Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder WTF has happened to nursing “care” in our NHS?

536 replies

AnnieGetYourPun · 27/02/2021 16:31

And don’t tell me it’s all Covid/staff shortages/staff illness related.

My niece was eventually admitted to hospital after being sent home twice from A&E (in agony) and is now on a gynae ward. It’s just her and an elderly lady on the ward. The elderly lady was getting agitated as she needed the toilet. The nurse came and said, and I quote “it’s alright, use your pad and we’ll come and sort you out later”. This has really upset my niece who’s dodging sepsis now, on the ward, on massive IV antibiotics/anti-emetics and IV analgesia. She has narrowly avoided a ruptured uterus as there was no one to do a scan on her, after a 12 hr wait in A&E. She is 32.

Nurses now... all of ‘em have degrees. All dead clever. Very few of them have an ounce of “caring” in them.

Fry me on here. I’m past fucking caring.

Should add. I trained in the NHS. Was a student/junior staff nurse/senior staff nurse/junior sister and G grade senior sister before retirement. Never, in my f***g life have I seen such lack of basic care and maintenance of human dignity than I have witnessed in NHS hospitals, in the past two years.

Shove your clapping and rainbows.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OMG12 · 15/12/2022 11:10

Walkden · 15/12/2022 05:08

Sorry op but I think covid has a lot to do with it combined with staffing shortages / brexit and obviously lack of funding.

People in healthcare have been massively overworked the last 3 years, suffered massive moral injury, and at the end of day find that people will clap for them but their pay has been effectively cut for years and massively so this year.

Doing a degree doesn't remove compassion but 3 years being overworked then slapped in the face probably does.

This problem predates both Covid and Brexit though. I do think Covid very much played into the fantasy of nurses and doctors being some kind of untouchable heroes worshipped by the public.

You weren’t allowed to say anything about them. I had to go toA&E during the tail end of covid. My DH wasn’t allowed in even though I was unable to advocate. I saw one woman collapse and bang her head she was vulnerable and they wouldn’t allow her adult daughter to come in with her, a doctor actually walked round her whilst the cabin staff who were employed as meeters and greatest looked after her, I had to go and get a nurse who huffed and puffed.

I got such bad care I collapsed in a state of panic at one point only to be met with a nurse telling me I couldn't collapse there, standing over me demanding things. Eventually I tried running out the hospital as things were so bad (I had sat there listening to a doctor with a patient who had been mistakenly released a few days before with a broken hip calmly telling this poor chap if he refused the op they now decided he needed there was a good chance he’d die so better agree, others talking about how they hadn’t received treatment.

when I ran, I was chased by a nurse who only cared about me signing a form. I ended up collapsing in the middle of reception.

occasionally you will meet an amazing nurse, v rarely a doctor more commonly a HCP.

Greensky90 · 15/12/2022 10:16

sd249 · 27/02/2021 17:07

I was in hospital a few weeks ago and I saw exactly how lovely and caring the nurses were.

You don't know everything about a person - for example the lady next to me asked to go to the toilet all the time - but she had a catheter!! After many times they just told her it was ok to go, and this meant the lady was much more relaxed knowing that it was ok.

I can't do their job, I don't think I would even last an hour. They do an amazing job.

This

connie26 · 15/12/2022 05:47

I'm sorry about your niece but you cannot generalise. I've witnessed very poor care by nurses but also amazing care.

Walkden · 15/12/2022 05:08

Sorry op but I think covid has a lot to do with it combined with staffing shortages / brexit and obviously lack of funding.

People in healthcare have been massively overworked the last 3 years, suffered massive moral injury, and at the end of day find that people will clap for them but their pay has been effectively cut for years and massively so this year.

Doing a degree doesn't remove compassion but 3 years being overworked then slapped in the face probably does.

FeelWellEnoughToTellYou · 15/12/2022 05:05

Sympathy fatigue. It must be a very draining job. I have had terrible experiences also. With myself,DD and DM. YANBU

chaddydays · 15/12/2022 04:55

Sleepingdogs12 · 27/02/2021 17:06

To be honest how people in these roles maintain their compassion is a bit of a mystery to me rather than the other way around. It must be exhausting to work under constant pressure and traumatic to witness what is thrown at them. I wish they were better recognised for what they do and their well being looked after more so they can carry on performing their roles well. Really not a nice post op generalising from one incident.

If compassion is the first thing to go when you're under pressure and under stress, nursing is not for you. You shouldn't be a nurse if that's how you are! And yet so many are anyway.

I was a midwife for 6 years. Left because of the bullying culture between midwives! And the humiliation and 'laughs' I saw some have about vulnerable women. Disgusting. Yet my local hospital now has brilliant maternity care and all friends speak very well of the midwives they got

Zebedee55 · 15/12/2022 04:48

DH and I use the NHS quite a bit. He has been an inpatient quite a few times, and I'd say nurses are like many other public service professions.

Some are absolute stars, but some are so awful that you wonder why on earth they went into the profession to start with.

Some are aggressive, stroppy, uncaring and lazy.

A lot seem to forget that a few minutes of compassion can sometimes trump a ton of medicine and a nurse with a degree being able to operate machines.

At the moment, it feels like the NHS is just failing us in every way. GPs and hospitals.

I'm not blaming individual staff, but the whole thing needs root and branch reform. We throw billions at it, and nothing seems to help improve it much.

The police service where I live (London) is notoriously awful as well.

I feel sorry for those who are trying to do a good job, but are having to prop up the deadweights in their profession.🙁

GrimsbyOrangePippin · 15/12/2022 03:44

Just a lot of shrugging.

My recent experiences for both myself and with relatives tell me that this is far from uncommon. Far too much buck passing and disorganisation too. More nurses would do well to actually write and then read the notes for their patients. Some obviously are excellent and these nurses then end up doing EVEN more to make up for some of their colleagues short comings.

OMG12 · 15/12/2022 03:26

lovemelovemesaythatyouloveme · 14/12/2022 14:49

Are you having a ducking laugh?
The strike is anything but a joke.
I have not had a pay rise since I have been qualified (a decade in Feb) despite moving up to a senior level. Tell me how you think that's fair or just?

Well as nurses pay structure is by published bands something hasn’t been applied correctly in your case if you have moved between bands.

if you’re talking in relative rather than absolute terms and you’re factoring in inflation then you’re really no different to the vast majority of people in the UK (and actually the western world) so probably fair.

OMG12 · 14/12/2022 17:01

Ontheele · 14/12/2022 14:59

@OMG12 you need to have a hard long think about your own post for a START. Nurses save lives and police risk their lives. We work along side each other at times, let's not forget the prisoners who OFTEN attend hospitals for care. Its the NURSES and HCA to do the care, not the police.

What exactly do you do for a living yourself??

Why do I need to have a hard look at my post????

I really hope you’re not in the caring profession, or maybe you are a nurse and proving the point of the thread very well. You seem very aggressive. I have explained that workers within the NHS caused my ptsd yet you seem to think it’s appropriate to act in such an aggressive tone!!! You are only reinforcing everything I have experienced in the NHS. An inability to listen, demand for compliance, aggressively demanding information, inability to look at things from different angles. Wanting to be hero worshipped “ we save lives”. You know what? So do many others yet you don’t get them whining on. Quite frankly NHS workers made a damn good job at nearly killing me and my son so it’s hit and miss on that one too. Yet there is no apology without a fight, no responsibility. Caring more about how you feel than other people. Yep proves the point very well.

Ontheele · 14/12/2022 14:59

@OMG12 you need to have a hard long think about your own post for a START. Nurses save lives and police risk their lives. We work along side each other at times, let's not forget the prisoners who OFTEN attend hospitals for care. Its the NURSES and HCA to do the care, not the police.

What exactly do you do for a living yourself??

lovemelovemesaythatyouloveme · 14/12/2022 14:49

OMG12 · 14/12/2022 10:32

It’s impossible to generalise, there are still some incredibly caring nurses, but I think it’s becoming rarer and rarer. Although, to some extent this is a wider societal problem too.

But I see it home and time again, medical professionals with a God complex but more Old Testament God than New.

Poor midwifery and obstetrician care contributed heavily to My PTSD. The attitude of many medical professionals unfortunately triggers it repeatedly. However some are wonderful and caring and I can never thank them enough when I have a good experience in healthcare but this is the exception rather than the rule.

I did get v annoyed with the clap for our NHS (as they destroyed my life).

The Nurses strike for a pay rise is a joke. Look at starting salaries compared with average graduates and the police who actually risk their lives every shift, have to deal with the unthinkable etc.

Are you having a ducking laugh?
The strike is anything but a joke.
I have not had a pay rise since I have been qualified (a decade in Feb) despite moving up to a senior level. Tell me how you think that's fair or just?

Stompythedinosaur · 14/12/2022 12:26

Lemonlady22 · 14/12/2022 10:46

Degrees don’t make a good nurse either. Since nurses had to do degrees to qualify, medical science has increased, what you would have died from 20 years ago is not now the case, not sure what having a degree has to do with that to be honest.

When I hear the "nurses aren't better nurses for having degree level training" I always think that the person expressing that view might not really understand what nursing is.

Of course you don't need a degree to be caring. But nursing is not just a profession of making beds and being empathetic (though both those things are import). Nursing is a clinical role where a high level of clinical skill is required. Therefore training is very relevent. How do people imagine a nurse will assess a patient and know what to do without a high level of training?

Of courses nurses should be kind and caring, and my experience is that they mainly are, but there is a bit more to nursing than that.

shivbo2014 · 14/12/2022 10:46

Definitely not my experience. I was admitted last year after being bought in by wonderful paramedics, needed to stay in for 10 days and have a hysterectomy. The nurses were wonderful, as where the doctors and consultants. I suppose there are good and bad in every job. Also, people have bad days, stressful days upsetting days. It's not really fair to label all nurses.

Lemonlady22 · 14/12/2022 10:46

MonkeyPuddle · 27/02/2021 16:40

Degrees don’t make nurses less caring. No one says degree educated OT’s, SALT’s or PT’s are less caring, only ever nurses. Degree educated nurses reduce overall death rates on wards.

I’m sorry your niece and the other patient received poor care.

Degrees don’t make a good nurse either. Since nurses had to do degrees to qualify, medical science has increased, what you would have died from 20 years ago is not now the case, not sure what having a degree has to do with that to be honest.

Notanotherusername4321 · 14/12/2022 10:40

Blueemeraldagain · 27/02/2021 16:52

I was in hospital for a week recently (on a gynae ward as it happens) and would say it wasn’t that the nurses didn’t care, it was that they couldn’t care. Or at least they couldn’t care to the standard they wanted to. They were constantly rushed off their feet/understaffed and trying to juggle the varying need of the six patients in my room alone. Yes, there were times when I had to buzz more than once for help to go to the toilet or to refill my water jug but I never felt anything other than warmth and care from them.

I agree.

the massive issue with the nhs is there isn’t enough staff. Wards are considered “fully” staffed at unsustainable levels. E.g 4 m/w to a 32 bed ward is “fully staffed”. So not only have you 8 patients to every m/w, then you have one abstracted to theatre to assist with elcs/emcs, which leaves 3. Then you have no resilience for annual leave, sickness, maternity, emergency leave etc.

that’s why I left. Loved the job, pay was actually decent, but I couldn’t manage the workload and feel I’d done a good job, and although my colleagues and managers did their best, taking leave was a fucking nightmare, and nearly always left some poor sod working nights on their own.

more staff, then you’ll find nurses have time to “care”, and not just firefight trying to make sure no one dies.

OMG12 · 14/12/2022 10:32

It’s impossible to generalise, there are still some incredibly caring nurses, but I think it’s becoming rarer and rarer. Although, to some extent this is a wider societal problem too.

But I see it home and time again, medical professionals with a God complex but more Old Testament God than New.

Poor midwifery and obstetrician care contributed heavily to My PTSD. The attitude of many medical professionals unfortunately triggers it repeatedly. However some are wonderful and caring and I can never thank them enough when I have a good experience in healthcare but this is the exception rather than the rule.

I did get v annoyed with the clap for our NHS (as they destroyed my life).

The Nurses strike for a pay rise is a joke. Look at starting salaries compared with average graduates and the police who actually risk their lives every shift, have to deal with the unthinkable etc.

MissTrip82 · 14/12/2022 10:05

‘Dodging’ sepsis and almost had a ruptured uterus because of a delayed scan?

hmmmmm.

I wish more people were dead clever.

faffadoodledo · 14/12/2022 09:58

And then there was the community nurse who came and checked me 10 days after giving birth. And declared 'you'll never be a girl again' after surveying my stitches. And it wasn't said kindly!
She was definitely old school!
But I think that's the problem - the bad stories really do stick.

faffadoodledo · 14/12/2022 09:48

I should add that the petty tyrant was of an age who would have trained in the 1980s.
The staff in the bigger hospital would have had degrees for sure. And were infinitely better. But that's not really a reliable correlation!

faffadoodledo · 14/12/2022 09:47

Mum and dad both died earlier this year so we've been in and out of hospitals for the last five years prior. Some was under covid restrictions so we weren't allowed in.
We've seen both extremes and everything in between. The worst was from one particular small hospital where the ward sister was what I can only describe as evil. Both mum and dad deteriorated on that ward. We should have put in formal complaints but when you're in the thick of it you don't have the headspace.
Elsewhere, in the larger 'county' hospital we encountered literal angels.
In the community it was hit and miss.

Odessafile · 12/12/2022 06:20

@Sanguinesuzy good comment.

lovemelovemesaythatyouloveme · 12/12/2022 06:06

Lots of chat here about a nursing strike... and now they are striking!

LoveFall · 30/05/2021 23:30

I think ward culture is huge. My (5 bed) room was right across from the nursing station and I heard non-stop talking and laughing all day and night. I am sure that had something to do with the lack of empathy. They only talked to each other, not the patients except as necessary. My attempts at conversation and relating to the bully were futile and just gave her more ammunition.

Sanguinesuzy · 30/05/2021 21:35

Agree re ward culture. If the ward manager aka sister/charge nurse has a bullying manner, lacks empathy etc you can bet your bottom dollar that will filter down to other staff members and some will take advantage of it. Likewise if a ward is chronically understaffed, care is inevitably affected, bad habits and short cuts become ingrained simply to get the work done. So much emphasis is placed on bl*y tickboxes to prove the work has been done, the patient gets neglected Hmm. Hence nurses spending hours sat in front of computer screens documenting that they've turned their patient 2 hourly yet not having the time to engage properly with the actual patient in front of them.