Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To start the 1:1 diet (Cambridge Weight Plan) and then become a consultant to earn extra money

206 replies

cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 10:35

Hello

Over the last 6 months, I have been changing my eating habits and exercising more. I lost 2 stone, I'm 5ft 8. I went from a size 16 to a size 12 (between August and December). I was trying to reach a size 10, but since Christmas, I haven't been eating healthily. However, I have carried on exercising (for mental and physical health).

I was talking to a friend online the other day and she had lost 4st with the 1:1 diet. She had also become a consultant and suggested that I could join and earn more money. Also, I thought I could get to a size 10 and earn extra money whilst doing so.

I currently work part time. DP said "you won't make any money and its just a scam". "You will put money in and never see it again". I liked the idea as I can work from home and earn some extra money.

Has anyone had any success with losing weight and keeping it off with 1:1 diet?

Has anyone made any money by becoming a 1:1 diet consultant?

OP posts:
FolkyFoxFace · 19/02/2021 21:41

I have to say, I find it really interesting the way MLM huns get so defensive about their line of "work". If I saw a thread entitled "should I become a lecturer" I might pop my opinion up, but I wouldn't sign up to start arguing the toss complete with block capitals and barely concealed rage if someone said it's a shit job.

YouokHun · 19/02/2021 21:41

[quote Mumto3kiddies82]@YouOkHun I have a very small team of ppl who asked me over the years if they could join. Yup we are paid on 4 gens, however most ppl join to make money selling products- sponsoring you have to have really big teams and most ppl including myself aren't interested in that side of things . I buy products, see my slimmers every week, love what I do and love seeing the results. Just because I represent a brand that allows you to build a team does not devalue the fact that you can have a good business from just doing direct sales side of the business- like Avon/ tropics / body shop . There is no big conspiracy ! I don't give a hoots what HO business plan is I like what I do and ill keep doing it[/quote]
I, along with others, run a fairly large and influential MLM watchdog group (there are a number of other groups doing a very good job). We are a point of contact for media and other organisations seeking information or wanting to understand the impact of MLM. I’ve been doing this for quite a few years now, watching the conduct of a number of MLMs (who should not be calling themselves direct selling). Our group is made up of various professions such as journalists, economists, people with legal experience and medical professionals, some people have been in MLM. We are also in touch with experts like Robert FitzPatrick who is a leading authority on pyramid schemes. More importantly we are in touch every day with potential sign ups to MLM, people who are in MLM, people who have quit MLM or been cast out. On this basis I can quite categorically tell you that many more people lose money than make it in MLM such as Avon, BSAH and Tropic. If you are signing up for a hobby that’s all very well but it’s clear from research that under 10% sign up to dabble or just for the discount, most sign up because they actually need to earn from it consistently. The only way to reach the giddy heights of the national minimum wage in MLM is to RECRUIT. You cannot earn a living wage by product sales alone. The possibility of “building a team” means that it is not direct selling and it therefore has built in an opportunity for exploitation. You may not be getting damaged, you may conduct yourself well but it does not mean that the MLM business model isn’t causing financial, emotional and social loss over all. You may not care but you are helping to perpetuate one of the greatest scams of the Internet age.

FolkyFoxFace · 19/02/2021 21:30

[quote Mumto3kiddies82]@FolkyFoxFace because you clearly have nothing better to do than be obnoxious and narrow minded. I doubt you have had much if any experience with any ' close friends ' in the direct sales business.. you're clearly just trying to look like you've lots of experience . If you did then you would have seen the balance of success stories where people actually make a good living in direct sales. And nobody is trying to sell you anything, if you don't want it don't buy it ! I'm defending what I do as THE ORIGINAL POST ASKED FOR ANYONE WHO HAS EXPERIENCE in the field , it didn't ask for some expert whos watched a TV documentary on some bad MLMs and thinks they're right. #painful[/quote]
Dear me. How embarrassing.

Well obviously, I must just be making up my experiences with people involved with MLM's because I've got nothing better to do. The OP asked for advice, and I gave it. Many people have seen how MLM's turn out - there isn't a vast distrust of them for no reason.

As for "nobody is trying to sell you anything" - they are. The woman who harassed me throughout my pregnancy was. The old friend who got involved was. That is, after all, the point of sales.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 19/02/2021 21:20

You sort of sound like you thought these sorts of things (selling to friends and family) are a fairly standard way to "make extra money". They really aren't. 96% of people who become consultants in multi level marketing programs make nothing or lose money. The odds of you making any money from this would be very low.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 19/02/2021 21:07

Anything what wants me to pay to work for them is goimg to turn up as bullshit ime

Mumto3kiddies82 · 19/02/2021 21:07

@Yesmate I'm involved only in as much as I like what I do . I genuinely have never seen anyone badly damaged by an experience in an MLM . This isn't a thousands of pounds investment that could go majorly wrong . I suppose if major money is concerned it could see serious consequences, I just have never seen it first hand

Pebbledashery · 19/02/2021 21:05

Also.. My consultant lost 7 stone in 8 months on the plan.. I wouldn't want to buy products from someone who had only lost a stone that didn't do the plan long enough to truly believe in what they are selling.

Mumto3kiddies82 · 19/02/2021 21:05

@FolkyFoxFace because you clearly have nothing better to do than be obnoxious and narrow minded. I doubt you have had much if any experience with any ' close friends ' in the direct sales business.. you're clearly just trying to look like you've lots of experience . If you did then you would have seen the balance of success stories where people actually make a good living in direct sales. And nobody is trying to sell you anything, if you don't want it don't buy it ! I'm defending what I do as THE ORIGINAL POST ASKED FOR ANYONE WHO HAS EXPERIENCE in the field , it didn't ask for some expert whos watched a TV documentary on some bad MLMs and thinks they're right. #painful

Pebbledashery · 19/02/2021 21:04

Just to add.. I wouldn't do this OP.. I did the Cambridge weight plan.. I lost 2 stone. It is only good for a short term weight loss. Don't join a MLM. It's unethical and you can do better than this if you need some extra money.

Mumto3kiddies82 · 19/02/2021 21:00

@YouOkHun I have a very small team of ppl who asked me over the years if they could join. Yup we are paid on 4 gens, however most ppl join to make money selling products- sponsoring you have to have really big teams and most ppl including myself aren't interested in that side of things . I buy products, see my slimmers every week, love what I do and love seeing the results. Just because I represent a brand that allows you to build a team does not devalue the fact that you can have a good business from just doing direct sales side of the business- like Avon/ tropics / body shop . There is no big conspiracy ! I don't give a hoots what HO business plan is I like what I do and ill keep doing it

Yesmate · 19/02/2021 20:56

@Mumto3kiddies82 you think me saying people have seen the damage is strong. Wow, there is nothing strong about this statement.
The problem is, you are involved and therefore will never see any negative. I’m out.

YouokHun · 19/02/2021 20:53

[quote Mumto3kiddies82]@folkyfoxface well I have never been given a script or told how to ' sell ' - God knows what companies you have experience with. I did the diet, I lost weight, I trained and started supporting ppl losing weight .
Whether you agree with the diet or not you your opinion Is very narrow minded. Why not just take people at face value ? Anyway enough of this , I gave my opinion , end of . I hope you find the satisfaction you are searching for[/quote]
@Mumto3kiddies82 do you have a team or is it just you and customers who have not converted to team members?

Do you know whether uplines are paid a slice of what their downlines sell to customers outside the scheme or are uplines paid a slice of what their downlines purchase (uplines being rewarded on downlines purchases (not sales) is the usual in MLM).

FolkyFoxFace · 19/02/2021 20:53

[quote Mumto3kiddies82]@folkyfoxface well I have never been given a script or told how to ' sell ' - God knows what companies you have experience with. I did the diet, I lost weight, I trained and started supporting ppl losing weight .
Whether you agree with the diet or not you your opinion Is very narrow minded. Why not just take people at face value ? Anyway enough of this , I gave my opinion , end of . I hope you find the satisfaction you are searching for[/quote]
It isn't narrow minded to have a well formed opinion on a destructive, disingenuous, and corrosive business model. Nor is it narrow minded to dislike what it does to friends who get involved, or the countless other people conned out of their money for products that in some cases are really quite harmful.

Why would I take someone trying to sell me a product I don't want or need at face value? Or someone defending the practice of doing it?

I have no idea what you mean by the "satisfaction you're searching for". That doesn't even make sense. Thanks, I suppose? Confused

Mumto3kiddies82 · 19/02/2021 20:50

[quote Yesmate]@Mumto3kiddies82 I haven’t seen any bullying statements but the opinions are strong because presumably most of us have seen the damage MLM does.[/quote]
Isn't that a bit strong, most of us have seen the damage? I have loads of school friends who sell tropics/ fm fragrance/ Avon/ body shop - what's the damage . The start ups are usually low , they don't all stock any products so what's the risk with low outlays ? They may not say get any body shop orders, so don't make any money. Or they may make a few quid to treat the kids... how is that damaging ? Or maybe I'm naive as I've never invested mega money in a MLM before and never seen anyone lose a lot x

Mumto3kiddies82 · 19/02/2021 20:46

@folkyfoxface well I have never been given a script or told how to ' sell ' - God knows what companies you have experience with. I did the diet, I lost weight, I trained and started supporting ppl losing weight .
Whether you agree with the diet or not you your opinion Is very narrow minded. Why not just take people at face value ? Anyway enough of this , I gave my opinion , end of . I hope you find the satisfaction you are searching for

Yesmate · 19/02/2021 20:46

@Mumto3kiddies82 I haven’t seen any bullying statements but the opinions are strong because presumably most of us have seen the damage MLM does.

Mumto3kiddies82 · 19/02/2021 20:39

[quote Yesmate]@Mumto3kiddies82 who is comment aimed at?[/quote]
Sorry @FolkyFoxFace saying all MLM speak the same.
I agree with some of the threads. I would never approach anybody about losing weight , it's such a personal thing. The woman asked originally for opinions and ppl have given them , but to get personal is ridiculous . It's bullying behaviour and ridiculous

FolkyFoxFace · 19/02/2021 20:38

@Mumto3kiddies82

Talk about stereotyping. I can't see how that's possible considering it's such a diverse variety of people who choose to work in the industry. Since I have a degree and Masters and have spent just as much time in further education as I Have in direct sales I pretty much find your statement narrow minded !
Who brought up education? I didn't mention that. What I mentioned was your style of writing/the style of writing of others involved in MLMs. Writing has a tone to it, and it's always the same when it comes down to discussing this topic. Almost like it's being taken from a script. How bizarre...
Yesmate · 19/02/2021 20:34

@Mumto3kiddies82 who is comment aimed at?

Mumto3kiddies82 · 19/02/2021 20:31

Talk about stereotyping. I can't see how that's possible considering it's such a diverse variety of people who choose to work in the industry. Since I have a degree and Masters and have spent just as much time in further education as I Have in direct sales I pretty much find your statement narrow minded !

FolkyFoxFace · 19/02/2021 20:14

[quote YouokHun]@FolkyFoxFace that’s appalling.[/quote]
Isn't it just? It genuinely scares me when I think of the other women who will get sucked in by it. Pregnant women feeling vulnerable about their body, ED sufferers as mentioned here. It's nowhere near the same as TV advertising or anything like that - having someone supposedly single you out in a DM regarding your weight is such an awful thing. It only served to make me angry, but I can easily see how some women would be upset, start to worry, and get sucked in.

YouokHun · 19/02/2021 20:06

@FolkyFoxFace that’s appalling.

YouokHun · 19/02/2021 20:04

[quote Cocomarine]**@YouokHun* I think that’s a really* important question.

@cerealdieter how would you feel about encouraging, enabling, and make money out of those with disordered eating?

And don’t say you wouldn’t sell to someone 5’10” and 6.5st... because you can have an eating disorder at any weight.[/quote]
Exactly right. Having worked in an ED unit years ago during my training I can vouch for the fact it’s extremely difficult to spot in the general population and many sufferers are very good at obscuring their illness. Added to that Cambridge is now about getting bums on seats; no one is going to be asking too many questions of potential customers even if they know the questions to ask.

BTW the training will be all about mindset and nothing about ethical behaviour, risk management and sensible nutrition and nothing about profit and loss either.

FolkyFoxFace · 19/02/2021 19:32

[quote Cocomarine]**@YouokHun* I think that’s a really* important question.

@cerealdieter how would you feel about encouraging, enabling, and make money out of those with disordered eating?

And don’t say you wouldn’t sell to someone 5’10” and 6.5st... because you can have an eating disorder at any weight.[/quote]
I'm 9 months pregnant, and I had one trying to sell me slimming shakes the other week, to "get a head start" for when my baby's born. She also tried it at the beginning when I had morning sickness as it would "help". Disgraceful as far as I'm concerned.

Cocomarine · 19/02/2021 19:25

@YouokHun I think that’s a really important question.

@cerealdieter how would you feel about encouraging, enabling, and make money out of those with disordered eating?

And don’t say you wouldn’t sell to someone 5’10” and 6.5st... because you can have an eating disorder at any weight.

Swipe left for the next trending thread