Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Ronan Keating can’t sing? Which other famous singers can’t sing?

519 replies

BlackBucketOfCheese · 05/03/2021 14:23

When I was a teenager I thought Ronan Keating had a great voice (despite not being my type of music) but I think I probably just fancied him. I’ve just heard one of his songs from around 1999 pop up on a Spotify playlist and he sounds like a goat yelping into a Pringles can.

I know lots of pop stars can’t sing for shite but in my head I had him in a bracket of people who can sing nicely - despite probably not having listened to his music for 20+ years.

Can RK sing?

Which other pop stars who people think are decent singers actually turn out to sound like a farm yard animal with trapped wind.

OP posts:
beguilingeyes · 05/03/2021 23:43

Lian Gallagher once described Florence (and the Machine) as singing like someone was standing on her foot. I'm still laughing.

PS The Beatles were stone cold genius.

boon · 05/03/2021 23:42

Gary Barlow - he was shocking on Ant and Dec the other night and his crooner sessions are cringe.

DrSbaitso · 05/03/2021 23:41

@GreatTeaMonkey

It may have been over-exposure to however long China in your Hand” was in charts for in the 80’s - but I always thought Carol Decker sang off-key and ran out of breath mid-line

I’ve always thought she was off key on the big note, even as a child I noticed that.

Apparently the accompanying music was slightly off true pitch...and Decker has perfect pitch, meaning she was on the true note, but out of tune with the actual backing music.

Perfect pitch isn't at all necessary to be a brilliant singer or musician, and it can even be a disadvantage, as per that example. Relative pitch is more useful.

DrSbaitso · 05/03/2021 23:35

Can someone tell me what is so very special about Adele? She's obviously very talented and her voice is beautiful, but what is it about her that makes people say it's a "once in a generation" voice and all that? It's lovely but I don't see how it's better than the cast of any current musical or many other beautiful singers I've heard.

lighteincastlewindow · 05/03/2021 23:21

@RitaFires For example Cheryl sounded crap with Gary Barlow but sounded much better duetting with Snow Patrol youtu.be/lVjQYbX-F7k

Because she was miming that one which was pre-recorded and blended and it's the audio equivalent of photoshopping a kardashian's backside.

FlossieTeacakesFurCoat18 · 05/03/2021 23:14

I don't normally mind Florence and the machine but the cover of Beyoncé's Halo is shocking. It sounds like the worst karaoke you've ever heard.

Eastie77 · 05/03/2021 23:13

@Obviouspretzel - no, what a strange conclusion to draw. I was giving an example of one singer (who I explained I'm not a fan of) at one event in the 1980s as an example of the quality of singers and live performers then who did not have to rely on assistance such as auto tune.

There are plenty of decent singers nowadays I'm sure. I just personally think the quality overall has declined.

HTH

WhatWouldBuffyDo13 · 05/03/2021 22:55

Amanda Seyfried

Obviouspretzel · 05/03/2021 22:40

@Eastie77

I watched footage of Live Aid online the other day. Watching singers like Phil Collins, who I am not a particular fan off, walk on stage with nothing apart from a piano to accompany him and just sing live - zero auto tune or any other 'help' - made me realise how poor singers are today compared to those of yesteryear. They had real talent and could actually sing. Honestly most of the best singers are already dead.
So within 30 years or so, something has happened that has resulted in no one across the world being able to sing as well as Phil Collins? And anyone that could has died?
PolaDeVeboise · 05/03/2021 22:37

@TakeTheCuntOutOfScunthorpe

Interesting user name. You lost any credibility you may have had with the inclusion of George Michael in your list.

anxiouscrazymum · 05/03/2021 22:28

Gary Barlow

quince2figs · 05/03/2021 22:10

@GreatTeaMonkey, yes, exactly. Suspect her popularity was due to her looks and micro-skirts, though, rather than singing ability 😀

GreatTeaMonkey · 05/03/2021 22:07

It may have been over-exposure to however long China in your Hand” was in charts for in the 80’s - but I always thought Carol Decker sang off-key and ran out of breath mid-line

I’ve always thought she was off key on the big note, even as a child I noticed that.

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 05/03/2021 22:04

RK does have a very ‘affected’ fake singing voice. He always sounds like an impersonation or parody of a singer. Not pleasant to listen to IMO but each to their own!

With people like Robbie Williams and Madonna it’s all about the showpersonship isn’t it. The charisma. And they do have great songs, songwriting partners and producers behind them. Kylie’s the same. And Elton John’s voice isn’t technically good but again, good music, good lyrics.

Agnatha and Frida from ABBA have really sublime voices. Just amazing when you really listen to them, even live.

Lincslady53 · 05/03/2021 22:03

@RaveOnThisCrazyFeeling

I'm with you, onemorecupofcoffee. I love the sound of Dylan's voice and would rather hear him sing his songs than anyone else. The Rolling Thunder performances in particular sound amazing, I could listen to them every day and never tire of the sound of Bob's voice.
I am on the loving Bob Dylan side. I have a USB stick full of bootleg performances from the 60s right up to 2019 which I listen to in the car, or via headphones. I like some covers of his songs, but to my ears, the majority of covers are watered down versions. Give me the originals anyday. I find Joan Baez a tad squarky, and can't stand singers who sing 10 notes when one will do a la Mariah Carey. Good job we are all different isn't it?
Beetlebum76 · 05/03/2021 21:52

Jessie J - really unpleasant to listen to

quince2figs · 05/03/2021 21:51

@BlackBucketOfCheese

For me, a bad singer is one that sings with no emotion. Doesn’t matter how technically good they are. You can tell when a singer really ‘means it’!

For me Ronan Keating sings it best, when he sings nothing at all.

🤣🤣

Or, as my DH used to say “ can he sing Far Away?”...

It may have been over-exposure to however long China in your Hand” was in charts for in the 80’s - but I always thought Carol Decker sang off-key and ran out of breath mid-line

Nomorepies · 05/03/2021 21:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on the poster's request

BeReet · 05/03/2021 21:34

Cilla Black - I have to turn off the radio if they play her. Also Paul McCartney - and tbf many of the older singers, their voices just aren't up to it any more. Debbie Harry, (god how I love that woman) couldn't hold a tune to save her life.

poundoflard · 05/03/2021 21:25

ugh Stevie Nicks, so flat and out of tune I hate her voice soo much.

Adele just shouts, and says Skyfow...crumbow which bugs the hell out of me

Jess Glynn bleaty awful noise

Whitney and Mariah screeching shouty divas.

Mel C was the WORST of the Spice girls

All the Beatles together so nasally.
George Harrison or Lennon , good in their own right. McCartney however, nasal and v annoying.

Saw Elton John live, front row, we left less than half way through, ( we were given the tickets as we werent really fans but he was feckin dismal)

I'm glad someone started this thread as I was getting a rage with the radio playing all these flippin annoying artists and who the hell thought they were good, and it seems lots of us are in agreement that many artists have dreadful vocals.

DreamEvenBigger · 05/03/2021 21:22

The Beatles. All of them. How did they ever reach the status they did?

Eastie77 · 05/03/2021 21:22

I watched footage of Live Aid online the other day. Watching singers like Phil Collins, who I am not a particular fan off, walk on stage with nothing apart from a piano to accompany him and just sing live - zero auto tune or any other 'help' - made me realise how poor singers are today compared to those of yesteryear. They had real talent and could actually sing. Honestly most of the best singers are already dead.

TSBelliot · 05/03/2021 21:08

In our house Tsmainsqueezw Anyone who had a heart is sang Cilla style as a way of condemning a singer. I wonder if we are listening to the same versions!

DrSbaitso · 05/03/2021 21:07

I've heard a lot of singers who were very passionate but still sounded like shit. Passion and emotion are important, but to be art, they need to be shaped.

ChocBeforeCock · 05/03/2021 21:07

I saw Ronan live in Once the Musical (which is genuinely utter wank but that’s not his fault. It was about 5 years ago and he was decent. Not world class but I think can’t sing is but harsh

... this however made me laugh Grin

For me Ronan Keating sings it best, when he sings nothing at all