Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Ronan Keating can’t sing? Which other famous singers can’t sing?

519 replies

BlackBucketOfCheese · 05/03/2021 14:23

When I was a teenager I thought Ronan Keating had a great voice (despite not being my type of music) but I think I probably just fancied him. I’ve just heard one of his songs from around 1999 pop up on a Spotify playlist and he sounds like a goat yelping into a Pringles can.

I know lots of pop stars can’t sing for shite but in my head I had him in a bracket of people who can sing nicely - despite probably not having listened to his music for 20+ years.

Can RK sing?

Which other pop stars who people think are decent singers actually turn out to sound like a farm yard animal with trapped wind.

OP posts:
GrouchyKiwi · 06/03/2021 21:53

Joe Strummer.

Obviously the point of The Clash was not the singing. But still.

(I love The Clash.)

For those who think that Bowie couldn't sing, have you tried to sing Life On Mars? Those jumps between notes are mighty difficult and he did it effortlessly.

PinkiOcelot · 06/03/2021 21:16

Sting.

rockingthelook · 06/03/2021 21:13

Jet 2 used one of Jess Glynnes songs on the planes in the times when it was stationary before and after landing....on bloody repeat, ' standing in a crowded room and I can't see your face',,,, everytime the goat starting bleating everyone moaned...torture, poor cabin crew , what the hell were Jet 2 thinking?

yolandafostersfridge · 06/03/2021 21:11

Simon Le Bon cannot sing for toffee (runs away)

gingganggooleywotsit · 06/03/2021 20:46

Glad to see so many agree about Jess Glynn she cannot sing for toffee. As I mentioned up thread a singer friend of mine has recorded with her and said she had an appallingly flat voice. Apparently she only got a record deal because her mum is in the music industry! I know I’m being bitchy but it’s true!

Bawdrip · 06/03/2021 19:53

@Againstmachine

James Arthur sounds like the pub drunk singing.

Sam Smith too short tongued for my liking.

Short tongued!! That's exactly the problem. Excellent observation
TheCrowening · 06/03/2021 19:52

@KittyKattyKate

Nicole Shitsinger
Agree with a PP that she can bloody well sing. You can say you don’t like her voice but nobody can say she can’t sing.
lynsey91 · 06/03/2021 19:51

@Creamcrackersandricecakes

Oh!! And I never forgave LA for murdering that gorgeous Keane song in the John Lewis advert. Her vocals on that are absolutely horrendous, yet people were all losing their minds over it. ConfusedConfusedConfused
I've never forgiven her for murdering that song either. I love it sung by Keane and she ruined it.

Why did John Lewis not use the Keane version

lynsey91 · 06/03/2021 19:49

@KittyKattyKate

Nicole Shitsinger
Have you actually heard her sing? Look at the video on youtube of her singing Don't cry for me Argentina.

Me and DH saw her in Cats. When she sung Memory there was complete silence in the theatre. She finished and there was a sort of stunned silence then the audience went mad clapping and quite a few people gave her a standing ovation. Never seen that in the middle of a show before

TheCrowening · 06/03/2021 19:36

@gingganggooleywotsit

For me, a bad singer is one that sings with no emotion. Doesn’t matter how technically good they are. You can tell when a singer really ‘means it’!
This is true. It’s why I always hated Susan Boyle’s performances. She can sing alright (nothing special) but simply couldn’t engage with the emotion in the lyrics.
woodhill · 06/03/2021 19:22

Used to love the club singer bit on shooting stars

Nuitsdesetoiles · 06/03/2021 18:38

Robbie Williams
Ian Brown
Paloma faith
Katy Perry
Sarah Cracknell (st Etienne)
All of the spice girls.

LemonadeBudget · 06/03/2021 18:35

@DrSbaitso

What do people mean by "like a pub/club singer"? I've heard it used as an insult, on here and on singing shows, but I've never really understood what it means or why it's undesirable.
It refers to a skit Vic Reeves and Bob Mortimer used to do on Shooting Stars, where Vic would sing a piece of a song 'in the style of a club singer'. And it was ludicrous Grin

It doesn't mean an actual club singer. At least, that's the way I used it and I think others on this thread did too.

Ritascornershop · 06/03/2021 18:22

Bloody hell, just saw on the previous page someone saying Van Morrison can’t sing.

What is the criteria?! Van Morrison is my favourite male vocalist, miles ahead of the rest.

KittyKattyKate · 06/03/2021 18:11

Nicole Shitsinger

RandomDent · 06/03/2021 18:11

@StripeyDeckchair

Paul McCartney Paloma Faith - she puts on that wierd accent
Paloma Faith was in a chat show after murdering some tune or other. I remember her saying she thought her voice had improved after having her (first) child. I just thought, nope, your hearing has deteriorated!
DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 18:05

What do people mean by "like a pub/club singer"? I've heard it used as an insult, on here and on singing shows, but I've never really understood what it means or why it's undesirable.

Ritascornershop · 06/03/2021 17:58

I love Amy’s voice, it has/had warmth, expressiveness, skill.

A lot of singers (Elton, Paul McCartney) do lose their voices as they get older. I’ve been watching recent Pete Townshend videos and his voice has changed but he still sounds great to me.

LadyEloise · 06/03/2021 16:17

@MMfanalltheway
I love the Green Fields of France. A brilliant anti war song.
Sung by the Fureys, who are awful not good singers but theirs is such a powerful rendition.
I'd love to hear your version.
Eric Bogle wrote it and that other amazing anti war song And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda.
Such genius.

PuppyMonkey · 06/03/2021 16:11

I think it's sad about Elton John as if you listen to his performances from the early 1970s, he very much CAN sing - Your Song and the original Candle in the Wind and all that. But he completely lost his tone and his softness in the 1980s and now can only do the painful pub singer style singing. Sad

I never thought any of the Beatles had a particularly good voice. And Amy Winehouse in her not very good fake US accent just sounded silly to me.Confused

LadyEloise · 06/03/2021 16:04

Two more that can't sing but can sure get a song across are :
Van Morrison and Bob Dylan.
Saw Dylan live two years ago. Dreadful.
But love listening to him

RightOnTheEdge · 06/03/2021 15:58

@EnglishGirlApproximately that Elton video made me laugh and I really needed that thank you!
It's so bizarre 🤣

isthismylifenow · 06/03/2021 15:48

Can someone explain this to me... . Tom Rosenthal (edith Whiskers) Home, he's singing both the male and female parts. From what I can make out it was recorded long before being used on Tiktok videos. So just why?

My dd loves it. I do ask her to press skip if I'm around.😊

I do quite like the original though.

RebeccaCloud9 · 06/03/2021 15:13

I think Jess Glynne has the most hideous voice. It gives me shudders like nails on a blackboard even on her produced songs.

And Katy Perry live is just laughably bad.

woodhill · 06/03/2021 15:12

Love Madness but Suggs is a bit monotone

Swipe left for the next trending thread