Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh work making people go flexi and take a pay cut

212 replies

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 08:31

Dh works for Network rail. He’s been with them roughly 10 years but at his currently job for 3.

He’s a signaller and they are changing the hours from 6/2 - 2/10 6/6 etc to 12 hour days/nights.

But they have announced they need 14 people to go flexi, meaning they won’t get any overtime or Sundays etc. We rely to the overtime and 2 Sundays a month.

If people go flexi he would have to take a £10k pay cut from missing out on the overtime etc.

They said it will be the people who haven’t been there the longest.

Aibu to think this is wrong and the job he applied for wasn’t flexi shift? Can they even make you do it?

It also means he won’t know his shifts until a week or so in advance, which with young children makes things so much more difficult and hard for me to work.

OP posts:
FredaFox · 28/02/2021 16:24

I feel for you as it will obviously affect your home life of you have relied on all this extra money though like others said, you shouldn't have been relying on it, overtime isn't a right
No business surely can afford to be paying out that much overtime each year, the numbers are outrageous especially for a governmen agency, it's not value for money especially now when the country is in such a mess
It makes sense that they are reviewing this especially now you've mentioned the safety aspect
I hope you get to sort out the hours for your family life and your job but you've been extremely lucky to get thousands extra every month, all good things come to an end,I hope you saved some of it

AdventureIsWaiting · 28/02/2021 16:14

@Thedarksideofthemoon30 As I suggested upthread, he can request a set pattern via a flexible working request. This is by no means unusual.

Thedarksideofthemoon30 · 28/02/2021 15:55

He already does 12 hour shifts, that’s not the problem really it’s more the fact that he won’t know his shifts until the week before etc which causes massive issues with me working and our children. Atm he gets his rota for the year so we can plan etc

OP posts:
peak2021 · 28/02/2021 15:40

Could you (or the union or your DHs behalf) argue that 12 hour shifts are unsuitable for the job?

Fgs1 · 28/02/2021 14:49

Not being able to do overtime isn’t a pay cut. It’s taking away an additional benefit not a basic right.

Onjnmoeiejducwoapy · 28/02/2021 14:26

@Tinkerbell1010

Sunday isn't part of the working week
Greetings, Plymouth brethren!

Unfortunately it’s not the 17th century anymore. A LOT of the population works Sundays. Most don’t get a cent extra for it.

VivaLeBeaver · 28/02/2021 14:26

Every company I’ve ever worked for apart from my current one has done similar to me. It makes me think that contracts aren’t worth the paper they’re written on. They can just do a consultation, produce new contracts and you either sign them or they get rid of you. It stinks. I’ve had my shift length changed, I’ve been moved to work in another city over an hour away, paid breaks taken away so suddenly every day instead of working 8 hrs you’re working 7.5 and every month have to work 6 days a week one week to make up the shortfall.

Dh they stopped paying his overtime which resulted in about a 20% effective pay cut. Said they could take TOIL instead but then nobody could as they were too busy, then they made them all 4 days a week instead of 5 days a week so another 20% paycut but still had the same amount of work to do. So he was working 6 days a week and getting paid for 4 days and had lost about 40% pay!

SeasonFinale · 28/02/2021 14:22

The OP said near the beginning of the thread that this has been under consultation since before Covid and therefore the unions are probably already involved and indeed If It has been put to workers already agreed by the unions.

GintyMcGinty · 28/02/2021 14:20

Sunday isn't part of the working week

What century do you live in?

SmudgeButt · 28/02/2021 14:15

Network Rail and other parts of the rail system in the UK have been sticking it to their staff and customers for the last few years.

But for this to work it needs to be a change of contract which he can accept or not accept. If he doesn't accept it he will be "released from his contract" (aka fired) I don't believe however that they can change contracts just for those who have worked for less than X years, that it would have to be everyone in a particular job.

Check with the union.

SundayTeatime · 28/02/2021 14:15

It’s to be expected that a company wants to reduce its overtime bill. 10k is huge. I would have expected any new shift to introduced to all staff. Saturdays, Sundays, bank holidays, including Christmas Day are normal work days for me too. There’s no extra payment for working those days.

Tinkerbell1010 · 28/02/2021 14:11

Definitely isn't hence why you get enhancements

Neron · 28/02/2021 14:06

Sunday isn't part of the working week
It most definitely is on the railway. As are bank Holidays, including Christmas day etc

Tinkerbell1010 · 28/02/2021 14:03

Sunday isn't part of the working week

starbrightstarlight8888 · 28/02/2021 13:52

Why are they not employing extra staff to cover hours needed? They'd only need to pay regular salary rather than £500 per Sunday for overtime for existing staff (which is ridiculous). No wonder they're taking a look at it.

SundayTeatime · 28/02/2021 13:46

Any change in contract will have to go through consultation with staff and unions. It’s unlikely that overtime is contractual. I work in an industry where shift patterns were changed from 9-5 Mon-Fri to 6am-midnight 7 days a week with no extra pay for bank holidays. You get about 10 weeks’ notice of the shift pattern. Union involvement mitigated some of these changes.

lolulop · 28/02/2021 13:39

Anyone who works in travel, tourism, non-essential retail or hospitality who still has a job on whatever terms is very fortunate indeed and has absolutely nothing to complain about.

It's hardly their fault that their industries were closed or heavily reduced & it was to stop the spread of covid to stop the NHS collapsing to benefit the whole of the population. Why shouldn't they complain?

Eleganz · 28/02/2021 13:38

@AgeLikeWine

I work in a related industry, in which demand has been decimated by the pandemic and thousands of my industry colleagues have sadly lost their jobs.

I’m one of the lucky ones. I have been furloughed twice, and I have accepted pay cuts and part-time working to avoid the need for further redundancies, but I probably will have a job when this nightmare is over.

Anyone who works in travel, tourism, non-essential retail or hospitality who still has a job on whatever terms is very fortunate indeed and has absolutely nothing to complain about.

Network Rail isn't really the same as other travel companies, they are responsible for maintaining national infrastructure that moves an awful lot of important goods as well as passengers. It is also a GoCo/NDPB so is funded directly from government.
Eleganz · 28/02/2021 13:34

OP, your DH needs to get advice from the union here. I am surprised that they are essentially asking some staff to take on worse conditions than others, that could easily expose them to anti-discimination action.

As for those saying that £500 a day is ridiculous. Plenty of people get paid more for less. Management consultants regularly pull in such sums and I don't see anyone on MN complaining about it and that is an almost entirely pointless industry.

AgeLikeWine · 28/02/2021 13:32

I work in a related industry, in which demand has been decimated by the pandemic and thousands of my industry colleagues have sadly lost their jobs.

I’m one of the lucky ones. I have been furloughed twice, and I have accepted pay cuts and part-time working to avoid the need for further redundancies, but I probably will have a job when this nightmare is over.

Anyone who works in travel, tourism, non-essential retail or hospitality who still has a job on whatever terms is very fortunate indeed and has absolutely nothing to complain about.

Neron · 28/02/2021 13:31

It’s not so much the loss of overtime but the fact that shifts will be different and it could be nights one night and days the next and that there would be no option of over time but if they are shift staff they get offered 2 Sundays over time a month
He won't be on nights one day and days the next contractually. A 12 hour break is needed in-between. Everything will be done by the union, they always fight for their workers.

Rail workers can only do 13 shifts in a row also, so if people are doing more than this, they are comprising the safety of themselves and their co workers.

You say it is not about the OT, but it clearly is. It's a lot of money to lose when you've got used to it coming in. OT is a bonus, it shouldn't be relied on. Seems NR are getting in line with some of the other rail companies.

Cocomarine · 28/02/2021 13:26

@doubleleopardy

This is a tricky one for unions because actually they will be fighting for properly staffed services so companies are not reliant on overtime. There is also the issue of work life balance and an expectation of overtime disrupts that.

I'm guessing that there will be consultation over the flexi shifts and people will be able to discuss the impact on their family life and any mitigation they have for not being able to do the new flexi role.

Agree with your first sentence here. When I worked in a highly unionised environment, the local rep was very clear with our staff (every one a member) that the union would always put more full time jobs ahead of overtime.
Cocomarine · 28/02/2021 13:25

@Thedarksideofthemoon30

Apparently they are changing the shifts because they are working too many hours a week which is classes as not safe.
Which is a pretty good reason.
lightand · 28/02/2021 13:17

@2bazookas

When covid releases people back into the workplace a lot of people are going to find their worklife changed beyond all recognition. Given the rise of WFH and slump in rail services, your DH is going to be badly affected. Be grateful his industry has not gone bust leaving him jobless. Many others are not so lucky.
  My advice is, accept  whatever the new conditions are.  That gives you an income  while he considers what other work he could do and applies for other vacancies.   Its always easier to job hunt from employment, than from living on benefits and desperate.</div></div>

Good post.
Trying to change jobs is going to become harder I think.
Harder times to come for lots of people.

Springsnake · 28/02/2021 13:14

I think my dh is in the same job with a different company.
( notice I said ,I think,not 100% sure what he does )
Point being,it’s a nightmare because he only gets his shifts 2 weeks in advance if we are lucky ,or 1 week in advance if not