Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That £26.50/hour for weeding is insanity?

494 replies

LaBellySausage · 21/02/2021 19:54

I'm looking for someone to come around for 3 hours/week to help with weeding the garden.

I was given a couple of names of local people who do gardening. I expected to pay somewhere between £10-12/hour, perhaps £15/hour if the person was an experienced gardener. I believe minimum wage is £8something but I don't think people can live on that.

The first person wouldn't give a quote til they came to view the garden and then was hesitant to give an hourly rate, preferring to give a rate for 'the job'. It's not a job that can be finished- it's like when I shave my legs the bastards on the other one have started growing back when I start the second. I just want a few weeds less per week. He eventually said £18/hour. I thanked him for his time but said it was a bit more than I had budgeted. The second guy said £26.50/hour!

This is simple weeding. Trowel and hoe provided. £26.50/hour is about £55,000 annually.

I worked jobs like this while in uni at minimum wage. For reference, we live in a very inexpensive part of the country- he would not be weeding Chelsea Flower Show. Both candidates were local so didn't have more than a 5/10 minute drive.

Am I being unreasonable, or is this a crazy rate?

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 21/02/2021 21:55

@LaBellySausage

I wish people would stop saying I wanted to payminimum wage. Minimum wage is £8.72 if you are over 25. I was expecting to pay between £10 and 15 per hour. £10 for someone young with little or no experience, £15 for someone a bit older who has seen a nettle before.

Neither of those are minimum wage.

No. That's not minimum wage. However that is quite low for someone who is self employed. I speak as a self employed person who has to show that my business is profitable which means taking costs into consideration. £10 an hour is only £1.18 per hour above minimum wage. That isn't enough to pay a minimum wage plus associated business costs. Because being self employed involves costs that people on paye don't have to consider.

So if I only charge £10 an hour and a self employed person, I might only actually take home £7.50 after necessary costs (that I cannot legally avoid). Why should I earn less than minimum wage?

SoulofanAggron · 21/02/2021 21:54

@LaBellySausage You could do stuff like tie a ribbon round things/areas you want to keep if possible, to save any issues.

LaBellySausage · 21/02/2021 21:54

@VinylDetective I get about £9.50 per hour for being an FY1 doctor in the North East. I would get more in London yes.

OP posts:
VinylDetective · 21/02/2021 21:53

Do you get paid less because you live in the north east @LaBellySausage? Or are you paid the same NHS salary as you would be if you lived in Berkshire?

LaBellySausage · 21/02/2021 21:53

@SoulofanAggron thanks

OP posts:
SaltyTootsieToes · 21/02/2021 21:53

A gardener does not work a 40 hour week year round. In the depth of winter when the day light is limited, snow or absolutely pissing down with rain, they’re not working. Additionally, if you’re wanting a gardener, you’re paying for their expertise. While you may be providing the trowel, you’ll find they have their own plus loads of tools that they’ve invested in for their business

For all of these reasons, I can understand their hourly fee.

For what you’re looking for, you’d be better off finding someone who is not a gardener, maybe a retired person or student, just looking for some extra money.

suggestionsplease1 · 21/02/2021 21:52

@MMAMPWGHAP

Gardening - traditionally a male job.

Cleaning - traditionally a female job

Draw your own conclusions.

Yep. I tend to agree. This is a historic hangover of trends of paying more for traditionally male work rather than traditionally female work.

There are too many industries where this inequality is still at work in the background - look at care role average pay vs trades average pay, where the time taken to train is the same obviously...of course there will be a difference for the plumber/electrician who has taken 3 yrs to qualify.

SoulofanAggron · 21/02/2021 21:52

I'm self employed and have been for 20 years. What's your point?

You were saying that self-employed people couldn't work for a low wage. You are wrong. Many of us do, sadly.

user1467486752 · 21/02/2021 21:51

I'm an experienced gardener and charge £20 per hour. I remember taking green waste to the tip and there was a lady next to me emptying her bags of green waste left by her gardener. Each bag she tipped out had various different plants that her 'gardener' had weeded out, rose bushes, perennials. She was pretty upset when she realised what he had done.
I've worked as a professional gardener for 20 years and if you love plants it can be painful to see how they have been butchered by inexperienced gardeners. Think cutting a beautiful Acer with a hedge cutter into a square. I'm worth every penny I charge!

LaBellySausage · 21/02/2021 21:51

@FangsForTheMemory

(If I paid £13 rather than £26.50 for 3 hours)

OP posts:
SoulofanAggron · 21/02/2021 21:51

I was expecting to pay between £10 and 15 per hour. £10 for someone young with little or no experience, £15 for someone a bit older who has seen a nettle before.

@LaBellySausage Yep, it's more than reasonable. I think £15 would be quite generous, actually. I suppose the better off someone is the more they'd be prepared to pay, depending on what they have to spare. So what relatively well-off people might pay wouldn't apply if I were hiring someone to do a job, for instance. Cos I just don't have the money to shell out as much as some.

I think £10 is reasonable. Or maybe £12.50 as a bit towards any travel.

LoveSummerNotIcecream · 21/02/2021 21:51

I live in the Midlands. I pay £15 an hour for an experienced gardener who has a qualification in horticulture.

LaBellySausage · 21/02/2021 21:50

Yes but I would have £40 spare per visit to just buy a new plant if they dug one up.

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 21/02/2021 21:50

@SoulofanAggron I'm self employed and have been for 20 years. What's your point?

FangsForTheMemory · 21/02/2021 21:49

Someone with little or no experience might well not know the difference between a weed and a plant you want to keep, you know.

LaBellySausage · 21/02/2021 21:46

@SaltyTootsieToes but do you live in a place with a higher cost of living? I live in the North East

OP posts:
SoulofanAggron · 21/02/2021 21:46

I know a not qualified gardener who charges £13-15 per hour. She has work in the winter. I clear mum's garden and there's flowering plants in winter and debris to clear away.

Do you already have a 'day' job though? Because if you do, that's why you can afford to charge less.

@CandyLeBonBon You don't think there are self-employed people who work for a low wage? I can assure you there are many. As a cleaner I worked for min/'living' wage and knew many other cleaners who worked for less. Maybe that's hard to believe for you. Confused There isn't even really a minimum wage for self-employed people I don't think, unfortunately.

SaltyTootsieToes · 21/02/2021 21:45

Round where I live, gardeners are £25 an hour.

LaBellySausage · 21/02/2021 21:45

I wish people would stop saying I wanted to payminimum wage. Minimum wage is £8.72 if you are over 25. I was expecting to pay between £10 and 15 per hour. £10 for someone young with little or no experience, £15 for someone a bit older who has seen a nettle before.

Neither of those are minimum wage.

OP posts:
Candodad · 21/02/2021 21:45

What about travel time? What about time lost from other jobs? What about the years of experience regardless of what you are wanting?
Put it this way would you expect to be able to provide a joiner with the materials and her work for £15 an hour? A brickie? Plummer?

No chance.

CandyLeBonBon · 21/02/2021 21:44

@FreekStar

It's ridiculous isn't it when you get paid more for pulling up a few weeds than I do for being a highly experienced and skilled and trained teaching assistant who is responsible for covering the teaching of classes of primary children, teaching intervention groups, creating displays in school, administering first aid etc. and all the other things that go along with my job!
You have job security, your Ni paid, employment rights, training, equipment, insurances, maternity/smp and taxes taken into account with your employed position. If you are self employed, all of that is factored into your hourly rate which is why it's higher than nmw.

What makes you think a Gardener is any less skilled than a TA?

Porridgeoat · 21/02/2021 21:42

I would see if a local teen or mum would come and do it for you for less. As long as they were active and motivated you’d be fine

chomalungma · 21/02/2021 21:41

@FreekStar

It's ridiculous isn't it when you get paid more for pulling up a few weeds than I do for being a highly experienced and skilled and trained teaching assistant who is responsible for covering the teaching of classes of primary children, teaching intervention groups, creating displays in school, administering first aid etc. and all the other things that go along with my job!
The thing is - there are plenty of people who do the job of a TA for that pay rate.

If you were running a business, how would you set pay rates?

Why do some jobs have higher salaries than others?

partyatthepalace · 21/02/2021 21:40

Well the going rate is what people will pay, so it is what it is.

If you can’t afford it, try an odd job man or a teenager and give them instructions?

CandyLeBonBon · 21/02/2021 21:39

@Chicchicchicchiclana

I paid a student (son of a friend) who lives nearby £10 an hour to do digging and weeding for me last summer. I gave him 2 full days work to make it worth his while and gave him really clear instructions on what was a weed and what wasn't, provided all the tools and garden rubbish sacks and was on hand all the time for advice/providing mugs of tea/took care of recyling or taking rubbish to the tip.

If you want a self employed gardener with plant knowledge to come on a regular basis for just a few hours per week or fortnight you're obviously going to have to pay a lot more.

And did he declare his income? Did you pay cash? £10/hour is barely above nmw and absolutely not feasible as a chargeable self employed rate. I really wish people on PAYE would understand why the two rates are not comparable