Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She is 18, he is 34!

340 replies

ManyBooksLittleTime · 28/02/2021 09:03

I am so upset. My daughter has been dating since lockdown and has stopped us seeing her boyfriend. She told us he was 20. We have become increasingly suspicious as to his age. When we have caught glimpses of him from afar, he has hidden in a big hood and turned away.

The day before yesterday she announced he had been phoning flats for them to move in together.

My husband and I decided we needed to see this guy. She had managed to get him a job with her and I went into the shop unannounced yesterday.My husband and I both saw him and could tell he was older even with the facemask. We paid for searches online and discovered he is 34!

We then went to his house to meet him. We met him and his dad and he seemed reasonably nice.

We don't want her moving in with him. He constantly makes her cry eg he ignored both her 18 th and Valentine's day.

What do you all think? I think if we hadn't had the pandemic, she would have met someone younger and more dynamic and I'm gutted she is settling for this guy.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Raincoatdog · 03/03/2021 22:32

When I was 19 I dated an older guy and my parents sat back and let me get on with it under their roof. In hindsight I wish that they had questioned the situation a little more as he really played me for a mug and it was quite clear for anybody to see. He had lied to me about his age and I naively wanted to believe him, he also cheated on me and gave me an STI, purposely forgot valentine's/xmas and birthdays and was just on a huge power trip.
I really struggled to find the strength to break away from him and I think he played on the fact that my family so willingly accepted his nonsense and turned a blind eye to the way he was treating me.
I'm not sure what advice to give but do keep a close eye and make sure she knows her worth and that she deserves the best.

Blueberries0112 · 03/03/2021 21:52

I also want to tell you I was 17 who moved in with a guy who was 7 years older than me. He was the one who lied about his age.

Nothing my family could do to convince me to stay away, they only made me mad because I really liked him at the time.

The best you can do is talk to her how you feel but always make sure to keep communicating with her. Don’t talk bad about him, it will just make her mad when she is not ready. She will let you know.

Alfiemoon1 · 03/03/2021 21:44

Watching this thread with interest as I am in a similar situation with dd not so much the age gap dd is 19 and her boyfriend is 24 but he doesn’t treat her well is controlling doesn’t work and smokes weed all day.

Just out of curiosity how did they meet? What do her friends think of him or the relationship my dd friends don’t like him so unfortunately she is losing her friendship groups

Kateguide · 03/03/2021 21:08

Hi OP, you mentioned you have a son - does your daughter get on with him? Are they similar ages?

I have a brother and sister, we are similar ages and have always got on bar the odd sibling row. Whenever my brother or sister said to me "Kate - he's a bit of a prat" it made me think and reassess and usually it fizzled out pretty quickly. Could he help?

FireflyRainbow · 03/03/2021 19:33

Oh God I'd be devastated at that

Blueberries0112 · 03/03/2021 18:57

Didn’t read the rest but I wanted to point out that any man who lied about his age is not a good man and will continue to lie. And This is based on my experiences. With that said, She is of age to make her own decisions about her sex life even if it means he is going to take advantage of how little she knows about life and how people can be. Just talk to her and let her decide.

marly11 · 03/03/2021 18:49

What's worrying is the way he treats her. My mother did this, meeting my dad at that age. My grandparents were totally anti. I guess from what I know that this made her more determined. She didn't leave him until many, many years later. I would guess that if they had not been so averse, she may have been more critical herself. I guess you are just going to have to play it carefully, hope it can delay a little and then keep close to her so that you can watch and be there for her if it goes wrong, but it won't be easy. The worst thing would be to alienate her. If he does turn out to be very bad news indeed she will be more isolated with him if you dig your heels in now.

Szyz2020 · 03/03/2021 18:45

Can you talk to her about the budget needed for living together? Rent, bills, council tax, broadband, food? Furnishing it and kitting it out. Has she worked out a budget? Has he? If he hasn’t, why not? He’s the mature one with life experience surely. ;-)

What is his expectation of her in terms of her job applications and career plan, does he support it? How will they split the chores? If you ask her questions about him - is he a good cook? Will he make her favourite meals after a day at work? Is he tidier than her or a slob? A night owl or early bird? A Gamer with his mates or keen on hanging out with her? Take an interest but see if you can steer her towards seeing that having only ever had 2 dates Shock despite seemingly having been “together” for almost a year she doesn’t really know him. What did she get him for his birthday? It must have felt bad when he forgot her 18th hey. Ditto Valentines.

She needs to think through whether she’s ready to tie herself to the needs of a 34 year old or if she might not be somewhat envious of her carefree peers once lockdown lifts.

If her savings are going on a deposit, where’s his share? Why can’t he, such a lovely caring and exciting mature man of 34, match her financial input? Etc etc. Does he drive and own a car or does his dad run him about the place? Does she like his dad and his family?

Invite him round for a nice family dinner, if that’s something you do with your DD (when Covid allows). Talk about the stuff you would talk about with her normally - does he join in, hold his own? Get her to open her eyes to him in a safe environment...

LucilleTheVampireBat · 03/03/2021 18:43

I wish I could find and link some of the threads from here when Caroline Flack was dating Harry Styles. The names she was called. Disgusting.

I will never understand the people who defend men like this, utter nonces. All of you who are sooo cool with it, tell me, any of you have an 18 year old son? You'd presumably be totally cool with him bringing me home for tea. Yeah I'm 40 but the age gap isn't an issue is it. You've all said so.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/03/2021 18:42

@eeyore228

Wow some people really have dark thoughts. I get why you're wary, I think that's natural. The Way he treats her is the issue rather than the age difference. I was 19 when I met my now DH and he was 34. Not all teens are naive and immature. I knew what I was doing. Fast forward and we celebrate 17 years of marriage this year. Maybe you need to be honest about your concerns and state that you are worried but want to listen to her and her you. Beyond that now she's an adult ultimately you can be there but you can't force her to do your bidding .
The Way he treats her is the issue rather than the age difference.

I appreciate things worked out in your case but I would wager that the majority of relationships between girls of 17/18/19 and men in their 30s are not healthy and happy or viable long term because it is incredibly unusual for a well adjusted, decent man in his 30s to be comfortable dating someone who is either in school or a year or two out of it. It's a total power imbalance and life experience imbalance.

You're the exception to the rule which is obviously good for you and your partner, but doesn't mean an age gap like that in which one partner is either legally a child or only a year or less into adulthood, isn't an issue. It really is.

RootyT00t · 03/03/2021 18:34

@IcedPurple

Omg. I didn't say it was OK. How many times do I need to say it?

You didn't say it wasn't OK either.

So do you think it's wrong for grown men to date teenage girls?

I think youl find I did, more than once.

Yes

eeyore228 · 03/03/2021 18:23

Wow some people really have dark thoughts. I get why you're wary, I think that's natural. The Way he treats her is the issue rather than the age difference. I was 19 when I met my now DH and he was 34. Not all teens are naive and immature. I knew what I was doing. Fast forward and we celebrate 17 years of marriage this year. Maybe you need to be honest about your concerns and state that you are worried but want to listen to her and her you. Beyond that now she's an adult ultimately you can be there but you can't force her to do your bidding .

IcedPurple · 03/03/2021 18:18

Omg. I didn't say it was OK. How many times do I need to say it?

You didn't say it wasn't OK either.

So do you think it's wrong for grown men to date teenage girls?

RootyT00t · 03/03/2021 18:17

@IcedPurple

*This.

Also to PP who used the maturity argument, what about same sex relationships? You say that a 34 year old man dating a 17/18 year old girl is ok, but by your 'maturity' logic the same man dating a 17/18 year old boy is less ok? Is that right?*

"Maturity" - which is never actually defined - is always used in these discussion to justify creepy (relatively) old blokes chasing teenage girls. Almost every teenage girl thinks she's so grown-up and sophiscated. Hardly any of them actually are.

If a near middle aged man is near the level of 'maturity' of a teenage girl, there is somthing profoundly wrong with him.

Omg. I didn't say it was OK. How many times do I need to say it?
IcedPurple · 03/03/2021 18:16

*This.

Also to PP who used the maturity argument, what about same sex relationships? You say that a 34 year old man dating a 17/18 year old girl is ok, but by your 'maturity' logic the same man dating a 17/18 year old boy is less ok? Is that right?*

"Maturity" - which is never actually defined - is always used in these discussion to justify creepy (relatively) old blokes chasing teenage girls. Almost every teenage girl thinks she's so grown-up and sophiscated. Hardly any of them actually are.

If a near middle aged man is near the level of 'maturity' of a teenage girl, there is somthing profoundly wrong with him.

RootyT00t · 03/03/2021 18:13

@IcedPurple

The difference isn't slight. It's a scientific fact

No it isn't. There isn't even any scientific consensus of what 'maturity' means, certainly not in the context of dating people twice your age.

But as I said, even if it was 'scientific fact' there will always be exceptions. There must be some 17 year old schoolboys who are so incredibly 'mature' and some 17 year old girls who are immature. So to use your argument, maybe a "mature" 17 year old boy might be a great match for a near middle aged woman? If it's all about the 'maturity', that is?

Okay we can do the no it isn't yes it is all day.

I don't have an argument. Ice already said I don't agree with it necessarily either way.

I was just responding to a PP who completely dismissed the maturity thing because it's not totally invalid.

IcedPurple · 03/03/2021 18:11

The difference isn't slight. It's a scientific fact

No it isn't. There isn't even any scientific consensus of what 'maturity' means, certainly not in the context of dating people twice your age.

But as I said, even if it was 'scientific fact' there will always be exceptions. There must be some 17 year old schoolboys who are so incredibly 'mature' and some 17 year old girls who are immature. So to use your argument, maybe a "mature" 17 year old boy might be a great match for a near middle aged woman? If it's all about the 'maturity', that is?

NameChangedForThisFeb21 · 03/03/2021 18:09

But men in their 30s are far more of an equal to a 17 year old girl than your other example. It's a fact

No it’s not. No they aren’t. It’s laughable of you to suggest this.

Compare salaries. Having lived independently. Potential property ownership. The likelihood of being a parent or having been married. The fact, the SCIENTIFIC fact, that the brain isn’t even fully developed until 25.

Most men and women I know in their 30s have professional level jobs, they are married or in a long term partnership, they have young children, they’ve been to university or completed as high a level of education as they wanted to, they have mortgages or have been renting for at least 10 or close to 20 years, they’ve lived outside of the parental home for well over a decade, they’ve travelled extensively, voted in several elections, made mistakes, MATURED (either sex)...

I cannot think of a SINGLE 17 year old (either sex), for whom any of that is the case.

And a 34 year old man that’s not hit any of those milestones? Not relationship material. Especially not for a teenage girl.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/03/2021 18:08

@IcedPurple

Girls are far more mature than boys.

No they aren't. A 17 year old girl is a legal minor, probably still at school and with almost certainly very little life experience. Any difference in 'maturity' - however that is defined - between boys and girls is very slight.

A 17 year old boy is nothing like a 30 odd year old woman

Well no. But neither is a 17 year old girl anything like as 'mature' as a grown man, no matter how much the creepy bloke tries to convince them otherwise.

But men in their 30s are far more of an equal to a 17 year old girl than your other example. It's a fact.

That is not a 'fact', or anything close. And even if we accept your broad generalisation as 'fact' there will always be exceptions. So presumably you'd be fully suppotive of a nearly middle aged woman 'dating' a 17 year old schoolboy, provided he was 'mature'?

This.

Also to PP who used the maturity argument, what about same sex relationships? You say that a 34 year old man dating a 17/18 year old girl is ok, but by your 'maturity' logic the same man dating a 17/18 year old boy is less ok? Is that right?

Purpleneonpinkunicorns · 03/03/2021 18:07

I was wondering maybe she could be pregnant, or controlled by him. Hope that she speaks to you op

RootyT00t · 03/03/2021 18:07

@IcedPurple

Girls are far more mature than boys.

No they aren't. A 17 year old girl is a legal minor, probably still at school and with almost certainly very little life experience. Any difference in 'maturity' - however that is defined - between boys and girls is very slight.

A 17 year old boy is nothing like a 30 odd year old woman

Well no. But neither is a 17 year old girl anything like as 'mature' as a grown man, no matter how much the creepy bloke tries to convince them otherwise.

But men in their 30s are far more of an equal to a 17 year old girl than your other example. It's a fact.

That is not a 'fact', or anything close. And even if we accept your broad generalisation as 'fact' there will always be exceptions. So presumably you'd be fully suppotive of a nearly middle aged woman 'dating' a 17 year old schoolboy, provided he was 'mature'?

The difference isn't slight. It's a scientific fact

I personally don't think it's great either way round.

IcedPurple · 03/03/2021 18:06

Girls are far more mature than boys.

No they aren't. A 17 year old girl is a legal minor, probably still at school and with almost certainly very little life experience. Any difference in 'maturity' - however that is defined - between boys and girls is very slight.

A 17 year old boy is nothing like a 30 odd year old woman

Well no. But neither is a 17 year old girl anything like as 'mature' as a grown man, no matter how much the creepy bloke tries to convince them otherwise.

But men in their 30s are far more of an equal to a 17 year old girl than your other example. It's a fact.

That is not a 'fact', or anything close. And even if we accept your broad generalisation as 'fact' there will always be exceptions. So presumably you'd be fully suppotive of a nearly middle aged woman 'dating' a 17 year old schoolboy, provided he was 'mature'?

RootyT00t · 03/03/2021 17:59

@NameChangedForThisFeb21

Girls are far more mature than boys.

A 17 year old boy is nothing like a 30 odd year old woman

Not sure you can say that the other way round.

Ah yes the usual bollocks that is used to justify middle aged creeps targeting teenage girls.

So would it be gross if it were a 34 year old
man targeting a 17 year old boy?

And a 34 year old woman and a 17 year old girl? Is that ok? Does the maturity thing make the older woman practically a grandma?

Or does this magic formula only apply to straight men in their 30s, 40s etc and the super mature and sophisticated teenage girls?

It’s vile IMO.
All ways round. No excuses.

I'm not trying to justify anything.

PP said 'well people will probably just say girls are more mature than boy'. But they are.

But men in their 30s are far more of an equal to a 17 year old girl than your other example. It's a fact.

NameChangedForThisFeb21 · 03/03/2021 17:55

Girls are far more mature than boys.

A 17 year old boy is nothing like a 30 odd year old woman

Not sure you can say that the other way round.

Ah yes the usual bollocks that is used to justify middle aged creeps targeting teenage girls.

So would it be gross if it were a 34 year old
man targeting a 17 year old boy?

And a 34 year old woman and a 17 year old girl? Is that ok? Does the maturity thing make the older woman practically a grandma?

Or does this magic formula only apply to straight men in their 30s, 40s etc and the super mature and sophisticated teenage girls?

It’s vile IMO.
All ways round. No excuses.

RootyT00t · 03/03/2021 17:49

@IcedPurple

All of this. I've asked a number of times on this thread if the women saying they dated much older men at 17/18 would date 17/18 year old males now they are women in their 30s. Nobody has said yes which I think is telling.

Exactly.

They'd probably say that 'girls are so much more mature than boys' but no 17 year old is anywhere close to being as mature as an almost middle aged man, no matter how much she likes to think she is, or how much her 'respectful' older guy wants to convince her that she is for his own purposes. She's a kid.

I'll bet any amount of money that if these women had a friend who said -"Oh you know what! I've met this wonderful new man! Well a boy really - he's 17 and still at school - but you know, he's just so mature! I'm going to go round to his parents - who are only a few years older than me - at the weekend and ask them if they're OK with me dating their boy" - they would all consider it creepy and seriously question their friend's state of mind.

Girls are far more mature than boys.

A 17 year old boy is nothing like a 30 odd year old woman

Not sure you can say that the other way round.