Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Priti Patel wants to ban protest. Bill going through this week.

258 replies

flashbac · 14/03/2021 08:22

The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill is some scary looking stuff. 10 year sentence for being at any protest that, amongst other things, causes or is at risk of causing 'serious annoyance'. That's all protests then is it?
The right to protest is the cornerstone of every democracy.
Aibu to be scared about where this is heading?

OP posts:
CrunchyBiscs · 16/03/2021 10:20

The police, as an institution, are sexist in the same way they are institutionaly racist. It's systemic.

You mean like the whole of the rest of UK society - or are you trying to say only racists and sexist people apply for the police because that is a bit of a stretch.

The racist abuse that black police officers receive from black people (and others) makes it hard to recruit them. A quarter of the met are women but shift work etc makes it hard to recruit them but I'm pretty sure there will be a determined effort to recruit more of both.

flashbac · 16/03/2021 08:59

@crunchybiscs

The police, as an institution, are sexist in the same way they are institutionaly racist. It's systemic.

OP posts:
CrunchyBiscs · 16/03/2021 05:35

Why would they act so foolishly and apparently against their own interests? Because they are feeling defensive due to one of their own being accused and their own force under scrutiny for protecting him from other prior alleged offences AND because they arrogantly think they can get away with it

You talk about 'the police' as if it's 20 bobbies in the police station down the road, with a macho attitude. FGS, there are 31,000 met police a quarter female - so you think they are all protective of the psycho murder in their lot?? So Shipman is a typical GP? Be sensible.

LexMitior · 15/03/2021 21:46

Yes! In the absence of that, both sides had an argument, which was not decided.

People write here as if the police say "unlawful" and that is the end of it. Good job its not that way.

Nacreous · 15/03/2021 21:30

The point of the court case was that one of the points on which the judge had originally been asked to rule (the police saying the protest couldn't take place because protests were not permitted under covid laws) the police then themselves agreed that protests weren't banned, and that it was a matter of proportionality to the matter in hand - the judge therefore did not rule against them as there Was No Ruling To Be Made on this item - because the police had ceded this point.

LexMitior · 15/03/2021 21:15

[quote flashbac]@bourbonic

This is taken from The Legal Feminist Twitter account:

'The Court agreed that the Covid regs do not amount to a ban on protest, because the rights to freedom of expression and freedom of assembly under the ECHR must also be taken into account (3/6)"[/quote]
Yes and it is law that all legislation in the UK must be interpreted to be human rights compatible.

The police argument wasn't accepted.

Graphista · 15/03/2021 21:11

@Bourbonic I'll admit I'm struggling to find links (which is annoying as I'm sure I saw at least 3 just a couple days ago on different sm than here and now I can't bloody find them! I must admit I struggle with this sort of thing on the apps)

So hands up there - for now at least I will keep looking

I did find this from just over a year ago

www.politicshome.com/thehouse/article/there-is-widespread-abuse-of-postal-votes-this-simply-cannot-go-on

Which albeit isn't "official" still I think shows how the presiding govt thinks on such matters

@Dustyboots totally agree! I have a Dd who is very politically engaged and she's horrified, it's much harder to get these things overturned if they are passed, than to prevent them being passed in the first place

His bafoon, teddy bear image is a hoax, that’s for sure.

I never bought into that

@LexMitior I agree, the criminalising of political action is not a route we should be going down as a supposed democracy

@Frazzled2207 msm in this country are a disgrace! Ethical journalism doesn't exist nor does impartiality. The bbc pay lip service to impartiality but don't practice it, eg the cancelling of the mash report this week (I'm not a particular fan, but I do think it is important that voices critical of the govt SHOULD be given a platform on a supposedly impartial public broadcast service!)

NOBODY with a major voice seems to be representing those of us who don't support and didn't vote for this govt - and by the way, we are NOT the minority, we're a majority! Because even though the tories won the election the majority of the electorate did not vote for them, when you combine the votes for all the other parties - and that's not even including those who couldn't/wouldn't/didn't vote for whatever reason.

It's not a minority being silenced its the majority! That's very frightening

flashbac · 15/03/2021 21:03

@bourbonic

This is taken from The Legal Feminist Twitter account:

'The Court agreed that the Covid regs do not amount to a ban on protest, because the rights to freedom of expression and freedom of assembly under the ECHR must also be taken into account (3/6)"

OP posts:
Frazzled2207 · 15/03/2021 20:59

@lightand
Yes
They are debating now
There is a suitably noisy “kill the Bill”‘protest going on outside.
MS media just not interested 😡

lightand · 15/03/2021 20:43

Bumping. Not noticed this thread before now.
Is the vote tomorrow?

Bourbonic · 15/03/2021 20:11

@LexMitior the judge didn't agree with the police because that was not what they were there to pass judgement on, and thus it would be wrong for them to make comment which would be deduced as doing so.

They found that the case against the MET police had no basis in our laws. Thus they've upheld the law and consequently found in favour of the police, yes?

Reinventinganna · 15/03/2021 19:11

‘It's not a police state, it's just protecting the majority who don't care about a particular cause from the minority who want to force them to’

Next time you want to protest to protect wildlife in your area or you want to protest against a kfc being built outside your dc school you won’t be able to. Will you care then?

Funny how it’s just as nursing unions are talking about protesting for fair pay.

MercyBooth · 15/03/2021 18:54

@LexMitior i agree. If you watch the vid the ppl on the way to work dealt with it.

LexMitior · 15/03/2021 18:51

@CrunchyBiscs

Extinction Rebellion brought central London to a standstill jeopardising the jobs of ordinary Londoners - they've been through enough with Covid - let normal life resume without issue mad protesters being allowed to ruin their living. This is what the legislation would put a stop to. Londoners should support it.
I won't support it - its tantamount to letting the Government and the police decide who offends them. I may not like BLM, or XR, but criminal offences are about harm, the seriousness of it, not annoyance or inconvenience. The redefining of those words into the criminal sphere, for a protest involving one person is totally disproportionate.

Perhaps later generations will be less happy with the decision to throw basic freedoms away on the basis of a few young idiots in Canning Town.

LexMitior · 15/03/2021 18:48

I don't think so, as charges related to protests are few and far between generally.

I agree - they are usually tactical to get rid of protesters in practice. But in a small scale event, with very few arrests, I think we can say in this case the charges are very very unlikely to be made, aren't they? And that would be because of lack of evidence.

Of course if this Bill went ahead, that wouldn't be a problem...

Covid law is an act, not a set of regs or guidelines, which draws from already existing primary law. The addition of schedule 22 allows for limits on gatherings based on any criteria as defined by the government.

That doesn't mean it is lawful, just that the government claims the power to say so. Otherwise, I would say that the High Court would have felt empowered to side with the police.

As the High Court judge refused to agree with the organisers and referred to the laws which already define gatherings as not allowed, I'd say that was fairly conclusive in them being illegal, no?

HC also refused to agree with the police either and did not conclude matters - so where does that leave your argument?

MercyBooth · 15/03/2021 18:47

@Bourbonic I suspect seeing what they have got away with re. Covid has made them more bold.

XR did make me angry when they held up the trains at Canning Town but this Bill is not the answer.

Dustyboots · 15/03/2021 18:42

Remember Boris investing in those water canon?

Ever since then I wondered what his game was. Back then he was mayor of London but it was such a strange thing to do.

His bafoon, teddy bear image is a hoax, that’s for sure.

CrunchyBiscs · 15/03/2021 18:38

Extinction Rebellion brought central London to a standstill jeopardising the jobs of ordinary Londoners - they've been through enough with Covid - let normal life resume without issue mad protesters being allowed to ruin their living.
This is what the legislation would put a stop to. Londoners should support it.

Love2cycle · 15/03/2021 18:37

@Donotfeedthebears

It’s almost as though the Meghan Markle vs the royal family stuff is being used as a distraction...
Yep I agree and also have been thinking worse things being used as a distraction.
Dustyboots · 15/03/2021 18:33

Wow. Majority of mumsnetters want our human rights and freedom of speech to be taken away. They actively want this.

Are you reading this Boris and Priti. You’re being given the go ahead. You’ve got free reign.

In which direction is our country currently heading? Away from democracy - towards autocracy. Our kids will not thank us for this.

Bourbonic · 15/03/2021 18:30

@LexMitior

And why does it not matter that these women aren’t charged? I’d say that there was a clear link between that likely outcome and the Bill being introduced today.

Or would you like to tell me the relevant different degrees of legality of COVID regs v actual primary law?

I don't think so, as charges related to protests are few and far between generally.

Covid law is an act, not a set of regs or guidelines, which draws from already existing primary law. The addition of schedule 22 allows for limits on gatherings based on any criteria as defined by the government.

As the High Court judge refused to agree with the organisers and referred to the laws which already define gatherings as not allowed, I'd say that was fairly conclusive in them being illegal, no?

Bourbonic · 15/03/2021 18:27

@MercyBooth

So going by the argument being put forward in favour of this new Bill i wonder if any can explain why it wasnt put forward after the 2011 riots.
You'd have to put that question to the government at the time really. Theresa May was home secretary so she'd be the one to tell you why it wasn't proposed.
Bourbonic · 15/03/2021 18:18

@Graphista can you please provide a link to a proposal to remove postal votes? As I recall it was suggested some 3 or so years ago on the basis of potential ballot fraud and dismissed outright.

BonnieDundee · 15/03/2021 17:18

Most protests will be unaffected by this law

The Home Secretary gets the final say on what protests are allowed. Doesnt that bother you? especially considering who the current incumbent is

MercyBooth · 15/03/2021 16:28

So going by the argument being put forward in favour of this new Bill i wonder if any can explain why it wasnt put forward after the 2011 riots.

Swipe left for the next trending thread