Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stepmum and mothers day

484 replies

Thattimeoftheyearagain · 11/03/2021 13:19

Stepmum here! A nice one I like to think. I am not mum but I do a lot of mum duties for them Aibu to be recognised on Sunday? Not as mum but just a thank you for everything I do? I know its mothers day but its not like there's a step mothers day?

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 12/03/2021 10:22

I stand by what I said - those who feel they've had it easy in forming positive SM-SC relationships or feel they are "excellent" SMs, have not just achieved this simply because they "put in the required effort" - they have almost certainly also (luckily) had a relatively easier ride in terms of the multiple and complex dynamics outlined above that affect the relationship.

Absolutely agree, well said!

HappyStep1 · 12/03/2021 10:17

You're not their Mum.

And don't we know it Smile. I very much love my DSChildren and think we have a pretty good relationship but I would never expect anything on Mother's Day, if nothing else they might upset their Mum.

However, plenty of step parents do lots of stuff for their partners children and get very little if any acknowledgement, tis the life of a step!

LucieStar · 12/03/2021 10:16

I think people forget (or choose to ignore) that the SM-SC relationship is a two way one like any other. It's not simply a case of SM makes the effort and is lovely, kind and welcoming and all is dandy. There is another human on the end of that relationship, child or not makes no difference - they are responding to that effort regardless and bringing their own personality and interaction to the table. That affects the dynamic whether people want to recognise it or not. Added to this, the SM-SC relationship is in some ways harder to establish than that with your own child or any other adult, because it's affected by outside influences and dynamics over which you have little control (dynamics that don't affect other types of relationship including the parent-child one or the partner-partner one), including first and foremost the dynamics brought to the table by the child's two parents. You're essentially caught in the middle of all of that, trying to navigate the influence of multiple personalities and relationships.

So your own efforts are one small part of the picture. I stand by what I said - those who feel they've had it easy in forming positive SM-SC relationships or feel they are "excellent" SMs, have not just achieved this simply because they "put in the required effort" - they have almost certainly also (luckily) had a relatively easier ride in terms of the multiple and complex dynamics outlined above that affect the relationship.

aSofaNearYou · 12/03/2021 10:09

@LucieStar

People forget that the step parent relationship is a reciprocal thing, influenced not only by how the child responds to your attempts to build a relationship, but also by multiple other factors outside of your control include amount of contact, the resident parent's (sometimes negative) influence on how SCs feel towards you, the expectations and/or limitations imposed upon you by your partner in terms of what degree of involvement you "should" be having, etc. You don't have to navigate any of this with your own DC. So no, it's not just as straightforward as "the onus is on SM to build a relationship" and so long as effort is made on her part, all will be well. Those who believe this have either never been SMs themselves, or have luckily not had to navigate the difficulties of the variables mentioned above.
Yes this, you've put it much more succinctly than me!
LucieStar · 12/03/2021 10:06

In much the same way you can put the effort in and deal with shit in an adult relationship, sometimes for many years, and still be banging your head against the wall years down the line... it's no different.

Alsohuman · 12/03/2021 10:05

As a step mum I’m delighted that all my stepchildren acknowledge me on Mothers’ Day. It’s really heartwarming.

JustLyra · 12/03/2021 10:04

There's no blanket right or wrong answer to the question "should a stepmum get a card on mother's day" Blended families are all so very different. What's fair, understandable or reasonable in one situation is different in another situation.

In my house alone we have three different situations where the card/gift on Mother's Day is very different.

DS1 is my DSS technically. His Mummy died when he was a toddler. He took to calling me Mum when he was around 9 and it was his choice and suggestion. He was the first to suggest he wanted to buy two bunches of flowers when DH took him to buy flowers to take to his Mummy's grave.

My girls have experienced two step-mother figures from their Dad over the years. His wife, who he recently split from, was originally lovely if not a little over-bearing, however as soon as she had their first half-sibling unfriendly, unwelcoming, and on various occasions downright cruel. She frequently bitched to them about how much maintenance their father paid (the minimum), told them they couldn't attend their half-brother's Christening because it was for "close family", frequently "accidentally" booked things that didn't include them for their contact time and actually told one of them it would be better if she left school and got a job because staying on was going to be very expensive for her Dad. Most recently, after splitting with their Dad, she pretended she wanted the girls to spend time with their half-siblings on a set night a week. When the girls had to change the timings after a few weeks because the bus timings changed she called them selfish little bitches and banned them from seeing their siblings. Turned out she had a class booked and was simply using them as free babysitters.

However, they do still send a Mothering Sunday card to his ex partner because she was lovely to them when they were young. She was the kind of step-Mum who made them dinner, wiped their tears and helped with their homework. They've never forgotten her kindness and they still keep in touch. They call her child their "sort-of-half sibling" and she's a lovely lady.

aSofaNearYou · 12/03/2021 10:03

@FullofCurryandparatha Well I had a sense you would say that, as I could read the bias between the lines of your previous post. But no, I don't think the onus is mainly on SPs to make it work. In my opinion, the greatest onus should be on the parents. They are the one's who bring all the complications and hugely demanding requirements to the table, and they need to be doing their utmost to make the situation actually pleasant for potential partners. Very often, that does not happen.

Situations where the SP "falls short" of being a "card worthy" third parent arise for a lot of reasons other than the SP simply rejecting a parent/child relationship with the ever willing step child. Those reasons include; the parent making no effort to make the situation liveable for their partner and perhaps even mistreating them when it comes to their kids; the kids being terrible towards the step parent and rejecting THEM, or perhaps simply not being bothered by their presence and WANTING another parental figure (ie, the lack of parental relationship is mutual and not upsetting anyone). As you mentioned before, the contact arrangement may simply not allow for a close parental bond, which is not the decision of the SP at all, and the other parent may also present a variety of roadblocks to the SP and SC developing a parent/child relationship; they may be very much against that and take steps to prevent it. And then there's the extremely pervasive negative attitudes towards step parents of society at large, which often also manifests in people surrounding the SP such as ILs, grinding the SP down until they cannot cope anymore and disengage to protect their own mental health. It is something that people who have never been a SP consistently overlook, but it can be enormously detrimental.

The tone of "those dastardly SPs don't bother with the SC who of course do nothing but smile at them meekly, begging them to love them, is not lost on me, and it is highly biased.

LucieStar · 12/03/2021 10:03

@FullofCurryandparatha

So no, it's not just as straightforward as "the onus is on SM to build a relationship" and so long as effort is made on her part, all will be well. Those who believe this have either never been SMs themselves, or have luckily not had to navigate the difficulties of the variables mentioned above.

I didn't say "all will be well" or imply it, and I am a SM (an excellent one).
The point remains that as the adult who made a choice its on you to put the hard work in and deal with the shit, and as the child who had no choice, it isn't.

"Putting the effort in and dealing with the shit" is one thing. Whether or not the outcome is a close relationship between SM and SCs is quite another. One doesn't guarantee the other.

FullofCurryandparatha · 12/03/2021 09:53

So no, it's not just as straightforward as "the onus is on SM to build a relationship" and so long as effort is made on her part, all will be well. Those who believe this have either never been SMs themselves, or have luckily not had to navigate the difficulties of the variables mentioned above.

I didn't say "all will be well" or imply it, and I am a SM (an excellent one).
The point remains that as the adult who made a choice its on you to put the hard work in and deal with the shit, and as the child who had no choice, it isn't.

mangocoveredlamb · 12/03/2021 09:53

I’m a step child, and I send a card to my step mum. She does the mothering and is a good granny to my DC.

Youseethethingis · 12/03/2021 09:50

It sounds very hurtful for the children
That’s the sort of sweeping assumption that can actually be quite damaging.
My DSDs mother lectured me when I first met her how I wasn’t to get involved in the care of her daughter, as I wasn’t her mother.
I’ve never particularly wanted or needed to get involved beyond the general being nice to her. So I took my lecture as it made the ex feel better to put me in my place.
Everyone’s happy. Th least thing DSD needs is me wading in and parenting her, not least because I think her mother has very odd ideas about child rearing as I’m sure she would think about me if she knew much about how I parent my own child.

Mittens030869 · 12/03/2021 09:48

Some step-parents do more for the children than their parents do.

That certainly was the case for my DSis with her DSS. She was a SAHM, with three DC of her own with her DSS’s dad, as he was the resident parent. She was careful not to step on his mum’s toes (he stayed with her EOW) and he called her by her first name. But she loves him as much as her own DC.

I never asked her about Mother’s Day cards, though.

LucieStar · 12/03/2021 09:46

People forget that the step parent relationship is a reciprocal thing, influenced not only by how the child responds to your attempts to build a relationship, but also by multiple other factors outside of your control include amount of contact, the resident parent's (sometimes negative) influence on how SCs feel towards you, the expectations and/or limitations imposed upon you by your partner in terms of what degree of involvement you "should" be having, etc. You don't have to navigate any of this with your own DC. So no, it's not just as straightforward as "the onus is on SM to build a relationship" and so long as effort is made on her part, all will be well. Those who believe this have either never been SMs themselves, or have luckily not had to navigate the difficulties of the variables mentioned above.

LucieStar · 12/03/2021 09:41

Whilst I agree with the sentiment that neither party might necessarily feel a parent/child connection, this is very much a chicken and egg situation. It's unfair to put all the "blame" for SP situations where the SP doesn't behave or be treated like a third parent, on them - as though everyone else involved including the children, parents and society at large generally make slipping into the role easy for them.

100%

FullofCurryandparatha · 12/03/2021 09:32

Whilst I agree with the sentiment that neither party might necessarily feel a parent/child connection, this is very much a chicken and egg situation

Is it though? That implies both sides are on equal terms, and they are not. If you choose to become a SM, the onus is very much on you to make it work.

I object to lumping all stepmothers into the same bracket anyway. There are stepmothers who have full time care of their SDC, and stepmothers who want rid of their SDC and do everything possible to cut them off, and everything in between. I would say the majority are on an EOW type basis, which doesn't put them in a strong position to claim mothertype status. 2 nights out of every 14 isn't really card territory, unless of course the children themselves want it.

Norwaydidnthappen · 12/03/2021 09:27

I think it depends on the individual circumstances. Some step-parents do more for the children than their parents do. If you’re just a weekend step-mum then no, I don’t think you deserve the credit but if you raise them 50% of the time or even the majority of the time then a card would be nice.

aSofaNearYou · 12/03/2021 09:24

Not necessarily at all. See above where posters said "I married their father, not them, I'm not their parent and I'll only do as a I choose". If they don't feel like they owe the children a parental relationship, the children are hardly going to be giving them presents on mothers day. Lets not pretend all stepmothers are doting mother figures.

Whilst I agree with the sentiment that neither party might necessarily feel a parent/child connection, this is very much a chicken and egg situation. It's unfair to put all the "blame" for SP situations where the SP doesn't behave or be treated like a third parent, on them - as though everyone else involved including the children, parents and society at large generally make slipping into the role easy for them.

justforthis7 · 12/03/2021 09:18

@FullofCurryandparatha Yes, that’s exactly my point - I personally can’t understand marrying someone with children if you’re not willing to take on a parental role. It sounds very hurtful for the children. In those cases, indeed why should the stepmum get a card on Mother’s Day. Sorry, I was really just going off on a tangent and moaning about the weird attitude towards step families that is often found on here Grin

LaRidiculata · 12/03/2021 08:52

I don’t really understand the level of vitriol some people in here have for step mothers. It’s one of the weird MN tropes

It depends on the relationship. I can hand on heart say that my step mum brought a lot of misery into my life. As a result I’ve put up with a lot of crap from my DH because I’d rather do that than bring a step mum or dad into my child’s life.

Some people have lovely ones. For others it’s a terrible experience.

FullofCurryandparatha · 12/03/2021 08:39

Lots of ‘they’re not my kids’ or ‘you’re not their mum’. No but they are your stepkids/you are their stepmum, so surely a familial/parental relationship is normal and to be encouraged (not forced of course)

Not necessarily at all. See above where posters said "I married their father, not them, I'm not their parent and I'll only do as a I choose". If they don't feel like they owe the children a parental relationship, the children are hardly going to be giving them presents on mothers day. Lets not pretend all stepmothers are doting mother figures.

Bottomlesspit21 · 12/03/2021 05:52

I give my stepmum flowers and a card and so does my boyfriend for his. She massively appreciates it especially as her own son doesn’t bother!
Nice gesture and the right thing to do in my opinion.

Mally2020 · 12/03/2021 05:49

I dont know it depends on how much you do and how important etc, ie if you have them most of the time etc then yes woould be nice but don't just expect it and don't be upset if not

JollyJlly · 12/03/2021 04:52

I think a lot of these YABU replies are personal to them. I think have a chat with your partner because they should organise/ help organise xxx

JollyJlly · 12/03/2021 04:50

I have a step mum we do something for her the same as we do my mum. I’m a step mum myself and I get something from both my DSS and DD. So I think it would be normal to receive an acknowledgment x

Swipe left for the next trending thread