Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Ronan Keating can’t sing? Which other famous singers can’t sing?

519 replies

BlackBucketOfCheese · 05/03/2021 14:23

When I was a teenager I thought Ronan Keating had a great voice (despite not being my type of music) but I think I probably just fancied him. I’ve just heard one of his songs from around 1999 pop up on a Spotify playlist and he sounds like a goat yelping into a Pringles can.

I know lots of pop stars can’t sing for shite but in my head I had him in a bracket of people who can sing nicely - despite probably not having listened to his music for 20+ years.

Can RK sing?

Which other pop stars who people think are decent singers actually turn out to sound like a farm yard animal with trapped wind.

OP posts:
Creamcrackersandricecakes · 06/03/2021 10:52

@DrSbaitso - oh dear god. I hadn't had the misfortune to come across that before. Just 🤮🤮🤮. Not just LA either, the whole thing is just horrific. Angry

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 10:44

Remember when Lily murdered Dub Be Good to Me? I remember hearing it, thinking "what, they remade that?", listening out for the female vocals and then thinking "shit, it's Lily Allen, nobody else sounds that horrid, how the hell this happen??". And to think what a beautiful voice the original singer had!

Creamcrackersandricecakes · 06/03/2021 10:37

Oh!! And I never forgave LA for murdering that gorgeous Keane song in the John Lewis advert. Her vocals on that are absolutely horrendous, yet people were all losing their minds over it. ConfusedConfusedConfused

tigger1001 · 06/03/2021 10:36

@likeamillpond

Voices age. People shouldn't be judged on how they sound now.
Yes voices age, but if they are still attempting to release music and get people to go to their gigs now why can't we judge their voices now?
Creamcrackersandricecakes · 06/03/2021 10:33

Oh I forgot about Lily Allen, (or my brain had blocked her out). She's not great at all is she. I once caught the end of one of her sets, (she was supporting the Scissor Sisters), and she's not even entertaining and charismatic on stage. She's a wonderful example of how being related to the right people will open doors.
Actually, come to think of it, I remember half watching a documentary about her a few years ago when she was at the height of her fame. They interviewed the music teacher from her school. This woman was literally gushing about how she'd one day 'overheard' little Lily singing away to herself and she 'couldn't believe' how beautiful her voice was. I recall DH and I were like, if you really think that then you've got no business being a music teacher.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 10:31

@likeamillpond

Lilly Allen. Basically melodic talking rather than actual singing.
It's not even melodic. I know her entire schtick was that she wasn't meant to sound as if she had been trained at an exclusive drama school (and she sure didn't) but she didn't sound as if she had any talent, however raw. Just droning with no feeling, no strength, no pleasant tone, no nothing. Could have been anyone burbling.

I also really disliked the way she would always go after other women on social media for no reason. I think she thought she was dismantling beauty standards or something, but it was just misogynistic.

looseddaughter · 06/03/2021 10:29

George could sing obviously Blush

looseddaughter · 06/03/2021 10:28

Ds would never forgive me if I didn't come on and defend Ariana Grande. I completely agree her diction is appalling and she does that breathy thing all the time on her albums but I took him to see her live a couple of years ago and I was pleasantly surprised by how powerful and impressive her voice was. She's not really to my taste but she can definitely sing.

George Michael - yes, of course he could sign and he was a great performer too. I was a huge fan as a teen then sort of forget him then saw him at the Linda McCartney memorial concert and was taken aback by how amazing he was.

Some of the people mentioned haven't got technically great voices but have distinct voices/emotional range and/or great presence as performers. Cheryl Cole stands out as having none of the above.

likeamillpond · 06/03/2021 10:25

Voices age.
People shouldn't be judged on how they sound now.

likeamillpond · 06/03/2021 10:17

Lilly Allen.
Basically melodic talking rather than actual singing.

PolaDeVeboise · 06/03/2021 10:04

My urge to defend George was such that I didn't nominate my worse - Florence Welch - I've always said her version of 'You Got the Love' sounds like a pissed up bird singing karaoke at the end of the night.

I also second Jamie Cullum - hate his nasally whine.

lynsey91 · 06/03/2021 09:50

I have to agree with other posters that people are mixing liking a singer's voice with whether they can sing or not.

I can't deny that Karen Carpenter could sing and well but I can't stand her voice. I also can't stand Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston, Adele and Celine Dion but they can all sing.

On a thread about best singers a few posters have mentioned Katie Melua and how she is absolutely pitch perfect. I dislike her voice so much I have to turn the radio off if they play one of her songs. I have been known to run across the living room to do this!

Just the fact that one poster said George Michael shows how personal taste is the main factor. It's ludicrous to say he couldn't sing. He had an amazing voice. I saw him live a few times and he was incredible.

I think Paul McCartney definitely could sing and had a good voice back in the day. He is 80 (or almost) now for goodness sake. How many 80 year olds can still sing well?

I love singing but will only sing when alone or with DH. I am absolutely dreadful. A cat in pain sounds better. Even the singers that don't impress me - Madonna, Kylie can definitely sing when compared with me.

starfishmummy · 06/03/2021 09:38

Somebody even mentioned Ed Sheeran? Have you ever seen him recording with Bocelli? Now, that's a blind man, so all he really has is sound, and he rated Sheeran enough to record with him!

Or got paid enough

thecatsthecats · 06/03/2021 09:27

Even if it's lighthearted, I find this thread awfully sad.

I'm objectively a better singer than my sister, but I don't have much confidence in it, whereas she happily breaks into song all the time.

Singing is one of the most joyful things you can do, whether you're good at it or not.

RichPetunia · 06/03/2021 09:13

Madonna
Beyoncé

Pootle40 · 06/03/2021 09:12

Beg to differ about Madonna. Yes she has bad days. Anyone who watches this and says she can't sing is wrong.

0blio · 06/03/2021 09:07

@merryhollybright

Can I nominate Jess Glynn and her wobbly bleating?
Nails down a blackboard!
Pootle40 · 06/03/2021 09:04

@OrangeBananaFish

Katy Perry. When she is on TV in concert or singing live its just awful
I thought so too. Then I watched her inauguration performance and she is fantastic.
BorderlineHappy · 06/03/2021 09:02

Olly Murs is another one,and its so obvious when he sings with better singers.

But i like him and his voice suits his music.
So hes another one the whole package rather than an amazing voice,

MsMiaWallace · 06/03/2021 08:59

I'm a 90s girl, massive take that fan. Used to adore Robbie. Went to the first reunion tour they did when Robbie came back for a time. Around 2011 & they released the flood.
Robbie came on & he was dreadful!
My heart sank. He looked good but was dreadful performing solo.

Cam2020 · 06/03/2021 08:51

I remember my sister and I used to impersonate Cilla Black by screeching 'Surprise surpriiiiise, the unexpected hits you between the iiiiiieees .....' (spelling adjusted accordingly!) and laughing our heads off at the sheer awfulness of her voice (and ours). I used to wonder how anyone had ever thought she could sing

Yes!! I remember doing this too grin

Us too 🤣 I bet we were all doing it in unison up and down the country!

That's such a funny thought 😂

TigerDroveAgain · 06/03/2021 08:16

I know I’m incredibly late to the party and completely missed it in the summer but “I’m dill danding”GrinGrinGrin

TheRogueApostrophe · 06/03/2021 08:05

This is the reason The X Factor came about, isn't it? Because being a successful performer isn't all about having a perfect voice. It's about having the whole package.

I've always hated Robbie Williams's voice. I don't think he can sing but his success isn't about his voice alone. See also Gary Barlow and Mark Owen. I'm.not a TT fan! Kylie's always been nasally but her success is about being Kylie, and she's done amazingly well to stay current.

Voices definitely weaken and change with age though, so it's probably unfair to be judging some of the greats by how their voices sound today.

DinosaurDiana · 06/03/2021 08:04

@Iwasonceabrownie

I never understood the love for David Bowie to be honest.
Agree.
Bawdrip · 06/03/2021 08:00

Jamie Callum. I've no musical talent whatsoever so can someone tell me is he flat on nearly every note because that's how it sounds to me. Awful scratchy voice too. Always changing key to the point it's unsettling.