it is spent e.g. deposit on house purchase

garlictwist · 22/03/2021 06:42

There is something wrong about hiding it - even if you intended to keep it all for yourself and not share it (which I guess is up to you as it's your money) it does feel deceitful not to mention it. I can't imagine keeping something like that a secret, and DP and I have completely separate finances.

Skyla2005 · 22/03/2021 06:40

You buy strawberries and Ribena then have to hide the evidence ? Seriously you have major problems I. Your marriage because that is no way normal

bjjgirl · 22/03/2021 06:32

I think a lot of posters here are struggling to understand that for some families strawberry's and individual sugary drinks are a luxury.

I can see both points of view but I would tell him but also inform him that you intend to keep the £500 for these such luxuries.

Partayof5 · 22/03/2021 06:20

It’s a tough one because your husband sounds a bit difficult and controlling if he would get upset splurging on fruit and cordial for your kids. If you keep it a secret you prob have to do so forever otherwise he won’t trust you again and it may make him think well she was sneaky so I can be too. Plus if you have a bill come up it’ll look bad if you’ve been sitting on this money. Any reasonable husband would say it’s your inheritance have fun with it, do what you like you normally only get that once in a lifetime. But if he’s not like that I can totally see why you’d want to hide it so you have something for yourself for once. Perhaps you could say you were keeping it a secret for a romantic holiday away for your anniversary etc and that would at least be a good reason for keeping it quiet. Not because your husband is tight with you! Hope that helps and you get to enjoy it and spoil your kids (that’s exactly what I’d do with it too!) 😊

torquewench · 22/03/2021 04:50

Absolutely. I used to work for a firm who had a client who'd won millions on the lottery and not told any of her family, as they'd just burn through it in a couple of years.

PeggyHill · 22/03/2021 04:43

If you feel the need to hide the fact that you bought strawberries and ribena, which must have cost less than a tenner (not lived in the UK for a few years so feel free to correct me if prices have shot up) then your marriage is not happy and good, and the same goes for hiding the fact that inherited a large sum of money.

Either you are being very selfish and sneaky and not sharing the burden of the family money problems, or your husband is financially abusing you and you need to leave.

I honestly can't tell which it is from your posts.

MessAllOver · 22/03/2021 04:42

I think you need to have a chat with him. It sounds like things have been extremely tight but are getting better. So you need to agree a small budget with him for treats for the children and personal spending so you're not always having to watch your pennies.

Though I'd be tempted to keep the £10k secret and put it into savings. Once you have children, relationships often become subject to power imbalances when one of you earns less and it's good to have an "exit fund" so you don't feel trapped. It doesn't sound like your DH is financially abusive, only very frugal, but it is possible for the one to tip into the other and before you know it, you're forbidden to have a coffee out with friends or buy a present for a birthday party. And that's no way to live.

Tinkerbell456 · 22/03/2021 04:35

If you feel the need to hide throwing out strawberries and Ribera bottles, I don’t think you have a great marriage, to be blunt. My husband works and I don’t and I can’t imagine him giving me a hard time about something like that. If I turned up in a brand new Porsche he’d certainly have something to say!

timeisnotaline · 22/03/2021 04:20

I’m glad you feel like you can talk to him about this now.
I think what I’ve gained from this thread is the realisation that we’ve become fragmented due to finances and my not contributing 50/50 which I managed to do with one child.
You do contribute 50/50 I expect, possibly even more, it’s just not all in the form of hours at paid employment. He can arrange childcare or drop to parttime and you work full time, possibly for net less money if he doesn’t think you are contributing 50/50.

Meowchickameowmeow · 22/03/2021 04:13

Hiding and sneaking have no place in a happy relationship. I came into a similar amount last year, my husband is happy for me to spend it on whatever I want.

Ploughingthrough · 22/03/2021 03:08

No way. It would go into our joint saving our something that would benefit the whole family. I'd be upset if he hid a 10k inheritance from me.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 22/03/2021 00:13

@PorcelainCatStack

In a normal relationship I’d say hiding it was not.

With a DH who is controlling with money - especially over tiny things such as strawberries for the children, I’d not only say YANBU but I’d also say LTB. That’s not normal.

THIS^
Dasher789 · 21/03/2021 23:51

I don't no where you live op but is it possible you could use the money towards a house deposit? It might help you live better if you had mortgage payments at less than your rent? Anyway, yes, spend the £500 - years ago, when I was at uni, my parents split up and for a period, times were very tough financially for my mum and that had a knock on effect on me. I was sending my mum money from my part time uni job so she could buy food. During the summer when I was back home, we walked past an ice cream van on a sunny day and my mum asked me if I wanted an ice cream, I replied asking whether we could afford it and my mum said, 'whats life if you cant have an ice cream'. Those words always stuck with me. Buy your kids their metaphorical ice cream and enjoy some of lifes small pleasures.

fucksat50 · 21/03/2021 23:26

Yes

WisnaeMe · 21/03/2021 23:26

OP has already agreed that the right thing to do is to tell her Husband. 🌺

Keepyourdistance000 · 21/03/2021 23:26

Why would you keep that from him, especially such a huge amount of money?

How would he react if he found out you'd hidden this from him?

Or if you divorced and had to disclose your finances?

sansou · 21/03/2021 23:24

10K is a huge amount if you're on the breadline. Relatively expensive strawberries & Ribena are treats is you can only afford the basics normally for your weekly food shop.

You definitely need to tell your DH and unless the household has debts, I can't see why you couldn't agree to save say 9K and spend up to £1K on whatever you want.

Secrets erode trust.

Personally, I wouldn't fritter it away on day to day small luxuries which is extremely easy to do. It's a fantastic lump sum contribution towards a house deposit/retraining/setting up a business.

excuseforfights · 21/03/2021 23:21

Yep s it ok for the higher earning man to have a secret fund?

My husband earns significantly more. I’ve always felt better having my own savings. He isn’t tight at all, we buy stuff for each other all the time.

But he doesn’t know how much I have in savings.

JustDespair · 21/03/2021 23:16

@BillMasen

I am assuming she hasn't been. As she has been defending her husband as just being a bit tight I'm sure she would have mentioned if she used to go out and treat herself to hotel chocolat a few times a month while he never treated himself to anything.