Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Priti Patel wants to ban protest. Bill going through this week.

258 replies

flashbac · 14/03/2021 08:22

The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill is some scary looking stuff. 10 year sentence for being at any protest that, amongst other things, causes or is at risk of causing 'serious annoyance'. That's all protests then is it?
The right to protest is the cornerstone of every democracy.
Aibu to be scared about where this is heading?

OP posts:
Bourbonic · 14/03/2021 19:10

And isn't it applying the same standard to static protests as exists for marches?

Bourbonic · 14/03/2021 19:08

Was this not drafted in response to the BLM and extinction rebellion protests in which numerous statues and memorials were damaged, including the cenotaph? Labour supported it at the time.

I have no real issue with it. As much as I support people's right to protest, I feel there has to be balance because that shouldn't trump everyone else's right to a peaceful existence either.

Chanjer · 14/03/2021 19:05

I don't think that many people want it I just don't think many consider the full implications or care really

Baluchistan95 · 14/03/2021 19:03

@Theluggage15

This doesn’t surprise me. The government have been watching with great pleasure the way in which a large proportion of the population have loved all the authoritarian measures that have been brought in as a response to covid. Look at all the many comments about locking people up for breaking a rule, refusing NHS treatment for rule breakers and for people who don’t want the vaccine. Virtually frothing at the mouth that U.K. lockdowns have been half hearted and should have been like China’s, they seem to love being told what they’re ‘allowed’ to do.

I think the past year has shown that the U.K. population really doesn’t care about free speech and human rights, if the government says it will keep them ‘safe’ they happily nod along to anything they’re told.

Wow, what a great post. I honestly don't know what the problem is here. As you rightly say people have been begging for this, for months, now it looks like they may get what they want!! How many times have we heard posters on here encouraging other posters to report a neighbour for flouting lockdown rules? Yet, as I type this, there are thousands of women doing just that in London, which appears to be supported by many on here. Such hypocrisy. Given the events from yesterday and today, I fear that this bill may just get through. If anyone on here, attended today's events, you should hold your head in shame. These protests have been hijacked and have nothing to do with poor Sarah.
YoyoRiot · 14/03/2021 19:00

In that case, that's really scary how our freedom is being chipped away at

Frazzled2207 · 14/03/2021 18:59

@YoyoRiot
As explained upthread this is nothing to do with the pandemic. This is about curtailing people’s right to protest generally.

YoyoRiot · 14/03/2021 18:57

Does she want to ban protests in the context of the current time to protect the health of others? Or just protests full stop?

Chanjer · 14/03/2021 18:40

blocking a bridge or road to stop pedestrians and/or traffic from getting through;

That one in itself is sufficient to never allow a march or occupation though

And that's the vast majority of protests I've ever been on

Protests are meant to cause some disruption, it is frequently a part of what marks the event as not just a normal day

Doomsdayiscoming · 14/03/2021 18:25

@hayley037

Spot on. Goddamn. Thank you for writing that, probably the best summation of this country I have read in years.

SakuraEdenSwan1 · 14/03/2021 18:15

They want to protest because they know what is going to happen when this corrupt governments lies are exposed to the public, those who researched themselves are called 'conspiracy theorists' and insulted across MSM, they will be riots and I hope this lot go to prison for what they have done.

GlassOfPort · 14/03/2021 18:09

I am sorry Crankley, but the policy paper is not exactly an unbiased source of information...I mean, they are hardly going to say "Yes, this policy will make it more difficult to organise a protest".

Also, if there was a Labour government, would you be happy for them to have the ability to restrict your (sacrosanct) right to protest against them?

Donotfeedthebears · 14/03/2021 18:06

@Crankley

I agree with mellongoose. While you're all having hysterics, have you read the Policy Paper?

Paragraph 4.1 states:

"4.1 Will these measures undermine freedom of expression?
No, freedom of expression is a cornerstone of British democracy. The majority of protests in England and Wales are lawful and will be unaffected by these changes.

These measures will balance the rights of protesters with the rights of others to go about their business unhindered. They will achieve this by enabling the police to better manage highly disruptive protests."

I appreciate left wingers are desperate to bash this government whenever possible but to make up bullshit to fit your agenda is risible.

Ahhh the old “women are hysterical” line. Lock them all up in an asylum!
Lonelycrab · 14/03/2021 18:00

enabling the police to better manage highly disruptive protests

And you type this the day the front pages are plastered with images of a young woman attending a peaceful vigil with a police officers knee on her headHmm

And that’s before this law has been enacted.

NoWordForFluffy · 14/03/2021 17:49

Keith is way too busy trying to fight the left, which would be the obvious target from the unity candidate, instead of the current government

Anybody deliberately calling Keir Keith just looks like an idiot and undermines any argument they might raise.

I agree that Priti looks like a raging hypocrite. And the Tories under Johnson are clearly only libertarian (or claim to be) when it suits / benefits them.

Crankley · 14/03/2021 17:47

I agree with mellongoose. While you're all having hysterics, have you read the Policy Paper?

Paragraph 4.1 states:

"4.1 Will these measures undermine freedom of expression?
No, freedom of expression is a cornerstone of British democracy. The majority of protests in England and Wales are lawful and will be unaffected by these changes.

These measures will balance the rights of protesters with the rights of others to go about their business unhindered. They will achieve this by enabling the police to better manage highly disruptive protests."

I appreciate left wingers are desperate to bash this government whenever possible but to make up bullshit to fit your agenda is risible.

hayley037 · 14/03/2021 17:33

@blackheartsgirl

Will they?

This is 2021. Everybody follows the rules these days and don't question or can't be bothered to stir themselves from the sofa. Just trying to survive within their own family and develop an im alright Jack attitude.

People just can't be bothered these days. Of the poll tax thing happened in 2021 no one would bat an eyelid.might be a few mutterings but I reckon would just get on with it. And pay it

Exactly this.

Most people these days seem to actually want authoritarian rule. I used to think the Daily Mail comments section was just a very small hateful section of society. Since 2016 I actually now think it is more representative of the country and society.

The general public hate minority groups, be it people protesting for equal rights, better pay and conditions or for women to be able to walk around safe at night. To these people the only thing that matters is that there are people worse off than themselves to look down on and that they can feel jingoistic about England and its exceptionalism.

England is not a kind country. Being racist, misogynistic and hateful is fairly mainstream and I don't see us getting a compassionate liberal government for at least a decade or two especially with a FPTP democracy that ensures those at the top end of society keep their power and wealth.

Frazzled2207 · 14/03/2021 17:14

@blackheartsgirl

They’re seriously getting to the point where there will be another Poll Tax situation - full on rage and non-compliance. Don’t push people too far. Especially not after the year we’ve had.

No they won't. The British public will do as they are told, only have to see how willing people on here were willing to snitch on their neighbours to know that the how apathetic the general public is

It's the general apathy of the British public on stuff so fundamental that I find most concerning tbh
Frazzled2207 · 14/03/2021 17:12

[quote mellongoose]Ian Dunt is - not for the first time - talking absolute nonsense.

“Serious disruption” is a well-established and defined concept. The changes bring “static” protests in line with equivalent provisions that apply to marches / processions under s12 Public Order Act.

To help Ian out, no, a protest does not cause serious disruption just because it may “[distract] employees in a nearby office”. Nor would a peaceful vigil in a park cause serious disruption.

Examples of things that could cause serious disruption might include:

  • blocking a bridge or road to stop pedestrians and/or traffic from getting through;
  • preventing a train from leaving a station;
  • physically preventing a printing press from operating because you disagree with the editorial position of that publication.

This might help [[https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-factsheets/police-crime-sentencing-and-courts-bill-2021-protest-powers-factsheet]][/quote]
respectfully I don't think he's spouting nonsense. He is saying that 'noise' could come under serious disruption and that crucially, the Home Secretary will have the discretion to say whether or not a protest constitutes serious disruption or not.

Frankly, I don't think any of us want to get to a situation that it's Priti Patel's call whether or not we get arrested for attending a peaceful protest.

Donotfeedthebears · 14/03/2021 17:12

“People should not be afraid of their governments, governments should be afraid of their people.”

I’m getting serious V for Vendetta vibes from this.

Lonelycrab · 14/03/2021 17:10

So to those that think this is all perfectly fine: what happens to a peaceful protest that is infiltrated by trouble makers? Are the organisers then liable to a potential ten year sentence? And the bbc are mentioning noise limits; how do you control exactly how much noise gets made? Will the police be waiting with decibel meters ready to pounce?

Seems to me that it could potentially put people off organising any kind of protest through the fear of prosecution.

Ylvamoon · 14/03/2021 17:06

They might just get away with it.

If you look at the news articles/ broadcasts over the last 12 months there is hardly anything worthwhile noting.

A lot of European citizens have been protesting against lockdown rules and curfews in their countries. Some governments have been taken to court over this...
There is minimal media coverage here about keeping our freedoms and democracy.

There are more news stories that seem to have been suppressed...

MercyBooth · 14/03/2021 17:01

DH has just quoted this

"Dont scare someone so much that the person forgets what fear is"

MercyBooth · 14/03/2021 17:00

Quite a few of us were sounding warnings about this on the Covid board for the last year. We were branded Covid deniers and anti lockdowners. But we told you so.

Donotfeedthebears · 14/03/2021 16:57

Why are we not angrier about this? What can we do?

Devlesko · 14/03/2021 16:47

My dh said this would happen, this time last year.
I told him to stfu with his conspiracy theories Shock
I hope he's not right on the others.
He's not an anti vaxer, flat earter, micro chip, etc theorist. But he does seem to see the depths that gov will go to, especially this one.