Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

22 year old business/mindset coach - AIBU

109 replies

2021namechanges · 25/02/2021 17:43

Have been looking around for a business coach recently. In my investigations I’ve come across some guy who is 22 years old - and from what I can tell - the only business he’s ever “built is the fucking coaching business he’s trying to flog.

Now I may be getting old (am 38) but Aibu to say that quite frankly this is fucking ridiculous. Along the way I’ve found coaches that have also set up and when I take a look at their LinkedIn profiles - in the nicest way - their jobs before will be along the lines of “recruitment agent”, or “PA” - again nowt wrong with this - but being a business advisor - sorry no

I do get that you can retrain but Aibu to say this is absolute nonsense

OP posts:
terrywynne · 26/02/2021 12:48

@idontlikealdi

Why is this all over mn in the last couple of days, have I missed something?!

It's all a load of bullshit anyway.

Because they seem to be proliferating due to Covid. There are a lot of promises of high salaries and glamourous insta friendly lifestyle. Who wouldn't want that when you've seen your employment options decimated (as a pp said the young coaches thing does partly reflect a lack of opportunities for young people at the moment) and have been stuck at home for months?
GeordieGreigsButtButtZoom · 26/02/2021 12:44

The only skill I could see she had in the time we worked together was self promotion.

And that's a skill...some people could do with learning it.

idontlikealdi · 26/02/2021 12:40

Why is this all over mn in the last couple of days, have I missed something?!

It's all a load of bullshit anyway.

Angrymum22 · 26/02/2021 12:36

Slight tangent.
Why do pp insist on using the phrase ‘like comparing apples and oranges’. Biologically they are identical, the seed carrying part of a plant. The difference is purely visual. A better phrase would be ‘like comparing apples and light bulbs’.
Sorry I just find it really annoying.

Catscakeandchocolate · 26/02/2021 12:10

I had the great misfortune of working with a woman who had a side business in coaching. She was lazy, sneaky, backstabbing and just shit at her job. Couldn't deliver anything, let everyone down, blamed anyone she could for her failures and pissed off senior stakeholders so she was let go. She keeps bouncing from job to job in our industry but coaches people on how to succeed in the industry. It blows my mind how anyone hires her and how she actualy has the guts to hold herself out as an expert. The only skill I could see she had in the time we worked together was self promotion.

Shinyletsbebadguys · 26/02/2021 11:59

The concept of life coach is ridiculous in itself and nowhere close to being a business or management mentor or consultant.

Read Sartre , Nietzsche, Marcus Aurelius ...any number of philosophers / thinkers will help a mindset (mix and match to what works for you) rather than a 22 year old with no experience.

Shinyletsbebadguys · 26/02/2021 11:58

This sort of thing makes me roll my eyes. I actually do / did some freelance consultancy. It took me 22 years of high level industry specific management experience experience , an industry specific management qualification, the training and qualifications to then teach that qualification , decades of training experience , publishing books on my industry. That's what qualifies me to be a good management coach in my industry (and no I am not affiliated with any stupid MLM I did / do it through my own back). I had the professional contacts and standing to be able to advise my industries managers . I've owned my own business in the industry (most importantly I've failed and picked myself back up and succeeded again).

Being 22 I physically couldn't have had enough experience to do it. It annoys me that people claim these jobs and aren't even close to the real deal.

Emmelina · 26/02/2021 11:53

They’re all over Facebook at the moment - I think it must be a new MLM thing.

Sahm101 · 26/02/2021 11:49

Life coach is just another nonsense made up course that people are trying to promote as an actual career. Why would anyone trust or take advise from someone who has done a few courses?

GeordieGreigsButtButtZoom · 26/02/2021 11:33

Perhaps it's a sign of how few opportunities there are out there for young people.

Shetoshe · 26/02/2021 11:26

I know someone who’s daughter aged mid 20’s is advertising as a life coach , Reiki healer and herbalist.

I know someone like this too although she's in her 30's and has actually worked in a professional role before all the this mumbo jumbo started. She's a lovely girl but completely batshit and absolutely not in a position to be anyone's "life coach"!

terrywynne · 26/02/2021 10:51

Based on OPs description, this coach would seem to belong to a particular subset of life/mindset/success/business coach that has flourished recently. Hallmarks are a very broad net that they will coach (multiple industries, multiple areas of your life), a tendency to talk about 4/5 figure income months and manifestation, and a lack of evidence of any expertise to qualify them to help you. At best they peddle banal content templates for your business, generic mindset leaflets. They mostly want you to sign up for expensive programmes of the back of these. At worst they are advertising to coach other people to coach (And then coach coaches to coach coaches).

So, no age isn't a barrier to having expertise but it is often a clue that the person may be one of the above types of coaches. I have come across teenagers who can claim that they are success coaches in lifestyle, fitness, health and business. I mean really, in your teens??? That is different from someone in their early 20s who has a proven business that they made a success of in a particular field, offering coaching on how to grow in that particular field or using a particular method.

If you haven't come across the former type of 'coach yet, count yourself lucky!

Sittingonabench · 26/02/2021 10:33

Different people/businesses have different needs. While this persons experience/skill set may not be for you, it may be of assistance to someone else.

Macaronirabbit · 26/02/2021 10:10

OMG yes! Or similarly, I know of at least two men who were TERRIBLE headmasters of independent schools and are now working as consultants for the sector as well as school inspectors. If they turned up to consult I would have to walk out.

In my DCs experience there have been 2 head teachers who seemed unsuited to public facing roles. The first one seemed quite abrupt, borderline rude and didnt appear to like speaking to parents (or children!) at all. The current one is virtually mute (no idea how he is with children). He sat in on a performance the children did to parents, when he had newly joined the school. I felt sure he would congratulate the children and introduce himself to parents. He did neither, nor did he greet parents afterwards. in meetings its glaringly obvious he barely contributes, even when a question is directly addressed to him.

CounsellorTroi · 26/02/2021 09:59

23 year old neuro surgeon - that is simply not possible. It takes about 14 years, including medical school, to train as a surgeon.

TheVanguardSix · 26/02/2021 09:57

A 23 year old neuro surgeon saved my relatives life as well. It was fairly odd meeting him before the op as we thought he was very young, but he did his job (with an older consultant and entire team of staff)

You're talking about a medical student in training, not a qualified neurosurgeon at 23. That doesn't happen here. Let's not Doogie Howser this.

TheVanguardSix · 26/02/2021 09:53

The thing about using Richard Branson as an example or young adults off The Apprentice is that these people aren't telling you how to manage your life or maximise your potential, they're establishing themselves, gaining experience, learning, and setting personal goals... in other words, they're working on them.

It reminds me of the time my green 17-year-old cousin gave me parenting tips for me then 5 year old (I was 34). I mean, you wouldn't take it on board would you? I didn't! Confused

You live it, you learn it. And those are the people you listen to.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 26/02/2021 09:47

Oh

TheVanguardSix · 26/02/2021 09:47

I see your point, but as far as a young surgeon goes, the doctor who very literally saved my child's life when she was born, was 23.

You don't become a surgeon until 36. Confused

SchrodingersImmigrant · 26/02/2021 09:47

Could he go and advice other hospitals on how to run their teams though?

MrsPinkCock · 26/02/2021 09:40

[quote imalmostthere]@2021namechanges
I see your point, but as far as a young surgeon goes, the doctor who very literally saved my child's life when she was born, was 23. I owe her everything. I think it very much depends on the individual. I also think berating someone trying to make a living in this climate, solely based on age, is harsh. I hope he proves everyone wrong 😊[/quote]
I agree with you here! A 23 year old neuro surgeon saved my relatives life as well. It was fairly odd meeting him before the op as we thought he was very young, but he did his job (with an older consultant and entire team of staff) and did it well. Age isn’t always everything.

TonightMatthew · 26/02/2021 09:28

I do think it's a bit unreasonable to judge someone's skill based purely on age. And the comparison with a surgeon is comparing apples and oranges.

OK maybe he doesn't offer you what you want but it doesn't automatically make him crap at his job. Just look for someone else who will offer you what you want. If you want someone with decades of experience in a particular field that's fine. Other people might be looking for something else in a coach - a youthful spark and energy, the latest knowledge straight from training, cutting edge social media/internet presence or whatever. Maybe he can offer those things? Who knows.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 26/02/2021 09:08

Still, a savvy person of that age now might still have monetised a website or social media channel, or started a small business.

Yeah. There are 12 year olds making more money on youtube than my dh and I together 😂

On a serious note. Can they really though advise a business on their expansion etc really well (not the 12 year olds lol)?
Think about it this way. Would you go and pay someone with much less experience than you to advise you which route might be best to take?

Imagine you've been gardening last 5, 6 years. You want to take it further and maybe build a glasshouse and move onto some more difficult plants. Would you
-ask someone with less practical gardening experience or
-would you ask someone who did it number of times and knows in and outs of it well

It's nothing personal. But it's a fact of life that 22 year old will simply has less experience than someone who was expanding businesses for last 20 years. The former can have good ideas, bit the latter has track record. Since this is about business, a livelihood, not a hobby, I think it's absolutely understandable people will look for the "best" option

GeordieGreigsButtButtZoom · 26/02/2021 08:22

They did start work at 16 iirc.

Yeah, you're right that it was a different world. Still, a savvy person of that age now might still have monetised a website or social media channel, or started a small business.

I'm certainly not saying anyone who hasn't done that by 22 is lost, it's a very young age. Just saying that I wouldn't disregard someone purely based on it if they did have as much of a track record as someone that young could have, because it's still likely to be better than mine.

Business acumen does seem to be something that people are kind of born with, but maybe I'm just showing how little I know about it by saying that! I'm not business minded at all.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 26/02/2021 08:09

@GeordieGreigsButtButtZoom

I'm shit at this kind of thing and I've no reason to think a 22 year old wouldn't be better. Would need to see a bit of track record, though. The ones on The Apprentice have usually got something. Alan Sugar and Richard Branson were once 22.
Yeah they were, but I am not sure how many businesses they could have advised on future route at that point tbh. Thoigh their 22 was different to today's graduate's 22. They did start work at 16 iirc.