Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To start the 1:1 diet (Cambridge Weight Plan) and then become a consultant to earn extra money

206 replies

cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 10:35

Hello

Over the last 6 months, I have been changing my eating habits and exercising more. I lost 2 stone, I'm 5ft 8. I went from a size 16 to a size 12 (between August and December). I was trying to reach a size 10, but since Christmas, I haven't been eating healthily. However, I have carried on exercising (for mental and physical health).

I was talking to a friend online the other day and she had lost 4st with the 1:1 diet. She had also become a consultant and suggested that I could join and earn more money. Also, I thought I could get to a size 10 and earn extra money whilst doing so.

I currently work part time. DP said "you won't make any money and its just a scam". "You will put money in and never see it again". I liked the idea as I can work from home and earn some extra money.

Has anyone had any success with losing weight and keeping it off with 1:1 diet?

Has anyone made any money by becoming a 1:1 diet consultant?

OP posts:
jelliedreels · 20/02/2021 08:04

I understand that customers need to take some personal responsibility for their eating habits. However, I do think that the way the product is sold to them is unethical. To repeatedly sell to the same person who is severely overweight and needs real help doesn't feel right, it clearly isn't working for them or doing them any health benefits. Similarly, to sell as a 'crash diet' so that weight can be lost for specific events seems very dubious to me. This has happened to my family members. I understand this might not be the same with all consultants, but it leaves a bitter taste in my mouth. They are grown adults and of course have some responsibility, but I think the consultant exploits their vulnerability in this area. I find it hard to believe that she (or the company she represents) has their wellbeing at heart. After all, there's a built in incentive for repeat custom.

YouokHun · 19/02/2021 23:52

@hellabored

Do it! I’ve been a consultant for 3 years and earn around £36,000 per year - from new clients and yes some returning! I’ve only recruited 2 other people that were passionate and lost a lot of weight on the diet! Also it’s GP recommend now, so I’m busier than ever! Ignore the people that don’t have a clue!... I work 5 days a week but 4 hours a day seeing clients, doing orders and using social media
There has been some research for the use of VLCD in some cases but you’ll struggle to find a GP happy with the idea that their patient will go off and take nutritional and psychological advice from an MLM person. It’s very easy to make income claims here but you should know that your earnings are in no way typical. OP, please stay away from MLM.
hellabored · 19/02/2021 23:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 23:19

@hellabored

Do it! I’ve been a consultant for 3 years and earn around £36,000 per year - from new clients and yes some returning! I’ve only recruited 2 other people that were passionate and lost a lot of weight on the diet! Also it’s GP recommend now, so I’m busier than ever! Ignore the people that don’t have a clue!... I work 5 days a week but 4 hours a day seeing clients, doing orders and using social media
You have done so well and achieved so much in a short space of time. Its good to hear a success story.

I do want to do the plan to get slimmer and stay slimmer.

OP posts:
hellabored · 19/02/2021 23:16

Do it! I’ve been a consultant for 3 years and earn around £36,000 per year - from new clients and yes some returning! I’ve only recruited 2 other people that were passionate and lost a lot of weight on the diet!
Also it’s GP recommend now, so I’m busier than ever! Ignore the people that don’t have a clue!... I work 5 days a week but 4 hours a day seeing clients, doing orders and using social media

cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 23:04

@Rachie1973

Must admit my stepdaughter lost 6.5 stone on Cambridge and went on to be a consultant. Works for her.
That is an amazing loss. Well done to her. How does she find working for them?
OP posts:
Rachie1973 · 19/02/2021 23:02

Must admit my stepdaughter lost 6.5 stone on Cambridge and went on to be a consultant. Works for her.

Bluewavescrashing · 19/02/2021 22:53

Also. Any 'training' offered won't actually give you a qualification in nutrition, which is what most people look for when buying a diet product. It will just be meetings and activities to keep you busy and believing you are 'working your business'. Advertising on Facebook groups etc. Making goal boards. Listening to other reps bang on about the products and the opportunity. I'm sure you have better things to spend your evenings doing Smile

Bluewavescrashing · 19/02/2021 22:50

OP you sound like a caring, thoughtful and intelligent person. Don't be fooled into becoming an unpaid sales rep. You won't own your own business as they'll lead you to believe. You'll end up spending loads of your own money on the products to stay active in the mlm game, to meet targets or to appease up lines. You'll feel guilty trying to recruit vulnerable people who need extra income. You'll alienate your friends and family.

Keep up the weight loss in a healthy way and maybe look at doing some ironing, typing etc if you need extra cash. Mlm will cost you money and cause a lot of stress that you really don't need.

FolkyFoxFace · 19/02/2021 22:44

@cerealdieter Unfortunately they won't be offered that training. There's no way of knowing the truth about who you're selling to - and like someone has said upthread, things like BMI can't even show you if someone has an ED because they present in so many different forms.

I had an ED as a teen, and spent time later doing research on it as part of an academic study. Some of the women I interviewed mentioned diet pills and meal replacement shakes, and I remember being shocked that it was through MLM's and the like that they got hold of them. I'm glad I didn't have access when I was ill because I would 100% have been all over it like a rash.

cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 22:40

@Beforethetakingoftoastandtea

Op ive never been above a size 10 and have never ‘dieted’. And im also a terrible snacker. But i always have veg or fruit to snack on. Carrot sticks, handful of grapes, tomato, baby corn etc... small amounts of veg can take the edge of hunger. And is significantly better than shakes
Yes healthy eating is good. I used veg etc to lose weight before.
OP posts:
cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 22:32

[quote FolkyFoxFace]@cerealdieter Just because they fill out the form doesn't mean they don't have an ED, or won't lie on the form to get the product.

Just because they could buy it off eBay doesn't make it any better - if they're buying from you, you'd be profiting from their disordered eating and giving them tools to harm themselves.

I don't say this to make you feel bad, I'm glad you're asking all of these questions before jumping in. It's not something to go into blindly - losing money aside, the ethics and morality side of things are really shady.[/quote]
I would never want to cause any harm to anyone.

It sounds like the "Consultants" need more qualifications/training in terms of ethics, morality etc to ensure that they aren't just someone selling something to earn money.

OP posts:
Beforethetakingoftoastandtea · 19/02/2021 22:29

Op ive never been above a size 10 and have never ‘dieted’. And im also a terrible snacker. But i always have veg or fruit to snack on. Carrot sticks, handful of grapes, tomato, baby corn etc... small amounts of veg can take the edge of hunger. And is significantly better than shakes

Crankley · 19/02/2021 22:25

OP, if you want to learn everything about MLMs - there's a long running thread in the Money Matters Board. They are currently on the 65th thread on the subject. www.mumsnet.com/Talk/legal_money_matters/4169970-mlm-bot-watch-65-get-your-bikini-bod-for-your-inteletravel-holiday-here

FolkyFoxFace · 19/02/2021 22:21

@cerealdieter Just because they fill out the form doesn't mean they don't have an ED, or won't lie on the form to get the product.

Just because they could buy it off eBay doesn't make it any better - if they're buying from you, you'd be profiting from their disordered eating and giving them tools to harm themselves.

I don't say this to make you feel bad, I'm glad you're asking all of these questions before jumping in. It's not something to go into blindly - losing money aside, the ethics and morality side of things are really shady.

Cocomarine · 19/02/2021 22:16

@cerealdieter still interested if you’re going to respond about encouraging and enabling eating disorders in some of the people you’re making money off...

cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 22:15

[quote Cocomarine]**@YouokHun* I think that’s a really* important question.

@cerealdieter how would you feel about encouraging, enabling, and make money out of those with disordered eating?

And don’t say you wouldn’t sell to someone 5’10” and 6.5st... because you can have an eating disorder at any weight.[/quote]
I've been told that you have to fill out a form before you can buy the items. Likewise if I was selling to a client. They need to fit a certain criteria (BMI, health conditions, medication etc).

Also, I've been told by another poster on here that you can buy the items on ebay. So if you had an ED, you could just buy them without going to see a consultant.

OP posts:
cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 22:04

@SchrodingersImmigrant thanks. I will have a look at the section :)

OP posts:
cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 22:03

@jelliedreels

OP I wouldn't recommend. Like others I'm sceptical about MLM's. But I'm also not a fan of this type of dieting. I have watched several members of my family do this diet. They have spent huge amounts of money with a 'friend' who sells the product. They get quick results, and then rapidly put the weight back on when they go back to eating real food. It did nothing to reset their eating habits, I can't understand how it could be considered a good approach to weightless when it is essentially a 'quick fix'. Once the weight goes back on they simply spend more money and go back on the diet again and again and again...
I get that it can be a vicious cycle for some people. However, sometimes the root cause of under/overeating is never actually found.

I think its pretty obvious if you go from eating 3 shakes/bars a day to eating biscuits, cakes and big meals, its inevitable you will gain weight.

Also going back to old habits will cause you to gain.

OP posts:
SchrodingersImmigrant · 19/02/2021 22:03

@cerealdieter why don't you check out the weight loss chat section? There are support threads running with great people and people give each other tips. May be healthier than this

cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 22:00

@Pebbledashery

Also.. My consultant lost 7 stone in 8 months on the plan.. I wouldn't want to buy products from someone who had only lost a stone that didn't do the plan long enough to truly believe in what they are selling.
Thats an amazing achievement. But surely everyone has different amounts to lose.

Also, it would take time to learn about the plan etc. The more you do it, the better you become.

OP posts:
cerealdieter · 19/02/2021 21:58

@spicedemerald

You’ll lose weight definitely. Then you’ll put it all back on and then some-that’s how those companies work. Far better to calculate your own calorie deficit and take it slow.
I just want to try a different approach.
OP posts:
spicedemerald · 19/02/2021 21:52

You’ll lose weight definitely. Then you’ll put it all back on and then some-that’s how those companies work. Far better to calculate your own calorie deficit and take it slow.

Sapho47 · 19/02/2021 21:43

[quote cerealdieter]@ShulamithFirestone why would I con friends and family?[/quote]
Because that's the only way you'll make money.

YouokHun · 19/02/2021 21:42

^sorry about the lack of paragraphs!