Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Priti Patel wants to ban protest. Bill going through this week.

258 replies

flashbac · 14/03/2021 08:22

The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill is some scary looking stuff. 10 year sentence for being at any protest that, amongst other things, causes or is at risk of causing 'serious annoyance'. That's all protests then is it?
The right to protest is the cornerstone of every democracy.
Aibu to be scared about where this is heading?

OP posts:
Awwlookatmybabyspider · 14/03/2021 23:44

10 years. !!!!!TEN FUCKIN YEARS!!!!!!!!!!!!. Dirty nonces get a suspended sentence!! Angry doesn't even come within a decillion miles of how I'm feeling. Yet they moan that the prisons are over crowded. Not only that but. Where exactly are the going to put these people!!!!!!!!

JustAnotherPoster00 · 14/03/2021 23:39

@Sstrongtn

We’re heading straight at the far right or the far left and nothing in between, have said it for a long time and either way is absolutely terrifying.

Every single person that said Covid was being used as a smokescreen was called a tin foil hatter though.

Ive been wondering what this far left people keep talking about, the overton window has shifted so far to the right in both here and the US that I dont think anyone in rgis country knows what hard left is anymore, and if Corbynism is your go to for hard left then I thank you for proving my first point correctly

I cant believe people are suprised by this, Thatcher (fucking witch) broke the power of the unions for good or bad in the 80's, their power further eroded by Camerons lot and now they want to introduce this, perhaps this is them planning ahead for when the Brexit 'dividend' becomes more apparent to those who voted for it

Sstrongtn · 14/03/2021 23:25

We’re heading straight at the far right or the far left and nothing in between, have said it for a long time and either way is absolutely terrifying.

Every single person that said Covid was being used as a smokescreen was called a tin foil hatter though.

Graphista · 14/03/2021 23:20

Although... I kind of hope they do, and the Tories end up as tainted, despised and scorned as they did in the 90s.

Same

But that said I have emailed my Mp about this

It's an absolutely appalling, oppressive and controlling piece of potential legislation

@Mooda did you honestly expect kier to be a decent, socialist leaning labour leader? With his background?

If Labour merely abstain then what is the point of them

They need to go too, they no longer represent the people they are supposed to, we need a new party that represents the working class and otherwise disenfranchised

This terrifies me. We are truly sleepwalking to a police state

Absolutely.

I expect the next elections will be cancelled “for your safety.”

Apparently plans are for postal votes are to be abolished and photo ID will be required - to prevent non existent voting fraud!

I'm disabled and housebound, I have no passport as it's bloody expensive to have when I can't afford holidays, and I don't have a license at the moment as for several years I was on meds that meant I couldn't drive and now I can't afford a car either.

It also means my parents wouldn't be able to vote, so as they are over 70 and would statistically age wise be more likely to vote Tory they could slightly be shooting themselves in the Foot though I suspect they have crunched the numbers and this is not much of an issue.

I've found that almost no one I know had heard this bill was coming, and most people seem totally unaware of the damage this will do to our democracy.

Same - the appalling lack of ethical journalism in this country in the msm is a Fucking disgrace

I've just heard on radio that Labour is going to vote against the Bill.

Really hope it's true, not holding my breath

The hypocrisy and stupidity of Priti Patel is beyond a joke.

Hypocrite, dangerous, vile even yes, stupid? Far from unfortunately

Met shouldn't have even been at that vigil imo- whole other thread which I am on

I suspect that workers rights will be next er hello brexit already started that

This has been in the making for approximately 20 I'd say over 40

I would urge those of you who are against this and haven't already to email your mps now - of whatever party. Mine is snp but is a good man and I would be very surprised if he supported this or even abstained, but it's still good to contact them

What else can we do?

I'd like to know this too, what stage is the bill at has it been to the lords yet?

Just checked, it's not gone to the lords yet so I'm thinking to email lords although I have no idea who - anyone more informed able to say

In bold so anyone who knows the answer can see the question

I was deeply impressed by the way they handled the maternity bill mess

Are we not coming to an end of lockdown with restrictions easing somewhat in April?

If you believe that I have a tower in London to sell you or possibly magic beans...

The pandemic is a convenient excuse.

At this point it's impossible to avoid Godwin's law!

The nazis used the excuse of a failing economy, this govt is using the pandemic similarly

@mellongoose I can't link the pdf but you can access it and read the details here

bills.parliament.uk/bills/2839

Part 3 "public order" which is on p56 is the most relevant portion

I'm summarising but basically any gathering that is deemed to be noisy, inconvenient or disruptive will be outlawed and those found guilty may receive custodial sentences - British citizens will literally be political prisoners

The levels of noise etc they are talking about are fairly minimal - about the level you'd get in a busy high street on a normal Saturday for comparative purposes

It IS in real terms banning all physical, in person protesting

But then it appears your "naïveté" was not real!

Keir starmer shouldn't need "political nous" to have understood what a shit bill this is - he was a senior lawyer ffs!

@MercyBooth excellent quote

People will snap when pushed into a corner, however placid they were until that point

Seems to me that it could potentially put people off organising any kind of protest through the fear of prosecution.

Which is precisely the point

have you read the Policy Paper?

And that's a lazy and patronising way to argue against people who hold a different opinion to you

So is using one VERY small - and contradictory - part of that document to try and claim the rest of it doesn't matter!

And drop the use of misogynist and outdated insults too please

@bourbonic what it was in response to is largely irrelevant, it's the future effects which matter

And frankly nothing ever really changes without some disruption and damage to the status quo

Do you think suffragettes or anti apartheid or anti racism or jarrow marchers or anyone who protested for civil liberties throughout the 20th century and even in the 19th century were out of order for their actions? (Which were often a lot more "disruptive" than modern protests)

Shameful attitude to have - particularly if you're someone who has benefitted from the rights those people gained for oppressed groups

I have no real issue with it. As much as I support people's right to protest

You're contradicting yourself right there

@Frazzled2207 don't lose heart, just because someone hasn't reacted on fb doesn't mean they're unconcerned and inactive, I tend to not be political on my fb mainly as I have poor mh and in the past it's led to me being harassed online (I have since tightened my privacy settings but fb are constantly messing with these) but I do discuss these things with people privately and I do what I can in other ways

@Icantreachthepretzels another great quote thank you

I did really think that fundamentally Johnson was a libertarian

Genuine question - why did you think that? He's never come across that way to me

What on earth are they planning that they want to prevent our rights to protest?

This is what concerns me too, and by "govt" I include all parties, I can't help but think Labour at least know exactly why they're doing it and aren't saying

@MercyBooth that the thread I'm on too? I'm deeply suspicious of that poster and have reported

MercyBooth · 14/03/2021 23:17

@TempsPerdu Agree.

MercyBooth · 14/03/2021 23:14

@Theluggage15 There is another poster (one who was one of the biggest ones crying out for more and more and tighter and tighter restrictions) now posting on another thread about the vigil. Trying to minimize what happened. Doubling down i believe its called.

SunscreenCentral · 14/03/2021 23:09

@FrankButchersDickieBow

Priti Patel, is actually evil. I mean, proper evil.

There Re few people on this earth who are actually evil, but I swear to god, she is one of them.

I agree. She is terrifying. When she threatened to “starve” the Irish during one the Brexit battles, everything in me shuddered.
Ireland is in the top 3 of Food Secure countries on the globe and she can’t get her cold, dead hands next or near us THANK FUCK - but she wasn’t afraid to try to ring the Famine bell. Shows who she is.
Stellaris22 · 14/03/2021 22:25

Anyone who doesn't view this as terrifying is deluded. Personally I'm scared at the rights being taken away from people. Between this and the actions of the police against a peaceful vigil, I'm worried about the future.

Why are the government doing this? What on earth are they planning that they want to prevent our rights to protest?

FrankButchersDickieBow · 14/03/2021 22:20

Priti Patel, is actually evil. I mean, proper evil.

There Re few people on this earth who are actually evil, but I swear to god, she is one of them.

TempsPerdu · 14/03/2021 22:15

Yes I’m finding it all very scary too. I’ve been concerned about the suspension of civil liberties since the start of the pandemic, but have been regarded as a melodramatic crank by most of those I’ve discussed it with. And I’m now very wary of being dismissed as a crazy covid denier, which seems to have been the case with anyone who even remotely questions the wisdom or utility of lockdown measures.

Relieved that Labour look to be actively voting against rather than their usual fence-sitting shenanigans, but I’m so disappointed in Keir Starmer, who seems to be afraid of his own shadow.

Even more frustrated by the unquestioning apathy of most of the British voting population. My friends are well educated, kind and socially engaged - far from the rabid Daily Mail commenters mentioned upthread. But they are also almost completely disengaged from politics and unable to see beyond their comfortable middle class bubble. I doubt many of them even know about this bill, let alone oppose it.

I just wish we as a country would wake up.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 14/03/2021 22:00

I'm with you OP. Started a similar thread (sorry, missed yours).

Thanks to everyone contacting their MP.

Whichever side of the left -right debate you're on, this is about our democratic rights. Everyone's democratic rights.

JSL52 · 14/03/2021 21:57

Scary

Sally2791 · 14/03/2021 21:56

The whole situation is very scary indeed, and there is complete lack of a meaningful opposition.We are being marched into a police state

wonderstuff · 14/03/2021 21:50

I've written to my MP, but my MP is Kit Malthouse and I'd bet my house on him voting with government on this. I still feel I have to write because if we all give up he can imagine everyone is fine with it.

I find it so depressing that Boris is ahead in the polls currently. People are asleep surely?

I did really think that fundamentally Johnson was a libertarian and wouldn't seek to reduce freedoms, looks like I was wrong.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 14/03/2021 21:42

Anybody deliberately calling Keir Keith just looks like an idiot and undermines any argument they might raise.

Aww bless, ill make sure I make extra effort to call him keith from now on then Smile

BonnieDundee · 14/03/2021 21:40

Or maybe we're just a Conservative country and people like Boris.

I dont mind people voting for Boris. I just dont expect Keir to back Boris all the time Grin

TotorosFurryBehind · 14/03/2021 21:32

Thanks for raising awareness OP, I'd not even heard of it.

User133847 · 14/03/2021 21:23

@BonnieDundee

No. They're flying in the polls at the moment.

Possibly because the Opposition is non existent

Or maybe we're just a Conservative country and people like Boris.
BonnieDundee · 14/03/2021 21:03

No. They're flying in the polls at the moment.

Possibly because the Opposition is non existent

User133847 · 14/03/2021 20:40

@YoniAndGuy

They’re seriously getting to the point where there will be another Poll Tax situation - full on rage and non-compliance. Don’t push people too far. Especially not after the year we’ve had. Although... I kind of hope they do, and the Tories end up as tainted, despised and scorned as they did in the 90s.
No. They're flying in the polls at the moment.
User133847 · 14/03/2021 20:39

We're in a pandemic. Any protests are irresponsible and unlawful unless they conform to the Covid rules. Simple as that.

Icantreachthepretzels · 14/03/2021 20:37

@Donotfeedthebears

“People should not be afraid of their governments, governments should be afraid of their people.”

I’m getting serious V for Vendetta vibes from this.

They are afraid of us - that's why they're doing this. They're hoping that if they make it illegal to protest they will just get away with the unnecessarily high death toll, the track and trace fiasco, the dire brexit deal, the crashing economy, the destruction of peace in NI ...

they are just so fucking stupid that they can't think their way to the natural conclusion of a ban on legitimate, democratic protest.

'Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable' - JFK

I won't cry for them when their day comes.

Frazzled2207 · 14/03/2021 19:19

I’ve shared my concerns on my Facebook today. Predictably three people (the usual suspects) are outraged. No one else has reacted.

Polecat03 · 14/03/2021 19:12

I've emailed my MP to ask them to vote against it. Make your voice heard, what more can we do.

Baluchistan95 · 14/03/2021 19:11

@Chanjer

I don't think that many people want it I just don't think many consider the full implications or care really
To be fair, I think you are right on that one.