Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Removing shoes indoors

615 replies

diagold4u · 04/03/2021 15:35

Am interested to know how many people actually have the rule of no shoes indoors.
We've had this rule from when I was young and have carried it on when I moved out. I think it makes sense not to walk all over the house with shoes that have been worn outdoors, who knows what you've stood on and then bringing all that in to your home.
I have shoe covers that I provide to workers.
Especially with young children I think it's even more important not to wear outdoor shoes indoor, carpets/rug will harbour all that dirt no matter how much you Hoover up.

My actual aibu is, if someone came to my house as a guest would it be U for me to ask them to remove their shoes? Obviously in a polite manner.
I feel quite embarrassed having to ask when these people already know.
My current house is all flooring with large rugs everywhere, the main living room is carpet.
I've noticed certain extended family members get annoyed at my request but the way I see it, it's my house, if I don't walk with shoes, why should you when you've chosen to come to my house.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 20:53

@wellthatsunusual

Or you would do some basic research to have an idea of what is acceptable abroad? As opposed to make them feel like a horrible host who need to spell everything, or to make you appear as someone full of themselves, too grand to be casual.

Full of myself for trying to be polite? Confused

I haven't at any stage said I'd refuse to do what is expected, all I have said is that I can't read minds. Even reading thks thread must show that some people think it's horribly rude to take your shoes off whilst others think it's horribly rude to not take your shoes off. And then on top of that some people think that it's rude not to be able to guess which type of house you are in.

The basic manners I was brought up with is that when you are a guest in someone's house, you wait until they ask you to sit down, you don't ask if it's ok. You wait until they offer you food or drink, you don't ask for something. And taking your shoes off would be the same; unless they suggest you take them off, you'd assume they want you to keep them on. Much like your coat in that respect. I'm not trying to be grand, I'm trying to be polite.

If they take their shoes off, it's fine to assume they don't mind if you do, even if they don't actively want you to (they do). They are probably trying to be polite by demonstrating it so they don't have to ask you. But if in doubt, just ask.

I think you've had a few weird things taught to you, by the way. While a host certainly should offer you a drink, there's really nothing wrong with politely asking if you could have one.

The shoes off social cues really aren't this mysterious or complicated.

wellthatsunusual · 06/03/2021 20:43

Or you would do some basic research to have an idea of what is acceptable abroad? As opposed to make them feel like a horrible host who need to spell everything, or to make you appear as someone full of themselves, too grand to be casual.

Full of myself for trying to be polite? Confused

I haven't at any stage said I'd refuse to do what is expected, all I have said is that I can't read minds. Even reading thks thread must show that some people think it's horribly rude to take your shoes off whilst others think it's horribly rude to not take your shoes off. And then on top of that some people think that it's rude not to be able to guess which type of house you are in.

The basic manners I was brought up with is that when you are a guest in someone's house, you wait until they ask you to sit down, you don't ask if it's ok. You wait until they offer you food or drink, you don't ask for something. And taking your shoes off would be the same; unless they suggest you take them off, you'd assume they want you to keep them on. Much like your coat in that respect. I'm not trying to be grand, I'm trying to be polite.

mainsfed · 06/03/2021 20:41

Shoes off all the way. I’ve seen too many people inadvertently walk in runny dog shit to ever allow shoes, even on wooden floors.

seepingweeping · 06/03/2021 20:34

I have 3 dogs and 2 children. You wearing your shoes in my house would not bother me in the slightest. You're not going to add to the germs from the dogs and kids.

goodbyelenin · 06/03/2021 20:33

That's the polar opposite of how I was brought up, which was that you only do something in someone else's house if they specifically ask you to do so. You don't ever go in and make yourself at home by copying them.

You MUST have some basic manners that allow you to survive as a guest without being told absolutely every single thing? Confused

Or you would do some basic research to have an idea of what is acceptable abroad? As opposed to make them feel like a horrible host who need to spell everything, or to make you appear as someone full of themselves, too grand to be casual.

wellthatsunusual · 06/03/2021 20:27

I have no idea why that would be rude, but if you don't want to assume, why not just ask?

Fair enough, I will if I ever find myself in that situation. Although I don't understand why the host can't just explain to make it clear.

Surely it's rude NOT to mirror your host in their own home? They're literally demonstrating in front of you how they do things.

That's the polar opposite of how I was brought up, which was that you only do something in someone else's house if they specifically ask you to do so. You don't ever go in and make yourself at home by copying them.

QueenofGallifrey · 06/03/2021 20:27

@MrBullinaChinaShop

I am disgusted at the thought of wearing slippers worn by someone else. People could have all sorts of foot afflictions (verrucas, athletes foot for example). Some peoples feet are just sweaty and rank. So I don’t want to wear slippers worn by someone else. It’s a perfectly valid opinion. I take my shoes off in other peoples houses. I take my shoes off in my own house. I just don’t like the idea of wearing slippers worn by someone else. But I didn’t realise everyone in life had to have the same opinions as everyone else, my bad.
When people visit my house they are given a pair of nice spa / salon disposable slippers. This means they can either keep them and take them home or I will bin them.

Guest slippers never get used more than once.

Family have a pair of their own slippers that they leave at mine for when they visit.

I must stress though due liking my own company, I don’t actively encourage people to come and see me, so I don’t have a lot of people in my house, so don’t go through lots of pairs of guest slippers.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 20:23

Surely it's rude NOT to mirror your host in their own home? They're literally demonstrating in front of you how they do things.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 20:16

there's no way I'd copy someone's behaviour in their own home and assume that they want me to do the same. It just seems so rude to assume.

I have no idea why that would be rude, but if you don't want to assume, why not just ask?

wellthatsunusual · 06/03/2021 20:07

Honestly, you can usually work it out. If you get there and you see a large rack of shoes by the door, and your host is shoeless or removes their shoes as they go in, it shouldn't be too much of a puzzle.

I could certainly work it out if there were a group of other guests and they don't have their shoes on. But there's no way I'd copy someone's behaviour in their own home and assume that they want me to do the same. It just seems so rude to assume.

I've never been in a house with a rack of shoes by the door though, so hopefully I haven't offended anyone.

I wasn't even allowed to wander around my own house without shoes growing up, never mind take them off at someone else's.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 20:03

But how are they supposed to know if you don't tell them? This is what I don't understand. I'm happy to do it if someone wants me to, but how would I know what is expected of me if no one tells me?

Honestly, you can usually work it out. If you get there and you see a large rack of shoes by the door, and your host is shoeless or removes their shoes as they go in, it shouldn't be too much of a puzzle.

If you're at all unsure, you can just ask. Sometimes when I've gone somewhere and they're wearing soft shoes that aren't quite slippers, I've just asked if they would like me to remove my shoes. Might add that I have a shoeless house to make sure they don't feel obliged to say I can keep them on if they don't want me to. If asking has ever caused great offence, I don't know about it. They've invited me back.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 19:58

It just seems odd to me to prioritise carpets over guests

And to the other side, it's odd to prioritise your preferences over respect for your host's home.

They're not prioritising the carpet over you, anyway; that makes it sound as though you and the carpet both want the last slice of cake. Guests also have obligations. You have been invited into their private home, and while you are receiving their hospitality, you respect their environment. If you dislike the rules of their home that much, you have no business accepting the invitation to go there.

Would you think it "odd" or "prioritising the carpet over guests" if a Muslim family asked you to remove your shoes for faith/cultural reasons?

wellthatsunusual · 06/03/2021 19:57

@Alonelonelyloner

I'm from the UK, am Middle Aged and was brought up in a British shoes off house. This idea that it's foreign is just rubbish and actually all the shoe on houses I remember as kids (and even now) I thought of as being really dirty.

I don't ask people when they come round, it should be obvious. I don't insist but it does make me judge them harshly when they keep their shoes on.

But how are they supposed to know if you don't tell them? This is what I don't understand. I'm happy to do it if someone wants me to, but how would I know what is expected of me if no one tells me?
ArtichokeAardvark · 06/03/2021 19:55

Halfway house here. Upstairs (carpeted) is shoes off. Downstairs is all tiled and very cold to walk on so shoes are actively encouraged!

Alonelonelyloner · 06/03/2021 19:51

I'm from the UK, am Middle Aged and was brought up in a British shoes off house. This idea that it's foreign is just rubbish and actually all the shoe on houses I remember as kids (and even now) I thought of as being really dirty.

I don't ask people when they come round, it should be obvious. I don't insist but it does make me judge them harshly when they keep their shoes on.

TheNestedIf · 06/03/2021 18:56

I don't allow shoes in my flat. I live in London where the streets are paved not with gold but with urine, faeces and vomit.

I do have a large stock of shoe covers, which I'm happy to provide if needed, although it's astounding how many workmen don't get the concept that they can't keep them on if they're "just going to the van" and then walk back in in them.

23PissOffAvenueWF · 06/03/2021 18:53

I was brought up with the rule that you should absolutely above all be a good host to your guests ,even if it inconvenienced you - give them the last slice of cake, let the visiting child choose the game etc - so that’s probably why I fall into camp (A), but I guess it’s arbitrary really.

It just seems odd to me to prioritise carpets over guests, but that’s my upbringing.
Maybe I’m a doormat!

Absolutely agree with your top two points - and no, you’re not a doormat!

user143677433 · 06/03/2021 18:45

@DrSbaitso

Given how many people on both sides of the divide think the other one is "rude", we can probably discount manners as a means of justification, since there's absolutely no consensus on it.

I can't help noticing that many people who have gone for "I wouldn't be so rude" are quite happy to be extremely bad mannered towards those on the other side.

So far as I can see (but I admit I am biased) it’s divided into:

(A) People who think the host should defer to the guest (on or off is the guests choice)

(B) People who think the guest should defer to the host (on or off is the hosts choice)

I was brought up with the rule that you should absolutely above all be a good host to your guests ,even if it inconvenienced you - give them the last slice of cake, let the visiting child choose the game etc - so that’s probably why I fall into camp (A), but I guess it’s arbitrary really.

It just seems odd to me to prioritise carpets over guests, but that’s my upbringing. Maybe I’m a doormat!

Itsokthanks · 06/03/2021 18:14

I always take my shoes of in houses with carpet. I find it awkward to ask people but also don't understand why they don't automatically do it. Shoes on carpets is a big no for me.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2021 18:10

Given how many people on both sides of the divide think the other one is "rude", we can probably discount manners as a means of justification, since there's absolutely no consensus on it.

I can't help noticing that many people who have gone for "I wouldn't be so rude" are quite happy to be extremely bad mannered towards those on the other side.

Localocal · 06/03/2021 17:39

We take our shoes off as soon as we come in, but more for comfort than cleanliness. I would never ask a guest to do so, though. For some people their outfit is their armour, their costume. I think it's rude to ask them to remove a piece of it. Plus my feet get cold really easily and most people's houses are not warm enough for my taste. I hate having cold feet - am never without slipper socks or slippers at home, even though I keep the house at 23 when I'm home. So I am sometimes physically uncomfortable if made to remove my shoes in someone's house.

Unless you have very expensive white carpeting I think it's rude to ask people to remove their shoes.

wellthatsunusual · 06/03/2021 16:35

[quote amispeakingenglish]@wellthatsunusual Demographics hey! All my Muslim friends would think it very rude not to take off shoes.

I think its rude to traipse germs and filth all over someone's house. Mind you if I go to a house where the owners wear shoes inside, I do too as their floors are as dirty as the street outside and I don't walk on that in my socks!
I also ask when I go to someone's house for the first time.[/quote]
I have no objection to taking my shoes off, it just would never occur to me that someone might want me to take my shoes off unless they say so.

shadypines · 06/03/2021 16:10

I can't tell you how many times DC have stood in dog mess so no brainer for me. Why woud you want dog/cat/bird mess in your house, not to mention people's spit etc etc (blurrgh..pass me a bucket.) Apart from that rugs, carpet, laminate are expensive, I really don't get shoes on unless you've got a really large house with numerous choices of rooms and a maid who hoovers/mops every day i.e your the Queen.

amispeakingenglish · 06/03/2021 16:09

@wellthatsunusual Demographics hey! All my Muslim friends would think it very rude not to take off shoes.

I think its rude to traipse germs and filth all over someone's house. Mind you if I go to a house where the owners wear shoes inside, I do too as their floors are as dirty as the street outside and I don't walk on that in my socks!
I also ask when I go to someone's house for the first time.

amispeakingenglish · 06/03/2021 16:05

@user143677433 Not a hazard if clean slippers are provided or shoe covers. Crocs are great for this as comfy warm and washable!

Swipe left for the next trending thread