Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ban DD from watching Anime?

105 replies

SmellsLikeTeenBedroom · 12/03/2021 09:29

My 11yo DD has just told me her group of friends (Y7) are into Anime. She has watched a couple of things they suggested and said she likes it.

This rings alarm bells for me. I've read bad things about anime: misoginistic, hyper-sexualised, pornograpgic, unhealthy body image, confusing messages about gender, furries.

However, I dont know nearly enough about this. I'm sure there must be good and bad anime (Pokemon etc) but is there a way of distinguishing (without watching every bloody video with her)? I'm inclined to just keep dd away from all of it, but maybe that's an overreaction.

I am not afraid to ban my dd from something all her friends are allowed, but feel like I need to be able to explain why, and at the moment I can't.

(Just to pre-empt any "just tell her its because I said so"/"you'rethe parent" responses: yes, obviously I know that, but if I'm creating a division between dd and the rest of her friendship group at a time when transition to secondary school and making friends has already been so disrupted, I need to know it's worth it)

OP posts:
enchantedspleen · 12/03/2021 18:33

There are so many wholesome, child friendly anime with fantastic female leads.
Cardcaptor Sakura,
Detective Conan,
Little Witch academia,
Studio Ghibli (steer clear of Grave if the fireflies until you feel your DD can handle especially hard hitting stuff
See also- In this corner of the world, and Barefoot Gen. Kids NEED to see these in my opinion but they need to be old enough to handle very heartrending scenes of war and death.
My next life as a business
Ascendance of a bookworm
Even the 90s Moomins cartoon is technically an anime!

None of these are sexual or concerning for young girls. I get your concerns, but to deny an entire genre will be shutting your daughter out of a world of adventure and imagination. There is trash out there, god almighty. Stay away from anything that's has "loli" "guro" "hentai" "ecchi" in its description. But dont let the trash ruin the treasures, if you get my meaning.
Research, and use it as a bonding experience together, maybe?

Itsjustaride8w737 · 12/03/2021 15:21

There's lots of good anime, just need to do your research. I had to ban something called 'Gacha life', most of the videos were fine but a few had misogynistic terms and violence!

As pp said Pokemon is good, completely harmless. I'd also recommend checking what your child is watching as there's so much crap on youtube. I have access to dds watch history so I can see exactly what she watches. She hates it but tough she's only 12!

trhfxbtht · 12/03/2021 15:18

Would you ban her from watching films because films like Saw exist? How do you stop her from watching other kinds of inappropriate media?

FolkyFoxFace · 12/03/2021 15:15

It's such a wide genre. I'd say do research before banning it - just as you would with any TV show or movie she was watching? A lot of it is fine, a lot of it is explicit, just like any genre out there.

I absolutely loved it as a teen and still have a soft spot now. Led on to all kinds of other interests, including music, history, art, fashion, etc.

Just monitor it in the same way you'd monitor anything else! Anime in and of itself is in no way harmful.

happysunr1se · 12/03/2021 15:01

If you go on an anime streaming website there will normally be a way of filtering by genre.

You can then click on the specific series and it will have a synopsis and you can see the tags; violence, nudity...whatever.

I use animegogo, anilinkz, anime season, anime planet...

A lot of cartoons which are otherwise suitable for younger viewers will still have stereotypes (girls being passive, only interested in hair and make-up etc etc) and also big boobed girls/women. For eg One Piece where the main female character wears a bikini top the whole time with huge boobs. Or My Hero Academia; the female love interest has to wear a skintight costume, the main female superhero too.

There's nothing you can do to filter this out. I guess it's still the prevailing attitude in the anime studios that this type of sexual representation is still OK in Japan.

Some anime that may be suitable;

Natsume's book of friends; about a highschool boy and traditional Japanese folklore characters.

Tanten gakuen Q: about a school for child detectives

Kadocha; about a girl who is a child actress and is at primary school, fun and wacky but also discusses mature issues like being adopted, bullying, parents death.

Arte, about a young woman who wants to be an artist in renaissance Italy.

Hanako of the toilet; about a girl who sees a ghost that haunts the school toilets. Sounds a bit dodgy but isn't.

Also;
Princess principal
Deca-dence
How to keep a mummy
Zombieland saga
8th son, are you kidding me?
My next life as villainess...

I've watched all of these as an adult and enjoyed them. Maybe you could watch together. But if you want to try watching some for yourself, here's some adult anime that I rate highly;

Id:invaded
Acca
Kokkoku
Steins Gate
Golden kamui
Vinland saga
Nodame cantabile
Shinseki yori
Ajin
Parasyte

SingToTheSky · 12/03/2021 13:44

I understand that smellslike - have been through similar lately with my DD1. 💐
Hopefully she can start enjoying some new stuff to talk about with friends and will be equipped to avoid anything inappropriate.

SmellsLikeTeenBedroom · 12/03/2021 13:24

Thanks for all the helpful comments. I take the point about comparing it to South Park etc. I have not banned anything and would not do without looking into it first. Posting here was the first step in that, and its useful to hear different peoples perspectives. I'm a bit knee jerk with anything around body image/gender atm: DD just started at all girls school this year and it has been an eye-opener...

OP posts:
frogswimming · 12/03/2021 13:04

I have to say I understand how you feel. It is harder to know what is ok and what isn't when you aren't familiar with it. I know peppa pig is ok and family guy isn't because I am familiar with them. I'm not familiar with anime and I don't know the pointers to whether something is ok or not.

SingToTheSky · 12/03/2021 12:59

I’m not sure about Ouran High - I loved it and it was so funny but from what I remember there’s a fair bit of innuendo etc? About the twins especially. I might be wrong though, it’s years since I watched it

SingToTheSky · 12/03/2021 12:55

I’m currently looking at my giant cuddly No Face :o

One series my two really like atm is Haikyuu, about volleyball

cliftonbear · 12/03/2021 12:48

@ExcusesAndAccusations

Death Note is not suitable for 11 year olds! Especially given the OP’s general stance on unsuitable content.
but it’s such a classic! haha i think maybe i’m biased though as all my friends and i were obsessed with death note at that age 😅
minniemoocher · 12/03/2021 12:47

Spirited away is a good entry movie, properly on Netflix.

TeacupDrama · 12/03/2021 12:47

my 11 DD watches my hero academia yuri on ice sailor moon one about basketball it is fine I check history etc she hates kissing stuff and knows some is bad we chat about things so I know what she watches without watching everything

ExcusesAndAccusations · 12/03/2021 12:46

Death Note is not suitable for 11 year olds! Especially given the OP’s general stance on unsuitable content.

Soubriquet · 12/03/2021 12:33

Calcifer*

Soubriquet · 12/03/2021 12:33

Oh Howls moving castle!

I used to love that film. Haven’t seen it in ages

My favourite was obviously Calciferol Grin

FrankButchersDickieBow · 12/03/2021 12:31

Howls Moving Castle and Kiki's Delivery Service are both age appropriate and brilliant and the other SG ones mentioned.

cliftonbear · 12/03/2021 12:26

I’ve made a rec list of good anime that should be suitable for 11 year olds!

disastrous life of saiki k
love live!
the promised neverland (though the theme of this anime is that children are raised on a farm to be eaten by demons so if that’s not suitable by your standards just a heads up!)
death note
madoka magica
mew mew power
ouran highschool host club (this show is SO good)
lucky star
demon slayer

LeviAckerman · 12/03/2021 12:20

I got into anime recently as my 16 year old is into it and asked me to watch Attack on Titan. Bonding with a teen boy can be tricky as we don’t exactly share many interests so I agreed to watch. It's so SO good! We've started watching other ones together. We get up early so we have peace. It's been good for us. (It's a 15 so not suitable for your DD, not sexual stuff, just gory at times)

Obviously it's less an issue with an 11 year old as they mostly still think you’re great. Grin

Don’t ban it. There's so many great shows that will be a good influence on your DD.

Meruem · 12/03/2021 12:20

DS and I have watched numerous anime series together since he was around 11 (he’s now 31!). We’ve seen some really good ones and they often have themes of friendship, family, not giving up on your goals, being kind. etc. Things that are good for young people to absorb. DS actually ended up doing a degree in Japanese and worked in Japan for a while. Try watching something with her, you may surprise yourself!

Eteri · 12/03/2021 12:12

Oh, and Sailor Moon for a real classic.

Man that show gets a bad wrap, but I've been rewatching the dub lately and I actually think it's my favorite 90's sitcome. So far ahead of its time, and absolutely worth the hype.

Eteri · 12/03/2021 12:08

There are some fabulous anime out there. Maybe try and get her onto some movies like studio Ghibli and I want to eat your pancreas (which despite the weird name is a real tear jerker about teenage friendship and pancreatic cancer), then move onto the classics (Haruhi Suziymia, Ouran Highschool host club, death note, Angel beats, maybe even Black Butler), sports anime (Free! And yuri on ice), and a good slice of life (Kimi to Boku).

Member984815 · 12/03/2021 11:55

My kids love anime , ghibli studio is a big hit just watch for age ratings

ExcusesAndAccusations · 12/03/2021 11:53

This is a useful selection of ratings from Commonsense Media
www.commonsensemedia.org/lists/anime-tv-for-teens-and-tweens
Netflix has a whole bunch of anime which will all have age ratings on it. If she sticks to that with age ratings ideally 12 and below but certainly no higher than 15 rather than random internet stuff she’ll not go too badly wrong.
But banning an entire genre is not good parenting.

thelegohooverer · 12/03/2021 11:45

I’m not sure banning it outright is even possible. She’s going to see it on someone else’s screen if you ban it on your house.

I dislike it intensely. My dc got into Pokemon which I wasn’t thrilled about. The gender roles are awful and the implications about how we treat animals are awful too. I try and open up discussions around these things but we’re quickly getting to the stage of heavy sighing because Mum is missing the point again!

Avatar was quite good I thought, but I wasn’t prepared for dd to come across porn for the first time searching for images of her favourite Avatar characters to draw. Really, really vile pictures. It broke my heart that that has been her first exposure to sex.

You have to be incredibly more vigilant than you imagine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread