Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She is 18, he is 34!

340 replies

ManyBooksLittleTime · 28/02/2021 09:03

I am so upset. My daughter has been dating since lockdown and has stopped us seeing her boyfriend. She told us he was 20. We have become increasingly suspicious as to his age. When we have caught glimpses of him from afar, he has hidden in a big hood and turned away.

The day before yesterday she announced he had been phoning flats for them to move in together.

My husband and I decided we needed to see this guy. She had managed to get him a job with her and I went into the shop unannounced yesterday.My husband and I both saw him and could tell he was older even with the facemask. We paid for searches online and discovered he is 34!

We then went to his house to meet him. We met him and his dad and he seemed reasonably nice.

We don't want her moving in with him. He constantly makes her cry eg he ignored both her 18 th and Valentine's day.

What do you all think? I think if we hadn't had the pandemic, she would have met someone younger and more dynamic and I'm gutted she is settling for this guy.
AIBU?

OP posts:
ThePriceOfSugar · 28/02/2021 21:37

I dated a 32yo when I was 17, my dad had words with him but parents didn't try to stop me. I was with him 3 years, it ended when he assaulted me and I spent the next 2y in court trying to get him convicted for it (successful). I learned a lot about what not to do/tolerate in a relationship but it was a huge waste of time and not worth it just for the Audi of his which I thought was sooo cool. I wish someone had intervened.

MorganKitten · 28/02/2021 20:42

To me that age gap isn’t an issue at all, making her cry is.

ItscoldinAlaska · 28/02/2021 20:32

As someone in a relationship with someone who has previously been in an age gap relationship I would just keep giving your DD the message 'We are here for you' and be the practical crutch.

My DP got into a relationship at 17 with a 36 year old married teacher, whose own son was 16 (vomit). They were together over a decade and she moved him 150 miles away from his family. She is a controlling, abusive nightmare who still tries to wreak havoc in his life. He struggled to say no to her so he (at my insistence) cut her off. I basically had to educate him that it was an abusive relationship. The damage to DP is very apparent - his mum said nothing (he got badly beat up by the husband and his mum just seemed to wash her hands with it all Hmm)

Just be there for her. As someone who has a 17 year old DS thoufh, I would struggle to keep calm if he got into a relationship with a large age gap after seeing what I have seen.

SummerWhisper · 28/02/2021 20:02

So many blood-red flags:

  • Two dates that daughter orgainsed and paid for
  • In love already
  • Daughter has to organise his employment
  • Moving in together already
  • Ignores her 18th birthday (doesn't want to spend his money?)
  • Ignores valentine's day (ditto re his money)
  • Happy to call your daughter a liar to you regarding his age
  • No capability to manage his life

He is really worrying me. Please, check up on his past some more.

His family probably can't believe their luck in getting rid of him - to an innocent and trusting young woman with prospects. My flesh is crawling.

MrsBobDylan · 28/02/2021 19:38

Agreed this isn't good, must be horribly stressful for you op. All I would say is that it is quite likely your dd lacks confidence and if she had found a man nearer her own age, he might also have been a complete twat too.

I would focus on building your dds sense of self-worth and confidence. I wouldn't engage in conversation about this man other than "that's nice dear, am glad he makes you happy" then go on to detail how she deserves to be happy. Talk about your own relationship and why was important to you in terms of equality, respect, kindness etc.

ManyBooksLittleTime · 28/02/2021 16:42

Thank you so much for all of these messages, we are really grateful. I have been reading them out to my husband. Thank you so much for sharing your experiences.

In particular, I will watch the language that I use with her and focus on her decisions and life choices without being insulting or patronising.

She has actually only been 18 for 2 months, so we will keep trying to delay this decision to move in together. We have asked him to delay things and it will be a test of his character to see if he does. I don't think he will.
She is at work until 5 PM and I'm currently dreading her coming home . Her conversation this morning was all about us meeting and whether or not we would be notifying their work about the age difference, ( obviously not).

The more I think of our conversation with her bf yesterday, the more dubious I am. He told us he thought we knew about his age and it must be our daughter that just decided to lie about it. His family seem totally on board with the relationship.

One reason we were partially taken in by the lies was because his life stage seems to be that of a 20 the old. He has drifted between lie paid jobs, doesn't drive and lives with 8 relatives. I now want to explore if there is anything dodgy about what he has been up to in the last 18 years since leaving school!

Thank you all again and I am so sorry about the bad experiences some of you have been through. Xx

OP posts:
TurquoiseDragon · 28/02/2021 15:36

Everyone is focussing upon the age gap - surely that isn’t relevant.

It is very relevant. As others have said, there's a huge amount of grooming going on, because older women wouldn't put up with some of these men, they aren't really capable of being mature, decent blokes in a relationship.

It's about life experience. A 16-20 year old isn't going to have much experience, while an older bloke is going to have so much more, which contributes to the power imbalance between the two.

I'm 52 and my ex would have beeen 60 this year. 8 years isn't much at this stage of life, but was a huge difference when we met when I was 18. I'm not the same person I was when I was 18. I was immature then, no matter how much I wanted to believe I was a mature adult.

Thing is, even at 18 I hadn't finished growing up, and most 18 year olds are in the same boat.

I grew up and realised I couldn't be in the relationship. Took me a while to get free, he was abusive. My lack of experience at 18 meant that I was vulnerable and missed the massive red flags.

However, OP says she's remaining calm, and I think it would be better to focus on the behaviour not the age. It's easier to point to tangible reasons if the behaviour is the focus.

Kateguide · 28/02/2021 14:52

This thread has made me think of my MIL & FIL, they got married to each other at aged 18 and 33 years old respectively. Unfortunately my MIL (who was lovely) died last year from cancer but had lived a very small life in most part due to her painfully socially awkward husband - they didn't go out, go on holiday, have friends over - in fact, I don't think he has any friends, she did as she fortunately had a job that gave her a bit of a social life.

He is not a horrible man but equally not someone you look forward to going to see either. They were married for nearly 40 years and raised 3 sons - I married the most emotionally intelligent of them, he left to go to uni at 18 and never went back.

My MIL really hated her father, who was apparently not a nice man, I think she got married so young to rebel and escape. I often wonder what her life would have been if she just waited a few years.

dottiedodah · 28/02/2021 14:39

I always think 18 is so young ,and yet supposed to be a fully grown Adult! At that age moving in with anyone at all, seems far too young to me, let alone with someone twice her age! Has she ever had a boyfriend before now? Maybe she wasnt treated well by them either and has low self esteem? As said here ,hopefully she will come to her senses sooner than later ? Do you have other DC she could turn, to or similar age cousins /friends at all.She may open up to them maybe?

partyatthepalace · 28/02/2021 13:59

I can absolutely see your concerns, but I think you have to tread carefully to get the result you want. At this age your daughter will not listen to you about her love life. Wrong foot her a bit by being neutral and supportive of her.

Get to know him, and be nice, but organise it so you also see her separately. When you are with her talk about her future and all the things she could do, and when lockdown lifts all the things her peers are doing - with any luck living with a 34 year old who has a presumably minimum wage job in a shop and only because of her will loose it’s appeal pretty quickly. If you can help her with money so she can go and have some experiences that will widen her world view (eg weekends or holidays with friends, or college course) then do.

Slowly slowly catchy monkey as my Granny used to say.

haggisandmarsbar · 28/02/2021 13:30

He sounds like he's of limited intelligence if he needs an 18 year old to help him apply for jobs, either that or he's manipulative as fuck and as devious as they come.

user1936784158962 · 28/02/2021 12:54

@HairyChin I'm sorry you got such a shitty response on your other thread. What you described sounds like abuse and I'm sorry it happened to you.

There are organisations who can support you with your trauma and I hope that one poster's response doesn't stop you reaching out for support from one of them. Flowers

PurBal · 28/02/2021 12:19

I was in an age gap relationship at the same age (same gap too). Whilst it didn't work out we are still good friends 12 years later. I would say that he never took it as seriously as I did or as your daughters BF seems to. He wouldn't label us as girlfriend/boyfriend until years later but acknowledges it now. I never kept his age from my parents though. They are both adults. Let them get on with it.

billy1966 · 28/02/2021 12:16

@WishingHopingThinkingPraying

I think you need to empower her. Tell her you trust her to make her own decisions and that if she ever changed her mind or needed any support you're there.id tell her that his age is a bit of a red flag because without knowing him, him choosing an 18yr old indicates he prefers a certain power balance and a more vulnerable partner rather than an equal one. But you trust her to protect herself from that if it later becomes clear that is the case. Tell her you'll follow her lead because it's her decision and you'll always try to be fair to him and give him a chance out of respect for her.
This.

And help her bullet proof her contraception.

How awful for you.

Hopefully the reality of being with a lazy waster, and especially living with one, will wake her up.

By being very very open with her, will make it easier for her to confide when things hopefully go tits up.

Flowers
IstandwithJackieWeaver · 28/02/2021 12:14

When I was a student we had a housemate our age who was a bit odd and immature. We were all 21. His girlfriends were always the 16 year old Saturday staff at the supermarket he had a part time job in. Because he could impress them, but not the women his own age. A guy in his mid 30s living with his parents with no job until his 18 year old girlfriend helps him out is not a catch. He's not even an equal.

Tiktokersmiracle · 28/02/2021 12:14

@MrCheeseIsAnImposter

^nd for the record, my DP was 31 when we met and I was 18. At the time I was engaged to a 19 year old who was a violent, abusing prick. So age is fuck all to do with it.^

Funny you're not the only poster to say they left an abusive person before their massively older partner showed up.

Do you think low bar, lack of boundaries, is usually the best foundation for a healthy relationship?

Considering we are still together 21 years later with two DC's and he rebuilt me after abuse from that ex-partner and a very abusive childhood, yeah pretty much was a great foundation in our case

HTH.

MrsHusky · 28/02/2021 12:11

@littlepattilou

Can't add anything to what most people have said.

Abnormal and weird. What can a man in his mid 30s POSSIBLY have in common with someone in their TEENS? Weird.

marriage failing after 12+ years aside, for my age gap relationship... we liked the same music, followed the same bands, watched the same films.. we both liked gaming, had full time jobs (i never went to uni and went into full time work at 18) drove and maintained our own cars and were in the same social scene/shared friends.

Its not always as simple as 'what do they have in common, ew'

The issue isnt what they do/dont have in common, in hindsght and looking back at why my relationship failed.. its about levels of maturity, and the older person having some level of control/protective inclination.

These kind of relationships dont work out because (like mine) once the younger person matures and begins to assert themselves, finds new interests, new friendship groups...etc the older/controller/protector suddenly feels left out, unloved and gets nasty about it.

My ExH's line was 'i dont recognise you, you aren't the same person i married' too right i fucking wasnt.. i was a mid 30's mom with a lifetimes experience, not a 19 yo who thought she was a grown up.

ManyBooksLittleTime · 28/02/2021 12:07

Hi, we are being very calm about the situation with her. We will take all the advice to stay calm, talk as adults and keep our doors open. Thank you. At the end of the day they have only had two dates and she organised and paid for both. She says she hasn't loaned him money.She just doesn't know him.

They work at a supermarket , so she can get as many shifts as she likes. He got the job because she collected adverts for him and helped him to apply, then sung his praises to her boss and he got a job with her. We are worried about their finances. This should be a p/t job whilst she finishes her college course. She is currently applying and interviewing for the profession she wants. We really don't want her to throw this away.

It isn't just the age gap. I wouldn't want her moving in with this guy if he was 20.

OP posts:
Kateguide · 28/02/2021 11:57

Hi, so many good comments on here. What kind relationship do you have with your daughter? Would she listen to you or is she quite rebellious /defiant? Could you have a meaningful discussion with her about this? I remember being a total nightmare at 14 to 16 but by 18 I had calmed down and realised my parents just wanted me to succeed in life.

There are so many red flags on this:
*he makes her upset
*disregards major milestone events
*lacks motivation
*lives at home with extended family
*he is double her age
*ignoring the age gap, they haven't 'dated' properly as everything has been shut down. It would be too soon in normal circumstances

Some people keep saying she's an adult, let her do what she wants. I disagree. Just because she is legally an adult doesn't mean she is suddenly blessed with common sense, maturity and good decision making skills overnight and sometimes needs guidance to find her way. Good luck

IcedPurple · 28/02/2021 11:41

@MrCheeseIsAnImposter

I wonder how many posters here who think it's 'totally normal' would try it on with an 17 year old themselves. Hmm I'm, betting the number is close to zero.

And those with huge 20 year age gaps are probably really enjoying the age related ED that comes with it.

Exactly.

Funny how we've had several people here saying they were 17 - but so mature and sophisticated - when they met their 50 year old husband and they've been 'happily married' for years, but none saying they were 40 when they met a really 'mature' 15 year old boy and they've had a healthy relationship for decades.

Caplin · 28/02/2021 11:37

When I was about to turn 17 I started dating a guy aged 34 who I worked with. He was a really lovely person, my parents adored him.

It all fizzled after 4 years. I went uni, wanted more out of life. He was happy where he was.

Maybe your daughter’s relationship will work, chances are it won’t. She has to learn this for herself.

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 28/02/2021 11:31

When we were 19, my friend had a fling with a guy who was 38. At the time we thought it was fine. Now I’m 37, I think it’s unnerving. Legal, but immoral due to the huge imbalance of power.

I agree on being cautious and avoiding any ultimatums. Don’t make it difficult for her to end it. I would get her to talk about the birthday and valentines disappointments. Does she have friends? What do they think?

HarlotOscara · 28/02/2021 11:30

Everyone is focussing upon the age gap - surely that isn’t relevant. What is important is that he isn’t making her happy. If she’s unhappy in the early days of a relationship it doesn’t bode well for longer term.
The same would apply if they were a similar age.

DH and I met when I was 20 and he was 35.
He was living with his mum at the time which MN always seems to think is the reddest of red flags.
We’ve been together 33 years and I’ve never regretted it. He’s my best friend and has done nothing but do his very best to make me happy in all the years we’ve been together.
He’s encouraged me and supported me in my career. He’s never told me what to do because we are equal partners.
Yes, I was young but we’ve both changed and matured as time has passed. Surely change, growth and adaptation are part of every long term relationship.
Does the age gap mean he is the dominant one in the relationship? Definitely not.
Do I wish the age gap was less - yes, purely because the odds are he will die before me and I’d rather we grew old together. But let’s face it there are no guaranties in life and he could out live me.
Would I have stopped seeing him at the start because my parents disapproved? No, in fact it would have made me rush headlong into the relationship instead of just taking things as they came.

IcedPurple · 28/02/2021 11:29

*My BIL was 28 ( and with a 5 year old son) when he met his to be wife - then 16.

Still happily married 25 years on.*

Are we meant to see this as a good thing?

So your BIL met a girl just barely above the legal age of consent when he was already a mature man with a son? No wonder they're still 'happily married'. She probably never had a real relationship before she met him and therefore knows no better.

Gerla · 28/02/2021 11:24

Does she actually know how old he is? When I was only slightly older I was in a relationship with someone 15 years older and I thought he was only five years older - yes, I know, I was very naive. By the time I realised he was controlling, it was very difficult to leave, not helped by the fact that my mother thought he was lovely. Hmm I wish someone had talked to me honestly about their misgivings as I already had my own but thought I was being ridiculous.