Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder WTF has happened to nursing “care” in our NHS?

536 replies

AnnieGetYourPun · 27/02/2021 16:31

And don’t tell me it’s all Covid/staff shortages/staff illness related.

My niece was eventually admitted to hospital after being sent home twice from A&E (in agony) and is now on a gynae ward. It’s just her and an elderly lady on the ward. The elderly lady was getting agitated as she needed the toilet. The nurse came and said, and I quote “it’s alright, use your pad and we’ll come and sort you out later”. This has really upset my niece who’s dodging sepsis now, on the ward, on massive IV antibiotics/anti-emetics and IV analgesia. She has narrowly avoided a ruptured uterus as there was no one to do a scan on her, after a 12 hr wait in A&E. She is 32.

Nurses now... all of ‘em have degrees. All dead clever. Very few of them have an ounce of “caring” in them.

Fry me on here. I’m past fucking caring.

Should add. I trained in the NHS. Was a student/junior staff nurse/senior staff nurse/junior sister and G grade senior sister before retirement. Never, in my f***g life have I seen such lack of basic care and maintenance of human dignity than I have witnessed in NHS hospitals, in the past two years.

Shove your clapping and rainbows.

OP posts:
digbygreen · 01/03/2021 06:53

Can only comment on my own experience, currently in hospital with my newborn after being readmitted and the nursing team could not be more compassionate or caring, they have been immensely supportive.

MissTrip82 · 01/03/2021 06:21

Having a degree = ‘dead clever”.

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

ElphabaTheGreen · 01/03/2021 06:01

I’m an OT - I’ve worked with ward nurses for almost 20 years.

You get great nurses, you get not so great nurses, I’ve worked with three nurses who I’ve reported for shocking care (the one who put soup into a large syringe for a confused patient refusing food and told an HCA to pull his head back while she squirted it in saying, ‘He’ll have to swallow now or he’ll drown’ got deregistered, I hope). But it’s the same for all health care professionals. I’ve worked with some awful OTs.

The not so great nurses have very, very common themes which drive me batshit every day:

  • they treat their printed handovers as the font of all information about the patient, even if it hasn’t been updated for days. Reading the medical notes is only for the doctors, apparently
  • what they see on the day must be what the patient is forever and ever and they exist in a vacuum. Making contact with the family to find out what this patient’s ‘normal’ is is everybody else’s job but theirs. If we ask, ‘who have they got at home?’ we get ‘I don’t know, it hasn’t been handed over to me’. Well fucking ASK YOUR PATIENT.
  • communication is awful. Awful. They are the staff on the ward all the time so are in the best position to pass on information to the medical team or families from us when we’re not around to do it. They don’t. And if a family asks them a question about what therapists are doing they make zero effort to read our notes to let them know on the spot - we’re then left playing phone tig with family for days when they had that information in front of them to pass on straight away
  • if it’s slightly awkward or difficult it’s not their job and must be for a specialist nurse or doctor. A patient’s mother died while he was an inpatient with us. The B6 ward sister called the medical team to the ward to get them to tell him. She was a senior nurse and the most familiar face to that patient on the ward - there was zero reason to delegate that job other than can’t-be-arsedness.
  • sitting patients out. Getting some nurses to sit patients out when therapists aren’t about is like pulling teeth. Getting catheters taken out of less mobile patients who really no longer need them is also impossible as it saves them having to walk patients to the toilet. If I had a pound for every time I’ve gently reminded nurses about the role these things have in prevention of chest infections and UTIs, which would ultimately take more of their time and effort than taking the preventative actions in the first place, I could retire. Or do they really prefer the reduced physical effort in putting up IV antibiotics to hoisting out? Or delegating an HCA to 1:1 a patient out of their tree with UTI delirium to save a walk to the loo?
Maverickess · 01/03/2021 05:23

Disclaimer - I work in a care home, not a nurse.
Regarding the being told to use a pad instead of the toilet, on the face of it, not acceptable.
However, how would you feel if I left a relative of yours in a dangerous situation, to take someone else to the toilet?
Because in a home that's sometimes the choice we face, which is a less stressful and obviously non medical environment, with less going on. If we're dealing with someone who needs two for safety reasons, and someone else needs the toilet, well they need to wait unfortunately, we have to prioritise safety over anything else, and yes, I will reassure and say it's ok, you can use your pad, I can't discuss where I am or what I'm doing in detail because that's confidential.

Also, you know, someone has to go first, and someone last when people want or need help at the same time. Unless there's a massive investment in healthcare in general, to enable 1:1 (or 2:1 if needed) care across the board, someone's always going to have to wait. But then no one wants to be the one who waits.

We're not technically 'short staffed' either, in fact legally we've probably got more staff on some shifts than the guidelines state as a minimum, but we're still outnumbered (for want of a better phrase) by residents.

That's the practical side of things, and unfortunately there's no getting away from that.

That said, I have experienced some poor care, both as a patient (less so) and as an escort to residents that have needed to attend hospital. Dementia patients are particularly at risk ime, possibly due to lack of understanding and training, and also probably because they take up more time than an average patient with the same condition or injury due to the nature of dementia. I've been told to 'do something!' by medical staff - what they expected I don't know, I could no more force compliance than they could, I was there to basically stop them wandering and putting themselves further at risk and offer the constant reassurance dementia patients often need, working in dementia care doesn't mean I have a magic answer.
While there are definitely nurses that are poor at hands on care and dealing with patients as people, I don't think that can be purely put down to them having a degree, though I do think that maybe longer on the wards as well as the classroom might help with that. I've worked with care workers who weren't in the slightest bit caring too.
I think the poor care, like poor customer service stands out more, and poor management and poor resources contribute in no small way. I also feel that the social norm of presenteeism has a lot to answer for. We expect 100% performance all the time and no mistakes to be made, well apart from being unrealistic when you're dealing with humans, there's also the fact that being ill is detrimental to performance, yet you are often given a hard time, pressured to work when ill and can be disciplined for being ill too often, or for having a family crisis etc. So apart from having humans with faults at the heart of this, you've sometimes got humans that could be ill or in the middle of something going really wrong, who are being overworked and treated poorly by their employers and also sometimes by the people they're trying to help. It's no wonder that some lose their caring side sometimes or all together really.
I think we need to look long and hard about why it's being perceived to be getting worse, and what we're asking of nurses and other HCPs because they're human too.

MixedUpFiles · 01/03/2021 04:06

A human being states a need to use the toilet. There may be a legitimate reason taking that person to the toilet would harm the person making the request. The people problem
Is instead of explaining that to the patient they are told to pee on a pad like an animal. It’s ridiculously insulting.

WhatTheActualFreshHell · 01/03/2021 04:00

After experienced the 'care' extended to my DS when he had leukaemia, I have to agree with the OP.

I am totally disillusioned with nurses, doctors and HCPs.

Rainbows and clapping? Nope - never from me.

Vgtasd · 01/03/2021 03:46

Totally agree that some nurses dont care at all, a few years ago my ds had pneumonia, I stayed with him on the ward even though the nurses were determined to get me to go home, other babies monitors would constantly go off during the night and appeared to be ignored, when I went to the nurses station a grumpy nurse eating crisps grunted she'd be there in a minute, total lack of urgency and care

HoppingPavlova · 01/03/2021 03:14

Who knows? There may have been some very good reason why it was more appropriate for the elderly lady to go on the pad versus being taken to a toilet. I had one of mine in hospital recently and for the first two days I had them go on pads and the mats. It was genuinely a better option than a bedpan for various reasons and they were not able to leave the bed to use the bathroom. My (adult) child was begging to use the bathroom but we’re not in a rational state. I’m a loving parent, also a HCP. Your niece had no idea what this lady’s situation was and whether the nurses reaction was valid or not.

Crikeycroc · 01/03/2021 02:24

@WhoWants2Know

It's quite common for a person to need two people to assist them to the toilet if they are unsteady on their feet. It's also common for people with a UTI to have a constant feeling of urgently needing to urinate, even if their bladder is empty.

It's a shame if your niece was upset, but she has no idea about the woman's needs or why the nurse didn't immediately assist her to the toilet.

With a nursing background, I would have thought you would understand that. But instead you decide to start a nurse bashing, goady thread...🤔

Exactly. I’ve told numerous patients that they can pass urine in their pad. Am I horrible degree educated nurse lacking in compassion? No. Usual scenario is that they have a UTI, are confused and have just had a catheter inserted.
Tinkerbell456 · 01/03/2021 02:10

As a nurse of many years, I’m sorry to hear about your neice’s experience. On the face of it, not great care. I do think though that to call nurses as a whole uncaring is simply not true. Usual bad apples etc., but most nurses I’ve ever encountered care very much.

JFCO · 01/03/2021 01:54

I have to agreed with you OP, I am afraid :( Only had close encounters with GP and a hospital for the last 2 months, but the lack of care is astonishing! Every single complaint is met with: 'it is not possible to see/look/treat you because of covid', I had to beg dr for stronger painkillers with tears streaming down my face- it was for my DH- I had to beg nurses at the hospital to look at him, had to beg dr for an MRI (denied)... I have never thought I would be in this situation:( This is UK, NHS, by the way. We did clap last summer- little did I know how my DH will be treated by them :(
I have no tears left and no more fight in me. We got ourselves a loan and he will be seeing a private dr this week.

RosesAndHellebores · 01/03/2021 00:08

Why was it left within reach of him? Would a paediatric nurse leave a hot drink in reach of an infant. Probably. Would the same paediatric nurse speak to a mother like shit about the dangers of a hot drink when the mother was caring for her child and had herself between child and drink? Oh yes.

Schonerlebnis · 01/03/2021 00:02

So what’s the answer ? Huge thread. No solutions. 40,000 nurse shortfall. Has that any bearing or none at all ? You don’t think that an extra 2 nurses would ease the pressure of work somewhat and energise staff ?
I don’t think most nurses on here are denying there’s a problem. Clearly is but the job is more complex than it ever was, nurses require a greater depth of knowledge than ever before, patients are sicker, relatives are prepared to challenge. Even something like the med round can be a potential minefield of errors.
Years ago I nursed a lovely elderly chap. He’d been incontinent. We freshened him up and then it was time for tea. HCA fed him whilst I did the drug round. I tidied up round the 6 bedded bay before visiting time and noticed that this man’s pyjama top was stained again. I changed it and 10 mins later was then confronted by an irate relative because he had spilt some of a beaker of tea on himself. The HCA had left it within reach on his table and intended going back to give him it. In the meantime he had attempted to have a drink himself spilling it in the process. This woman was furious, quite clearly didn't believe my explanation. She accused me of neglecting her father and stormed off. I’d not done anything of the kind. No doubt she later told others how lazy and neglectful we all were Sad

RosesAndHellebores · 28/02/2021 23:38

Absolutely agree Lemmein. Under no circumstances would I allow a relative of mine to have to rely on hospital staff for their non clinical care. It beggars belief.

MonkeyNotOrgangrinder · 28/02/2021 23:37

So fuck your presumption and fuck you to hell and back

Not presuming anything, just going off what you actually put in your previous post. Fuck me to hell and back though, wow!
Obviously I'm way out of line with what I'm about to say, but blaming yourself for your dad's death isn't doing anyone any good and won't bring him back. Sounds like be wasn't in any pain amd had his family with him, which is all anyone can ask.

lemmein · 28/02/2021 23:27

I spend quite a lot of time in hospital due to ongoing issues my (young adult) daughter has - I completely agree with you OP. Obviously not all, but sadly in my local hospital I would say the majority of medical staff that have 'cared' for my DD really haven't given a shit. Quite a few times I've pushed for her to be discharged because I could do a better job looking after her at home.

She's been left in (her own) bloody bedsheets for days, despite asking them to change them numerous times. She's had a dr grog up a load of phlegm in her sink Envy making no attempt at all to clean up after himself. Once whilst I was visiting I noticed she was getting a rash; I alerted the nurse who said she would get the dr to check on her. I was worried she had sepsis as she already had an infection - 5 hours later nobody had checked on her. They mostly congregate around the nurses station and there they'll stay and seem most put out if you actually ask them for help.

I could whinge for hours about the care she's received - but, she's also had some lovely nurses too, and god do they stand out, if she's lucky enough to get a decent one I dread them going off shift.

I hate her going into hospital, when her symptoms start which normally indicate a stay is on the cards it's really disheartening because I know what is coming. luckily she's not had to be admitted whilst covid has been going on, at least in normal times we can take turns visiting to make sure she's looked after, I dread to think what it's like on the wards now with no visitors looking on.

MixedUpFiles · 28/02/2021 23:21

There are always going to be individuals who fail to meet the needs of patients, but the fact that the incidents happen so frequently speaks to a larger issue. I think that larger issue is that hospitals don’t operate from a place of patient centered care to begin with. Sure, things have gotten better than they used to be, but most of the structure is still for the convenience and efficiency or the staff, not for the best interest of the patient.

AnnieGetYourPun · 28/02/2021 23:08

@Cyw2018 and thank you... you’ve brought us full circle to the “take it or leave it/other countries don’t even HAVE an NHS/be grateful and shut up” attitude where poor care breeds and thrives. And you’re not yet fully qualified are you? Apologies if I confuse you with someone else, but as I remember you’re still training.

Dear me.

OP posts:
AnnieGetYourPun · 28/02/2021 22:58

@Murphs1. That’s kind of you.

My experience of “escalating” has seen my family wait since Oct 2019 to get a reply to a complaint which was processed through all of the correct channels. We’re still waiting. If we all waited forever for change to roll around, it’d be even more dire. Speak out. Tell it like it is. Many have done just that, over the past 16 pages of this thread. Thank you.

When you are ignored, I find it best to call it out.

As @PopperPet says, this thread has touched a raw nerve for many. It should.

OP posts:
ANP2020 · 28/02/2021 22:55

Bit more info needed than in your post... can the lady mobilise? Safe to transfer with/without assistance? Any fractures preventing hoisting? Not safe to balance on commode due to injury? Post operative? Not excusing it but sometimes not all the information is fully there for you to see...

EmmetEmma · 28/02/2021 22:54

I think it’s ward, and sometimes hospital culture maybe - combined with burnout, compassion fatigue and a few people being awful at what they do. I do not think it is degrees at all!

I have seen some terrible nursing in my work as a student nurse/HCA but also - mainly - excellent nursing.

No one should be told to “just do it in the pad” that is appalling. The hospital I work at now would not tolerate that at all unless it’s a genuine emergency - trying to imagine a situation! Sometimes catheterised patients need reminding that they are catheterised though.

Of course nurses aren’t angels - I hated the clap thing and lionising - there can be some shit care - and and I think it is a point of huge focus of ongoing training and trying to encourage staff to raise concerns.

Some of these stories on this thread are so grim and so shameful. I don’t know what the answer is to stop it but genuinely, I think the care given at in the hospital I work at now is better than the care when I did my training in 20 years ago. I can not think easily of any examples of poor care I’ve seen in the past year.

You are right that poor care should be called out but I feel pretty defensive of my colleagues when you basically say that few of those with a degree have an ounce of compassion. It is patently not true and designed to be insulting. A better question would be “AIBU to think that whilst some people working in the NHS do a good job, some people still receive terrible care? If you agree what can be done about it?”

RosesAndHellebores · 28/02/2021 22:52

Yes thank you @YouAlreadyKnow. Merely speaking the truth and I am sorry if you have an issue with that.

PopperPet · 28/02/2021 22:37

Annie and Albert, thank you. Sorry that was such a rant. I don’t talk about this with anyone outside my immediate family, even then not much as it isn’t something my mum wants to be reminded of. Your post struck such a raw nerve, Annie. I really hope your niece gets treated, soon, and gets out & home safe and well. And I hope this thread isn’t stressing you more.

@MonkeyNotOrgangrinder - of course he was getting morphine, what the fuck kind of people do you think my family are? The point was, lungs apart, he was in great physical health generally - his lungs were failing but his heart was strong, his other organs were strong. The ward sister or doctor - I honestly don’t know who was in charge - wanted to push up the morphine because she said it would slow his respiration and suffocate him. He wasn’t conscious at this point and we were told he wasn’t in pain. They just wanted to get it over, and they wanted us to make that decision - to tell them to go ahead, up the dose, snuff him out. And here’s the great thing: we did. We agreed to what they were pressing us for, so in the end he took only a couple of hours. Wouldn’t have made any difference in the end if he’d survived longer and passed away in his own time, but it turns out knowing you hastened your dad’s death so everything could be tidied away before the evening shift is a decision that is kind of hard to bear.

So fuck your presumption and fuck you to hell and back.

YouAlreadyKnow · 28/02/2021 22:35

And seriously the three nurses who were involved all had open Facebook accounts. None of which were edifying.

It’s to see you pop up on a NHS thread without banging on about being “Mrs RosesAndHellebores”, but massive WTF at this. Having another completely normal one, are you? 😂

giantwaterbottle · 28/02/2021 22:33

I hate to agree with you but I do. I worked in the NHS and have also been cared for there and although there are still some wonderful nurses I think the lack of dignity and care is horrendous. And it is NOT due to understaffing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread