Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Priti Patel wants to ban protest. Bill going through this week.

258 replies

flashbac · 14/03/2021 08:22

The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill is some scary looking stuff. 10 year sentence for being at any protest that, amongst other things, causes or is at risk of causing 'serious annoyance'. That's all protests then is it?
The right to protest is the cornerstone of every democracy.
Aibu to be scared about where this is heading?

OP posts:
LexMitior · 15/03/2021 16:25

And why does it not matter that these women aren’t charged? I’d say that there was a clear link between that likely outcome and the Bill being introduced today.

Or would you like to tell me the relevant different degrees of legality of COVID regs v actual primary law?

LexMitior · 15/03/2021 16:24

@Bourbonic

I'm not really sure what angle you're coming from Lex but covid laws make gatherings including protests illegal just now.

It was decided at every level that the vigil could not be legally sanctioned. Whether those arrested end up being charged is sort of irrelevant, and not really any different to any other protest in that regard either.

You don’t know what happened at the high court then? You know that Covid regs definitely prohibit protest then?

The High Court and the police could do with your opinion. I think you are just repeating what you’ve read.

MercyBooth · 15/03/2021 16:16

@Bourbonic Its disrespectful to put words in her familys mouth.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.thesun.co.uk/news/14338769/sarah-everards-family-call-for-positive-change/amp/

"Andrea Everard said of the crowd: “All they were doing was showing support for Sarah and other women victims of appalling crime.
“I hope Sarah’s death can bring about some positive change.”

Nick said: “We’re grateful for all the love. We appreciate that Kate went. The support is overwhelming. Thank you to everybody.”

Frazzled2207 · 15/03/2021 14:20

@HOkieCOkie do you even understand that many of the rights you currently benefit from were gained due to the actions of protestors? Especially if you're a woman!

Indeed - why don't you google what the Sugragettes actually did. This bill says we could be sent to prison for 10 years for doing exactly what they did. Do you want to come back and argue that they shouldn't have done it? good luck with that

Graphista · 15/03/2021 14:12

@HOkieCOkie do you even understand that many of the rights you currently benefit from were gained due to the actions of protestors? Especially if you're a woman!

Banning protest massively stifles civil liberties and the possibility of gaining fair treatment for all by the state.

What kind of state do you think bans such things?

It's places like China, North Korea, Russia, Iran...

Do you REALLY want to live in a country like those?!

Think this couldn't happen to you? That may be so but then you've just revealed what an 'I'm alright jack', 'don't give a shit about others' person you are.

Yep! And attitudes like this absolutely call to mind the poem by Niemöller!

The way to enact change is at the ballot box.

That too assumes certain facts are in place - which there is some evidence already is not the case in the Uk, not to mention the flaws in the FPTP system

In addition this govt is already considering removing postal votes and making it so only those with photo ID can vote (which is expensive and for some groups virtually impossible to obtain), we can’t enact change at the ballot box if we’re prevented from voting!

The police force has been defunded for years. The court system has been defunded for years

Just watch the funding "suddenly become available" just for this!

but they don't compare to the real thing

They are far too easily ignored!

Exactly

@User133847 - here's a question, if protests are so useless and pointless - why do you think they want to stop them?!

This is what a police state looks like

Precisely

Police states rarely occur overnight, even where there's coups, there's a buildup, there are signs.

My Mp has responded that he will be voting against the bill, as I thought he would. He agrees it is disproportionate and oppressive.

people marching holding placards doesn't bother them.

Really? Then why does this bill contain clauses that would outlaw exactly this?

Most protests will be unaffected by this law.

I wholeheartedly disagree. Having read the bill most protests WILL be affected by this law

The law is to stop disruptive protests - thugs smashing shop windows and setting cars on fire, idiots supergluing themselves to trains, that sort of thing.

We already have laws to deal with more extreme behaviour like this, plenty of them!

who don't care about a particular cause from the minority who want to force them to.

That's the whole point of a protest! To get the apathetic and unaware to know, to alert people to injustices and to show in physical numbers how many people hold that same view.

How that can possibly be a bad thing I really don't know

not even the Guardian, which, for all its faults, was a liberal voice

I think "was" is the operative word here. It's long since abandoned its liberal stance

Frankly it’s desperate agreed

@CrunchyBiscs on another thread regarding the vigil and I believe even some reporters and MPs are backing this up, there are multiple reports that women SITTING in SILENCE were grabbed and roughly handled by police at the vigil, including a homeless woman and a disabled woman who was pushed off her crutches! WHILE obeying a direction from the police to move - she simply wasn’t moving as fast as they wanted because she was disabled!

Why would they act so foolishly and apparently against their own interests? Because they are feeling defensive due to one of their own being accused and their own force under scrutiny for protecting him from other prior alleged offences AND because they arrogantly think they can get away with it

But I think your use of the words thugs and idiots reveals what side you are on.

Absolutely.

I’ve been on protests and marches and to vigils in the past. I am a 5’2”, softly spoken irl, disabled woman, I have never broken the law. I have witnessed police officers being over zealous and over stepping their bounds and even arresting people who’d done absolutely nothing wrong who were then released without charge without even an official warning and apologised to. Because this is not uncommon, it’s not new, such police behaviour has been an issue for literally ages, ever since the police came into being.

Based upon this interpretation, "the minority" who have no voice anywhere else, are being silenced and will no longer have a platform to raise awareness to their issues & concerns.

This!

This is why such laws are oppressive and dangerous

It makes it illegal to stand outside parliament as an individual and shout your opinion. Illegal. How is that not a terrifying restriction of our rights???

It IS absolutely terrifying

Graphista · 15/03/2021 14:11

@Bourbonic neither the vigil nor protests have yet been completely outlawed even under covid regs

Bourbonic · 15/03/2021 13:49

I'm not really sure what angle you're coming from Lex but covid laws make gatherings including protests illegal just now.

It was decided at every level that the vigil could not be legally sanctioned. Whether those arrested end up being charged is sort of irrelevant, and not really any different to any other protest in that regard either.

Bluethrough · 15/03/2021 12:24

Most protests will be unaffected by this law. The law is to stop disruptive protests - thugs smashing shop windows and setting cars on fire, idiots supergluing themselves to trains, that sort of thing

The riot is how change can happen, poll tax, womens vote, corn laws.... the french over throwing a repessive and cruel monarchy, the peoples of eastern europe riding themselves of the Soviets.

We all support the Burmese or the HK students but we are now taking away the right to protest in a meaningful way, no one took any notice of the Iraq war or Brexit protests because they were peaceful but had they smashed up central london?

you might not care about the destruction of the planet but many do and being able to make your point is an essential part of our democracy.

At the end of the day, if the govt act properly, riots don't happen.

Out right criminality has a host of laws and sentences to curb it.

People say Johnson is a libertarian, i say he is the opposite, a dictator who cannot stand any opposition.

LexMitior · 15/03/2021 12:12

The police already have powers to handle matters. They just aren’t very good at it.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 15/03/2021 12:07

@skirk64 there's no need to tighten the laws on destruction of property in a protest. This law extends the reasons to ban a protest to include it might be 'noisy' or have an 'impact'. It also extends it to single people protests.

It makes it illegal to stand outside parliament as an individual and shout your opinion. Illegal. How is that not a terrifying restriction of our rights???

IntermittentParps · 15/03/2021 12:06

The right to protest is hugely important, even if one never or rarely uses it. It's the principle. Police and totalitarian states work by not only actually stopping or preventing 'dissenting' behaviour but by making the populace feel that they might. Eventually a populace becomes so cowed by/inured to the idea that they mustn't 'rock the boat' that they no longer do. And so the totalitarian state wins.

ItWasTheBestOfTimes · 15/03/2021 12:01

Skirk64 all protests are affected by this law, if they are noisy or cause annoyance the protester can face a fine or up to 10 years in prison. They already have powers to arrest people who are destructive during protests.

Crowsaregreat · 15/03/2021 11:44

@CrunchyBiscs it was a candlelit vigil. It was socially distanced until the police started kettling them. FFS.

NurseButtercup · 15/03/2021 11:44

It's not a police state, it's just protecting the majority who don't care about a particular cause from the minority who want to force them to.

Based upon this interpretation, "the minority" who have no voice anywhere else, are being silenced and will no longer have a platform to raise awareness to their issues & concerns.

Crowsaregreat · 15/03/2021 11:42

@skirk64 Doesn't the law make a protest illegal if it causes 'serious annoyance'? Which encompasses pretty much all protest. Noise or taking up space cause annoyance.

The minority getting the majority to care about a cause is literally what protest is about. It draws attention to a cause. That's the flipping point. When people feel upset or angry about something, in a free society they get to voice those feelings through protest.

But I think your use of the words thugs and idiots reveals what side you are on.

CrunchyBiscs · 15/03/2021 11:35

Have you not seen the pictures of police holding down a young woman?

Yes on every front page. So, as a woman she must have been sitting quietly thinking of Sarah, couldn't possibly be doing anything troublesome, disobeying police orders?
I haven't watched any footage except for the clip I mentioned which was about 10 seconds long.

I feel the media go for clicks - and a comment that some disrupters were present wouldn't have got them so they stick a photo of a woman being arrested - lots of clicks, lots of bad publicitiy for the met - win, win lots of people happy to believe that the police went in heavy handed to destroy a peaceful vigil knowing full well how much bad publicity that would get, why would they, now calls to sack Cressida and probably replace with a white male police commissioner, win win for the vigilantes

LexMitior · 15/03/2021 11:19

@Bourbonic

I don't find it worrying at all. I think the wording is pretty clear in that it is targeting destructive protests.

And of course the vigil was against the law, irrespective of how peaceful it was intended to be. So disrespectful to Sarah's family too to go against their wishes. They'll be limited on how many people can attend her funeral, meanwhile complete strangers have done this in her name. It's horrid.

Of course it was against the law? Who are you to say that? A high court judge couldn’t decide that.

I bet you that none of those women at Clapham are charged. For that reason.

LexMitior · 15/03/2021 11:17

@skirk64

Most protests will be unaffected by this law. The law is to stop disruptive protests - thugs smashing shop windows and setting cars on fire, idiots supergluing themselves to trains, that sort of thing.

Any protest that doesn't cause damage, doesn't intimidate or threaten people and allows people to go about their lawful business will still be fine. Any protest that does the opposite deserves to be shut down and the perpetrators locked up.

It's not a police state, it's just protecting the majority who don't care about a particular cause from the minority who want to force them to.

There are already plenty of laws that govern behaviour like this.

Arguably why the police want this law is that they aren’t very good at applying those laws.

Frankly it’s desperate and shows that they would rather pass more restrictions over their own people than use the powers they have, because they don’t have the man power, training, or brains to use the tools they have.

flashbac · 15/03/2021 11:16

@skirk64
Can't work out if your either very naive/trusting in authorities or you work for Priti/the Tories.

OP posts:
Bourbonic · 15/03/2021 11:13

I don't find it worrying at all. I think the wording is pretty clear in that it is targeting destructive protests.

And of course the vigil was against the law, irrespective of how peaceful it was intended to be. So disrespectful to Sarah's family too to go against their wishes. They'll be limited on how many people can attend her funeral, meanwhile complete strangers have done this in her name. It's horrid.

Heartrateslowingdown · 15/03/2021 10:50

Very worrying.

Frazzled2207 · 15/03/2021 10:49

@LadyJaye
Indeed I find it troubling. There is quite a lot of discussion on Twitter about it but hardly any on the Guardian which I usually follow fairly religiously. Why do you think that is?

LadyJaye · 15/03/2021 10:42

I'm deeply concerned about this.

We're already seeing the increasing militarisation of the police - when 'policing by consent' has historically been the covenant in the UK - and these measures smack of control by stealth.

In a move that comes as absolutely no surprise, there is very little discussion about this or the implications in the media - not even the Guardian, which, for all its faults, was a liberal voice.

pinkearedcow · 15/03/2021 10:40

Actually I think my post is wrong, under tier 4 the law forbids protests.

skirk64 · 15/03/2021 10:37

Most protests will be unaffected by this law. The law is to stop disruptive protests - thugs smashing shop windows and setting cars on fire, idiots supergluing themselves to trains, that sort of thing.

Any protest that doesn't cause damage, doesn't intimidate or threaten people and allows people to go about their lawful business will still be fine. Any protest that does the opposite deserves to be shut down and the perpetrators locked up.

It's not a police state, it's just protecting the majority who don't care about a particular cause from the minority who want to force them to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread