Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Removing shoes indoors

615 replies

diagold4u · 04/03/2021 15:35

Am interested to know how many people actually have the rule of no shoes indoors.
We've had this rule from when I was young and have carried it on when I moved out. I think it makes sense not to walk all over the house with shoes that have been worn outdoors, who knows what you've stood on and then bringing all that in to your home.
I have shoe covers that I provide to workers.
Especially with young children I think it's even more important not to wear outdoor shoes indoor, carpets/rug will harbour all that dirt no matter how much you Hoover up.

My actual aibu is, if someone came to my house as a guest would it be U for me to ask them to remove their shoes? Obviously in a polite manner.
I feel quite embarrassed having to ask when these people already know.
My current house is all flooring with large rugs everywhere, the main living room is carpet.
I've noticed certain extended family members get annoyed at my request but the way I see it, it's my house, if I don't walk with shoes, why should you when you've chosen to come to my house.

OP posts:
Bananaman123 · 05/03/2021 19:23

I always have slippers on but my dp always has shoes on, does my headin. I dont ask guests to remove shoes but if i go to my parents first thing i do is take shoes off.

SplendidSuns1000 · 05/03/2021 19:10

We live on a farm so shoes stay downstairs, no carpet only rugs so it's not too much of an issue if a bit of mud is walked through. We have a covered porch where we put very mucky shoes and guests usually follow suit or at least take them off by the door. I've never had to ask guests to take their shoes off because they do anyway. Cream carpets upstairs though so no shoes on the ground up there.

queenbee72 · 05/03/2021 19:05

Really??? That’s bizarre. Lots of visitors then.

queenbee72 · 05/03/2021 19:04

Shoes on here. I often offer in posh houses but hope they’ll say “don’t worry it’s fine”. I don’t wear nice shoes to take them off when I arrive. Who’s eating off the floor, lying on their carpet that it has to be disinfectantly clean. The mind boggles. I want guests to be comfortable. A house is for living in.

VinylDetective · 05/03/2021 19:03

Thing is you don’t have to compromise in your own house. What you say goes.

RMNMummy · 05/03/2021 18:59

@VinylDetective

I would however ask them whether I could possibly keep my socks on as a compromise

And I’d say no because I don’t want your shoes cluttering up my tiny hall and making it untidy. In this house the place for shoes is on your feet.

Wow, stern!

I like compromise. If someone insisted on wearing shoes in my house the compromise would be disposable blue shoe coverings.

Jayne35 · 05/03/2021 18:58

Downstairs I’m not bothered, I have a dog and the floor gets covered in mud constantly at the moment. MIL always takes off her shoes and I always say please don’t your socks will be filthy. Stair and upstairs carpets are newish so we do take off shoes before going up.

TrishTeres · 05/03/2021 18:58

Your house. Your rules. That's totally fine. Don't hesitate to ask. Nice to have spare thick socks to offer for anyone who might be cold but it's your choice.

therealteamdebbie · 05/03/2021 18:58

@DrSbaitso

I happen to CLEAN my floors, unlike most people with carpets!

Where have you got the idea that people with carpets don't clean/hoover them?

hoover is not cleaning

its merely removing the dust

My point exactly

80sMum · 05/03/2021 18:54

We don't wear shoes indoors but I would never ask a guest to remove their shoes! If they do it spontaneously, fine. If they don't, then I don't ask them, as I assume that would embarrass them.

I do, however, ask traders and workmen to take shoes off - especially if they are going upstairs, which is carpeted.

FinallyHere · 05/03/2021 18:53

I grew up in a climate with winters much harsher than the UK experiences. Shoes off indoors makes absolute sense when the shoes are snow boots.

Never wear shoes indoors, keep a pair of shoes at the back door and store all shoes at the front door. Never had to ask people, they either take their shows off when they see all the shows at the door or hesitate, so that I can offer shoes covers.

Most of our circle will bring 'indoor shoes' to change into for parties and things.

Floors downstairs are all wood, with a patch of dark mat between the front door and the sit down and change shows area.

Seems to work.

VinylDetective · 05/03/2021 18:53

I would however ask them whether I could possibly keep my socks on as a compromise

And I’d say no because I don’t want your shoes cluttering up my tiny hall and making it untidy. In this house the place for shoes is on your feet.

DrSbaitso · 05/03/2021 18:51

I happen to CLEAN my floors, unlike most people with carpets!

Where have you got the idea that people with carpets don't clean/hoover them?

therealteamdebbie · 05/03/2021 18:50

I have seen groups with photos of carpeted rooms, living room or bedrooms, everybody in socks, and toddlers being potty trained, or having their nappy changed 😂

so spare me the "it is ONLY a hygienic issue"

I don't take my shoes off to go to the loo at work, I respect your rules absolutely, but I don't like walking in your home without my shoes on.

I happen to CLEAN my floors, unlike most people with carpets! So I am pretty confident my house is much cleaner anyway, even if I don't cook or lick the floor or need to have any air about shoes inside.

DrSbaitso · 05/03/2021 18:49

@ItsIgginningtolooklikelockdown

Ah get a life drsbaito, it is perfectly reasonable to point out that shoes-off can't be quite as commonplace as some posters believe or it would be reflected in television programmes. I mention keeping up appearances as a joke was made in it of the main characters obsession with removing shoes. I can't think of other shows where it happens. Do you sit shouting "take your shoes off!!" at unrealistic portrayal on the tv? Well no, as many many people do not have this as a rule. These days, my family do all remove their shoes but I wouldn't ask it of a guest.
Oh my God, you were serious. I wasn't actually being facetious. I genuinely thought you were being ridiculous on purpose and trying to set off the classism. The whole "ooh, only on the one about the truly posh people" just cinched it in my mind.

Awkward. Sorry, I guess?

Right, OK. Er, where do we start? The fact that TV programmes are not reality? That they serve a dramatic purpose and are staged that way? Taking off shoes every time would slow the dialogue down. Characters being shoeless would be distracting for viewers and would spoil the look of their outfits. They don't break off sentences and talk over each other as they would in reality either, unless that's a desired dramatic effect (same for removing shoes). They don't say "bye" at the end of phone calls, at least in American shows. They wear makeup in bed. They have lifestyles that their jobs wouldn't really sustain.

They're not generally supposed to be a true reflection of real life. They are dramatisations staged for particular effect.

supperlover · 05/03/2021 18:49

Only read about half way through so far and am amazed by how many people have a shoes off rule. I've lived in different parts of the uk, mostly in rural areas, and don't have any friends or relatives who do this. Years ago we used to know one couple who lived in Surrey and they asked us to remove our shoes. We were very surprised and thought it quite rude. We live in the country and I just about persuade my husband to remove his gardening boots in the kitchen before tramping through to the sitting room.

bondgirl76 · 05/03/2021 18:47

I dont worry about it because i have wooden floors through out.If i had carpets..i would worry.When i was first married..we had a new flat.It had very nice off cream carpet..2 days later..someone dropped a cup of coffee on it..it never really came out.I would never have carpets..ever.

RMNMummy · 05/03/2021 18:44

@TheKeatingFive

Why on earth would you WANT someone to keep their shoes on in your house...?

I don’t want to see people’s feet. I hate feet. I have sensible flooring and am capable of cleaning it when required.

Is it a phobia? If so, totally understandable.

Are sock-on feet acceptable?

I didn’t realise one spends time with their visitors sat looking at their feet. Interesting!

littlejlb · 05/03/2021 18:42

I dont think its an unreasonable request to be honest,especially if it's your household rule. If I am visiting a household, often one i have not been to, I often ask if they would like me to remove my shoes, out of politeness. At home, its not necessarily a rule, but on the whole, once in, we take our shoes off, out of comfort.

mussymummy · 05/03/2021 18:41

I was raised in a keep shoes on house and dp was raised in a shoes off at door house. To be honest never bothered him unless I was wearing heels (wood floors downstairs). Since covid I have insisted all shoes off at door, even my mum (extended family) keeps a pair of slippers at ours now
However I would never ask a guest or insist they remove their shoes. I remember the utter embarrassment of being at my MILs house the first time and do did not warn me, mismatching socks, one with a hole my big toe was sticking through!

TeaAndBiscuitsAndWine · 05/03/2021 18:40

May inside ad outside front door, and I always indicate the Uber one to guests and say “you can leave your shoes here”. If they don’t take the hint, I stop them and ask them to take their shoes off. Workpersons I ask to use shoe covers. Parents and grandparents houses it was always shoes off, and at all my friends. I would really not want it any other way, as frankly otherwise you may as well be rolling around on the pavement!

Ddot · 05/03/2021 18:40

Its gross, I argue relentlessly with fella. To save yelling I bought him some huge slippers that go over your boots.

LILLYPRINT · 05/03/2021 18:39

I would expect the same. We never wear outdoor shoes indoors and would not expect visitors to,.

RMNMummy · 05/03/2021 18:37

@therealteamdebbie

RMNMummy

Urm... How is it disrespectful to take your shoes off in any way shape or form?

Ignoring your host preferences or customs is just rude.

Do you also ignore any social rules when you travel because you think you are superior to every one else, or just in this country?

Necessary with the ‘superior’ part? 🙄😑

I’ve never, in my entire long life, in this country or the many I have visited (and respected) been ASKED by my host to keep my shoes ON.

If, for example, a friend informed me in advance that they would want me to keep my shoes on when coming over, then I would presume there would be a proper reason and obviously I respect that. I would however ask them whether I could possibly keep my socks on as a compromise.

It’s my opinion that it’s absolutely disgusting to keep your shoes on inside a house, seeing as our shoes are walked all over outdoors where dogs pee & people spit.

ItsIgginningtolooklikelockdown · 05/03/2021 18:35

Ah get a life drsbaito, it is perfectly reasonable to point out that shoes-off can't be quite as commonplace as some posters believe or it would be reflected in television programmes.
I mention keeping up appearances as a joke was made in it of the main characters obsession with removing shoes. I can't think of other shows where it happens. Do you sit shouting "take your shoes off!!" at unrealistic portrayal on the tv? Well no, as many many people do not have this as a rule.
These days, my family do all remove their shoes but I wouldn't ask it of a guest.