Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Picky Eater

32 replies

Blueberries0112 · 13/03/2021 16:19

I have a daughter who is extremely picky eater (I think she has a texture issue). I am trying to decide how to handle it.
My sister loves to cook but my daughter will not try any food. I often begged her to take a bite. Sometimes she does, sometimes she doesn’t.
What I don’t like is how she expressed herself when she doesn’t like the food. Like splitting it out or says says she doesn’t like it even before she give it a chance.

Usually, I had let her express herself and accepted and move on when she says she foesn’t like it and I prefer not to pressure her but my sister told her it is rude when someone is trying to cook for her and expect her to at least try it. What would you do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Allelbowsandtoes · 01/03/2022 10:56

So good to see so many posters saying don't force her.
I was a horribly picky eater as a child, it was the textures which were the issue for me. Anything slimy like cooked mushrooms were just awful for me, I would be trying to force them down and retching, sometimes I'd be in tears. I absolutely loved raw veg though and would happily eat loads.
It would often end in a standoff with me having to sit at the table with a cold plate of food, hours after everyone else had finished. I'd never eat it though.
As an adult although there are a couple of things I won't eat (cooked mushrooms), I have a really healthy varied diet with tons of cooked veg.
Please don't worry OP, she'll grow out of it, although I agree you could work with her on politely declining things rather than spitting out.

skyeisthelimit · 01/03/2022 10:50

Please don't force her to eat anything. I was forced by my father and school headteacher who were from the Victorian train of thought that children must obey their parents every command and eat everything that they are given.

It has left me with huge issues over food. I can't stand the texture/smell of so many things.

Ask your DD to just try it, and don't make an issue if she won't. Have a chat with her though about how it's polite to just quietly put the item on your plate and not say that its yucky or whatever.

Your DD is far more likely to eat normally when she is older if people don't pressure her now.

Sirzy · 01/03/2022 10:24

You know what she will eat. Sounds like she eats a decent balance of foods if she has fruit and veg in there.

I would tell your sister to leave feeding her to you.

Migrainesbythedozen · 01/03/2022 10:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Kcurrie · 28/02/2022 13:52

Sorry to gatcradh i cannot figure out how to start a new thread 😂 can anyone help?

Newmum912 · 21/09/2021 20:03

Hi Kastle 345 mum, im not sure that you would receive this respond, i really appreciate your thoughts. Im sorry to hear that your son is the same, must be so stressful for you both at meal time, i am so proud of you be honest, i feel that eveyday meal :(( i guess try your best mum
Yes my son 18months now, and he still has not changed anything, still picky eater, and fussy, spoon fed milk still now because he hates milk when he was 2 months old, there is no way he would hold the cup or straw to feed himself unfortunately. We are constantly worry for his eating habit (either foods or liquid). We have tried to listened to doctor again same as you, but he starved himself for 3 days without eating (i still spoon fed him milk at that time), one time he was on strike with any liquid, there was no way liwuid can go inside him for 3 weeks (i went nuts) we had to fed any fruits has juicy, i was so so stressful.
Now basically he is surving by yogurt (4 containers a day) and 3 cups of milk (sometime i add fruits) for him to have some calories :(( and one in a blue moon he would have some vege or noodle or pasta :(( but not much. I dont force him as much, i let he tried the foods, if he like them he would have abit or i would stop (bcz when i force spoon feed him, the monent the spoon went inside, i was abit happy, but right away he spat right out, he is big now, he control himself very much) i gave up :(( yogurt and milk then :((
Doctor wont listen to us, they said he is fine ( he 18months, 12kg =27lbs, he hasnt gain any weight for 4months) :(( he hasnt grow
I dunno what would i do when he start to get bigger and he will stop drink the milk or anything, whats about day care in the future :((i always stressful to take him to the public.
Me and my husband just had to accept that fact my son is really fussy and pikcy when go to foods, just suck it in and lets time fly :((
My mom has 5 kids, all she can advices me that time will pass, all kids are differetn, might take longer, but he will be fine after 3years old or 5 at least :((
I feel you, tough! hugs :)

Kastle345 · 21/09/2021 10:43

Hi @Newmum912 I'm not sure if you'll see this but I wanted to give you a huge hug and let you know you are not alone. Your story could be mine!
My LO is 33 months and became picky at 9 months old by 14 months we were down to yoghurt and crackers. He suffered from teething terribly which put him off eating. He also caught a vomiting bug at around 9 months which immediately put him off wet textures.

I too got told by a Dr to "starve him out". We tried it and it was hell - we had non-stop tantrums due to him being so hungry but he still refused food, to the point if he saw his high chair or a plate he would scream. I would be so upset after a meal, I'd have to go to my bedroom and scream into a pillow, while my partner saw to screaming LO. How could he be so visibly hungry yet refuse or destroy any food in front of him? The nursery intervened and said they could not have a child with them for four days a week not eating anything all day. I felt so ashamed & we gave up on the Drs advice. We paid for a private dietitian who told us to stop worrying about what he eats and focus on making mealtimes fun. She said to have safe food (crackers and yoghurt) available at every meal so he knows there is something he can eat alongside his meal. Serve the food describing what it is ("the carrot is crunchy" etc) but do not make any attempt to force-feed, shame or beg. You choose what to serve, he chooses what to eat. Make peace with tipping food in the bin and ignore all the "wasting food is a sin" comments , it will only make you feel bad. While they learn to love food, there will be waste, nevermind.

We had a 3-way call with nursery & dietician and nursery adopted the safe food approach. We also did lots of no-pressure food positive play at home at and at nursery. The dietician recommended we pursue the Drs for blood tests / more support to rule out medical issues like allergies, intolerance or oral motor function problems. That has taken forever as they really did not want to listen to me or the dietician but we are finally registered with a feeding clinic and see them next year.

My LO is still resistant to food and only eats a handful of things but he comes willingly to the dinner table, can touch and name everything on his plate and neither of us has anxiety over mealtimes anymore. Sometimes at social things or when I see families in cafes or restaurants, I get really sad and wish he'd change but having read the comments above, I can see it is much better to make peace with their food aversion than using force or shame. I'd love to connect/share experiences as it can be very lonely going through this. All children are different and ours have a thing about food, it does not make you a bad Mum, please look after yourself. All the best xx

Freckers · 13/06/2021 15:03

Quite a bit younger than your DD but DS14 went through a phase as a 2/3 year old and I definitely think it was texture related as well as maybe a bit of laziness with cutlery.

I kept introducing him to new foods but always with a sensible crunchy/handy accompaniment eg poppadoms with curry, garlic bread or crusty bread with a lot of things, even tortilla chips as the carb of a meal. He enjoyed the balance and learned about eating foods together from a texture point of view. He's fine with absolutely everything now barring tuna and salmon. Still occasionally has a roast dinner without gravy though which re-enforces the texture theory for me.

As for the situation overall, as with PP, create as little fuss/drama around it as posible.

KarmaStar · 13/06/2021 14:56

Agree don't force her but I understand your sister's frustration with her niece spitting when other people are eating .it is not acceptable and she is old enough to display some manners,not drawing attention to herself and making the meal unpleasant for others.

Kerantli · 13/06/2021 14:50

@Clydesider

Please don't put your daughter in situations that she can't cope with, or have her around people who are rude (like your sister) and will point out her issues.

Even now, at 51, I still have food issues (yes, texture is a huge part of it) and eat only a small variety of foods. I don't accept invitations to eat at other people's houses etc to avoid any embarrassment. I still cringe and feel shame when I think back to awkward incidents when I was young.

This is something to be worked on in private.

This . All of this.

I'm 32 and still have a lot of texture and food issues even now. Please please let her take her time in trying new things, even if it's still left on the plate at the end of the meal.

I don't eat at other peoples houses unless I know they have something I can eat, or have taken small things to eat (In-laws are the hardest for me to deal with, as I can't just disappear at meal times.)

Also, talk to your sister about her comments. Your DD doesn't need to hear them, she's 8, that is still young when to comes to broadening her horizons on food.

My DP just read over my shoulder and said "I hope you put in something about me and the seperate meals, or the restrictions in cooking when doing something for us both" - and I was going to, I'm glad that DP understands, hasn't tried to force me into trying new things unless he has my consent to add something new to a dish, and has been extremely patient with me when I have tried something and left most of it because I couldn't handle the new thing.

Also, best (worst) part of meeting someone new who wants to know of any diatry requirements is me saying "It's easier to say the things I can eat than can't..."

FactsAndFigs · 13/06/2021 14:34

@Clydesider apologies this thread is few months old so op probably done with it. It was in my notifications of someone commenting in it, which was 4days another mum asking about her son and food

Clydesider · 13/06/2021 14:28

Please don't put your daughter in situations that she can't cope with, or have her around people who are rude (like your sister) and will point out her issues.

Even now, at 51, I still have food issues (yes, texture is a huge part of it) and eat only a small variety of foods. I don't accept invitations to eat at other people's houses etc to avoid any embarrassment. I still cringe and feel shame when I think back to awkward incidents when I was young.

This is something to be worked on in private.

FactsAndFigs · 13/06/2021 14:20

@Newmum912. Totally random question but have you checked or Dr looked to see if he got tongue tie?

As long as he getting fluids I wouldn’t be worried about water one of mine refused unless I held my cup to him and then most of it went down him.

DS liked those milk ice lollies which I’d hold. Food time was very messy affair.

The Dr sounds like using that old book of bad school advice.

I can imagine that food is very stressful time for you both. Do you have routine meal times or is it random. Am much as you try to appear chilled kids know and simplest thing has to happen ie mine gagged on banana and that set tone for all foods for awhile so took lots of coxing.

Another idea if not tried something like sitting on sofa with him watching tv you eating ie a banana paying attention to tv - not offering him any, kids are very inquisitive and there is no pressure on you or him.

Another idea is to put food say on coffee table that ok for him to eat, it really can be small steps first him getting used to seeing it there but no pressure to eat, then he might start touching it, squeezing it etc. Make sure it ok to have it where u don’t mind mess.

Another trick is to get him to smell, you could do that with yoghurt he eats, get him to smell it & keep doing that. You do it too let mummy smell your yoghurt - kind of diverts focus of just eating. After few days ask him to smell a food but don’t expect or ask him to eat it. It’s kind of leading horse to water trick.

Lastly cut yourself some slack, take deep breath and remember you will get there, it really is trial & error. Do check he has no issues with mouth - lip or tongue tie.

Newmum912 · 09/06/2021 01:08

Hi everyone,
Please help me whoever gone through this.
My 15 months old hates everythibg, milk, water, foods.. (except yogurt and cucumber, abit of cracker,thats all)
He hates bottle when he was a baby (all kind), he tried to wean himself when he was 6months but we didnt let him bcz we didnt know to feed him milk bcz he cried so much when he saw bottles. We strecthed to 12months and stop breastfed. After that untill now i still have to feed him milk by using sryine and force him, same as water, he hates all cup.. :(
He was ok with solids food untill 11 months, he was quiet eat mostly of everything, spoon fed and he fed himself as well.
But The moment he turned 1 years old, meals time are nightmares, he chucked everyhting on the floor or pushed thing away, cried and cried, at first i thought could be he was teething, but it was going like this for 5 months already, i spoon fed him, and now i had to force him, he could go without solid foods for 4 days,then that time i had to increase the milk to feed him because i am afraid he didnt have enough calories.
I still let him touch all the foods,feed himself whatever he likes and play with dofferent textures, show him when i cook, no tv, soft music only.. i have tried all, he still hates foods.
We went to doctor today, he gained only tiny of weight less than 1lbs in a month (from yogurt and milk only) but he didnt grow of his height. But Doctor say he is fine, and doctor said let he starve then he will eat?? Im not sure that i can be good idea that for picky eater?
I am wondering that there is anyone go through this? Please share with me? I am so much stress, i cry everyday, why is he giving so much hard time??
I am so sorry for a long post.
But really really appreciate for your help.

Baws · 14/03/2021 20:31

Definitely don’t force her! I was like this as a child, it was all to do with textures and I would get into a real state if there was something on my plate I didn’t like the look of. Having tea at friend’s houses and going out for meals was a real ordeal too as it would make me very anxious. I have gradually improved over the years but fortunately my friends and family are very understanding and know not to suggest restaurants which would cause me an issue. I have a terrible relationship with food now as a result of being forced to eat as a child, don’t subject your daughter to this. What’s interesting is that my dad and one of my sisters have the same issue. I can remember my Stepmother saying that my sister wouldn’t grow up being as ridiculous as me when it came to eating! Hmm Do not make this an issue for your daughter and definitely have a word with your sister.

MargotMoon · 14/03/2021 07:22

@Blueberries0112

She will eat the food I cook. Including fruits and veggies. Just simple kid meals.
Sounds like the problem is your sister, not your daughter. She needs to stop policing her at meal times. Maybe you need a conversation to reminder her that you are her parent and don't want her to develop an unhealthy relationship with food so you are not going to force her to try things, just let her when she is ready?
Waxonwaxoff0 · 14/03/2021 07:09

Don't force your DD to eat anything.

I was an extremely picky eater as a child and I was so embarrassed by it. When I went over to friends houses for dinner I had to ask my mum to check what they were serving in case I didn't like it. When we went out to a restaurant I used to work myself up so much worrying that there would be nothing on the menu that I would eat I felt physically sick with anxiety, which didn't help the eating!

I'm not fussy at all now as an adult so it's sorted itself out over time. I'd have hated to be forced to eat things I don't like and it probably would have made me physically vomit.

I would perhaps address the spitting out as that's not great table manners but for now I'd just give her what she likes.

ChameleonClara · 14/03/2021 06:22

@Blueberries0112

Yeah, I am not going to worry about it, I will continue to make what our daughter likes to eat. My sister is staying with us because of job loss
Have a quiet word with your sister then - it is actually your sister being rude, not your daughter.
charlottemont · 13/03/2021 19:43

I was a fairly picky eater as a child, and I often found it very embarrassing, so I agree with the others to not make it seem like a big deal to her. At the same time, though, I would recommend talking to her and asking if she could just try one small bite of everything. If she does not like it, she does not need to continue eating. That's how my parents handled it with me and it worked very well because your taste evolves over time and you just need to keep trying!

TheBabyAteMyBrain · 13/03/2021 19:37

Never make food a battle, you'll create more issues than you'll ever solve.

Respect your child and their boundaries.

Ynwa12345 · 13/03/2021 19:33

My nearly 8 year old DS also has these problems with food. It's obviously different as your sister has just moved in and is prob trying to help by cooking for the kids /you. I agree with pp with even trying it is amazing and a well done and keep a tissue by the side...again my child will eat what you give simple pastaodr veggies and fruits but new or diff textures he's unwilling.

Stroppyshite · 13/03/2021 19:28

I think it's unreasonable to force an 8 year old child to eat something they don't want, especially one with textural issues. I think
work on politely declining/not spitting it out overtly if she has tried and doesn't like something. Sounds cliché, but cooking together really helps if you've not done so already.
Your sister needs to back off though. Don't let this become a huge issue. Kids can sometimes exert control with food.

SeaToSki · 13/03/2021 19:10

When my dc were little we had a sniff it and lick it rule. If it was being served then you had to sniff it and lick it but were then completely entitled to leave it on the side of the plate. Dramatic yucks were not allowed either as someone had spent time and money making the food, so politeness was required. Somehow knowing they wouldnt have to put any food in their mouths destressed alot of the battles

Jumpers268 · 13/03/2021 16:42

My son's 6 and not great on food. If I get him to try anything new, even if he spits it out he gets a massive well done for trying. I don't force anything as above, put it on the table with stuff she does like and maybe once in a blue moon she'll try it Wink. Also, as above, I give him kitchen roll when trying something new so he can spit it out if he wants to and that relieves some of the anxiety. Good luck.

FactsAndFigs · 13/03/2021 16:31

Sorry I was typing whilst you updated