Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ban DD from watching Anime?

105 replies

SmellsLikeTeenBedroom · 12/03/2021 09:29

My 11yo DD has just told me her group of friends (Y7) are into Anime. She has watched a couple of things they suggested and said she likes it.

This rings alarm bells for me. I've read bad things about anime: misoginistic, hyper-sexualised, pornograpgic, unhealthy body image, confusing messages about gender, furries.

However, I dont know nearly enough about this. I'm sure there must be good and bad anime (Pokemon etc) but is there a way of distinguishing (without watching every bloody video with her)? I'm inclined to just keep dd away from all of it, but maybe that's an overreaction.

I am not afraid to ban my dd from something all her friends are allowed, but feel like I need to be able to explain why, and at the moment I can't.

(Just to pre-empt any "just tell her its because I said so"/"you'rethe parent" responses: yes, obviously I know that, but if I'm creating a division between dd and the rest of her friendship group at a time when transition to secondary school and making friends has already been so disrupted, I need to know it's worth it)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Balonzette · 14/08/2021 08:35

Studio Ghibli is anime and it's beautiful. Not any of the things you mentioned.

Iimaginethiswillbefun · 14/08/2021 08:31

Dd has ASD and is anime obsessed. She is 16.

She watches:

Attack on Titan
A new one called Jujitsu something Kaisan?
Death Note
One about an attorney? Ace Attorney??

I got her a crunchy roll subscription for her birthday.

I try and watch some with her but she gets annoyed with the amount of questions I have.

ASimpleLampoon · 14/08/2021 02:00

Go by the age ratings. They all have them just like any film. Loads on Netflix and if your CD watches on a child profile it should be OK.

BillyWhozz · 13/08/2021 16:46

There are some lovely PG/U rated anime films. I think some people don't realise how broad a genre it really is. Just treat it on a film by film basis as you would anything else and stick to the certifications you'd be comfortable with. Or read the Wiki pages of any specific film she mentions.

If your DD said she wanted to watch musicals you'd probably be fine with Oliver but not the South Park movie. Similar thing here.

Hemingwaycat · 13/08/2021 16:40

It’s just Japanese animation. Why have you decided it’s all misogynistic and sexualised exactly? So ignorant.

My DC love anime. We watched the whole studio ghibli collection when they were 5, 6 and 7 and we’ve watched it a few times since. They’re into my hero academia atm and they like little witch academia too. It isn’t sexualised or misogynistic.

It’s all age rated like anything else so avoid the 15s and 18s, the rest will be fine.

Rannva · 13/08/2021 16:37

@MumCookingBacon

You make very good points! However, Anime is not all bad. You can look in to these Animes and maybe find an appropriate one. Just make sure you and her stay of of hanime and hentaihaven these website scared my kids for life. Try Animes like bit.ly/3sYtEHo, or one me and my 6 yr old DD enjoyed was this one; bit.ly/3vfxNrY. (they links take you to parent review sites, so you can see the age rating) this one is good too bit.ly/2Pq620B I hope you reconsider banning this.
How the hell did your kids end up on 'hentaihaven'? Put the pc in a public room, sit with them! Jeez.
Rannva · 13/08/2021 16:35

When you 'don't know anything about' something, you learn.

Some anime is sexual. Some isn't. It's just the medium - animation from Japan. Some animation from America is sexual but you wouldn't ban her from Disney movies.

Just google around a bit for 'anime suitable for 11 year old girl' and look at the age ratings, just as you would a normal TV show or film.

You sort the good from the bad in just the same way - you already know she's not going to be watching The Witcher, but she can watch Frozen.

Your Name is a good film. I hate Ghibli stuff personally, the art style turns my stomach and the plots are dull af, but if you just look at 12 rated stuff you should be fine.

Subbaxeo · 13/08/2021 15:59

My son (22) has always loved Japanese films and culture and when I accompanied my dh he gave me a long list of anime books/magazines to get. None of them were sexual. We went to a huge anime bookstore and there are so many different genres. Loads of teenage girls there. Banning all anime because some have sexual content is like banning western comics/magazines because there may be unpleasant content. Educate her to be discriminating rather than banning.

Rivermonsters · 13/08/2021 15:49

YABU I was watching pornography at her age. Anime ain’t bad, how is it misogynistic?

Jayhas4eyes · 13/08/2021 15:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

iolaus · 11/08/2021 21:22

There are age rating - you sound like my mum a few years ago when my son asked for some anime for christmas - she rang me up saying he'd asked for cartoon porn when she googled it

When I told her to put the age rating on when she was picking what to buy she calmed down and only got him PG stuff

It's Japanese animation - a drawing style - some good, some bad.

HarrisMcCoo · 11/08/2021 21:16

@thelegohooverer

I’m not sure banning it outright is even possible. She’s going to see it on someone else’s screen if you ban it on your house.

I dislike it intensely. My dc got into Pokemon which I wasn’t thrilled about. The gender roles are awful and the implications about how we treat animals are awful too. I try and open up discussions around these things but we’re quickly getting to the stage of heavy sighing because Mum is missing the point again!

Avatar was quite good I thought, but I wasn’t prepared for dd to come across porn for the first time searching for images of her favourite Avatar characters to draw. Really, really vile pictures. It broke my heart that that has been her first exposure to sex.

You have to be incredibly more vigilant than you imagine.

We were checking DS's social media account and one friend had mentioned Hentai so DH had to have a word with him about why it was not appropriate to view. He is 14.

So much to learn as a parent. I had never heard of it before. Definitely we all need to be vigilant.

I have seen animé porn and it's pretty disgusting stuff to be fair. Incredibly graphic. You can't unsee it😬

Jayhas4eyes · 11/08/2021 20:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MumCookingBacon · 27/04/2021 01:17

You make very good points!
However, Anime is not all bad.
You can look in to these Animes and maybe find an appropriate one.
Just make sure you and her stay of of hanime and hentaihaven
these website scared my kids for life.
Try Animes like bit.ly/3sYtEHo, or one me and my 6 yr old DD enjoyed was this one; bit.ly/3vfxNrY. (they links take you to parent review sites, so you can see the age rating)
this one is good too bit.ly/2Pq620B
I hope you reconsider banning this.

Anchoredowninanchorage · 15/03/2021 18:50

Thankyou for posting all the anime suggestions, my dd is also very keen and has been going on about Danganropa ?? She’s just seen pics of cosplay and mercy not sure if she’s sneakily watched it on YouTube , anyone know what it’s about?
We watched a silent voice yesterday together, she loved it !

JaninaDuszejko · 12/03/2021 21:25

I can fairly well guarantee you that her peers are not going gaga for 30 year old Studio Ghibli films.

My 11yo and particularly my 13yo are still obsessed with My Neighbour Totoro. They've been watching it since they were tiny and love it in the same way they love Disney cartoons. DD1 got Studio Ghibli socks at Christmas and wears them all the time.

I actually actively encouraged then watching Studio Ghibli U and PG films when they were little because it is so different to Disney, the films are much less frenetic than modern Disney films. And the animation is gorgeous. They've been forced to watch lots of European animation as well for the same reason.

AWhisperWillDoIfThatsAllYouCan · 12/03/2021 20:26

I used to love Vision of Escaflowne.

There really are a lot of great ones out there. Dont be afraid of anime as a blanket rule!

sbhydrogen · 12/03/2021 20:23

Hell yeah Sailor Moon 🌙

sbhydrogen · 12/03/2021 20:21

All films have age guidance on them, so just look at that. Do your streaming services have parental guidance turned on? It was easier when everything was on DVD or VHS so you could easily see, haha.

As for manga, ask for recommendations from a bookseller (once bookshops are open again).

UnitedRoad · 12/03/2021 20:14

@Iwantacookie Me too. I was intrigued! Love Annie, didn’t think I’d like the newer version with Cameron Diaz but I love that too.

I know nothing about Anime however.

KevinTheGoat · 12/03/2021 19:38

YABU. It's not all hentai. Some shounen anime such as Naruto and One piece are a bit problematic, but then you have magical girl shows aimed at girls like Pretty Cure, Sailor Moon and Cardcaptor Sakura/Cardcaptors, shows about games like Yu-Gi-Oh and Pokemon, and slice-of-life stuff like Azumanga Daioh which is pretty harmless. I mean, I don't think she should watch stuff like Hellsing, which is very violent, but there are a lot of different types of anime out there.

Bellemb · 12/03/2021 19:00

@SmellsLikeTeenBedroom YABU, as other posters have said, anime is not a genre. I also think you might have the idea that anime is random videos that you have to police individually? This is not true. Just like for TV and film, there are feature-length productions, short stories, long series, you name it. If your DD started watching Naruto for example, that's over 300 episodes of TV.

In terms of content, it's again no different from Western offerings. Whoever said Attack On Titan is fine because it has won hundreds of awards needs to get their head checked. Attack on Titan is a great show, but it's not for 11-year-olds. Similarly to how I think Django unchained is a great movie, but I'm not about to watch it with a child.

Some suggestions for shows with strong female leads:

Anything Ghibli, though as someone said, Grave of the Fireflies can be upsetting at her age.

Chihayafuru

Full metal alchemist

Haibane Renmei

A silent voice

There are also very popular shows that have male leads, and can be watched by all ages, Haikyuu springs to mind.

Basically, there's anime out there for everyone, from drama to comedy to sports and to psychological thrillers. It's becoming more mainstream now as well due to Netflix getting more shows, so please don't dismiss it as some kind of weird alt-entertainment for adult men.

Common sense media has age ratings for anime, same as other media.

ginnybag · 12/03/2021 18:57

NOT attack on titan for an 11 year old girl.

Hell, no!!

Episode one has the lead character watching his mother get eaten alive!!

Op, we're big anime fans.

My 11 yo DD loves Naruto, Fruits Basket, Full Metal Alchemist (although give this a watch first) Also Yuri On Ice, although there's the odd sexy comment in a couple of places.

The Gundam series (there are many and not related) are free of over-sexualisation and has some decent characters and plots

PrelovedWithValue · 12/03/2021 18:53

Banning all anime is basically the same as banning all cartoons, because some have adult or dodgy content.

There is amazing anime out there, and you've had some great suggestions already.

enchantedspleen · 12/03/2021 18:34

my next life as a business
Sorry, that's meant to read
"My next life as a villainess" ! Sorry!

Swipe left for the next trending thread