Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Ronan Keating can’t sing? Which other famous singers can’t sing?

519 replies

BlackBucketOfCheese · 05/03/2021 14:23

When I was a teenager I thought Ronan Keating had a great voice (despite not being my type of music) but I think I probably just fancied him. I’ve just heard one of his songs from around 1999 pop up on a Spotify playlist and he sounds like a goat yelping into a Pringles can.

I know lots of pop stars can’t sing for shite but in my head I had him in a bracket of people who can sing nicely - despite probably not having listened to his music for 20+ years.

Can RK sing?

Which other pop stars who people think are decent singers actually turn out to sound like a farm yard animal with trapped wind.

OP posts:
ALongHardWinter · 08/03/2021 19:41

I've often thought over the years that he can't sing. Reminds a bit of a sheep bleating. Other singers that I think haven't got very good voices are Marc Almond,although I still like him! Also,Paul Young,and Ellie Goulding. There's something about her breathy voice that irritates me intensely.

Wendyhause · 08/03/2021 19:30

@looselegs

My husband's mate always said Elvis was just a glorified pub singer.....
That made me laugh. Elvis a glorified pub singer! I don't think so. Grin
LadyfromtheBelleEpoque · 08/03/2021 19:28

@Eastie77

I thought Beyoncé could sing, though. Doesn’t she have a real powerhouse voice?

Nobody beats Roberta Flack for me, though. The way she sings ‘First time...’ breaks my heart each time🙂

looselegs · 08/03/2021 19:23

My husband's mate always said Elvis was just a glorified pub singer.....

Eastie77 · 08/03/2021 18:56

@SmokedDuck I agree. I think a lot of the older singers were multi-talented, they were actually able to play an instrument and were often trained. Aretha Franklin had an amazing voice AND she was a pianist. People compare her to the likes of Beyoncé who is essentially a stage entertainer with backing singers and dancers and I have to roll my eyes.

A lot of today's "singers" are just manufactured products who are selected for their looks and marketability rather than talent.

This thread is making me chuckle though. Do people truly believe Whitney, Mariah and Adele can't/couldn't sing?? You may not like the music but come on now, they CAN sing

Frazzled2207 · 07/03/2021 20:16

@ChocBeforeCock
Thanks for posting that video. Quite interesting. I love Hugh J and he can definitely sing but he’s not that great in LM is he.
But when I was thinking about the parallel “who CAN sing?” Thread earlier, the one person that came to mind was, Samantha Barks!

ChocBeforeCock · 07/03/2021 19:27

Sorry meant that it says they’re reasonably talented but sound awful due to technique

ChocBeforeCock · 07/03/2021 19:26

In terms of Russell Crowe and Les Mis, this video is interesting

m.youtube.com/watch?v=1ikqU6G6Xgs

It is long! But in terms of Crowe (and Jackman) says their technique was awful and they made rookie errors, eg Hugh Jackman not drinking and fluid for 3 days before he sang Look Down

ChequerBoard · 07/03/2021 16:49

@PolkadotsAndMoonbeams

Frazzled, Russel Crowe is actually a good singer and fronted a band for quite a long time.

What he is not is a musical theatre bass-baritone.

This reminds me of the epic line from the movie version of the musical 'The Last Five Years'.

Cathy has been auditioning (again) for a part in a musical, as we watch she changes from the audition song to sing to us' why am I working so hard? These are the people who cast Russell Crowe in a musical - Jesus Christ! I suck, I suck, I suck'

Love that movie!

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 07/03/2021 14:02

Frazzled, Russel Crowe is actually a good singer and fronted a band for quite a long time.

What he is not is a musical theatre bass-baritone.

boltfromtheblueblue · 07/03/2021 12:18

5 page of people who can't tell the difference between their personal preferences in music and peoples actual abilities.

fluffysocks89 · 07/03/2021 12:10

Even if it's lighthearted, I find this thread awfully sad
Singing is one of the most joyful things you can do, whether you're good at it or not.*

I think most of the singers mentioned here can take comfort in their enormous bank balances and great lifestyles. I doubt our thoughts on their voices is keeping them up at night. Or in any danger of shutting them.up

Totally agree, any singer in the public eye, especially those who are earning fortunes must expect to get critique. Nothing sad about it. There’s good singers and bad singers, they shouldn’t be all classed the same. Wouldn’t be fair on the good singers, there’d be no merit. Otherwise we might as well all do it. Grin

beguilingeyes · 07/03/2021 07:56

Totally agree about Debbie Harry. The woman is a goddess. I've seen her solo and with Blondie. Just listen to Hanging On The Telephone.

Rockbird · 07/03/2021 06:51

Also have to defend Ariana Grande as DD1 will kill me if I don't. I can't stand her music but she can sing. DD keeps going on about something called whistle notes?

Someone mentioned Debbie Harry? Beautiful voice especially now she is older and her range is lower.

tobee · 07/03/2021 01:10

@tobee

Maybe something in between a home singer and one who has a record contract?

A club/pub singer I mean

tobee · 07/03/2021 01:10

Maybe something in between a home singer and one who has a record contract?

Frazzled2207 · 07/03/2021 01:09

Not a lot famous singer as such but Ewan McGregor in moulin rouge was woeful as was Russel Crowe in Les Miserables. Pretty sure they’ve admitted it since and unsurprisingly haven’t done any more musicals.
Genuinely don’t know why you wouldn’t hire actual singers to star in a musical...oh wait yeah you want proper A listers to make sure it makes money.
See also Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone in La La land. They managed ok but clearly are not good singers!

Frazzled2207 · 07/03/2021 00:58

@DrSbaitso

What do people mean by "like a pub/club singer"? I've heard it used as an insult, on here and on singing shows, but I've never really understood what it means or why it's undesirable.
Somebody who might be “booked” to sing at a club or pub, on a regular basis eg Friday night. Or bookable for weddings etc. Might be generally doing covers. So not selling records or touring or anything. And probably doing another job by day. Some of these people are probably very good singers and just don’t want to take it any further. Some of them will be a bit rubbish. But nothing wrong with it per se.
theleafandnotthetree · 07/03/2021 00:58

@thecatsthecats

Even if it's lighthearted, I find this thread awfully sad.

I'm objectively a better singer than my sister, but I don't have much confidence in it, whereas she happily breaks into song all the time.

Singing is one of the most joyful things you can do, whether you're good at it or not.

I think most of the singers mentioned here can take comfort in their enormous bank balances and great lifestyles. I doubt our thoughts on their voices is keeping them up at night. Or in any danger of shutting them.up
theleafandnotthetree · 07/03/2021 00:53

@OrangeBananaFish

Katy Perry. When she is on TV in concert or singing live its just awful
Yes, she got totally found out on Carpool Karaoke, in my opinion. James Corden did a better job of her songs
GloGirl · 07/03/2021 00:49

Kathryn Jenkins. Someone on Mumsnet wrote once it sounds like she was gargling custard - that's exactly what she sounds like.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 07/03/2021 00:44

Liam Gallagher literally tries to imitate John Lennon's singing voice nowadays. The man is obsessed.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 07/03/2021 00:40

I can't believe some of the comments on here. David Bowie not a good singer? Christ.

Ian Brown isn't a good singer. Nor is John Lydon, he's dreadful. Although I appreciate the Sex Pistols weren't supposed to be talented musicians. None of the Spice Girls.

Paul McCartney has lost his voice now but in my personal opinion he was great back in the day. He had a very wide range if you compare a song like Helter Skelter to Yesterday. Definitely the best singer in the Beatles.

tobee · 07/03/2021 00:16

Personally I can't bear a Whitney belter of a voice. But plenty of people think she's the epitome of a fantastic singing voice. No debate. It's often to do with how a song is "put across" surely that counts for enjoyment?

Also, pop voices, rock voices, folk voices and jazz voices etc are very different to classically trained operatic voices. I'm sure there are plenty of operatic voices I might like listen to where someone knowledgeable would be able to point out their weaknesses?

scentedgeranium · 06/03/2021 21:57

Sam Smith and all those other crying/ whining singers

Swipe left for the next trending thread