Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh work making people go flexi and take a pay cut

212 replies

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 08:31

Dh works for Network rail. He’s been with them roughly 10 years but at his currently job for 3.

He’s a signaller and they are changing the hours from 6/2 - 2/10 6/6 etc to 12 hour days/nights.

But they have announced they need 14 people to go flexi, meaning they won’t get any overtime or Sundays etc. We rely to the overtime and 2 Sundays a month.

If people go flexi he would have to take a £10k pay cut from missing out on the overtime etc.

They said it will be the people who haven’t been there the longest.

Aibu to think this is wrong and the job he applied for wasn’t flexi shift? Can they even make you do it?

It also means he won’t know his shifts until a week or so in advance, which with young children makes things so much more difficult and hard for me to work.

OP posts:
Onjnmoeiejducwoapy · 28/02/2021 11:36

But £500 for working on a Sunday?! Outside of a highly unionised train line that would be considered mental

lolulop · 28/02/2021 11:32

It's not necessarily insane. It's often cheaper to pay some people overtime rather than employ a new person.

Onjnmoeiejducwoapy · 28/02/2021 11:30

Jesus no wonder they’re restructuring that, that is ridiculous and wasteful of company money. I’d be glad I had it so good for all those years because that is INSANE.

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 28/02/2021 11:28

@Berthatydfil

To be honest if he earns too much to qualify for child benefit - then he’s not badly paid.

“I very much doubt we would be entitled to anything, we don’t even get child benefit x”

This!

I imagine this has all been done via the union, and with good business economic reason judging by how much overtime a huge organisation like NR must be leeching in Sunday overtime.

You say you rely on the 2 Sundays per month ie £1k. I get that you get used to having the extra - however, you will likely find that they can legally do this unless his contract allows for guaranteed overtime.

If in doubt he needs to speak with his union.

AdventureIsWaiting · 28/02/2021 11:24

OP NR offers a good flexible working policy - can your DH request set shifts for childcare purposes? I know several traincrew (I know that's the TOCs, but IME NR is even more family friendly) who have successfully got set shifts for this reason, especially if they can find someone to partner up with to do the other side i.e. one does days, one does nights. It may also affect his pension - you may want to look into this as, IIRC, signallers and drivers get their overtime taken into account for the RPS scheme, if he's in that.

Unfortunately it is clear that redundancies and cost savings will be required post-pandemic (still going ahead with HS2 though Hmm) and I've heard the DfT has been challenging all railway companies about reliance on overtime and Sunday working.

Berthatydfil · 28/02/2021 11:22

To be honest if he earns too much to qualify for child benefit - then he’s not badly paid.

“I very much doubt we would be entitled to anything, we don’t even get child benefit x”

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 11:13

It’s not so much the loss of overtime but the fact that shifts will be different and it could be nights one night and days the next and that there would be no option of over time but if they are shift staff they get offered 2 Sundays over time a month. It’s just abit crap really. 😔

OP posts:
Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 11:12

I’m really stuggling to find work that works around his shifts with 3 Dc at home. I currently bank staff for as a support worker but I make roughly £300 a month. It pays my debt though from before I met DH.

OP posts:
WeIcomeToGilead · 28/02/2021 10:56

10k on overtime is ridiculous from a
Business perspective

Rubbish for you though

Caramelwhispers · 28/02/2021 10:43

Do you work op? If not, can you return to work to make up the £10k shortfall since your dp will be on regular hours. There's plenty of working from home jobs atm you could apply for. I just applied at my local uni processing admissions for Oct. Really good money at £15 an hr, it's only temp for 6 months but there's loads of permanent roles wfh available.

Comefromaway · 28/02/2021 10:41

It’s not that crazy depending on how many hours a day is & what the normal rate of pay is.

The firm I work for the first rate of overtime is 42% more than the normal hourly rate. (After 6pm and Saturdays) 2nd rate of overtime (after 10pm & Sundays ) is 84% more than normal rate. These rates are in the contracts.

Throwntothewolves · 28/02/2021 10:38

I think they can do this following the necessary consultations with the unions. Overtime isn't ever a right and if they can save money (and it sounds like they need to if most are making 10k extra doing OT) by making people take flexi contracts then it makes business sense to do so. But I would expect the union to be fighting for the employees to be compensated accordingly, they can't get something for nothing. I wouldn't expect it to be as much as the extra 10k your DH makes, but somewhere in between.

They have something on their side, they are clearly needed due to the overtime. So if need be the union could suggest an overtime 'ban' to ensure adequate recompense for the staff members future flexibility. That only works if people stick to it though

doubleleopardy · 28/02/2021 10:26

This is a tricky one for unions because actually they will be fighting for properly staffed services so companies are not reliant on overtime. There is also the issue of work life balance and an expectation of overtime disrupts that.

I'm guessing that there will be consultation over the flexi shifts and people will be able to discuss the impact on their family life and any mitigation they have for not being able to do the new flexi role.

Comefromaway · 28/02/2021 10:24

Is the issue not so much that they are cutting overtime (which isn’t guaranteed and they are entitled to do) but that your husband on flexi is going to be expected to to work Sundays but at the normal rate of pay?

I’d have thought that was a change in his terms/rate of pay that requires proper consultation etc.

Soontobe60 · 28/02/2021 10:22

@Thedarksideofthemoon30

Why is it an issue he gets £10k from over time and Sundays? On Sundays he earns £500 so it soon adds up.

We don’t rely on it for our bills etc, but it’s nice to have extra once the bills etc are paid.

Tbh we need to get rid of our car and that would save us a lot lol

£500 for one day’s work!!!!! That’s crazy! No wonder he’s not happy. My DH earns this much in one week.
lolulop · 28/02/2021 10:19

From the management side if someone is getting £10k in overtime, something has gone seriously wrong with the management in that department previously, and it isn't a suprise that they met to correct it now.

Not necessarily lots of police for example would earn that. Many industries pay o/t because it's cheaper then having more staff.

lolulop · 28/02/2021 10:15

Unfortunately this is inevitable with lower passenger numbers but my condolences. I guess he either looks for another job or takes this over redundancy. Does the job still pay well?

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 28/02/2021 10:07

£500 for a single days work is a ridiculously high rate of pay to be paying 1 in 7 days. You could be earning around the average income of the UK for only working 4 days a month. No wonder they need to cut that.

sanfranfibber · 28/02/2021 09:59

@TulisaIsBrill

If you have kids and rent, check out your universal credit entitlement. Chances are, it could top up pretty much all you ‘lose’ at a rate of 75p in each lost £.

If they are going to play silly beggars, use the system to make the most of it.

Jesus this attitude.

How much UC do you think someone earning £500 in a day is entitled to?

TryingNotToPanicOverCovid · 28/02/2021 09:53

@tinkerbell1010 cut the overtime payments like OP is suggesting- not the whole service!

TimeForTeaAndG · 28/02/2021 09:45

If this was talked about pre-covid then I would guess that it's already been through union negotiations and everything.

He could see if "last in, first onto flexi" is really how it's going to be done, I would think some folk might be happy to go onto flexi if asked.

My DH changed from 8 hours to 12 hour shifts when covid hit (key workers on site with legal minimum staffing levels) and the difference in our home life has been massive. If we had been still needing childcare (I'm wfh so don't need it, noone clutch your pearls, she occupies herself while I work) this year we would have had several days a month fewer because of DH being at home. He is less tired on night shifts because he has plenty of rest time after day12s.

Try and look at the positives that way round. Will it mean someone at home more often to organise dinner rather than takeaway when you both finish work knackered? Less childcare requirements?9

Can he speak to his boss about the assistant manager role and what's happening with that? What does the 12 hour shift rota look like for those not going onto flexi?

RedcurrantPuff · 28/02/2021 09:37

One of the unions recently got an interim court order to prevent Tesco doing it, @lightand. It’ll be interesting to see how it pans out, as you say it’s a pretty common tactic.

lightand · 28/02/2021 09:37

local government fire and rehire, and the rehire is often not quite the same jobs as before either. The "new" jobs, get rejigged.

Tinkerbell1010 · 28/02/2021 09:37

They won't cut Sundays and if they did how would you travel on a Sunday if no one works

TryingNotToPanicOverCovid · 28/02/2021 09:35

I think if they're paying so much for a sunday its rather obvious an area for them to cut and to move to not paying overtime.