Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder WTF has happened to nursing “care” in our NHS?

536 replies

AnnieGetYourPun · 27/02/2021 16:31

And don’t tell me it’s all Covid/staff shortages/staff illness related.

My niece was eventually admitted to hospital after being sent home twice from A&E (in agony) and is now on a gynae ward. It’s just her and an elderly lady on the ward. The elderly lady was getting agitated as she needed the toilet. The nurse came and said, and I quote “it’s alright, use your pad and we’ll come and sort you out later”. This has really upset my niece who’s dodging sepsis now, on the ward, on massive IV antibiotics/anti-emetics and IV analgesia. She has narrowly avoided a ruptured uterus as there was no one to do a scan on her, after a 12 hr wait in A&E. She is 32.

Nurses now... all of ‘em have degrees. All dead clever. Very few of them have an ounce of “caring” in them.

Fry me on here. I’m past fucking caring.

Should add. I trained in the NHS. Was a student/junior staff nurse/senior staff nurse/junior sister and G grade senior sister before retirement. Never, in my f***g life have I seen such lack of basic care and maintenance of human dignity than I have witnessed in NHS hospitals, in the past two years.

Shove your clapping and rainbows.

OP posts:
Crabbyboot · 01/03/2021 20:33

[quote AnnieGetYourPun]@crabbyboot You are in denial, I suspect. Have you read this thread? 🙄[/quote]
No not in denial, just being very sarcastic! Grin

ancientgran · 01/03/2021 20:25

Just watching Dispatches on channel 4. You should be bloody ashamed of yourself.

Babylonberlin · 01/03/2021 20:20

So what was the point ? However many pages and mostly negative. But then the premise was 'nursing care nowadays is shit ' so those are the stories you will get. Maybe next time to counterbalance this 'the nhs saved my life' ?
You didn't come up with any solutions and presumably you'd be quite happy to return to the good old days. Sadly the nature of medical care and the expectations of it's users would make that impossible.

AnnieGetYourPun · 01/03/2021 19:31

Thank you all for the replies.

It seems the poor experiences are now outweighing the good. So many distressing incidents. Some have rightly said that it can put a person off having any form of treatment or cause great anxiety, should a loved one need care.

I don’t know how to respond anymore. I’ve offended a lot of people. I don’t take my comments back. My “and they’ve all got degrees now” was a reference to the fact that when I was a kid, people who went to University were immensely clever. Most people went into office work or factory work where I grew up. A neighbour’s son went to University and I was totally in awe of him. It was a big deal. My point is that with better education standards ought to rise. For those who insist they have, massively, I think you cannot deny the many people on here who’ve backed up what I’ve said.

I don’t have a problem with HCA. My friend is ine and a bloody good one. If I went into hospital ive told her she has to drop everything and look after me! No, my bugbear is that in my experience the qualified staff have moved further and further away from the actual physical patient. As I said, my mums “named nurse” had no clue who I was talking about when I arrived on the ward, having been called in because she’d gone from (by the nursing assessment in admission) self caring to dying. She’d only been in a week. Sitting at a desk, delegating care, IMO does lessen contact and there is often a lack of connection between nurse and patient/family.

I’m thinking close to 500 posts, back and forth, is enough. For those who’ve shared their stories, thank you.

OP posts:
Lillylolo · 01/03/2021 19:08

I think like everything there is good & bad. I witnessed an elderly lady left on a commode for 45 mins & had to get a nurse to get her off as she’d been there so long. I’ve witnessed my auntie dying of cancer begging & crying for pain relief for it to take 45 mins to give her 2pills.

Then when I had my baby my care was amazing. My midwife was absolutely incredible, my aftercare was incredible

Coffeeandcocopops · 01/03/2021 18:45

My baby was in special care as he was 6 weeks early. I was on the post delivery ward without my baby as there was no room for me in special care and I was recovering from preeclampsia. It was hell anyway but made worse by the midwifes constantly asking me to keep an eye on the other babies in the ward whilst their mothers went to make a phone call or a smoke.

Anna12345678910 · 01/03/2021 17:18

There are good and back in all professions.

To improve people need to challenge bad care in a calm and correct way. Raise with the person running the ward or in writing so it is recorded.

saffire · 01/03/2021 16:24

About 10 years ago I was in hospital on a general ward (although fully of elderly) and the bed I was in was next to a broken window and it was snowing outside. I was freezing and begged them to let me move beds. The nurses weren't great and I really noticed the difference when I was moved to another bay on the same ward, different nurses and wow, what a change in care!

I think, unfortunately, that it's often a case of some people just shouldn't be in a caring profession when they don't care. I don't think it can be blamed on covid, of course it's not helped, but it's been going on for ages.

Ken1976 · 01/03/2021 16:15

Retired nurse here . My daughter is also a nurse . When I gave birth to her in 1973 the majority of the staff on the ward were absolutely horrible to me . Why? Because I was on bed rest for 2 weeks before she was born and there was no sign of my husband . They assumed that I was a single mother and judged me for it . I was 20 at the time and my husband was abroad with the army. 3 days after her birth he walked onto the ward and asked for me . The nurses had a complete change of mind laughing and joking . I signed myself out of the hospital later that day . They wouldn't let me off the ward to use the phone on the corridor to phone home for someone to come for me but one of the cleaners got the phone number from me and called on my behalf . Then as I was getting ready an auxiliary nurse shouted at me , 'you can't go , don't you know your baby has a heart murmur'?
Actually I didn't know this , because nobody had told me . I left with the baby anyway and had our family doctor check her over .

WaterOffADucksCrack · 01/03/2021 15:33

There's good and bad in every profession. I work in care and have seen good and bad care.

Our hospital isn't good for care to be honest. I had no food or pain relief after having my first baby. I took it with me for my second. With my second they told me I couldn't possibly be close to delivering then was rushed to the delivery room. Then I got told I wasn't trying hard enough to push the placenta out. They ended up giving me an epidural and had to manually rip it away as it was stuck.

When I was told I was having a miscarriage the woman told my partner and I there was no heartbeat and then immediately said I needed to make sure I looked after my partner as he would be very upset.

When I visited my grandma in hospital no one had emptied her catheter for over 12 hours so I did it.

ExConstance · 01/03/2021 13:13

There certainly is a problem with preserving dignity and continence. it happens time and time again that older people go into hospital, get catheterised or are compelled to use pads and then when it is time for them to go home they have become incontinent, with all that entails in leading a normal life. All nursing and care staff should have it ingrained in their training that preserving continence will make a huge difference to how someone lives their last few years. Perhaps ;before they tell people to "use a pad" they should try it themselves, totally repugnant if not already necessary.

peaceanddove · 01/03/2021 12:57

When my Mum was being treated for lung cancer she was stuck on a respiratory ward that looked like something out of the 1940s (except it wasn't nearly as clean or orderly). The noise level was dreadful thanks to there usually being 3-4 visitors at each bed, despite signs saying no more than 2 allowed. It was grubby. A pair of used gloves and a dirty tissue remained under her bed for 3 days until I removed them.

After my Mum used a commode I witnessed the 2 auxiliary nurses who removed it, wafting their hands infront of their noses and remarking on the smell. My poor Mum was mortified as she had always been fastidious about personal hygiene and was never seen without her hair styled and lipstick on. If I hadn't been so drained and low I would have roasted them both alive for such cruel, unprofessional behaviour. Later, when I complained via email I was told they couldn't comment on specific members of staff.

My Mum's cousin (retired matron) visited and was shocked and upset at the scruffy appearance of both the ward and its staff. It was all I could do to stop her tearing a strip off the staff, but I was scared that my Mum's care would just get worse as a result.

The only time there was a calm, professional atmosphere on the ward was if the Sister was on duty, but it wasn't often. Otherwise staff seemed to gather around the desk most of the time.

One night an agency nurse (male, Spanish) came on duty as I was leaving Mum and he was amazing so warm and kind to her. He squeezed her hand, tidied her bed and joked with her, all the whole discreetly checking her notes etc. I could see how Mum relaxed and responded to him. When I left them I cried in the car because it was the one and only time I felt I had left Mum with someone who genuinely cared.

Jimdandy · 01/03/2021 12:26

@AnnieGetYourPun

I agree. My Aunty was in hospital a few years ago after sustaining a head injury from dally down the stairs.

She had a catheter in and had messed herself. I kept ringing the bell and trying to find someone to sort her out, they were dismissive and kept telling me to go away.

She kept getting agitated and trying to pull the catheter out again I kept trying to find someone and was dismissed.

Finally she yanked it out and at last they came running, but they were awful she didn’t get any care at all.

Leaving people in their own filth is not acceptable and they didn’t give a shit.

Lollipop1234 · 01/03/2021 12:10

@ElphabaTheGreen

I’m an OT - I’ve worked with ward nurses for almost 20 years.

You get great nurses, you get not so great nurses, I’ve worked with three nurses who I’ve reported for shocking care (the one who put soup into a large syringe for a confused patient refusing food and told an HCA to pull his head back while she squirted it in saying, ‘He’ll have to swallow now or he’ll drown’ got deregistered, I hope). But it’s the same for all health care professionals. I’ve worked with some awful OTs.

The not so great nurses have very, very common themes which drive me batshit every day:

  • they treat their printed handovers as the font of all information about the patient, even if it hasn’t been updated for days. Reading the medical notes is only for the doctors, apparently
  • what they see on the day must be what the patient is forever and ever and they exist in a vacuum. Making contact with the family to find out what this patient’s ‘normal’ is is everybody else’s job but theirs. If we ask, ‘who have they got at home?’ we get ‘I don’t know, it hasn’t been handed over to me’. Well fucking ASK YOUR PATIENT.
  • communication is awful. Awful. They are the staff on the ward all the time so are in the best position to pass on information to the medical team or families from us when we’re not around to do it. They don’t. And if a family asks them a question about what therapists are doing they make zero effort to read our notes to let them know on the spot - we’re then left playing phone tig with family for days when they had that information in front of them to pass on straight away
  • if it’s slightly awkward or difficult it’s not their job and must be for a specialist nurse or doctor. A patient’s mother died while he was an inpatient with us. The B6 ward sister called the medical team to the ward to get them to tell him. She was a senior nurse and the most familiar face to that patient on the ward - there was zero reason to delegate that job other than can’t-be-arsedness.
  • sitting patients out. Getting some nurses to sit patients out when therapists aren’t about is like pulling teeth. Getting catheters taken out of less mobile patients who really no longer need them is also impossible as it saves them having to walk patients to the toilet. If I had a pound for every time I’ve gently reminded nurses about the role these things have in prevention of chest infections and UTIs, which would ultimately take more of their time and effort than taking the preventative actions in the first place, I could retire. Or do they really prefer the reduced physical effort in putting up IV antibiotics to hoisting out? Or delegating an HCA to 1:1 a patient out of their tree with UTI delirium to save a walk to the loo?
Completely agree, I am in a very similar role to you.

A good ward ward, with staff who communicate well and get on with the work is great to work on.

When working with the staff that you describe, and yes there are many people like this that I have come across in my career, it is a nightmare.

I worked last weekend, and there were a few “lazy” nurses on who basically prioritised their breaks and chatting and eating together over getting the patients up and washed. It was lunchtime before they finally got going, beyond the basic drugs rounds etc. I know there is a lot of paperwork, but spending all morning doing it is ridiculous.

ancientgran · 01/03/2021 11:57

@albertcamus

ancientgran I have not mentioned degrees; having worked for 28 years as a teacher, I am well aware that many totally unqualified people have more common sense, ability and knowledge than those with PhDs.

As I have mentioned earlier on this thread, my son nearly lost his life in 'wonderful' GOSH in 1989 while being treated for leukaemia due to uncaring, unprofessional, dirty, lazy and contemptuous nurses. I don't know or care whether they had degrees or not; almost all of them were not fit for their jobs.

Sadly, the situation appears to have deteriorated in the interim, which is an unnecessary and unacceptable state of affairs which needs to be addressed urgently.

Many of the responses from those employed as nurses, HCPs, call them what you like on this thread simply underline the OP's point that it is not just the lack of care, but the disgusting attitudes which are so hurtful for patients and their families.

Please check your facts before posting directly at me in future.

Please check the OP, the point of this thread seems to be to say nurses now are worse than nurses were because they have degrees. If you have a look I have commented on nurses in another well known children's hospital refusing to comfort a crying toddler as they hadn't done emotional development yet and that was in the 70s. There has always been good and bad care, to pretend this is new or because of degrees is ridiculous.

Did your son get treated by anyone other than a nurse? Maybe a doctor, maybe a senior doctor, maybe a radiographer, an OT? No it was all nurses wasn't it. They really should know their place, handmaidens to doctors only fit to wipe bottoms and make beds.

Hathertonhariden · 01/03/2021 11:00

IME the best care is on paeds wards where parents are available to do feeding/toileting/washing and monitoring their dcs general condition.

Emergency care is good

The biggest problem is on very understaffed wards with patients on observation. If you are responsible for 10+ patients, observation is taking temp/bp once or twice a day and handing out meds. There is no communication with the patient to see how they are feeling or if there have been any changes. Shift handovers take a very long time considering how little they know about the condition of their patients. If you are going 8hrs+ without any contact with nursing staff there is no meaningful observation going on. It would be far better just to send patients home with a list of things to watch out for that would warrant readmission.

stairway · 01/03/2021 10:56

Albertcamus, I have no idea about the issues with healthcare in 1989, so can’t comment on what you went through. There are issues with the NHS currently I totally agree. My opinion having worked there is it has nothing to do with qualifications. There are issues with management, staffing and resources. There is also according to this thread an issue with investigating and acting on complaints. Again more funding and resources are needed for that. It will get worse with the financial crisis and after effects of the pandemic. We need politicians and senior people high up to think of solutions or we really will end up with third world healthcare. I don’t really see how slagging off a whole profession helps tbh although I understand people need somewhere to let go of their grievances and doing it in here is preferable to releasing them onto the newly qualified nurse on her first night shift.

HeadNorth · 01/03/2021 10:56

CYW2018 and HeadNorth you both sound like the sort of nurses whose attitudes cause the hurt, fear and disgust voiced by the vast majority of posters on this thread.

Where on earth did you get the notion that I am a nurse? I certainly am not, I do a far easier and better paid job, thanks. I am someone who is fed up of hearing constant whinges about how it 'was all better in their day'. Well, no it wasn't. A better educated work force is a positive and it take a special sort of stupid to decry any profession being upskilled.

And for the nurses on this thread - I take my hat off to you. My daughter has received excellent and literally life saving care from the NHS. How wearying it must be to have to nurse some of the posters on this thread and I salute your professionalism.

BiBabbles · 01/03/2021 10:23

I don't think it's unreasonable to have concerns about medical care standards, I do think it's a bit unreasonable to focus it solely on nurses - or make it have anything to do with degrees.

The whole system is pretty fucked up, in many areas very efficiency focused and many other things that can make it very difficult to be properly caring. Many medical professionals still manage to do a great job, everyone has their off days but they are consistently doing good work, there are those so ground down in the system of this is what it is that it gets worse, and then yes, there are assholes who either never should have been in medical care or should have left much sooner, and it can be really difficult - particularly if you've a place that is known for circling around or fobbing people off when there are complaints - to do anything about the tiny minority of HCP who seem to enjoy the power they have over vulnerable people that tend to stick in people's minds far more and have such a major impact than the many people are doing things well and are very caring even in trying times in a system that doesn't properly support them to do that.

albertcamus · 01/03/2021 10:15

stairway Did you miss this part of my post?

Sadly, the situation appears to have deteriorated in the interim, which is an unnecessary and unacceptable state of affairs which needs to be addressed urgently.

stairway · 01/03/2021 10:01

Albertcamus, 1989 is a very long time to harbour resentment for all healthcare staff, many were not even born then! I understand traumatic experiences can lead to this. It’s like me saying I had a callous , horrible teacher when growing up, reading some of these threads now reinstates my belief that all or most teachers are cruel, horrible people except a few nice ones of course.

albertcamus · 01/03/2021 09:53

ancientgran I have not mentioned degrees; having worked for 28 years as a teacher, I am well aware that many totally unqualified people have more common sense, ability and knowledge than those with PhDs.

As I have mentioned earlier on this thread, my son nearly lost his life in 'wonderful' GOSH in 1989 while being treated for leukaemia due to uncaring, unprofessional, dirty, lazy and contemptuous nurses. I don't know or care whether they had degrees or not; almost all of them were not fit for their jobs.

Sadly, the situation appears to have deteriorated in the interim, which is an unnecessary and unacceptable state of affairs which needs to be addressed urgently.

Many of the responses from those employed as nurses, HCPs, call them what you like on this thread simply underline the OP's point that it is not just the lack of care, but the disgusting attitudes which are so hurtful for patients and their families.

Please check your facts before posting directly at me in future.

ancientgran · 01/03/2021 09:40

@albertcamus

CYW2018 and HeadNorth you both sound like the sort of nurses whose attitudes cause the hurt, fear and disgust voiced by the vast majority of posters on this thread.

Describing the thread as 'vile' is ridiculous; there is ample anecdotal evidence of a significant systemic problem with the standard of care given by SOME (probably the minority of) nurses in the NHS today. People like yourselves just do not like your own deficiencies and contemptuous, self-serving attitudes being highlighted and called out.

Patients and their families are not stupid; everybody who has to use publicly-funded services understands and accepts the resource constraints inevitably placed on them.

However, the recurring issue throughout this thread is the impact of the choice made by nurses like yourselves to not give adequate care to your vulnerable patients, and probably your colleagues, along with your foul-mouthed and defiant attitudes showing that you couldn't care less that the public's perception of the integrity of your 'profession' is diminishing rapidly, and IMO and IME, deservedly.

Can you explain where having a degree has anything to do with it? I can tell you from personal experience there were uncaring nurses long before nurses all had to have degrees. Talking about some nurses being uncaring is fair enough, pretending there was a golden time when all nurses were angels is just ridiculous.
albertcamus · 01/03/2021 09:37

CYW2018 and HeadNorth you both sound like the sort of nurses whose attitudes cause the hurt, fear and disgust voiced by the vast majority of posters on this thread.

Describing the thread as 'vile' is ridiculous; there is ample anecdotal evidence of a significant systemic problem with the standard of care given by SOME (probably the minority of) nurses in the NHS today. People like yourselves just do not like your own deficiencies and contemptuous, self-serving attitudes being highlighted and called out.

Patients and their families are not stupid; everybody who has to use publicly-funded services understands and accepts the resource constraints inevitably placed on them.

However, the recurring issue throughout this thread is the impact of the choice made by nurses like yourselves to not give adequate care to your vulnerable patients, and probably your colleagues, along with your foul-mouthed and defiant attitudes showing that you couldn't care less that the public's perception of the integrity of your 'profession' is diminishing rapidly, and IMO and IME, deservedly.

stairway · 01/03/2021 09:31

What I don’t understand OP is, why does it matter that more personal care in hospitals is now carried out by people called Healthcare assistants and not nurses. Why is a job name so important? It is much cheaper to train and employ people to do most of basic care work and then have fewer people to do the more complex work that requires degree level knowledge. Nurses should of course help out with all work when needed which most do when they have the time. Where I work everyone chips in, even the receptionist has helped feed patients when we have been overwhelmed. It is much nicer working on a ward without a blame culture where everyone helps each other out. Typically though it’s the bad wards where the good staff will leave because the working conditions are appalling.

Swipe left for the next trending thread