Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder WTF has happened to nursing “care” in our NHS?

536 replies

AnnieGetYourPun · 27/02/2021 16:31

And don’t tell me it’s all Covid/staff shortages/staff illness related.

My niece was eventually admitted to hospital after being sent home twice from A&E (in agony) and is now on a gynae ward. It’s just her and an elderly lady on the ward. The elderly lady was getting agitated as she needed the toilet. The nurse came and said, and I quote “it’s alright, use your pad and we’ll come and sort you out later”. This has really upset my niece who’s dodging sepsis now, on the ward, on massive IV antibiotics/anti-emetics and IV analgesia. She has narrowly avoided a ruptured uterus as there was no one to do a scan on her, after a 12 hr wait in A&E. She is 32.

Nurses now... all of ‘em have degrees. All dead clever. Very few of them have an ounce of “caring” in them.

Fry me on here. I’m past fucking caring.

Should add. I trained in the NHS. Was a student/junior staff nurse/senior staff nurse/junior sister and G grade senior sister before retirement. Never, in my f***g life have I seen such lack of basic care and maintenance of human dignity than I have witnessed in NHS hospitals, in the past two years.

Shove your clapping and rainbows.

OP posts:
Biffbaff · 28/02/2021 18:26

Poor care has always existed, it's nothing new. My grandmother told me about the poor care she received after having her first son 65 years ago - put her off hospital for life. And after having mine in 2018 I know why. I have a permanent health issue due to the poor care I received and will be free birthing next time.

Reinventinganna · 28/02/2021 18:25

I’m sorry that your niece (and the lady) are getting such bad treatment.

Some of us really do care though! I went into nursing after experiencing amazing care from NHS nurses and thought that I wanted to be that person one day. I did have to complete a degree to achieve my goal but I start every single shift remembering why I trained. My degree is a tiny part of what has made me the nurse that I am today.

Could you support your niece to make a complaint when she is able to.

Floralnomad · 28/02/2021 18:20

@BMHM I’m in no way going to say I was the worlds greatest nurse but I suppose primarily working nights in an era when it was 2 trained and one CSW to a ward of 24 patients I was accustomed to and considered it my role to be hands on with care . Perhaps they should change the name as nurse implies nursing which implies care giving .

CrayonInThreeBits · 28/02/2021 18:15

bun, if I say to you, "the French have raised winemaking to a fine art" do you assume I'm claiming every French person owns a vineyard?

Chill out and stop taking everything so personally. It'll do you no good as a mental health nurse.

bunintheoven88 · 28/02/2021 18:08

@CrayonInThreeBits

I didn't ask for your opinion regarding whether you feel I am in the correct field, however I would like you to answer my question regarding the sweeping generalisation you have made and the reason behind it Smile

luckylavender · 28/02/2021 18:06

I've been in hospital twice in my life, once when I gave birth and once when I was 14 (am 59) having a very painful dental procedure. I had terrible care & everyone else in the ward was over 70, it was traumatic. But there have always been good and bad nurses, teachers, police etc.

BMHM · 28/02/2021 17:59

@Floralnomad I suppose I was being a bit defensive because I would absolutely hate anyone to think that I was a bad nurse, it means a lot to me that I do my best for people. But...I think it is true that my 'best my not be what I want at all times given the environment.

One of the other student nurses had been upset on first placement because she had been primarily with CSWs instead of other nurses and doing a lot of personal care, which speaks to what you are saying.

I do think the environment in which nurses operate (from the very limited knowledge and exposure I've had) must wear down compassion and genuine care. Management in ivory towers, horizontal violence and I don't think patient incidents can be ignored...First placement nursing students have been filmed, threatened, sexually harassed, verbally abused...when the lecturer was told about consistent sexual remarks, the student was told that patients have sexual needs and as part of person centred practice we need accept that as part of them. In any other profession this would be sexual harassment.

But, I don't doubt that some nurses perhaps just shouldn't be nurses.

CrayonInThreeBits · 28/02/2021 17:58

bun oh dear, if you're that reactive to your own misinterpretation of a fairly mild comment, I think you may be in the wrong field.

bunintheoven88 · 28/02/2021 17:44

Another sweeping generalisation there @CrayonInThreeBits

I am a second year mental health student, following years of working as a Health Care Assistant, I do my upmost whether I am on a ward or in the community to ensure I give the highest standard of care possible, if I witness anything I feel is negligence or patients not being treated as they should (in situations whereby it is not a matter of lack of time for nurses or HCA's) I call that out and try to put it right. I have seen some things I was appalled at when I was a HCA and made sure to Datix it accordingly.

I went into the mental health profession due to witnessing mental health issues in my own family and wanting to help and encourage and treat every patient I ever have as I would my own family.

Are you still going to tell me as an individual that's me 'Not Giving A Shit'?

Not trying to start an arguement I'm just interested in how you can justify a generalisation of a profession, and what that justification would be?

Floralnomad · 28/02/2021 17:40

@BMHM you’ve hit the nail on the head by saying lots of what is being described is down to someone else ie CSW/ HCA and that’s the point people are making that many nurses who have worked hard for their degree etc see washing bums and handing out bedpans as someone else’s role . When my mum was in hospital there was a nurse and HCA for roughly 7/8 patients on an early shift and half the time the nurse didn’t help with any of the washing / toileting . Some of them spent from 8 am until 10:30 / 11 doing the drugs for their 8 patients , I’ve done plenty of early shifts and drug rounds it shouldn’t take that long and if it is taking that long you would expect fewer drug errors and in my mums case there were lots of those ! As a trained nurse I have a great deal of sympathy for HCAs / CSWs as they generally are doing their very best , with little or no support and taking all the flack off the patients . This was an acute admission medical ward not geriatrics .

isitfridayyet1 · 28/02/2021 17:38

Yes I received and also witnessed really poor care 2 years ago when I had my 2nd child. I feel a lot of nursing has been reduced to box ticking exercises and 'covering yourself' at the expense of real genuine empathy.

BMHM · 28/02/2021 17:23

While I do not doubt that you and your niece have had a bad experience of Nurses, you cannot tarnish all nursing staff with the same brush because it just isn't true.

The foundation of my nursing degree is person centred practice, all knowledge is built on this. Regardless, there Will be some that cannot learn compassion because it is not innate to them, but having an understanding of the macro structure which may lead to poor health can help people be considerate.

I also don't understand the blame towards soley nursing staff as they do not work in isolation. I also don't think many patients (as I didnt) understand the role of nurses now. A lot of what people have described would fall under CSW or HCA, some physio, some consultant. Even when someone's obs give a higher NEWS2 score, sometimes you really have to pester to have the patient looked at again. These are all relevant.

MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes · 28/02/2021 17:21

You want decent care you need more staff that aren't run off their feet, are offered decent educational training that's not in their own time, are treated with respect by management.

That's the answer right there. More staff - nurses to nurse and doctors to do doctoring, or if you insist on turning nurses into junior doctors then more HCAs to nurse, with no more responsibilities passed downwards and a clear recognition of the limits of different roles and that they are needed. Cleaners too. More flexible training options without ludicrous price tags are needed too, with transferability training between the roles if individuals want to take on more. It will cost. It is worth it. Worth it to patients, for the staff who save lives, to the country (it won't happen overnight either).

Sameshirt · 28/02/2021 17:17

My DM was shouted at by staff for not reminding them, that she needed her pain medication, shame she was unconscious at the time.
If was happening now she would be dead, everything was put down to her age.

lostandforgotten · 28/02/2021 17:10

I've no experience of working with hospital nurses to know if the situation is the same, however my experiences in hospital with nurses have been fine 🤷🏼‍♂️

lostandforgotten · 28/02/2021 17:09

I work in a nursing home which is obviously staffed with nurses. There are usually two nurses per shift for around 30 residents as well as around 6/7 care assistants. They see their role as purely clinical and will never, ever answer a buzzer or change a pad. They will come and get a care assistant and tell them that so and so needs a pad change or needs assisting to the toilet or needs water. I've worked there a year and can count on one hand how many times I have seen one do any personal care. I can quite believe that in the hospitals they see these jobs as beneath them too. If we are short staffed then they will not muck in and help. The other night there were only 2 care assistants on the night shift and they left them to struggle on there own rather than help. They are also trying to persuade the care assistants to take on training to do blood pressures and observations and we are resisting as it will stretch us even further and take us away from caring and we are only paid 8.72 an hour. The nurses are not happy and said we are 'protesting'. Damn right we are.

RosesAndHellebores · 28/02/2021 16:58

I assume that was in response to the arm waving? @AnnieGetYourPun Yep really. St George's community midwives more than 25 years ago. It's the sort of thing one never forgets. To be fair a few years later when dd was born, it was much much better!

AnnieGetYourPun · 28/02/2021 16:34

@ClockworkNightingale... if you’re giving up after one year, albeit an absolutely horrendous one, no one would deny, you might be better suited to another role. I wish you success in your future.

OP posts:
AnnieGetYourPun · 28/02/2021 16:32

@SirenSays... I too have unfortunately been on the end of “whistleblowing”. It took over two years of RCN CQC involvement but my complaint about a more senior qualified nurse was upheld. I remember getting a letter from management basically saying well done, thank you for bringing this to our attention and there then followed months and months of ostracising (of me) and it was at that point I felt retirement looming.

Perhaps nurses now are so busy doing additional medical care and are supervising HCAs in actual care and this is where it has changed and IMO has led to qualified nurses being out of touch with their patients. Maybe, the nurses who had no real clue who my mum was hadn’t actually “hands on” met her? Don’t know. Either way, something is going badly wrong.

@RosesAndHellebores... really?! 🤦‍♀️

@Babylonberlin... sad but true. Your last post explains much. So sad. And yet surely, nurses are getting more clever. Entry to training requires decent A Levels; there’s the actual degree qualification and seemingly endless updating/post grad courses etc following qualification. Surely nurses are better train now than ever before?

OP posts:
ClockworkNightingale · 28/02/2021 16:27

If you had been watching me on the covid ward last night, you might have seen me fiddling with a computer.

I was reviewing my patient's medication chart to see what medication they had taken to address a critically low blood result, and looking over their previous blood results, observations, and most recent medical plan, so that I could bleep the junior-junior doctor who had never met my patient and hand over enough information so he could prioritise this issue in relation to all the other issues on all the other medical wards in the hospital.

I also turned and cleaned and wiped and gave mouthcare and weighed urine bottles and cleaned commodes.

Going back tonight to do it all again.

I have a degree and it never stopped me doing the second group of tasks, just enabled me to do the first skillfully.

But I'm probably going to leave nursing. I qualified into a pandemic and have put myself and my family at risk for the past year. Hope y'all can find someone else to fill my post, because even the imperfect care I give is better than no care at all. But apparently nurse retention is too radical an idea for this country. Star

ancientgran · 28/02/2021 15:45

@Pinkfreesias

It seems yo me that, since new entrant nurses have been required to have a degree, we've had to employ huge numbers of healthcare assistants to do the very basics of nursing. Is this because the likes of making beds, emptying bedpans etc is now seen as beneath anyone with a degree? I don't understand how and why the role has diverged so much.Have nurses taken on part of a doctor's role?
Well qualified HCAs do the work SENs used to do so the same role another name. Yes nurses do many things that used to be a doctor's role, which is why they are trained as they are.
RosesAndHellebores · 28/02/2021 15:40

floralnomad thank you for stating that.

It varies. My experience of DS1's birth and post natally were horrendous. My 23 year old hv now teaches nurses on degree courses - someone who was completely incompetent and totally uncaring in practice. DD's birth however was marvellous. They are grown up now.

Factor in their stays as dc (2 x grommets privately I super nurse, one horrendous) (2 x broken bones - one stay OK, one shocking) (2 x bronchiolitis - one stay exceptional, one shocking).

Outpatient nurses, I have found completely beyond the pale in the context of capability and manners

It boils down to communication and often it is poor. There is also a smattering of constant complaint to the patient about their lot and far too often a loud cackle from the nursing station at 2am about boyfriends, holidays and other extraneous nonsense. That is really just so inconsiderate.

Just a couple of years ago I had to have a very personal test and was having it at our local private hospital. I had my pre-op stuff done my a nurse beforehand. A few days later I saw that same nurse in Sainsbury's and she saw a man she knew, hunkered down and belted out "nah, xxxxx, you f*ing ponce". It was vulgar and wholly unacceptable behaviour. That it came from a nurse, a member of our local community, was horrific and is the sort of conduct that brings nursing into disrepute. I contacted the hospital manager and requested that nurse came nowhere near me when I was admitted.

Whilst I think private care is a little better nursing remains very variable even when one pays. Somewhere standards must have slipped.

The system has to change and too often I have felt that nurses are abrupt and rather rude. I shall never forget the coarseness of the first community midwife who visited me after ds was born. She shot into my house before she was invited in and just didn't listen. She embarked on a directive about contraception and sex and when I said "thank you but I discussed it at the hospital, had a baby only a few days ago and am not discussing it again" completely ignored me and held her left elbow in her right hand and belted at me "well get the pelvic floor exercises done otherwise your man will say the sex feels like this" and waved her arm backwards and forwards. Vile, vulgar and wholly reprehensible.

There are good and bad in every vocation I agree, but in nursing too often there seems to be a little too much bad.

I also think it would be helpful if there was a clear explanation, visibly so, in every department about what the role of the different uniforms is. There are people in dark blue, pale blue, pink, green flowers and scrubs in many hospitals there needs to be absolute clarity about their roles.

Babylonberlin · 28/02/2021 15:15

@AnnieGetYourPun what's the answer ? We need educated professionals. Patients are sicker, older, more complicated comorbidities, more demanding and opinionated. They and their relatives are far more questioning.
Many of the stories upthread seem to be concentrated on elderly medical wards. Sad to say but many young motivated nurses don't want to work there.
It's physically hard work, emotionally challenging and a place where you quickly become clinically deskilled (hate to say it but true). It really doesn't receive the same acolades as ICU for example even when the care is good.

Floralnomad · 28/02/2021 15:11

@Eskarina1

No one goes into nursing for the money. It would be hard to find a career which requires a degree and professional registration and requires 24/7 flexibility (including Christmas) that pays less. Poor care happens for a wide range of reasons and while I don't think it is that common, sometimes loss of compassion is part of that (see Mid Staffs). However, we need to consider why people who choose to go into a caring profession end up feeling this way and how we change that.

This isn't a new problem but what's been asked of front line healthcare staff over the last year is unsustainable and if we keep blaming nurses for poor care rather than looking at what they need to do their job safely we are going to have a serious problem.

I actually disagree with this because once trained nursing can be very flexible particularly for working mothers who have partners / husbands that work . I gave up nursing at 48 due to a variety of health issues and that was 8 /9 yrs ago but prior to that for about 15 yrs I had worked 1 night shift per week , so 11 hours . For that , at that time I took home around £700 per month , got 7 weeks holiday and 6 months full sick pay / 6 months half pay when I was off for a year prior to my resignation . I never needed any childcare when my children were small and the only inconvenience was having to work at Christmas or new year and 1 night really wasn’t that much of an inconvenience .
SirenSays · 28/02/2021 15:10

Nursing is like teaching imo. It attracts all sorts. Some are lovely compassionate souls who go into the role for all the right reasons. Others are in it for the paycheck alone, possesing all the compassion of a pet rock. Anyone who thinks every single nurse is great is incredibly naive. I left the NHS as a whistle-blower so obviously don't want to say more but it's safe to say I've seen my fair share of bullies and the utter cruelty some people possess.