Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Mandela Effect

484 replies

Bellver888 · 07/03/2021 23:32

Has anyone experienced it?
I’m currently sending my head backwards and forwards because I thought “Vimto” was “Vimpto”

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
DrSbaitso · 08/03/2021 11:22

The Captain Pugwash myths come from a magazine that made some jokes in the 1970s. Clever ones, but bunkum.

I'm surprised they persist, because you'd think people would check the books out to see if they're true. They're also such brilliant books, everyone should read them even if you don't have small people around. Absolutely joyous.

BiBabbles · 08/03/2021 11:21

I lived near a Midwestern air force base on 9/11, and there were - I'm not sure they were sonic booms, but two similar noises that were reported to be planes from base -- but when those booms happened and what those planes were sent for, even in just the months directly afterwards seemed to have gotten very confused to the point I'm not really sure (I think I may be mixing when I heard them and discussions then to when I heard the news report explaining them) though I do remember that people thought either the base or one of the local hospitals had been hit in a missed attempt on the base which is likely why it had to be widely reported that they were planes leaving the base.

Not sure it's Mandela Effect as it may just be me and it feels awkward to write out, but the recent Shannon Matthews media coverage threw me off, because I "remember" her being found dead under the bed.

I didn't really follow the case at the time, I can only guess that plus a similar enough tragic story must have mixed up my memories, but I've no idea who else I can be mixing it up with. I do remember terrible news of a girl of about the same age going "missing" with big family searches and the girl being found dead under a bed.

This is part of why as an adult, I looked up court records for some events that happened to me as a child - I know my memories can be all weird and I really needed something solid I can look at to say yes, that did happen, as part of working through it.

StillCoughingandLaughing · 08/03/2021 11:16

Even if you have an excellent memory - which I generally do - you can find things have merged in your brain somehow.

Those of you active on the Telly Addicts forum will see me crop up a lot on the Corrie threads. When they started showing Classic Corrie in the daytime, it was amazing how often I could remember scenes almost word for word - and I mean ordinary scenes; not big moments regularly reshown on clips shows or tributes. But a couple of years back they showed a scene with Gail and Alma that I would have sworn on my life took place in Gail’s garden. The scene was exactly as I remembered it - yet it all took place in the cafe. I was genuinely really shocked.

In the next episode, there WAS a scene in the garden. So on one hand, you could say my memory is amazing for it to have all stuck with me 30 years on - but on the other hand, my brain had combined two separate memories as one, so my memory was wrong.

DrSbaitso · 08/03/2021 11:13

@CounsellorTroi

I think urban myth also plays a part. Used to work with someone who really did think Master Bates and Seaman Staines were characters in the children‘s TV series Captain Pugwash.
No Seaman anyone, in the books or programme. There is a Master Mates. The cabin boy is called Tom.
JackieTheFart · 08/03/2021 11:07

@Cactus1982

I’m sure Worcestershire sauce used to be ‘Worcester Sauce’.
Some brands are. L&P is definitely Worcestershire though!

I find it interesting reading about these things happening, and I have a few (although more personal family memories). It irritates me when people just will not accept their memory is flawed. Human beings are, in general, absolutely terrible witnesses!

The Mandela Effect
CounsellorTroi · 08/03/2021 11:04

I think urban myth also plays a part. Used to work with someone who really did think Master Bates and Seaman Staines were characters in the children‘s TV series Captain Pugwash.

honeylulu · 08/03/2021 11:00

Mr Peanut!!! Yes that would explain it.

I'm sorry everyone I got the Gone With the Wind one wrong. A false memory of a false memory ...

I saw a programme about this a few years ago, about how open to suggestion the memory is. I think the programme was looking at how reliable repressed memories of childhood abuse during therapy was. In an experiment they showed the subjects a number of photos of them with a favourite grandparent but one of the images was photo shopped, showing the pair in or next to a hot air balloon basket. This had never happened but curiously when then speaking about their memories all subjects claimed to "remember" the hot air balloon. It was quite uncanny. I suppose it's the sort of experience you think you should never forget, you see the photo and your brain "fills in the gaps". ???

Womencanlift · 08/03/2021 10:57

I wonder if the 9/11 ‘false’ morning memories are from the following day. Remember that footage was on the news for days. So OP you may have been watching that eating your cereal but on the 12th Sep and not the 11th

As time passes it all merges into one memory

boltfromtheblueblue · 08/03/2021 10:55

How in the heck do you live a life like that, with all the subsequent accomplishments and news coverage, or live through coverage of something like 9/11, and have so many people have the same false memory? It is really interesting

It's quite simple really: large numbers of people don't pay attention to the world around them and have no real idea what's going on. Certainly before it was so simple to get "news" in your news feeds and rolling coverage. So people heard a lot of fuss about Nelson Mandela st some stage, vaguely, and then later on when someone else says something about remembering that NM died back at that time, they attach the vague memory to that. Then they have a new "memory" of having seen on the news that he died or the funeral etc.
There is only lots of people misrembering NM because they've been talking about the Mandela effect in the first place! It's all back filled memories that they never had in the first place.

Bellver888 · 08/03/2021 10:52

I’m the same I have a false memory of 9/11 as well, I remember it as sat on the floor eating my cereal with “Breaking news” on bbc with the 2nd plane going in, only realised about 2 years ago that I couldn’t have been watching it as it was 8am here and like 1am New York time

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 08/03/2021 10:49

@MistyGreenAndBlue

While Clark Gable clearly did say the famous line it is a fact that in no Sherlock Holmes story does he ever say "elementary my dear Watson" Although this line may have been used in the films. I'm not sure.
He did indeed never say the actual line "Elementary, my dear Watson" in any of the books. But actually I think most people know this now, just like they do know that Frankenstein was the creator (and, of course, arguably the monster too).

But I don't know if things like this count as the Mandela effect. Most people probably haven't read the relevant book, or if they have, it does make sense that they might not recall every detail, especially if the incorrect line is indeed in a film or TV adaptation, which is likely to be more widely seen, or it's just more memorable as a quotation. After all, if the line was spoken in a film, they're not misremembering it, they just aren't aware it wasn't in the original.

I think it applies more to things like, well, Nelson Mandela. How in the heck do you live a life like that, with all the subsequent accomplishments and news coverage, or live through coverage of something like 9/11, and have so many people have the same false memory? It is really interesting.

CounsellorTroi · 08/03/2021 10:41

@boltfromtheblueblue

I have a distinct recollection of a miniseries I watched with my mum in the late 90s/early naughtiest. It was based on a novel I’d enjoyed as a teen called Bride of . It was set in Cornwall. The lead female character was called Favel - they pronounced it Favelle in the programme and I’d always thought it was Fayvel. The lead male character was played by Anthony Andrews. But this series doesn’t appear in his filmography and I’ve never been able to find any reference to it online!

Because it doesn't exist. A tv series was not made based on that book, clearly you read the book, and saw a similar tv show with that actor in it, and conflated the two into an amalgam memory.
That's how memory often works, and why it's so fallible.

Now, are you going to actually say that rather than the above happening, you have changed realties having previously lived in one that only differed by the fact of tv show?

No, not saying that. Perfectly willing to accept my memory was wrong.
sashh · 08/03/2021 10:41

My friends and I also collectively misremember 9/11 which is odd given that we were all together when the news broke live.

I don't think this is surprising, I have false memories. I KNOW I'd had a nap, woke up and put the TV on and it was showing.. well that's where my false memory started.

I think that over the next few days the same footage was shown over and over again with the second plane hitting I 'remember' it, but I'm not sure I do.

FancyPuffin · 08/03/2021 10:36

The o my one that really weird for me is that I clearly remember Disney VHS movies having Tinkerbell spell out Disney and then use her wand for the dot. Didn't happen Confused

boltfromtheblueblue · 08/03/2021 10:35

I have a distinct recollection of a miniseries I watched with my mum in the late 90s/early naughtiest. It was based on a novel I’d enjoyed as a teen called Bride of . It was set in Cornwall. The lead female character was called Favel - they pronounced it Favelle in the programme and I’d always thought it was Fayvel. The lead male character was played by Anthony Andrews. But this series doesn’t appear in his filmography and I’ve never been able to find any reference to it online!

Because it doesn't exist. A tv series was not made based on that book, clearly you read the book, and saw a similar tv show with that actor in it, and conflated the two into an amalgam memory.
That's how memory often works, and why it's so fallible.

Now, are you going to actually say that rather than the above happening, you have changed realties having previously lived in one that only differed by the fact of tv show?

Ponoka7 · 08/03/2021 10:30

@MiddletownDreams, the truth about Hillsborough was branded a conspiracy theory for decades. So I'm wary about what I dismiss. The extent that the corruption went was astounding. Likewise Saville and the awarding of Tory contracts etc. It's largely mis-remembering and not a personality flaw. It's why the law, changed on police questioning, it isn't difficult to put a false memory into someone's head. Domestic abusers are very good at it.

In all fairness lots of people have been declared dead on SM, so Trump might have been.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 08/03/2021 10:25

While Clark Gable clearly did say the famous line it is a fact that in no Sherlock Holmes story does he ever say "elementary my dear Watson"
Although this line may have been used in the films. I'm not sure.

DrSbaitso · 08/03/2021 10:24

The crisps one is easy to explain, because, as people have said, there are two major brands with different colour schemes who swapped places in popularity. The Nelson Mandela phenomenon is much odder and more inexplicable.

Cheese and onion should obviously be blue, anyway. Come at me.

ElizaLaLa · 08/03/2021 10:20

@SinisterBumFacedCat

Golden Wonder - salt n vinegar- blue, cheese and onion - green Walkers - salt and vinegar- green, cheese and onion - blue

Golden wonder was very much and 80’s crisp, Walkers seemed to take over when out of town supermarkets started popping up in the early 90’s.

Walkers have just got their colours wrong. Not only that they have got the wrong shade of blue too.

Salt and vinegar- fish n chips - seaside - sea - blue.
Cheese and onion - green.

Walkers are just being dicks.

Walkers are Leys in Europe and salt & vinegar here is blue.

So they are being extra dicky in the UK.

DrSbaitso · 08/03/2021 10:19

@dentydown

I thought Robbie Coltrane had died. I had to Wikipedia him and found out that he was in rude health! Grin
I wonder if, in your head, you were confusing him with Ronnie Corbett?
CounsellorTroi · 08/03/2021 10:18

Should have read Bride of Pendorric in my last post!

dentydown · 08/03/2021 10:16

I thought Robbie Coltrane had died. I had to Wikipedia him and found out that he was in rude health! Grin

CounsellorTroi · 08/03/2021 10:13

I have a distinct recollection of a miniseries I watched with my mum in the late 90s/early naughtiest. It was based on a novel I’d enjoyed as a teen called Bride of . It was set in Cornwall. The lead female character was called Favel - they pronounced it Favelle in the programme and I’d always thought it was Fayvel. The lead male character was played by Anthony Andrews. But this series doesn’t appear in his filmography and I’ve never been able to find any reference to it online!

DrSbaitso · 08/03/2021 10:11

@wellthatsunusual

I can understand lots of mis-remembered things, but I can never understand the Mandela thing. The campaign to release him, his release and then becoming President was such huge worldwide news that I can't get my head round how so many people could have thought he had died.
And yet they did, and all the same false memory. So there is something that commonly happens to cause this, though I'm not sure what exactly.
DrSbaitso · 08/03/2021 10:09

Rhett Butler does say "frankly" in the film. He doesn't in the book. The original line was supposed to be as in the book: "My dear, I don't give a damn." But Clark Gable ad libbed the change.