Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £26.50/hour for weeding is insanity?

494 replies

LaBellySausage · 21/02/2021 19:54

I'm looking for someone to come around for 3 hours/week to help with weeding the garden.

I was given a couple of names of local people who do gardening. I expected to pay somewhere between £10-12/hour, perhaps £15/hour if the person was an experienced gardener. I believe minimum wage is £8something but I don't think people can live on that.

The first person wouldn't give a quote til they came to view the garden and then was hesitant to give an hourly rate, preferring to give a rate for 'the job'. It's not a job that can be finished- it's like when I shave my legs the bastards on the other one have started growing back when I start the second. I just want a few weeds less per week. He eventually said £18/hour. I thanked him for his time but said it was a bit more than I had budgeted. The second guy said £26.50/hour!

This is simple weeding. Trowel and hoe provided. £26.50/hour is about £55,000 annually.

I worked jobs like this while in uni at minimum wage. For reference, we live in a very inexpensive part of the country- he would not be weeding Chelsea Flower Show. Both candidates were local so didn't have more than a 5/10 minute drive.

Am I being unreasonable, or is this a crazy rate?

OP posts:
Heavymetaldetector · 21/02/2021 21:22

Gardeners have a flat hourly rate - so whether it is weeding or other gardening work it will be the same. Your neurosurgen/cleaner analogy isn't the same thing is it? If you want two hours of my husband's time it's £20 an hour. If you don't want to pay that that's fine but you can't complain about how much people do or don't charge - that is their choice and their business, not yours.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 21/02/2021 21:22

Depends what you class as weeding and what the weeds are. Dandelion in the lawn, dock and thistle are a bugger to get out. What's your soil like, horrible hard clay full of stones or good quality easy to dig. Are you wanting every visible weed gone from a border and lawn edges trimmed or do you just want a border cleared so you can start again.
Personally I'd pay whatever to get it to the standard you want then cut them back to once a month and you just keep on top if mowing the lawn.

Beecham · 21/02/2021 21:21

I pay £25 p/h for experienced gardeners (South East). They know the difference between a weed and a perennial. They prune shrubs and trees at the correct time of year, and they're very knowledgeable.

But I once had someone inexperienced in to weed and they pulled out all my giant nepeta, roots and all. They look a bit like nettles before flowering so I can see why he made the mistake. But it goes to show you get what you pay for.

Motherofgirl · 21/02/2021 21:21

Those rates are insane. I would expect it to be minimum wage or a little above (because it's back-breaking work). Plenty of people who do jobs that require a degree and professional experience are paid far far less than that.
I think you need to look for a local person who wants to make a bit of money, perhaps a teenager, not a professional gardener.

Juo · 21/02/2021 21:20

Every one saying you don't need a gardener just a labourer, they need to know which are weeds. My "gardener" cuts the grass and will do heavy work but hasn't the first idea about gardening and doesn't know a weed from a rose. He was charging £12 an hour but has just increased it to £15. Cheap part of UK.

Mrgrinch · 21/02/2021 21:20

I'd post on your local community Facebook group if possible.

catsmother · 21/02/2021 21:19

I'm bemused by how many people are blithely suggesting 'anyone' can weed, or, think a typical teenager would be able to do the job well. I mean, if you wanted a bed totally cleared of everything - fine. But I really wouldn't be happy to let 'anyone' (without plant knowledge) loose on my garden, especially this time of year and once Spring gets going, when so many plants are only just starting to emerge - and wouldn't necessarily look established to the untrained eye. You've got all sorts of bulbs poking through, perennials which could have died back completely and might still look pretty grotty right now. Then you may well have any number of seedlings from plants that have self seeded .... you'd first need to identify that these weren't stereotypical weeds, but also be aware of course that any unwanted plant in the wrong spot is effectively a weed so you can approach your client and let them know you've found loads of baby foxgloves, nigella or lady's mantle or whatever and should they be left, thinned or removed. As for classic weeds, again, 'anyone' probably wouldn't know how to get rid most effectively ..... digging out as much bindweed root as possible and taking care not to leave even tiny bits on top of the soil that'll sprout into new plants, going really deep to get dandelion roots out and so on.

I'd say all that is a skill worth paying for if you want the job done properly.

MiddlesexGirl · 21/02/2021 21:18

Gardening, as pp have pointed out, is seasonal. Gardeners can only work for eight months of the year.

Not true. The only time our gardeners don't come is when it is snowy. Which is also coincidentally when the cleaner doesn't come.

SoulofanAggron · 21/02/2021 21:18

why would they quote less than they are worth? They set their own rates and that is what they can charge. If they are a busy person, why they would turn down more lucrative gardening work to weed for someone?

@PracticingPerson It's not a skilled job.

@LaBellySausage I don't think you need look for 'a gardener' if that means you get charged what is not appropriate for the level of skill and experience this job requires (virtually none- just the commmon sense not to dig up something that's not a weed.)

I'd post an ad saying you're 'looking for someone to do some weeding.' Post what you want to pay in the ad and I'm sure you'll find someone willing to do it. I would do it.

SlipperyLizard · 21/02/2021 21:17

DH is a handyman, his hourly rate is £30 per hour whether he’s fixing a toilet or putting a nail in a wall for a picture. He’d do weeding if you asked, but it would still be £30 an hour, as that’s what he can sell his time for to the many other people who want his services.

I expect the gardeners you have spoken to are the same - they have plenty of people who will pay them, they don’t need to work for you for less.

Ifionlyknewthenwhatiknownow3 · 21/02/2021 21:15

Could you pay a babysitter for an hour or two instead and go out and enjoy doing your own gardening?
Nothing more satisfying than a lovely tidy border, fresh air and exercise.

chomalungma · 21/02/2021 21:13

People can charge what they like for a job.

Whether that works depends on the market conditions.

Plus the person themselves - they could charge less because they don't need as much money.

e.g. a retired person with a mortgage paid off, and a pension could charge a lot less than someone who lives by themselves, has children and has to pay a mortgage etc.

BackforGood · 21/02/2021 21:13

If you charged minimum wage as a self-employed worker, you'd probably end up taking home around £5-6 an hour once all your costs were taken into an account.

If one of my dc, or dn or any of their friends that have lost their employment in pubs, leisure, retail, cafes etc over the last year accept a job in a local area that is paying NMW, then they will take home NMW.
I mean, OP is offering considerably more than NMW, but I'm not sure what costs you are referring to.

She ISN'T wanting a gardener. I have a gardener. I understand they have to buy a van, insure and maintain it. Buy and maintain tools. Pay for disposal of garden rubbish, etc etc etc, but that is NOT what the OP is looking for, so how can the person not end up with what they are paid ? Confused

SoulofanAggron · 21/02/2021 21:13

YANBU, I would keep hunting. You could ask on Gumtree or something.

fabulousspider · 21/02/2021 21:12

bear in mind these people have no holiday or sick pay, no national insurance paid by work etc. etc - so actually the hourly rate they receive is probably rather less than you think once these things are taken into consideration.

PracticingPerson · 21/02/2021 21:12

@saraclara

My gardener mows the lawn, weeds, prunes stuff back etc, and charges £14 an hour. The job's done properly, he has a proper van and he takes all the waste away. I can't believe someone is trying to charge nearly double that. And my area isn't cheap.
Surely you can believe someone is quoting double!

Either they will get the work at a good rate, or they won't, but why would they quote less than they are worth? They set their own rates and that is what they can charge.

If they are a busy person, why they would turn down more lucrative gardening work to weed for someone?

LakieLady · 21/02/2021 21:11

My DSS charges £20ph for gardening, considerably more for tree work (he's a qualified tree surgeon). This is in Sussex.

VinylDetective · 21/02/2021 21:10

[quote LaBellySausage]@VinylDetective what is the going rate and where do you live? Because I live in the NE where the average house costs £126,000. The average house in the SE costs £320,000. I'm not running some victorian workhouse. I don't understand the animosity.[/quote]
£20 an hour, E England. You’re not getting animosity. You’re getting a reaction from someone who thinks you either pay the going rate for the job or do it yourself. And hates exploitation.

House prices have zero relevance.

C152 · 21/02/2021 21:10

I think YABU, particularly if you want an experienced gardener for only £15/hr.

saraclara · 21/02/2021 21:08

My gardener mows the lawn, weeds, prunes stuff back etc, and charges £14 an hour. The job's done properly, he has a proper van and he takes all the waste away. I can't believe someone is trying to charge nearly double that. And my area isn't cheap.

homeschoolingyay · 21/02/2021 21:08

There're gardeners who are qualified, turn up in a van, with their own tools, and get a hell of a lot done in a day. They are worth £26.50ph at the very least.

Then there is Fred (*other names are available) from down the road who hasn't a clue, but has seen people turn up at other people's houses and get a good wage for gardening, and thinks he can do that just as well (he can't). You'll probably find Fred advertising in the local post office or news agent. He'll be able to fit you in straight away (good gardeners won't, they'll be booked up well in advance over the growing season). Fred will charge you £12.50, or £15 if he thinks you look rich or gullible, or both.

For a bit of weeding Fred will be fine, but go out there with him, and be specific about what you want left, or when he's finished you'll have a lovely tidy bare strip of garden with not a weed (or plant) in sight.

I employed a gardener for a big one off job, he did an amazing job very quickly. I've also employed a Fred. He worked out more expensive per hour as he did very little, very slowly.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 21/02/2021 21:08

AppleKatie

Virtually all of the comments about the gardeners worth and overheads etc can also be applied to cleaners. Whilst they are true society only cares about the jobs traditionally done by men.

*No they can’t. Cleaning isn’t seasonal, it doesn’t involve being out in all weathers and the client supplies the tools.

My gardener’s a woman, by the way and she charges the going rate.*

This.
A lot of people on here are being a bit thick, or deliberately obtuse. The same people who would be horrified at being paid less than minimum wage I suspect Hmm

BettysButtons · 21/02/2021 21:08

@killickthere

gardeners work about 8 months a year. they have to earn12 months income in 8 months.
Not mine. He does hard landscaping in the winter months. Garden maintenance the rest of the year.
LastTrainEast · 21/02/2021 21:07

@Greenmarmalade

Mine are.

I cannot believe anyone would pay over a tenner an hour for weeding. I’d do it for minimum wage- it’s just weeding and it’s nice to be outdoors most of the spring and summer too.

But you'd have to do it instead of your real job. People are not doing it as a hobby. They have to pay their mortgage out of it.
SadderThanEeyore · 21/02/2021 21:07

You can't equate minimum wage to self employed. Minimum wage is for employees that have holiday pay, pension contribution etc.
Self employed have to pay their own tax, ni etc, then travelling costs. It also seems they are experienced gardeners, maybe look for a student or similar instead?