Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Priti Patel wants to ban protest. Bill going through this week.

258 replies

flashbac · 14/03/2021 08:22

The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill is some scary looking stuff. 10 year sentence for being at any protest that, amongst other things, causes or is at risk of causing 'serious annoyance'. That's all protests then is it?
The right to protest is the cornerstone of every democracy.
Aibu to be scared about where this is heading?

OP posts:
pinkearedcow · 15/03/2021 10:36

The police enforce the law and the law was no large gatherings during covid

The covid lawa allows for peaceful demonstration. The police decided to ban the vigil instead of working with the organisers.

The people being moved on physically by the police at the vigil that was on my tv the other night were white males in hoodies

Have you not seen the pictures of police holding down a young woman?

Frazzled2207 · 15/03/2021 10:33

Thanks @Redwinestillfine have signed though there needs to be one of those official government petitions really - with those they are guaranteed a debate in parliament when they get to a certain number at least. I know the approval process is not that easy though.

CrunchyBiscs · 15/03/2021 10:31

The police enforce the law and the law was no large gatherings during covid. You can't have police deciding which laws to enforce - if the gov wanted the law changed for the vigil they should have done that.
The other issue is trouble makers and people with other beefs joining any gathering to get publicity or just to make trouble. They can get away with stuff in a crowd they wouldn't otherwise.
The people being moved on physically by the police at the vigil that was on my tv the other night were white males in hoodies. No bouquets to be seen ie possibly just blokes looking for a bit of excitement.
This might be what Priti Patel is trying to curb.
There are protests daily in London, the only ones which get national coverage are the violent ones hence they attract people with other causes and troublemakers.

Bourbonic · 15/03/2021 10:17

Because you need to have the capacity to use it when you need to.

User133847 · 15/03/2021 10:14

@roundturnandtwohalfhitches

Online petitions are pretty fucking useless when you've got an authoritarian government who doesn't even uphold the law itself. What scares them is people on the streets. That's why they want to stop it.
People on the streets rioting scares them yes, people marching holding placards doesn't bother them.
ItWasTheBestOfTimes · 15/03/2021 09:58

Even if they don't have the capacity to police every one and throw everyone in jail, such a Bill will act as a deterrent to protest which is surely the point of it in the first place. I have attended peaceful protests but if I could end up with a conviction or fine for protesting that would put me off, as I have my children to think about.

I also think these powers will be used to target particular protests that are particularly sensitive to the culture war this government are encouraging, and that isn't a good thing, BLM, ER, and anti-Tory protesters have a right to protest as much as anyone else. If people engage in rioting, criminal damage, abusive behaviour during etc protests then the individuals involved can be prosecuted under the relevant law that was broken. We do not need sweeping legislation that effectively criminalises most protests.

Flyonawalk · 15/03/2021 09:57

Limiting right to protest is a frightening prospect, but I fear there will be lots of public support for it. People approved last year when police disbanded anti-lockdown protests. The logical extension was the police disbanding the vigil for Sarah.

This is what a police state looks like. We reassure ourselves that truly repressive government couldn’t happen in the U.K., without noticing that we are allowing it to happen.

HOkieCOkie · 15/03/2021 09:54

@flashbac I’m not playing silly games. I’m giving an opinion honestly so hostile and rude. Wind your neck in. You don’t agree that’s fine lol

roundturnandtwohalfhitches · 15/03/2021 09:54

Online petitions are pretty fucking useless when you've got an authoritarian government who doesn't even uphold the law itself. What scares them is people on the streets. That's why they want to stop it.

Icantreachthepretzels · 15/03/2021 09:52

Forms of protest, yes, but in a digital word it can be done online. Petitions, email your MP, or write to your MP etc.

Yes writing to your MP is important - I will be writing to mine later, I write to him a lot. And on line petitions are good too ... but they don't compare to the real thing.

They are far too easily ignored.

It is our right to protest, in person, in great numbers - any one advocating for the removal of a right needs to take a good, hard look at why they think people will be better off with one less right. Because the right to sign an online petition on a none government website does not compensate for the loss of the right to go right into the heart of government and make yourself heard - to have those scenes broadcast across every news programme.

You could of course sign a petition on the government website - the only problem with that is, who decides whether or not to accept and publish the petition for signatures? ... oh yeah - the government.

User133847 · 15/03/2021 09:45

@Icantreachthepretzels

Protests are not the way to go.

The way to enact change is at the ballot box.

In an ideal world protests would not be necessary - however we don't live in an ideal world, we live in the one where we get a chance to vote for a new government every five years and if that government has a majority they can then enact whatever laws they like in that interim period.

And that is why we need to be allowed to protest - particularly this government who is responsible for some spectacularly bad laws, mishandling of the pandemic, cronyism costing the tax payer billions and has broken the law themselves several times.

Democracy doesn't pack itself up into a box after an election and wait for the next one. It is an ongoing conversation.

Protest is a part of that conversation, it is how people make their voices heard when there is no election - in large numbers to show strength of feeling, in public to raise awareness, it is a cornerstone of democracy itself. Anyone who doesn't understand that clearly doesn't understand the first thing about democracy.

Forms of protest, yes, but in a digital word it can be done online. Petitions, email your MP, or write to your MP etc.

Pressure can be put on democratically that way. Street protests are unedifying and futile IMO.

User133847 · 15/03/2021 09:42

Oh user, such naivety.

There's exceptions but protests don't really achieve anything. Over a million people marched against the Iraq war in London.

Professional protesters like Piers Corbyn or David Icke never actually get anywhere.

People always talk about the importance of the 'grey vote' in winning elections or referendums.They're not protesting every week, but they do vote.

roundturnandtwohalfhitches · 15/03/2021 09:41

I'm not sure how they are going to enforce all these new laws. Policing in the country is generally by consent. The police force has been defunded for years. The court system has been defunded for years.

But then this government is hard of thinking generally. I suspect they are shit scared. Once lockdown is over and the economic cost of the pandemic plus Brexit begins to bite, mass unemployment tends to concentrate peoples minds. So this legislation is being rushed through under cover of bringing protest laws up to date. I would say pound shop fascists but I like pound shops.

Icantreachthepretzels · 15/03/2021 09:38

Protests are not the way to go.

The way to enact change is at the ballot box.

In an ideal world protests would not be necessary - however we don't live in an ideal world, we live in the one where we get a chance to vote for a new government every five years and if that government has a majority they can then enact whatever laws they like in that interim period.

And that is why we need to be allowed to protest - particularly this government who is responsible for some spectacularly bad laws, mishandling of the pandemic, cronyism costing the tax payer billions and has broken the law themselves several times.

Democracy doesn't pack itself up into a box after an election and wait for the next one. It is an ongoing conversation.

Protest is a part of that conversation, it is how people make their voices heard when there is no election - in large numbers to show strength of feeling, in public to raise awareness, it is a cornerstone of democracy itself. Anyone who doesn't understand that clearly doesn't understand the first thing about democracy.

countrygirl99 · 15/03/2021 09:37

Oh user, such naivety.

User133847 · 15/03/2021 09:23

@IntermittentParps

Protests are never peaceful, they nearly always get taken over ppl who want to cause a riot. They should be banned. This is a dangerous, dangerous thing to wish for.
Protests are not the way to go.

The way to enact change is at the ballot box.

IntermittentParps · 15/03/2021 09:12

Protests are never peaceful, they nearly always get taken over ppl who want to cause a riot. They should be banned.
This is a dangerous, dangerous thing to wish for.

flashbac · 15/03/2021 09:11

@HOkieCOkie

Ok I'll play your silly game.

Let's give you an example to get this through to people with views like yours. Say something awful happened to you at the hands of the authorities. You find the same has happened to a few others. Nobody is helping you. You are left with nothing. You protest outside the office of that authority. You are arrested because you made a noise by chanting a slogan and the employees were getting distracted by watching you from the window.
Think this couldn't happen to you? That may be so but then you've just revealed what an 'I'm alright jack', 'don't give a shit about others' person you are.

OP posts:
Frazzled2207 · 15/03/2021 09:10

@HOkieCOkie

Protests are never peaceful, they nearly always get taken over ppl who want to cause a riot. They should be banned.

The violence at the Virgil this weekend! Does anyone think that helped? Hijacking a family’s grief to protest is not acceptable.

What rubbish. I am not a big protester but I turned up for the huge anti-brexit March. I think the estimation was that several million were there. Noisy at times but absolutely no trouble at all. In fact police praised us for our behaviour. The idea that I possibly couldn’t take part in something like that again fills me with horror.
ChameleonClara · 15/03/2021 08:59

@HOkieCOkie

Protests are never peaceful, they nearly always get taken over ppl who want to cause a riot. They should be banned.

The violence at the Virgil this weekend! Does anyone think that helped? Hijacking a family’s grief to protest is not acceptable.

This is absolute rubbish Confused
ChameleonClara · 15/03/2021 08:58

[quote User133847]@ChameleonClara

Yes he should never have been leader, but Labour would have sealed their own fate whoever was leader due to their Brexit policy which cost them their own heartlands and lifelong voters.[/quote]
Let's not get into how the referendum might have gone with a proper Labour leader Angry

HOkieCOkie · 15/03/2021 08:56

Protests are never peaceful, they nearly always get taken over ppl who want to cause a riot. They should be banned.

The violence at the Virgil this weekend! Does anyone think that helped? Hijacking a family’s grief to protest is not acceptable.

User133847 · 15/03/2021 08:54

@ChameleonClara

Yes he should never have been leader, but Labour would have sealed their own fate whoever was leader due to their Brexit policy which cost them their own heartlands and lifelong voters.

ChameleonClara · 15/03/2021 08:26

[quote User133847]@JustAnotherPoster00

It's easy to blame Corbyn but the question that needs asking is how did he become leader in the first place? The party had completely run out of ideas. New Labour was a busted flush and the leadership candidates in 2015 were uninspiring. None of them were on the left of the party and Corbyn was encouraged to run and then won. Labour then massively increased their vote from 2015 to 2017, but the next election was all about Brexit which the Labour Right insisted had to be run on a second referendum platform.[/quote]
This is a flawed analysis, imo.

Corbyn was a dreadful leader, leaving all internal left-right party debates aside. He just wasn't a credible candidate for PM.

Swipe left for the next trending thread