Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder WTF has happened to nursing “care” in our NHS?

536 replies

AnnieGetYourPun · 27/02/2021 16:31

And don’t tell me it’s all Covid/staff shortages/staff illness related.

My niece was eventually admitted to hospital after being sent home twice from A&E (in agony) and is now on a gynae ward. It’s just her and an elderly lady on the ward. The elderly lady was getting agitated as she needed the toilet. The nurse came and said, and I quote “it’s alright, use your pad and we’ll come and sort you out later”. This has really upset my niece who’s dodging sepsis now, on the ward, on massive IV antibiotics/anti-emetics and IV analgesia. She has narrowly avoided a ruptured uterus as there was no one to do a scan on her, after a 12 hr wait in A&E. She is 32.

Nurses now... all of ‘em have degrees. All dead clever. Very few of them have an ounce of “caring” in them.

Fry me on here. I’m past fucking caring.

Should add. I trained in the NHS. Was a student/junior staff nurse/senior staff nurse/junior sister and G grade senior sister before retirement. Never, in my f***g life have I seen such lack of basic care and maintenance of human dignity than I have witnessed in NHS hospitals, in the past two years.

Shove your clapping and rainbows.

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 03/03/2021 08:08

If the senior nurses bully the junior nurses and that's widespread, it's hardly surprising the nurses are rude and horrid to the patients really.

Midnightmusing · 02/03/2021 22:14

I forgot to add - probably one of the hardest things I find about nursing is that the general public thinks nurses are all a bit thick. That doesn’t endear patients to you.

Midnightmusing · 02/03/2021 22:07

It is easy to become disconnected from patients as a nurse. There is a lot of time pressure to complete tasks which is stressful in its own right and not something I have ever experienced to quite the same extent in office jobs. You are constantly interrupted which adds another layer of inefficiency and stress to the situation. You have fairly minimal autonomy and decision making ability but a lot of responsibility which is proven to reduce job satisfaction. The culture in some areas is very poor and no one helps one another/some people collude to undermine one person. The senior nurses in charge belittle inexperienced staff rather than educating them when they do not know or understand something. You often receive a rubbish handover so you are constantly chasing your tail trying to decipher frustratingly illegible hand written chart notes to find out what is going on. Most depressingly though, when you raise clinical concerns about a patient you are dismissed or even ridiculed by doctors/senior nurses. Complaining about these people is pointless. Lots of areas (geriatric, rehab etc) are dull to work in and you deskill there quickly. These are also the areas patients seem to have the most complaints about - I suppose they don’t attract the best staff?

I’d like to think I would never be cruel like some of the nurses described on here but I definitely don’t have the tolerance I used to have. When faced with a stroppy patient or relative I just don’t have it in me to suffer their abuse before we get to the bottom of their issue. Nursing is a hard slog. If care work was rewarding and straightforward we wouldn’t have masses of residential facilities for elderly people.

RosesAndHellebores · 02/03/2021 21:32

@Brainwave89 it means millions of others work every bit as hard as nurses and drs. Often without the overtime/extra shift payments of nurses. 50% of my staff many of whom earn about the same as nurses have had to take a pay cut due to covid. And not all nurses have been at the hard end during Covid. DD had a phone apt with her mh worker today. Our pharmacist took her bp and weight because the mh nurses and their staff are all presently working from home. Many of my staff are not.

Sadsiblingatsea · 02/03/2021 21:01

@doccybiscuits There is no link between intelligence and higher empathy as you suggest. Having a degree does not make a person kinder, lol.
What a ridiculous snobbish comment.

kneecapper · 02/03/2021 20:47

^Having been sent home from A&E twice in agony and disbelief they’re now considering emergency hysterectomy and Fallopian tube removal if she does not respond to the antibiotic treatment.

Disgrace^

And that’s the nursing staff’s fault how?

Brainwave89 · 02/03/2021 20:34

@RosesAndHellebores

Just like every other public sector employee *@brainwave89*. Those who work for the NHS render similar levels as everyone else.
Which means what exactly?
RosesAndHellebores · 02/03/2021 20:32

Just like every other public sector employee @brainwave89. Those who work for the NHS render similar levels as everyone else.

Brainwave89 · 02/03/2021 15:39

Both my sisters are nurses, and my son is a Doctor. Whilst noting that there are bad practitioners in every profession, I do not recognise your experience as being anything like the general patient experience. I cannot begin to describe how hard my sisters and son have worked over the last year. How emotionally draining it has been and how tired and scarred it has left them. Massive amount of unpaid work, very limited perks, very modest remuneration. All done out of a sense of duty and a real desire to help people. YABVU.

RosesAndHellebores · 02/03/2021 15:26

Sadly I think people remember the rudeness and heavy handedness delivered when they are vulnerable and it's hard to let it go. When ds had bronchiolitis as a baby and the staff were excellent I wrote to the CEO and sent biscuits but I haven't held onto it. However, the things that have been inappropriate and unkind have stayed with me. I could give many but for example when dd badly broke her leg in my mother's care (fell off her bicycle) and the ward sister laughed after I'd arrived and said in front of my mother "bet you won't be letting nanny look after her again ". So I had a frightened dd in pain to deal with and a mother with tears pricking in her eyes. How can a professional be so thoughtless and unkind? Regrettably it seems to happen time and time again.

I do think sensitivity and customer care need to start to form part of the training because too often it seems to be missing.

Babylonberlin · 02/03/2021 14:32

@albertcamus what's the solution then with this not fit for purpose
institution ? I don't expect an answer from you by the way. Obviously the OP has done a runner now and never engaged in worthwhile discussion regarding solutions anyway, just invited people to come forth with bad experiences and no counterbalance. Most of the nurses I work with are hard working and diligent, we have time to chat to rels and explain things. We have remarkably few complaints and poor practice is challenged quickly. Several staff members have been asked to leave over the >20 years I've worked there.
We have experienced and hands on managers who aren't afraid of making unpopular decisions which may explain why on the whole most are satisfied with our care. It's also a high status technologically advanced area of nursing,
full of life saving drama so has more cachet than a standard medical ward. Sad thing about this thread is the sheer negativity. People bringing up episodes from 20-30 years ago. Nurses seem to attract this weird dislike which other professions don't, apart from teaching, far from the lionisation which is entirely a media thing.

albertcamus · 02/03/2021 12:55

ChancesWhatChances that is absolutely shocking Flowers Flowers Flowers. I hope you feel more confident now.

This is why I get really angry when people naively say that 'more resources are needed"; what that nurse said to your newborn baby was NOTHING to do with money or resources, and everything to do with ignorant, uncaring and downright frightening individuals being employed by the NHS in power positions over vulnerable patients.

But it's apparently unacceptable for any of us to call this out. Ridiculous.

ChancesWhatChances · 02/03/2021 12:49

My newborn baby was told by a nurse, 3 hours after I’d given birth (wasn’t on the maternity ward, had been rushed into theatre straight after giving birth due to massive blood loss without even being able to hold him first) “your mum’s neglecting you already, maybe the nice social work will come and take you”. I couldn’t move. I couldn’t even sit up, DS was fast asleep and that comment knocked the wind out of me. I spent the first year of DS’s life floored with depression and anxiety because I thought I’d failed him in his first hours of life and I was convinced the social work were going to turn up and take him away. I ended up with postpartum OCD (that’s still present). I couldn’t even talk to my doctor or health visitor because I was so sure they’d call the social work and have him taken from me thanks to that nurse. I’d quite happily slap her stupid now. I’ll never forgive her the amount of damage she caused and the damage that’s still present because of her.

StormTreader · 02/03/2021 12:42

I've been in hospital twice with blood clots, so was on a respiratory ward for a week both times, totally mentally clear and the youngest patient there by a solid 50 years.

My experience both times was a clear "the patients can wait" attitude, in the first few days I genuinely thought I was going to wet myself because I wasn't allowed to go to the bathroom unaided and I had to stay in bed waiting for an hour while I could hear and see the nurses leaning around their desk, chatting away. I genuinely considered using the bell on a timed basis because I knew even though I didn't need to pee, I would by the time someone eventually came over.

In the last night when I was allowed to move around, I physically went over to the station after the woman next to me had been yelling for a nurse for over an hour and pointed out to them someone was waiting - they looked rather surprised to have their chatting and tea interrupted but no-one was getting any sleep!

FireflyRainbow · 02/03/2021 12:39

And this was on a child.

FireflyRainbow · 02/03/2021 12:38

Same situation this week for me apart from the organ did rupture and cause an infection. Sent home from a&e and out of hours drs before being rushed back in and them finding out. Apparently we dealt with a trainee at the weekend who MAY have made a mistake. Fuming.

albertcamus · 02/03/2021 12:06

ancientgran what the OP said she 'didn't fucking care' about was what she anticipated would be the self-righteous backlash from people like you who automatically spring to the defence of the (many) highly unprofessional, uncaring, undeserving but publicly-lionised employees of the NHS, she did NOT say she didn't care about patients, so please check your facts before posting.

You have throughout this thread shown an obsession with the mention of 'degree qualified nurses' and now claim that your son is a nurse ... I have repeatedly stated, as has the OP and other posters, that good and bad care are provided by NHS staff regardless of their qualification status. If anyone has a chip on their shoulder about qualifications, it is clearly you.

The atrocious recent and current experiences described on this thread by hundreds of people demonstrate that there is a serious and growing systemic problem within the NHS which has very little to do with funding and resources, and everything to do with SOME (once again, I emphasise, the minimum) staff clearly not caring for patients as they should do, and are supposedly trained and paid to do. This is not getting better, it is getting worse.

You appear to have missed my point that it is people like yourself who automatically defend these staff, and denigrate those who are brave enough to draw attention to them (which the OP is eminently qualified to do) who ARE the problem.

As long as people like yourself kowtow to all NHS staff and choose to live in denial of the unpalatable reality of the selfish, unprofessional and negligent attitudes of too many 'nurses', they will continue to get away with the behaviours amply described on this thread.

If you seriously think that the contemptuous attitudes of nurses described by hundreds of posters on this thread can be changed by an injection of 'resources', I would be fascinated to know how.

You are a naive, self-deluding apologist for a system which is not fit for purpose and fully illustrate why the problem is growing, leading so many people to live in fear of having to go into hospital.

ancientgran · 02/03/2021 11:17

@albertcamus

ancientgran One of the biggest reasons why many of the inappropriate, wasteful, uncaring, dangerous and incompetent practices which unnecessarily ruin the UK's NHS, as described by hundreds of posters on this thread, is the prevalence of ill-informed, judgemental, ignorant people such as yourself.

Who the hell do you think you are, after the OP (who was entirely justified in her disgust and concern about the appalling practice she has witnessed) has posted a reasoned, polite and balanced summary of the thread, to tell her she should be ashamed of herself?

Are you professionally qualified and experienced like her? Why do you object to her grieving over the state of the profession she served, which all of us rely on, pay for, deserve to be treated with dignity by, but cannot have confidence in.

You are clearly the kind of fool who thinks that banging a wooden spoon on a saucepan is helpful to the NHS.

Please realise how people of your level of ignorance and judgementalism of those who dare to challenge unacceptably low standards of 'care' are a large part of the problem.

Maybe read her OP where she doesn't fucking care.

In any organisation the size of the NHS there will be good and bad. I've made complaints to hospitals in the past, once about a doctor and once about a physio and that is what people should do if there is a problem.

What they shouldn't do is make allegations about nurses being worse now than in the past, not my experience but it might be for some but as a sweeping statement it isn't anything the oP or anyone else on here can prove. It is particularly unpleasant to make sarky remarks about nurses being worse being connected to them having degrees, shades of having a chip on her shoulder as they are better qualified than she was.

Finally, not that it is any of your business, but I have never clapped or banged saucepans for the NHS, my son is a nurse and hates it and says if you want a better service pay them properly and give them the equipment and facilities they need.

I think if it comes to ignorance you would give anyone a run for their money.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 02/03/2021 07:38

albertcamus - True, it’s easy to carry on providing poor care when no one complains. The NHS is supporting compassionate care through it’s values but in my experience and research shows that good care occurs when compassion is shown to patients and staff themselves. You can’t give when you are empty.

albertcamus · 01/03/2021 21:55

ancientgran One of the biggest reasons why many of the inappropriate, wasteful, uncaring, dangerous and incompetent practices which unnecessarily ruin the UK's NHS, as described by hundreds of posters on this thread, is the prevalence of ill-informed, judgemental, ignorant people such as yourself.

Who the hell do you think you are, after the OP (who was entirely justified in her disgust and concern about the appalling practice she has witnessed) has posted a reasoned, polite and balanced summary of the thread, to tell her she should be ashamed of herself?

Are you professionally qualified and experienced like her? Why do you object to her grieving over the state of the profession she served, which all of us rely on, pay for, deserve to be treated with dignity by, but cannot have confidence in.

You are clearly the kind of fool who thinks that banging a wooden spoon on a saucepan is helpful to the NHS.

Please realise how people of your level of ignorance and judgementalism of those who dare to challenge unacceptably low standards of 'care' are a large part of the problem.

8090sTv · 01/03/2021 21:54

I think a lot of the basic care is now provided by HCAs

This. I was in hospital for three weeks four years ago and definitely received care from HCAs as I got to know them and talked about their work. Things like taking my readings etc.

There were bits and bobs- being observed by student nurses when I felt they should have held my hand, delays in pain relief, but on the whole I have NO IDEA how they do it - 12 hour shifts etc. and am incredibly grateful.

There are channels to make a complaint which do work e.g. Patient Liaison.

Loustew12 · 01/03/2021 21:34

I reckon the answer is some nurses are incredibly caring. Some are awful. I've come across both.. Sometimes it's just your luck. I had a nurse drag me across a ward after a c-section for a walk saying 'I've not had kids but it can't be that hard' when I'd just had major surgery, my blood pressure was so low the alarms kept going off, I bled all over the floor and nearly passed out in the bathroom.. Other nurses have been lovely though. I intensely dislike the ones that should about how caring they are though Hmm

FeedMyFaceWithBattenberg · 01/03/2021 21:05

@AnnieGetYourPun

I didn’t say ALL NURSES didn’t care. Clearly some do. Read what I said in the OP. The training now requires a degree.

However, for all that study and high achievement, you can’t “teach” caring.

That is of course the debate. As you are aware lots and lots of the "day to day" care is left to HCAs now because nurses priorities and roles have changed. But... you can't recruit or retain good staff anywhere in healthcare. (i work in a hospice FWIW) Training is poor because the more experienced HCAs are burnt out, and as the old saying goes, if you pay peanuts you attract monkies!
FeedMyFaceWithBattenberg · 01/03/2021 20:55

@WhoWants2Know

It's quite common for a person to need two people to assist them to the toilet if they are unsteady on their feet. It's also common for people with a UTI to have a constant feeling of urgently needing to urinate, even if their bladder is empty.

It's a shame if your niece was upset, but she has no idea about the woman's needs or why the nurse didn't immediately assist her to the toilet.

With a nursing background, I would have thought you would understand that. But instead you decide to start a nurse bashing, goady thread...🤔

Absolutely this.
BrownEyedGirl80 · 01/03/2021 20:43

Didn't have a good experience in the maternity area of our hospital when I was having ds but other areas over the years have been great so I do think it's pot luck what type of person is caring for you at that time but on the whole the nurses I've had have been good.
The best treatment I've ever had was when I went private for an elected procedure but of course the hospital was much smaller so the staff seemed much more relaxed and happy tbh.