Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder WTF has happened to nursing “care” in our NHS?

536 replies

AnnieGetYourPun · 27/02/2021 16:31

And don’t tell me it’s all Covid/staff shortages/staff illness related.

My niece was eventually admitted to hospital after being sent home twice from A&E (in agony) and is now on a gynae ward. It’s just her and an elderly lady on the ward. The elderly lady was getting agitated as she needed the toilet. The nurse came and said, and I quote “it’s alright, use your pad and we’ll come and sort you out later”. This has really upset my niece who’s dodging sepsis now, on the ward, on massive IV antibiotics/anti-emetics and IV analgesia. She has narrowly avoided a ruptured uterus as there was no one to do a scan on her, after a 12 hr wait in A&E. She is 32.

Nurses now... all of ‘em have degrees. All dead clever. Very few of them have an ounce of “caring” in them.

Fry me on here. I’m past fucking caring.

Should add. I trained in the NHS. Was a student/junior staff nurse/senior staff nurse/junior sister and G grade senior sister before retirement. Never, in my f***g life have I seen such lack of basic care and maintenance of human dignity than I have witnessed in NHS hospitals, in the past two years.

Shove your clapping and rainbows.

OP posts:
Rupertpenrysmistress · 01/03/2021 09:18

Well this is an awful thread. Being a nurse is very complex, patient's have multiple complex needs and are living longer we are having to battle the effects of diabetes and dementia.
My drug round often takes 1-2 hours because I have 9 patients who may require cardiac drugs or insulin that is time sensitive but also requires me to access separate systems to check blood glucose/blood pressure etc. This is so I can justify every act or omission, this is all on me. Often my amazing HCA will therefore be the one trying to wash all 9 dependent patient's. I often have to help patient's take drugs which can require time and patience or thickening drinks. It is not uncommon during a drug round to have to see to a deteriorating patient. If I am in charge that day and caring for patient's (because we are short) I have to leave my drug round to hand over to AHP otherwise we can't plan discharges. I am also called to manage beds/sick patient's or deal with relatives.

I do wash and toilet patient's it gives me a chance to really know them but, often don't get the chance due to taking on Drs role's. I cannulate/take bloods/do VBG/.

I am exhausted by this pandemic wearing PPE dealing with angry relatives which I feel is mainly due to no visiting. I feel like I let my patient's down we rarely have enough staff due to isolation/positive for covid and the fact staff don't want to do extra. I often go without my breaks as my paperwork is always left until last. I have to access about 6 different systems to get all my patient's info and complete multiple pieces of paperwork. If a patient falls we have to complete 4 seperate pieces of paperwork and complete a datix. This takes so long and takes me away from observing my patient's. Care is not what it should be, I am devastated about this, this is not what I came into nursing to provide but,aa I have to choose which of my tasks is most important at that minute.

I am often going over shifts in my head and reflecting what I could have done better but unless we have more staff or longer shifts it is not possible. I am Caring for dying patient's and when relatives find it to hard to come in I try to stay with that patient as much as possible and inform the relative of the patient's condition, it breaks my heart that could be my dad.

As a ward manager I also have to worry about the offduty and caring for my staff who are at breaking point. There are some interesting articles related to caring fatigue which I am sure is affecting some staff. There are bad professionals in every job, I have come across some in all professions but I do not believe it is as wide spread as is suggested on this thread. We often have multiple siblings to deal with and sometimes one can be very difficult no matter what we do, the others often apologize and say they are just worried. I do understand but there is no need to swear at me.

Threads like this make me wonder why I stay in nursing, we are not angels, didn't ask to be clapped but, of course the clapping was covering up a much more fundamental issue - lack of adequate PPE we were put at so much risk at the beginning of the pandemic, lack of funds, dismantling of the NHS has gone on for years, nurses having to pay to study. The word nurse does not mean all we do is personal care and yes that is our role but we have multiple other roles, we may act as a physio (especially at weekends) drs because there are not enough. It has been proven time and time again that the risk of mortality goes down substantially when being cared for by a trained nurse. we have multiple roles that have removed us from providing personal care. My role was much easier before we took on drs role's.

So how about a thread describing good episodes of care? No I thought not. Makes great click bate. Thanks for adding to my already low morale.

smallandimperfectlyformed · 01/03/2021 09:14

So sorry for your loss tigerbread20. I am glad that your mum got good care

ancientgran · 01/03/2021 09:14

@tigerbread20

There is good and bad in every area of life.

I'm a student nurse and see it all, all the time. And I challenge bad practice, I'm proud of that.
But I think the good far far outweighs the bad.
My mum died very suddenly on Friday night and when I arrived at a and e to see her the consultant made me a cup of tea and biscuits and sat and comforted me until I'd stopped crying, the consultant!! The nurses who washed and dressed my mum did the most impeccable job and I'll always be grateful for how peaceful and dignified they made her look. Even the receptionist who let me in genuinely cared. None of them got anything extra for going the extra mile, every single one of them did it because they are compassionate people doing the job for the right reasons.
I think a lot of the time the bad comes out when people have been in the job for too long and are burnt out.

I'm sorry for your loss, it is hard to lose your mum. I am pleased you got such good support and of course that is how it should be.
ancientgran · 01/03/2021 09:12

There will always be people unhappy with care, some justified some not. The ridiculous thing about the OP is saying this is because nurses have degrees. There were good and bad experiences long before nurses had degrees, she probably had patients who were unhappy at times but obviously she isn't going to admit that.

tigerbread20 · 01/03/2021 09:11

There is good and bad in every area of life.

I'm a student nurse and see it all, all the time. And I challenge bad practice, I'm proud of that.
But I think the good far far outweighs the bad.
My mum died very suddenly on Friday night and when I arrived at a and e to see her the consultant made me a cup of tea and biscuits and sat and comforted me until I'd stopped crying, the consultant!! The nurses who washed and dressed my mum did the most impeccable job and I'll always be grateful for how peaceful and dignified they made her look. Even the receptionist who let me in genuinely cared. None of them got anything extra for going the extra mile, every single one of them did it because they are compassionate people doing the job for the right reasons.
I think a lot of the time the bad comes out when people have been in the job for too long and are burnt out.

Babylonberlin · 01/03/2021 09:02

@wewillmeetagain so do you have an issue with OTs, physios and social workers having degrees ? You want to return to a time when nurses were just
the doctor's handmaiden, there to mop fevered brows and remove bedpans ?
The fact that nurses are now more educated is surely a good thing ?
My 13 year old son was in hospital recently with appendicitis. The care on the whole was fine. One nurse in particular was very thoughtful and clinically spot on. A HCA made sure we were fed and watered as we couldn't leave the room due to us awaiting our covid status. Another s/n had to be prompted to tell us about post op aftercare and yet another allowed the obs machine to alarm incessantly for hours after the op. I think with some they just don't have much common sense, they are young and inexperienced, they are busy.
In my experience good communication is vital. That's when issues occur and patients become rightfully disgruntled. I've received poor treatment myself but mainly from medics rather than nursing staff. Again it was a case of not communicating or explaining things.

.

AnnieGetYourPun · 01/03/2021 09:01

There’s a theme running through this thread. I don’t mean the abuse I’ve gotten for speaking the truth...

I hate her going into hospital, when her symptoms start which normally indicate a stay is on the cards it's really disheartening because I know what is coming. luckily she's not had to be admitted whilst covid has been going on, at least in normal times we can take turns visiting to make sure she's looked after, I dread to think what it's like on the wards now with no visitors looking on

Absolutely agree Lemmein. Under no circumstances would I allow a relative of mine to have to rely on hospital staff for their non clinical care. It beggars belief

Seems it’s the basic nursing care (which was mostly given by hands on qualified nursing staff, back in the “bad old days”).

I’m not able to fully read the two pages added after 10pm last night. I’m off to work (I’m actually not that old - some on here seem to think I trained with Florence Nightingale herself) but when I get back I’ll reply.

OP posts:
ClockworkNightingale · 01/03/2021 08:54

Hi OP, thanks for sharing your thoughts about my personal suitability for nursing. It's pretty ironic actually, because as it happens I've outlasted several of my most experienced colleagues, who left specifically to avoid the winter wave that I spent nursing suffocating patients in covid ITU.

Maybe if they'd had degrees, they'd have been as resilient as me. We can only speculate.

Cyw2018 · 01/03/2021 08:34

@PinkPlantCase

There is no doubt that in an organisation as large as the NHS there is poor practice, this will be from the most senior consultant to the hospital porters and everyone in between including both degree and 'old school' nurses.

However, this is not what op thread is about, it is about her appalling attitude towards all current staff trained and qualified under the university system.

Also OP examples of poor care just don't hold up to scrutiny and if she is the experienced skilled nurse she says she is she will know this.

Many of the other examples of poor practice given by concerned relatives/ex patients on here also at best demonstrate a lack of knowledge and understanding of modern healthcare and in the worst cases totally unrealistic expectations, and this thread does not help educated or adjust expectations of healthcare.

HeadNorth · 01/03/2021 08:28

Dreadful older people.......

Ageist comment. Change older for black.

Bollocks is it ageist - I am decribing a particular type whose mind and worldview narrows rather than widens as they age. We all know and recognise it, sticking an 'ism' on it doesn't stop them exsiting. I am no spring chicken myself and it makes me sad when my generation start becoming all 'what is wrong with the youth of today'.

Old people putting down the younger generation is a tale as old as time and the OP matches that trope to a T.

JesusAteMyHamster · 01/03/2021 08:25

I was in a few months ago and elderly people in my bay being left on bedpans for up to an hour at a time was very much the norm. I remember one lady crying because she needed to go but also knew the HCP would 'just go off to do something ' and she'd be left. The smell when one had had a poo was horrific and humiliating for that person.

The ward was busy, there's no denying that but I wouldn't have said it was leaving elderly people balancing on a bedpan busy.........also I couldn't help but notice that they were very attentive towards one lady whose daughter had permission to come in each day and do some care due to her mum's dementia........this lady was very vocal about her mum's care needs and what she expected. She also wasn't shy about making complaints. Make of that what you will. Hmm

PinkPlantCase · 01/03/2021 08:19

@Cyw2018 @HeadNorth

If you put the OPs points about how nurses are trained aside people on this thread have shared experiences of where they have found care to be poor.

Are we not allowed to criticise anymore? We can both be grateful for nurses/the NHS and still admit that there are faults and areas of improvements.

Whilst poor care is (hopefully) very much the minority it has a big impact on people at a time in their life where they are vulnerable. It can leave them feeling scared of ever needed to be in hospital again because of the quality of care received in the past.

Even if people personally aren’t on the receiving end but just witness poor standards, this can make them concerned for themselves aswell as family members in the future.

Coffeeandcocopops · 01/03/2021 08:17

Got nothing to do with being black - I’m just pointing out the ageism in your comment. Who cares what age the OP is - she is perfectly entitled to have an opinion just like you. But there is no need to refer to her age !!

Cyw2018 · 01/03/2021 08:15

@Coffeeandcocopops

Why change it for black. I know plenty of highly educated forward thinking black people.

Coffeeandcocopops · 01/03/2021 08:13

@HeadNorth

The OP comes across as one of those dreadful older people who is convinved everything was 'better in their day' and thinks young people 'lack respect'. This genus often went to 'the university of common sense' and despise fancy university degrees, greatly distrusting education and the educated. We have all met them, many of us have a least one in our family. And boy I pity any professional who has deal with them, especially if they are the despised trifecta of young, female and qualified. So nurses really won't stand a chance.
Dreadful older people.......

Ageist comment. Change older for black.

HeadNorth · 01/03/2021 08:09

The OP comes across as one of those dreadful older people who is convinved everything was 'better in their day' and thinks young people 'lack respect'. This genus often went to 'the university of common sense' and despise fancy university degrees, greatly distrusting education and the educated. We have all met them, many of us have a least one in our family. And boy I pity any professional who has deal with them, especially if they are the despised trifecta of young, female and qualified. So nurses really won't stand a chance.

Ispini · 01/03/2021 08:07

@FatCatThinCat

YANBU it's been going down hill for years. My dad died 8 years ago and the care he received was extremely poor. We had to make sure he was fed, watered and cleaned. If he'd had no family support he'd have been in a bad way. In the end they woke him up at 3.00 am as they needed the bed so needed to send him home. Stuck a frail old man with Parkinson's and dementia in a taxi and washed their hands of him. First my mum knew about it was the local postie knocking on her door and waking her up having found my dad wandering aimlessly on the estate.
FatCatThinCat, that is absolutely disgraceful, your poor Dad, how upsetting for you and your family. 😔
wewillmeetagain · 01/03/2021 07:56

Op i agree! It's absolutely disgusting! I blame the fact that its all degree based! It doesn't attract the kind of people that see it as a vocation. Ex nurse/midwife here and I absolutely cringe when i go into a hospital ward now days.

Cyw2018 · 01/03/2021 07:45

[quote AnnieGetYourPun]@Cyw2018 and thank you... you’ve brought us full circle to the “take it or leave it/other countries don’t even HAVE an NHS/be grateful and shut up” attitude where poor care breeds and thrives. And you’re not yet fully qualified are you? Apologies if I confuse you with someone else, but as I remember you’re still training.

Dear me.[/quote]
Oh you really are confusing me with someone else, i'm a band 6 whose been working in the NHS for over 20 years across two different health care professions during that time.

OP there seems to be some serious holes in your posts.

You say you retired 3 years ago from a G grade role yet A4C has been in since 2004?!

Your niece in on "massive IV analgesia" yet you can't see the possible problem with her account of ward life, and can't for a minute think that is could be a legitimate mobility or manual handling issue as many previous posters have suggested rather than neglect. You would be better support for your niece if you reassured her that the staff will have had good reason for leaving the patient to pas urine on a pad, rather than winding you niece up over neglect issues at a time when you niece is alone, scared and vulnerable.

You know your nieces medical status in detail, yet I'm assuming (possibly wrongly) that you are not her NOK and also that a 32 year old would have the capacity to be dealing with the hospital staff directly, and since hospitals have no visiting except where patients are dying, therefore what you are passing judgement on is second or even third hand info, most likely via no healthcare qualified realtives. Do you see the possible problem there?

You complained that the nurses tried to prevent your father tearing out his urinary catherter. I once dealt with a man who had ripped his catheter out (accidentally at home, he snagged the tube to his leg bag on furniture whilst in just his dressing gown) and lost 2l of blood as a result. That kind of haemrohage would likely have killed an older person, like your 92 year old father. You would have certainly complained then, and likely sued judging by your attitude diplayed in this thread.

I just pity you local NHS staff who must dread the day that you or one of your relatives require hospital treatment.

You clearly have an agenda against current NHS staff and this thread your have started is vile.

FedNlanders · 01/03/2021 07:41

@Maverickess

Disclaimer - I work in a care home, not a nurse. Regarding the being told to use a pad instead of the toilet, on the face of it, not acceptable. However, how would you feel if I left a relative of yours in a dangerous situation, to take someone else to the toilet? Because in a home that's sometimes the choice we face, which is a less stressful and obviously non medical environment, with less going on. If we're dealing with someone who needs two for safety reasons, and someone else needs the toilet, well they need to wait unfortunately, we have to prioritise safety over anything else, and yes, I will reassure and say it's ok, you can use your pad, I can't discuss where I am or what I'm doing in detail because that's confidential. Also, you know, someone has to go first, and someone last when people want or need help at the same time. Unless there's a massive investment in healthcare in general, to enable 1:1 (or 2:1 if needed) care across the board, someone's always going to have to wait. But then no one wants to be the one who waits. We're not technically 'short staffed' either, in fact legally we've probably got more staff on some shifts than the guidelines state as a minimum, but we're still outnumbered (for want of a better phrase) by residents.

That's the practical side of things, and unfortunately there's no getting away from that.

That said, I have experienced some poor care, both as a patient (less so) and as an escort to residents that have needed to attend hospital. Dementia patients are particularly at risk ime, possibly due to lack of understanding and training, and also probably because they take up more time than an average patient with the same condition or injury due to the nature of dementia. I've been told to 'do something!' by medical staff - what they expected I don't know, I could no more force compliance than they could, I was there to basically stop them wandering and putting themselves further at risk and offer the constant reassurance dementia patients often need, working in dementia care doesn't mean I have a magic answer.
While there are definitely nurses that are poor at hands on care and dealing with patients as people, I don't think that can be purely put down to them having a degree, though I do think that maybe longer on the wards as well as the classroom might help with that. I've worked with care workers who weren't in the slightest bit caring too.
I think the poor care, like poor customer service stands out more, and poor management and poor resources contribute in no small way. I also feel that the social norm of presenteeism has a lot to answer for. We expect 100% performance all the time and no mistakes to be made, well apart from being unrealistic when you're dealing with humans, there's also the fact that being ill is detrimental to performance, yet you are often given a hard time, pressured to work when ill and can be disciplined for being ill too often, or for having a family crisis etc. So apart from having humans with faults at the heart of this, you've sometimes got humans that could be ill or in the middle of something going really wrong, who are being overworked and treated poorly by their employers and also sometimes by the people they're trying to help. It's no wonder that some lose their caring side sometimes or all together really.
I think we need to look long and hard about why it's being perceived to be getting worse, and what we're asking of nurses and other HCPs because they're human too.

Wholeheartedly agree.
FedNlanders · 01/03/2021 07:38

I care for the elderly and i am a bloody good nurse but I agree im constantly battling against benchmarks and lack of funds but I would still never say to them to do it in the pad.

stairway · 01/03/2021 07:34

Well anyway, I hope this thread makes people feel better, but the reality is the nhs and care is going to get much worse, delayed treatment due to covid, less money and less staff. Complaining likely won’t help either as there will be less staff to deal with that too. We might try and fill the gaps again by raiding developing countries for their health care staff, but considering the PPE scandal has killed so many from ethnic backgrounds maybe they won’t come. Anyway if working conditions worsen, I’d probably just look for work away from the ward as it’s so tough and quite often thankless. We’ll all just have to look after our own relatives in hospital like they do in poorer countries and expect minimal treatment.

ElphabaTheGreen · 01/03/2021 07:29

@NeedToKnow101

When my mum was dying last year I found the nurses mainly very caring. If I was a bit late to visit (tried to arrive before lunch), I would walk in to them patiently trying to feed her. I also found the OTs caring.

My sibling, on the other hand, found everyone uncaring. Sometimes we have wildly different perspectives of the same situation.

This is very, very true. Sometimes you can’t win for losing. One patient will think you’re God’s gift to healthcare, the next will report you to PALS, even if your standard of care is equally high and you think you’ve bent over backwards to adapt to individual needs.
Schonerlebnis · 01/03/2021 07:05

@RosesAndHellebores the tea was cool. If I’d moved it out of reach I would have been accused of denying him fluid. Can’t win sometimes can we ?

NeedToKnow101 · 01/03/2021 06:55

When my mum was dying last year I found the nurses mainly very caring. If I was a bit late to visit (tried to arrive before lunch), I would walk in to them patiently trying to feed her. I also found the OTs caring.

My sibling, on the other hand, found everyone uncaring. Sometimes we have wildly different perspectives of the same situation.