Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

friend got job she knew I wanted

833 replies

fcekinghell · 17/02/2021 17:39

It may be my own stupid fault, lesson learned but anyway.

I have an industry mentor. Mentors were being offered to people in my field about 2 years ago and I put myself forward as a means to widen my network, find out about new opportunities etc, especially as I wasn't happy where I was at the time.

I got assigned to a woman I will call Debbie. We had a few Zoom calls, emails etc where she gave me some tips and advice on how to move into employers like her own.

For the record, I am more qualified and experienced than Debbie but wanted a mentor to help me into that kind of employer. Debbie told me to keep her posted on my job hunting. Offered to help with my CV and interview skills if I needed it.

Well I got made redundant in Covid. Debbie still working where she is. Then my dream job came up. I excitedly told Debbie, telling her its my dream job. I did the application and asked Debbie what she thought, was there anything missing. She told me it was 'perfect' and 'good luck'.

Well, I didn't get the job. They said they might recruit later in the year and they'll let me know. I've now heard that Debbie got the job.

It feels like a real kick in the stomach. She was my mentor. She knew this was my dream job and jobs like this don't come up often. In fact, really rarely. She knew I was unemployed whilst she was still working. Plus this job is asking for a particular skill which I do not believe she has.

DH and my DM are telling me I am a fucking idiot for speaking to her. I am aren't I? I probably gave her all the answers too!

I'm so upset Sad Sad Angry Angry

OP posts:
Buccanarab · 17/02/2021 20:11

The lack of transparency about her own application is the main issue here. She shouldn’t be reviewing your application if she’s thinking of applying or has already done so. Conflict of interest and undermines her role as mentor.

How do you know Debbie didn't review the OPs application and then a few days or a week later look at the job advert again and decided to go for it?

Should she just sacrifice her own career because someone she new applied for it? Maybe she should have phoned the OP and asked permission before submitting her app? Or even put on her cv that she knew the OP and they should offer her the role as she'd applied first?

At the end of the day and application gets you through the door and the interview gets you the job. As the OP and Debbie both interviewed it suggests their applications were fine. The fact that Debbie was offered the job, despite being a mere shadow of the OP, suggests she outperformed the OP where it mattered.

Based on the content and tone of the OPs subsequent posts I'd be willing to wager a fair amount that her inflated ego/superior attitude shone through and didn't come across particularly well in the interview.

BadBathsheba · 17/02/2021 20:10

Debbie has been really underhand. She should absolutely have told you she was applying - especially as she is your mentor. I hope she doesn't mentor you in integrity or professionalism.........

Say nothing and wait for her to bring it up.

jay55 · 17/02/2021 20:08

You know, you might not have got the job even if she hadn't applied.

Sittingonabench · 17/02/2021 20:08

I’m sorry you have been made redundant and that you find yourself in a difficult position but I think you are being very unreasonable in how you are reacting. It is perfectly possible she came across this opportunity on her own, even if she didn’t and she applied after hearing about it from you I don’t see that is a breach of ethics in any way. She supported you in your application and now you have leaped to she must have used information from it to make her own better and she has lied. That’s a huge leap and a serious accusation. I appreciate you must be under pressure but your response is to immediately say she doesn’t deserve it and must have lied.

Cadent · 17/02/2021 20:04

I've just changed my vote to YANBU, because you have now said the job was only advertised on the website of a not very well known company. It sounds like a terrible way to recruit but it makes it likely that she did find out about the job from you and didn't tell you.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 17/02/2021 20:02

I think ethically Debbie should have told you she had gone for the job and shouldn't then have looked at your application. Even if I'd sent mine in, I would have flagged it at that stage. However that said, she's got the job on her own merits I assume. Sorry you're disappointed, understandably.

Daphnise · 17/02/2021 20:02

Not a pleasant situation.

But they wanted her and not you.

It can be hard when you don't succeed in competition for a job.

But try not to complain. It never looks good and achieves nothing.

AnneElliott · 17/02/2021 20:00

I think Debbie has been sneaky. She should have told you she was also applying and shouldn't have helped you with the app form as you were her direct competitor!

What has she said about it op now that you know?

oblada · 17/02/2021 19:59

People are mental! Debbie has been seriously underhand - how can she review an application if she is also applying for the same job? Bonkers! Completely conflict of interest and total dishonesty. Yes she can apply for any job she wants, absolutely, but to support a mentee through the application process for a job she is applying to too is completely unprofessional.
Since she's no longer a member of that professional body you can't report her for breach of the code of conduct (although I'd still contact them in case she wants to re-join). I'd definitely ask for more feedback in your shoes explaining that you know the person who got the job and are a bit confused as to your weaknesses on this particular occasions since it cannot be x/y/z. They obviously cannot disclose anything personal about her but maybe give you more clarity as to the reason they preferred her (assuming she didn't lie).

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 17/02/2021 19:59

I'm surprised at the mixed responses. Yes, Debbie might have been going to apply/have applied anyway, but in that case she shouldn't have fucking let the OP tell her all her answers. That is totally unethical. When you agree to act as someone's mentor, you have to behave ethically towards then.

Atalune · 17/02/2021 19:58

Debbie behaved unethically. Whether or not professionally so I am not sure but it certainly speaks to her moral character. Poorly.

She’s a shark.

DailyCandy · 17/02/2021 19:56

She should have been open with you. And you were naive to tell her. But on balance, I think she should feel ashamed of taking advantage of the situation.

Frannibananni · 17/02/2021 19:53

Sorry, you can’t call dibs on jobs. Whoever is the best fit and most qualified gets it. Employers choice.

Circumlocutious · 17/02/2021 19:53

@BlobbyYouTwat

Hmm, I understand that you're disappointed.

But maybe they really liked her, there every possibility that you may not have got the job anyway.

She may have applied before you; you can't be sure that she didn't. Maybe she didn't want to dent your confidence or make things awkward by saying so.

You have no idea how well she interviewed - that's an enormous part of getting the job. We sometimes see some great CVS but then for one reason or another we're not sold on the candidate, or they wouldn't fit our team/departmental dynamic.

We've on several occasions hired people with less "on paper" based on their interview.

There’s no ‘awkwardness’ about it. She shouldn’t be reviewing a competitors application if she’s already applied for the same role. That’s disingenuous, a clear conflict of interest, and undermines her stated impartiality.
FightingTheFoo · 17/02/2021 19:52

@Circumlocutious

The lack of transparency about her own application is the main issue here. She shouldn’t be reviewing your application if she’s thinking of applying or has already done so. Conflict of interest and undermines her role as mentor.
100% this. Responses on here are typically insane.
Circumlocutious · 17/02/2021 19:51

The lack of transparency about her own application is the main issue here. She shouldn’t be reviewing your application if she’s thinking of applying or has already done so. Conflict of interest and undermines her role as mentor.

LemonadeBudget · 17/02/2021 19:49

The fact that you seem so much better qualified on paper, yet they still chose her, shows how much they wanted her.

That must sting, but honestly, you need to move on. She's not the friend you thought she was, you don't have to have anything more to do with her. Concentrate on your job search- good luck.

BlobbyYouTwat · 17/02/2021 19:48

Hmm, I understand that you're disappointed.

But maybe they really liked her, there every possibility that you may not have got the job anyway.

She may have applied before you; you can't be sure that she didn't. Maybe she didn't want to dent your confidence or make things awkward by saying so.

You have no idea how well she interviewed - that's an enormous part of getting the job. We sometimes see some great CVS but then for one reason or another we're not sold on the candidate, or they wouldn't fit our team/departmental dynamic.

We've on several occasions hired people with less "on paper" based on their interview.

MrsKramer · 17/02/2021 19:48

Sue her. If there's a code of conduct then it must be an implied term of the contract of mentorship and/or a tortious duty not to breach it. Plus any information you disclosed to her in the course of the mentorship is subject to implied duties of confidentiality and not to profit from it. You can sue her for your loss of earnings and/or for an account of her profits. You can also write to her new employer telling them they are facilitating her breaches by employing her.

(This informal guidance is provided on a non-reliance basis and you should take independent legal advice 😉).

Henio · 17/02/2021 19:47

She could have told you in advance she'd also applied before you sent her your cv and application, it wouldn't have seemed so bad then I guess

AmandaHugenkiss · 17/02/2021 19:47

Agree with other posters that there was a conflict of interests and she should have disclosed she was also applying, and declined to review your application. However no reason for her not to apply. It’s common in my area of work; it’s niche, so I trained with and am good friends with people that I’ve also gone up against for rare posts. I’ve got some, they’ve got some. It isn’t personal although when you are unemployed it must feel like a kick in the teeth. I’m sorry.

However once you reach interview it’s all about how you come across and answer the questions. She did better on the day. The smart and professional thing to do would be to contact her, congratulate her and ask for her tips on her interview answers. Also, if she sees you being so professional she’s a potential contact still in a company you want to work for. Use it!

Smile, seethe inwardly, but use it to your advantage if at all possible.

Livelovebehappy · 17/02/2021 19:45

She really doesn’t owe you any loyalty. You present her as a friend in the post title, but she isn’t a friend. She’s a work related acquaintance. It’s a dog eat dog world out there, and unless she was a close friend, or family member, she owes you no personal consideration whatsoever.

LoudestCat14 · 17/02/2021 19:45

I'd have been gutted in your shoes too and disappointed she hadn't said anything when you asked her to look over your application. I get that she's not a friend, blah blah, but it's still a bit shady.

Thislittlefinger123 · 17/02/2021 19:42

Oh and your title is misleading she wasn't your friend, she was a mentor in a professional capacity.

SilverBirchWithout · 17/02/2021 19:42

Could you have appeared over-qualified for the role? Or they may have felt you were applying as a stop-gap because you were redundant, and would move on quickly.