Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh work making people go flexi and take a pay cut

212 replies

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 08:31

Dh works for Network rail. He’s been with them roughly 10 years but at his currently job for 3.

He’s a signaller and they are changing the hours from 6/2 - 2/10 6/6 etc to 12 hour days/nights.

But they have announced they need 14 people to go flexi, meaning they won’t get any overtime or Sundays etc. We rely to the overtime and 2 Sundays a month.

If people go flexi he would have to take a £10k pay cut from missing out on the overtime etc.

They said it will be the people who haven’t been there the longest.

Aibu to think this is wrong and the job he applied for wasn’t flexi shift? Can they even make you do it?

It also means he won’t know his shifts until a week or so in advance, which with young children makes things so much more difficult and hard for me to work.

OP posts:
flamingomingeo · 28/02/2021 09:35

@TulisaIsBrill

If you have kids and rent, check out your universal credit entitlement. Chances are, it could top up pretty much all you ‘lose’ at a rate of 75p in each lost £.

If they are going to play silly beggars, use the system to make the most of it.

They’re trying to run a business, not ‘playing silly beggars.’
lightand · 28/02/2021 09:35

@RedcurrantPuff

A lot of companies are doing this, fire and rehire. Some might be genuine but I bet there are a fair number taking the piss and using the pandemic as an excuse to cut terms and conditions.

I’d anticipate the Union to be all over it so he should speak to them.

local government that I know of, do it very frequently
Backtoschool101 · 28/02/2021 09:32

If they were talking about it pre covid, then you have had a long time to decide if this is right for you. Its not a shock really is it. £500 a day over time is amazing but also very expensive and post covid they probably cant afford this and now think actually this flexi no over time business is the right time to do it so employees have a fairer working day and the workload is spread so they dont rely on over time workers. He can either negotiate, accept it or look for something else. Or if i was you get rid of the car as you said. We did this in the first lock down. I have t had a car for a year now. Its not ideal but saved us a lot!

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 09:31

I very much doubt we would be entitled to anything, we don’t even get child benefit x

OP posts:
TulisaIsBrill · 28/02/2021 09:28

If you have kids and rent, check out your universal credit entitlement. Chances are, it could top up pretty much all you ‘lose’ at a rate of 75p in each lost £.

If they are going to play silly beggars, use the system to make the most of it.

RedcurrantPuff · 28/02/2021 09:27

A lot of companies are doing this, fire and rehire. Some might be genuine but I bet there are a fair number taking the piss and using the pandemic as an excuse to cut terms and conditions.

I’d anticipate the Union to be all over it so he should speak to them.

flamingomingeo · 28/02/2021 09:27

Because relying on overtime is risky, as it can be removed. I work in the emergency services where overtime is nearly always available, and have seen people come to expect it and not live within their means and then come unstuck when overtime is not available. It should always be treated as ‘nice to have, not guaranteed.’

GintyMcGinty · 28/02/2021 09:26

Cutting overtime is a way to reduce costs without making (or reducing the number of) redundancies.

Its quite legal to do.

Network Rail is heavily unionized so this will have been negotiated with the unions.

Tinkerbell1010 · 28/02/2021 09:26

I'm also a signaller...I don't understand how changing to 12 hours will require him changing from regular to flexi?

PurpleFlower1983 · 28/02/2021 09:24

I can see why they are going to flexi if they are paying people £500 a day overtime for Sundays in a 7 day a week industry. Saving have to come from somewhere and that’s the obvious place to start.

NerdyBird · 28/02/2021 09:22

If the money you're talking about losing is purely non-guaranteed overtime then he's not taking a pay cut. Cutting back overtime is a standard money saving exercise, and with the probably long-term reduction in rail use it's not surprising.
The rail unions are usually pretty strong so I suggest he joins pronto if he isn't a member.
Lots of people are in this position or have lost jobs and had to take actual pay cuts so this is far from unusual.

GraduallyWatermelon · 28/02/2021 09:19

I think before covid I would have agreed with you that it's unfair.

But rail networks have been massively affected by covid. Passenger traffic was down to 5% for a significant portion of the previous year, and has been far far below normal this year. People aren't renewing season tickets and many were given partial refund last year's. All rail companies are going to have to make cuts unfortunately.

Oblomov21 · 28/02/2021 09:17

Overtime is rarely contractually guaranteed. Sometimes, rarely. And yes contracts can be changed. Negotiations, then changes.

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 09:17

He is in the union, il get him to ask them.

The union is constantly fighting for pay rises each year too which they always get.

It’s not so much the 12 hour shifts that are a problem, it actually works out better as he doesn’t have to do 10 shifts in a row etc but it’s just going flexi which is rubbish 😭

OP posts:
Scarlettpixie · 28/02/2021 09:14

I suppose if they are paying people 500 a day for a overtime on a Sunday you can see why they might be having a rethink.

Unless the overtime is contractually guaranteed, I am fairly sure they can stop it. Other changes such as to working hours would require consulting and union involvement. If he isn’t in a union I suggest he joins one,

VinterKvinna · 28/02/2021 09:10

@Thedarksideofthemoon30

Why is it an issue he gets £10k from over time and Sundays? On Sundays he earns £500 so it soon adds up.

We don’t rely on it for our bills etc, but it’s nice to have extra once the bills etc are paid.

Tbh we need to get rid of our car and that would save us a lot lol

That's how they get you, oh pay isn't great, but overtime is.

I had a friend who worked for a delivery company (may have been royal mail, but the big lorry side) they got a 'turning up allowance, which meant they got paid extra for doing a shift, but couldn't really afford to take leave... as their pay went down

WhenSheWasBad · 28/02/2021 09:09

Why is it an issue he gets £10k from over time and Sundays? On Sundays he earns £500 so it soon adds up

It’s not an issue. But that is a lot of money for overtime. A lot of people do overtime, so they will just be comparing £10k to what they get.
£500 for one day it seriously good money. I can see why he would be sad to let that go.

Moondust001 · 28/02/2021 09:04

People often think that contracts can't be changed. They can. But in this case it is probably easier than most, because nobody is entitled to overtime. Network Rail is unionised - contractual changes are negotiated with the union, so what does the union say?

To be honest, given the fact that they have lost massive amounts of revenue over the past year, and given that there may be a lot less income due to employment changes across the country (so, for example, a lot less commuting going on), then paying £10k in overtime to employees may not be sustainable in the longer term, and it could be a choice of no overtime or no job. Many industries are facing such choices. That's not to have no sympathy with your position, but simply to recognise the reality of where we are right now.

Oblomov21 · 28/02/2021 09:04

Big cuts and contract re-negotiations are going to be happening across the world I fear.

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 09:03

Why is it an issue he gets £10k from over time and Sundays? On Sundays he earns £500 so it soon adds up.

We don’t rely on it for our bills etc, but it’s nice to have extra once the bills etc are paid.

Tbh we need to get rid of our car and that would save us a lot lol

OP posts:
Racoonworld · 28/02/2021 09:03

Is there anything in his contract about guaranteed overtime? If not he doesn’t have to be offered it. Its not a pay cut if it’s overtime being taken away so there isn’t anything he can do about it. Does he have set working times in his contract? If so flexi will be a change so he would need consultations etc.

B33Fr33 · 28/02/2021 08:59

Huge cuts are happening across the sector, extending into the engineers, smt etc. The historic contracts for full time etc keeping everyone in a wealth of overtime for the out of hours are going. The contracts go to base rates, less extras for "out" of hours or the classic bank holiday. The retail industry has had a strong influence. My husband's Christmas/ New Year overtime (in a different rail sector) used to pay for a decent family holiday on it's own, now it covers the school uniform budget.

Unfortunately the choices are rock and a hard place. Literally "do you want a job or not".

TokyoSushi · 28/02/2021 08:57

Something similar here, DH is working harder than ever and has had his wage reduced to 90%, they've now gone further and he is on furlough some weeks which impacts us further. I think at a lot of places the choices are this, or no job. A lower wage is obviously preferable to nothing, but it's far from ideal and we can only hope it doesn't go on for too much longer.

tttigress · 28/02/2021 08:56

First rule, don't really on overtime to finance your regular budget.

From the management side if someone is getting £10k in overtime, something has gone seriously wrong with the management in that department previously, and it isn't a suprise that they met to correct it now.

Sirzy · 28/02/2021 08:54

Unless there is a guarantee of overtime in his contract then I don’t think there is much you can do about that side of things.

It’s tough but a lot of companies, and as a result families, are going to be having to make tough decisions like this.