Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

22 year old business/mindset coach - AIBU

109 replies

2021namechanges · 25/02/2021 17:43

Have been looking around for a business coach recently. In my investigations I’ve come across some guy who is 22 years old - and from what I can tell - the only business he’s ever “built is the fucking coaching business he’s trying to flog.

Now I may be getting old (am 38) but Aibu to say that quite frankly this is fucking ridiculous. Along the way I’ve found coaches that have also set up and when I take a look at their LinkedIn profiles - in the nicest way - their jobs before will be along the lines of “recruitment agent”, or “PA” - again nowt wrong with this - but being a business advisor - sorry no

I do get that you can retrain but Aibu to say this is absolute nonsense

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Loopytiles · 12/03/2022 15:02

Think that went on much longer than the 90s thinwomansbrain! ‘Business support’ services.

ThinWomansBrain · 12/03/2022 14:15

Does anyone remember the godawful govt scheme in the 90's? I cant remember what it was called - Business Link maybe, but govt paid (or poss part paid) for "business coaches" for SMEs. We had a succession of boring twats about to retire with no ability to listen or "adapt" solutions to the business they were being paid to advise.
Agree a 22 year ond with no business experience is probably a waste of space, but age brings no guarantees.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/03/2022 14:12

[quote imalmostthere]@2021namechanges
I see your point, but as far as a young surgeon goes, the doctor who very literally saved my child's life when she was born, was 23. I owe her everything. I think it very much depends on the individual. I also think berating someone trying to make a living in this climate, solely based on age, is harsh. I hope he proves everyone wrong 😊[/quote]
Yes, but your 23 year old doctor didn't get her knowledge and qualifications doing an online course and go straight into operating without ever having seen the inside of an operating theatre before, figuring that her positive mindset and talking a good talk will ensure the survival of your newborn.

Loopytiles · 12/03/2022 14:02

This reminds me of my unease about management consultancy as a career option for people without other experience.

Entirely · 12/03/2022 14:00

I think 22 is stretching credulity.

I do know a 25 year old who has built up a significant property development, renovations and investment business. He did it himself from scratch, working away since the age of 16, tapping into expertise of other people etc.

He now owns a couple of companies and is reasonably wealthy and has a lot of insights and really interesting info. What he’s achieved is amazing actually. I’m a lot older than him but learn loads listening to him. I’m tempted to give property a go myself!

Thatsnotmygame · 12/03/2022 13:48

Also know someone else who is a life coach, has paid £10000s to ‘train’, of course has their own life coach. She is doing as she doesn't want to pay for childcare and wants to ear £50,000 a yearGrin She is now selling her house and moving somewhere cheaper and continuing to earn less that £1k and year and her own life is questionable

AchillesHeelys · 12/03/2022 12:19

I think YABU actually OP and conflating advising with coaching. A good coach shouldn’t be giving any advice, they should be guiding you to draw on your own knowledge and experience (not theirs!) to make decisions. Good coaching requires an ability to listen well, to reflect back what someone is saying, to ask open questions, etc. There are plenty of younger people who have these skills, he may or may not be one of them, but you can’t tell from his age alone.

I’ve seen plenty of experienced leaders go into coaching after partial retirement but actually be a bit crap at it because they can’t resist advising and telling others what to do, rather than supporting their clients to figure out the answer for themselves.

The best coaches I know don’t have a business/leadership background themselves, their profession is coaching.

Greengagesnfennel · 12/03/2022 12:07

The people you really need are probably running businesses of their own. Have you tried networking in professional entrepreneur groups in your business area? These are really helpful and often pair you up with someone who has experience of the particular point in your business path that you want some advice with. So if you are thinking about how to expand into us market for eg they pair you up for a chat with someone who has done just that. People are very generous. You're not going to get lots of 'sessions' It's usually free, and they are busy, but a couple of coffee chats are going to be worth 10000x 22 yo coaching sessions...Also going to their group networking events - you can pick up a lot just chatting and listening.

MarshmallowSwede · 12/03/2022 12:07

I wouldn’t take career advice from a 23 yr old without significant career experience themselves. I wouldn’t take any advice from a 23 yr old in general. Most people aren’t qualified to lead themselves let alone anyone else.

Hoppinggreen · 12/03/2022 11:45

I am an actual Business Mentor
I have 17 years experience of doing this as well as experience before that in large Corporates. I have also started several Businesses of my own and helped others taking their a Business to exit
This new “Business Coach” phenomenon pisses me right off. It’s basically an MLM scheme for people who know nothing about Business

Luredbyapomegranate · 12/03/2022 11:40

Yes, it’s hilarious obviously but I think all these jobs need to be regulated -

SingToTheSky · 12/03/2022 11:14

That’s hilarious. It’s normal for people that age to think they know/have experienced it all. But they haven’t. It’s just part of growing up!

I remember being most put out that, when I applied for A levels at college, I was too young to do a counselling qualification - you had to be 24 to study it. I certainly had more experience of MH stuff than many other 18 year olds (various diagnoses, psych hospital, abuse etc) but looking back I can see I absolutely did lack the “life experience” on a wider scale!

Laughing at the life coach MLM bot who still needs mum to get her out of bed and wash her clothes :o

Thatsnotmygame · 12/03/2022 10:34

I know someone who runs a very successful business and has just started coaching in that field. I would use her for that. However shes also ‘qualified’ as a life coach, which is bullshit plums her own oersonal life is a car crash.

majesticallyawkward · 27/02/2021 07:20

[quote poorbuthappy]@majesticallyawkward - I saw SH and he was all about mood hoovers and how to deal with them etc etc. I remember asking how to deal with it when the person simply wouldn't engage / listen to you. He told me to repeat their name to them until they listened to you.
Sounds great in a bloody room conference room, doesn't necessarily work in practice.
I remember thinking - christ have you got kids??? Grin[/quote]
I mean, my kids use that tactic 'mum mum mum mum mum mum MUUUM MUUUUUUUUUM' not sure it would the same affect in the workplace 😂

GeordieGreigsButtButtZoom · 26/02/2021 20:28

It's x-factor generation. The idea that it's easy to get up, make a speech or a plan, and you are a millionaire.

Plenty of deluded older people on those crap singing programmes. Probably more deluded than the younger ones. You could be forgiven for thinking you can be a pop star even if you can't sing, as long as you've got youth and good looks; God knows that covers enough of the earbleeders in the charts who are clearly supposed to be performing on mute.

therealteamdebbie · 26/02/2021 20:19

No one will ever beat David Brent Grin

2021namechanges · 26/02/2021 18:07

@AtTheBeginning

If your business is over 5 years old do you meet the requirements to apply for the Goldman Sachs 10k small business programme? It is fantastic, they really help you look at and understand your business and come up with a plan and it’s free if they accept you. I have a business coach, she’s fantastic - she’s worked in business for about 40 years, built up various businesses of her own and at her peak of her career was CEO of a business she had grown to over 2,000 staff. She just does coaching now, I don’t know if she has any space but PM me if you’re interested (she charges £125 an hour and I see her now and then when I have something to discuss rather than on a monthly retainer). Otherwise you could look at Action Coach but be really fussy with who you choose as they are a franchise but there are some experienced business owners that run them after they have sold their business.
Thank you - this sounds more like it!
OP posts:
therealteamdebbie · 26/02/2021 17:58

It's the x-factor generation. The idea that it's easy to get up, make a speech or a plan, and you are a millionaire.

Reinforced by the "working hard is not enough, doesn't bring you anywhere bladibla"

See how far it brings them.

Age in itself is far from everything, but not being able to find decent background to justify your "coach" role means this one 22 year old is nowhere near experienced Grin

Pukkatea · 26/02/2021 17:46

Next there will be a post on how chalk and cheese are quite similar, actually.

TonightMatthew · 26/02/2021 17:14

Why do pp insist on using the phrase ‘like comparing apples and oranges’. Biologically they are identical, the seed carrying part of a plant. The difference is purely visual. A better phrase would be ‘like comparing apples and light bulbs’.
Sorry I just find it really annoying

That was me.

People say it as it's a well-recognised phrase, and the whole point is that although they both fall into the same category (ie types of fruit) you would never mistake one for the other.

Training as a life coach and training as a surgeon. Both training for a job but you would never mistake one for the other.

Comparing apples and lightbulbs doesn't work because they have entirely different purposes, they are completely different beasts.

I've seen people get het up about a lot on MN but this really takes the biscuit (not sorry)

SeldomFollowedIt · 26/02/2021 16:23

I know of a few of these “coaches” and I do agree OP. I know of one professional one who works in London but he does not refer to himself as a coach, rather a transformationalist. He does very well for himself.
Each to their own I guess but if I was truly on the path to a better self, I think I would invest in proper evidence based therapy.

NancyPickford · 26/02/2021 16:16

@MrsPinkCock - as others have said, that is simply impossible.

poorbuthappy · 26/02/2021 13:27

@majesticallyawkward - I saw SH and he was all about mood hoovers and how to deal with them etc etc. I remember asking how to deal with it when the person simply wouldn't engage / listen to you. He told me to repeat their name to them until they listened to you.
Sounds great in a bloody room conference room, doesn't necessarily work in practice.
I remember thinking - christ have you got kids??? Grin

majesticallyawkward · 26/02/2021 13:16

@poorbuthappy I don't think so although blocked out most of it. I wish I could remember the name of his book... I think he's written one for kids too.
He gave away a tshirt as part of it. Singled out the only person who had engaged with him and gave her a bright yellow tshirt. The rest of wanted to applaud the very senior guy who halfway through announced 'this is shit' and left 😂

poorbuthappy · 26/02/2021 12:49

@majesticallyawkward

At 22, with no experience there can't be much backup to actually coach anything. The only coaches I've ever met who were actually good and worth the time and money are from one company, all 40+ and most ex-military. Just amazing lives they've led and truly inspiring people but able to hold the attention of a room with no effort.

On the flip side... one 'coach'/mindset/motivational whatever I had to sit through was a 50-something man who stood for an hour and said 'you're all mood hoovers, everyone is shit and you'll never be a deserving 2%-er' (2%-er being part of his theory only 2% of people are actually happy and so worthy of life). He's written a book... I imagine some of these set starting people are reading shit like that and spouting it.

@majesticallyawkward - were his initials SH?
Swipe left for the next trending thread