Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ban DD from watching Anime?

105 replies

SmellsLikeTeenBedroom · 12/03/2021 09:29

My 11yo DD has just told me her group of friends (Y7) are into Anime. She has watched a couple of things they suggested and said she likes it.

This rings alarm bells for me. I've read bad things about anime: misoginistic, hyper-sexualised, pornograpgic, unhealthy body image, confusing messages about gender, furries.

However, I dont know nearly enough about this. I'm sure there must be good and bad anime (Pokemon etc) but is there a way of distinguishing (without watching every bloody video with her)? I'm inclined to just keep dd away from all of it, but maybe that's an overreaction.

I am not afraid to ban my dd from something all her friends are allowed, but feel like I need to be able to explain why, and at the moment I can't.

(Just to pre-empt any "just tell her its because I said so"/"you'rethe parent" responses: yes, obviously I know that, but if I'm creating a division between dd and the rest of her friendship group at a time when transition to secondary school and making friends has already been so disrupted, I need to know it's worth it)

OP posts:
EmpressSuiko · 12/03/2021 11:15

I would let her start with films from studio Ghibli, studio Ponoc (if you have Netflix they have some movies on there).

You could try Mamoru Hosoda movies like wolf children and the boy and the beast, Makoto Shinkai movies, family friendly and great for all ages.

Oh and a silent voice is a fab movie on Netflix!

For anime series you have sites like crunchyroll or funimstion, it’s a subscription service.

Our hero acadamia is a great one, along with dragon ball z (it’s a classic bit fantastic!), Eureka Seven, the little witch academy, flying witch, AnoHana is a sweet one and there’s plenty of slice of life shows like Barakamon.

Naruto is very popular one as well.

As you can tell we watch a lot of anime!

The best advice I can give you is to read what the show is about and have a look at the age rating.
If you google family friendly anime series there’s whole lists of shows that have no nudity, perverse jokes or violence/bad language.

Iwantacookie · 12/03/2021 11:05

Ffs I misread and thought you said Annie. I did wonder what version you had seen Blush

Xiaoxiong · 12/03/2021 10:53

Also to add - just because an anime series has kids as the main characters doesn't make it suitable for kids either. Neon Genesis again being a good example. This is really different from Western series - if you heard that an American cartoon series was about a group of 13/14 year olds, you'd think it was probably aimed at younger kids (like the harry potter books or something), but Japanese ones aren't necessarily - you have to check them out a bit more.

greatauntfanny · 12/03/2021 10:50

OP, a few things.

Firstly, as others have said 'anime' is just Japanese animation. A.k.a. cartoons.

So you have effectively asked 'should I ban my daughter from watching Japanese cartoons'.

To which the answer is obviously you should not ban her from watching the anime (cartoons) made for children/teens. Otherwise you would be saying 'you can't watch any cartoons if they've been made in Japan' which would be a weird and xenophobic thing to say.

Some cartoons are made for adults. Think south park, family guy, drawn together. These can be very rude/violent, so you probably do not want your 11 year old watching them.

Then you have cartoon porn. This can be found on porn sites but also pops up elsewhere. The anime version is called hentai. There is 'non-anime' cartoon porn too (e.g. made in the UK/US/Germany). However, presumably the existence of cartoon porn doesn't mean you have stopped your daughter from watching all cartoons in case one day SpongeBob Squarepants gets down and dirty.

Child friendly: Pokemon, Digimon, all Studio Ghibli films, Cardcaptors, Inuyasha, Dragonball, Beyblade

Teen (12/13+ really but won't do an 11 year old any harm): Fruits Basket, Ouran high school host club, Yuri on ice, blue exorcist, attack on Titan

Think your answer is to find out what she watches and check it yourself. Just google it, look at the rating.

Don’t ban the lot just because you don’t understand it. That attitude will cause you a lot of problems in this subject and in life in general ;)

Xiaoxiong · 12/03/2021 10:49

For those saying Attack on Titan is ok - I found it incredibly gory and violent, I wouldn't want any 11 year old of mine watching it for a few years yet but I guess each to their own. That's a good example of a parent needing to watch an episode or two to decide for themselves what they're comfortable having their kids seeing.

Neon Genesis Evangelion the same - I watched it as an adult and loved it, but was shocked it's rated pg-13. There's a tonne of super disturbing imagery in there as well as very adult themes.

I do think sometimes the ratings get skewed younger because it's animation so it's seen as childish or less intense.

Xiaoxiong · 12/03/2021 10:41

I like some anime but the messaging around gender roles vary from wholesome and progressive, to super sexist. Common Sense Media isn't a bad place to read up on different series.

I would really keep her away from fan sites on the internet and Tumblr. It's fine just chatting with her friends about age-appropriate series. My kids love Avatar: the last airbender which I know isn't "proper" anime but is in an anime style.

pointythings · 12/03/2021 10:41

I think rather than an outright ban, you need to do some research. Anime is incredibly broad, as pp have mentioned. My DD2 is very into it, but has zero interest in the hentai or violent ones. She particularly likes Haikyu (which is about volleyball) and watches Ghibli movies regularly. I've really enjoyed sharing them with her - Ponyo is probably my favourite.

Crayfishforyou · 12/03/2021 10:37

That depends
If it’s ghost in the shell, Blood the last vampire l, she the ultimate weapon or ghibli - YABU

If it’s Akira, dragon knight, The testament of sister new devil or High school or anything even mildly hentai - YANBU

Anime just means animated, there are hundreds of genres of it. Some of it is spectacular.

andweallsingalong · 12/03/2021 10:37

Some of the studio ghibli films are on Netflix so would be easy to start watching those with her.

SionnachRua · 12/03/2021 10:33

Attack on Titan is fab and the theme song will burn its way into your brain. Tokyo ghoul is amazing too. But a bit gory.

TheGoogleMum · 12/03/2021 10:28

Fullmetal alchemist: brotherhood is my favourite anime

GingerBeverage · 12/03/2021 10:26

Get the names of the specific anime that her friends are into and research them.
I can fairly well guarantee you that her peers are not going gaga for 30 year old Studio Ghibli films. More likely to be about series fandoms.
Try and read up on yaoi. It's extremely popular with young girls.

Rhayader · 12/03/2021 10:25

As a child I watched “hikaru no go” which lead to a lifelong love of the board game Go. It’s very wholesome!

Rhayader · 12/03/2021 10:25

Some anime will be on www.commonsensemedia.org

Slidepastthevoid · 12/03/2021 10:24

Have you ever watched the stuff she watches or are you just making assumptions based on alarmist things you have read?

There are many different types of anime, as pp have said.

demelza82 · 12/03/2021 10:22

Also if you have an HMV near you when they reopen - have a look there. They tend to have an anime section where you can have a good physical look and are competitively priced with Amazon. if I remember correctly they tend to put together boxsets of similar level anime films

Hoppinggreen · 12/03/2021 10:14

@therocinante

Loads of anime is fine. Attack on Titan for example - very popular series, has won awards, nothing to be concerned about.
Some of AOT is a bit scary Try My Hero Academia or the basketball one I forget the name of
demelza82 · 12/03/2021 10:12

With regards to the films - BBFC website are the place to go if you want more info about the content.youd be best off researching some potential titles on blogs/Amazon and then digging in deeper from there

I am.not a huge anime expert bit there's some great Pg/12 ones if Studio Ghibli pitches too young - Your Name is fantastic. Ditto A Silent Voice, Mary and the with flower and The Girl Who Leapt Through Time. Grave of the Fireflies is amazing but a very tough watch for even adults and o would personally look at the themes around this one before suggesting it

Hoppinggreen · 12/03/2021 10:12

My 16 year old DD and 12 year old DS are into anime.
Some of it is very dark and the number of 12 year olds with big boobs Is pretty disturbing
However, some of it is appropriate so do your research and steer her accordingly (and don’t accidentally buy her a Hentai Tshirt because those faces ARENT like that because they are laughing )

daisyjgrey · 12/03/2021 10:10

You want to ban something you know nothing about?

Surely the logical approach would be to find out about it and then you'll know which parameters to set?

Ilovemaisie · 12/03/2021 10:09

Just check the age ratings. All films have them. TV programmes the information is usually on line (that may just be recommended age so you use your judgement).
Manga books (Manga = books, Anime = films/telly) usually have age ratings printed on the cover. Something other book genres rarely have.

Thehawki · 12/03/2021 10:07

Sailor Moon is an age appropriate series if you’re looking for something. Avatar is American but in the style of anime and it’s amazing. Pokemon is also great. Naruto is a good one. Any studio Ghibli is age appropriate, you could start off with one a week to keep her going? I think with manga you could just flip through to make sure the themes aren’t sexual or overly violent.If she wants to watch any particular series tell her to come to you and google them individually.

I do understand your concern as it can be hard to tell from the outside, but lots of anime is 100% age appropriate and really fun to watch! It will probably be a fun thing for her to get into, it just needs monitoring.

Crappyfridays7 · 12/03/2021 10:07

Really? My son loves Anime and has watched it for years, he’s 11 next week abs loves all things Japanese, he’s taught himself how to write and is learning how to speak Japanese. Anyway I have controls over what he can see and it’s all age appropriate he can’t access stuff with anything inappropriate on his iPad. And I check his history as you do with kids just in case anything slips through. Surely you just research this and you’d discover it wasn’t all based on your preconceived ideas?... rather than a knee jerk ban?

SionnachRua · 12/03/2021 10:06

Anime is like any other media. Some is appropriate for kids, some is not. There's nothing inherently wrong about it.

AWhisperWillDoIfThatsAllYouCan · 12/03/2021 10:04

I've been watching anime and reading manga since I was that age. There are some really lovely animes. There are also some very explicit ones. It's like every other type of book of tv style. Some lovely, some extreme.

Just check the content of what she is getting into.

Swipe left for the next trending thread