Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

friend got job she knew I wanted

833 replies

fcekinghell · 17/02/2021 17:39

It may be my own stupid fault, lesson learned but anyway.

I have an industry mentor. Mentors were being offered to people in my field about 2 years ago and I put myself forward as a means to widen my network, find out about new opportunities etc, especially as I wasn't happy where I was at the time.

I got assigned to a woman I will call Debbie. We had a few Zoom calls, emails etc where she gave me some tips and advice on how to move into employers like her own.

For the record, I am more qualified and experienced than Debbie but wanted a mentor to help me into that kind of employer. Debbie told me to keep her posted on my job hunting. Offered to help with my CV and interview skills if I needed it.

Well I got made redundant in Covid. Debbie still working where she is. Then my dream job came up. I excitedly told Debbie, telling her its my dream job. I did the application and asked Debbie what she thought, was there anything missing. She told me it was 'perfect' and 'good luck'.

Well, I didn't get the job. They said they might recruit later in the year and they'll let me know. I've now heard that Debbie got the job.

It feels like a real kick in the stomach. She was my mentor. She knew this was my dream job and jobs like this don't come up often. In fact, really rarely. She knew I was unemployed whilst she was still working. Plus this job is asking for a particular skill which I do not believe she has.

DH and my DM are telling me I am a fucking idiot for speaking to her. I am aren't I? I probably gave her all the answers too!

I'm so upset Sad Sad Angry Angry

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 21:14

A lesson for the future.

But what's the lesson?

Not one around Debbie.

The only lesson for OP is to get proper feedback from the company & use it to move forward.

SurvivalIsInsufficient · 17/02/2021 21:13

You may sound bitter but who wouldn't in your situation

Most of us wouldn't be in OP's situation, and if we were, would not be blaming our problems on someone else!

truthisalie · 17/02/2021 21:12

You may sound bitter but who wouldn't in your situation. A lesson for the future.

Obimumkinobi · 17/02/2021 21:10

I wouldn't contact Debbie to either congratulate her or question her. I'd also write off working for this company whilst she's there because she's done a shit thing and she knows it! She won't be your advocate.
Can you imagine if she pops up on your next interview panel? She'll probably be looking through her notes of your previous mentoring sessions trying to find something you'll be weakest on!

And as for the suggestions about applying for for Debbie's old job?! Who wants the cast offs of someone who's shafted you?!

Good luck OP, I hope you find a job soon - an even better one!

Hotzenplotz · 17/02/2021 21:08

@fcekinghell

Thank you to the PPs

The main thing that's bothering me is that she could have said something and/or declined to help.

The second thing that's bothering me is that I'm very sure she found out about the job from me.

And then there is the fact I am more qualified and experienced. I was only using her as a mentor because her type of employer was something I was considering e.g I was in an LA employer and she was in HE doing a similar job. Now I'm unemployed and she's never been unemployed, she's just transitioned smoothly. She didn't need this job.

I'm sorry to hear that you lost out, OP. Been there and it's not nice.

However, it's not her problem.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 21:07

@SurvivalIsInsufficient

For the love of God, of course Debbie was underhand. She should have told OP that she was applying for the same job

FGS, why should she? They aren't friends, they aren't colleagues. Debbie generously gave her time to mentor OP (who was never grateful and thought herself above Debbie the whole time), that doesn't mean she owes her anything at all, and certainly not to let her know her career plans!

@SurvivalIsInsufficient

Absolutely this.

SurvivalIsInsufficient · 17/02/2021 21:06

For the love of God, of course Debbie was underhand. She should have told OP that she was applying for the same job

FGS, why should she? They aren't friends, they aren't colleagues. Debbie generously gave her time to mentor OP (who was never grateful and thought herself above Debbie the whole time), that doesn't mean she owes her anything at all, and certainly not to let her know her career plans!

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 21:04

If this was formal mentoring, she betrayed your trust,

It clearly was as far from formal mentoring as it's possible to get.

I still think she should have told her. But she (Debbie) didn't have to, and did nothing wrong.

OP's own inexperience & naïveté as well as a nasty approach to bad-mouthing someone else in her profession are what shine through here for me.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 21:01

why didn't she just tell the OP that she was also applying?

Personally I would have.

But I know others who don't tell anyone at all when they apply for a job, including family.

She didn't have to.

Porridgeoat · 17/02/2021 21:00

Maybe they were looking at other softer unmentioned skills or she had additional qualities which could be utilised elsewhere in the company. You’re best just to let it go and be forward looking. What’s the point in getting chewed up about things

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 21:00

getting a second set of views on what the recruiters will be looking for.

Huh?

What 'second set of views'? She just saw OP's CV.

How is that a second set of views?

The post quoted referred to answers. There are no 'answers'. It's about matching your individual experience to the questions asked by the recruiting organisation. That's down to the candidate.

LolaSmiles · 17/02/2021 21:00

I don't think she was wrong to apply, but I do think it was quite unprofessional to decide to apply and then use the mentor role to gain the upper hand by looking through another applicant's application.

That is the sort of thing that sours professional relationships.

I think it's a lesson in choosing appropriate mentors/coaches. Having been both sides, a general rule I've found coaches more beneficial than mentors and that the best relationships are ones where the person coaching has enough distance from the coachees situation.

You'll have to chalk it up to experience and whatever you do, try to avoid falling into the pit of 'she didn't need the job so I deserved it more'.

candide47 · 17/02/2021 20:59

Sorry all...double posting malfunction!

candide47 · 17/02/2021 20:58

I mentor people and it involves building up trust to create openness and get the best out of the arrangement. Although there isn't a formal code for mentoring, whatever training you have to do it will have trust and confidentiality at its heart.

If this was formal mentoring, she betrayed your trust, in that situation as a mentor I would have declared my interest in getting a new role, wished you the very best of luck and told you that obvs I couldn't look at your CV. She possibly used information you gave her (your application) to her advantage as unlike you, she would have able to weigh up 'the other candidate' and play into this for her application.

Although it sucks that she didn't need this job as much as you, personally, I could live with her getting it on merit if she hadn't snuck around.

It's a small world OP, I hope karma bites her in the ass and you end up as her boss someday. Then you can pick her up on any untrustworthy behaviour.

In the meantime, you're no idiot. It's completely normal (in my world anyway) to have a mentor and to be open and trusting in that relationship. You've done nothing wrong, She, however, is a snake!

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 20:57

she would have able to weigh up 'the other candidate' and play into this for her application.

I assume there was more than 2 candidates for this job.

I really, really doubt anything on OP's CV gave Debbie the edge.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 20:56

We had a few Zoom calls, emails etc where she gave me some tips and advice on how to move into employers like her own.

This was your description of the mentor/mentee relationship. It's so slight as to be insignificant.

At various stages in my career, I've had mentoring. It was structured, regular & involved a lot more than this.

This was not really mentoring. It was some informal advice & chats.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 17/02/2021 20:56

@EarringsandLipstick

but in that case she shouldn't have fucking let the OP tell her all her answers.

There are no answers! It's not secondary school!

An interview is multi-faceted, any organisation worth their salt will ask questions that probe the interviewee sufficiently to find out if they are a good fit.

Oh come off it. Two heads are better than one. Even a very experienced job applicant, who has done her own research on the post, is going to benefit from getting a second set of views on what the recruiters will be looking for.

And, if there was no advantage to Debbie, why didn't she just tell the OP that she was also applying? The only possible motive for keeping it quiet was that she hoped to gain from doing so.

candide47 · 17/02/2021 20:55

I mentor people and it involves building up trust to create openness and get the best out of the arrangement. Although there isn't a formal code for mentoring, whatever training you have to do it will have trust and confidentiality at its heart.

She betrayed your trust, in that situation as a mentor I would have declared my interest in getting a new role, wished you the very best of luck and told you that obvs I couldn't look at your CV. She possibly used information you gave her (your application) to her advantage as unlike you, she would have able to weigh up 'the other candidate' and play into this for her application.

Although it sucks that she didn't need this job as much as you, I think I could live with that if she hadn't snuck around. Terrible Mentoring.

It's a small world OP, I hope karma bites her in the ass and you end up as her boss someday. Then you can pick her up on any untrustworthy behaviour.

In the meantime, you're no idiot. It's completely normal (in my world anyway) to have a mentor and to be open and trusting in that relationship. You've done nothing wrong, She, however, is a snake!

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 20:53

but in that case she shouldn't have fucking let the OP tell her all her answers.

There are no answers! It's not secondary school!

An interview is multi-faceted, any organisation worth their salt will ask questions that probe the interviewee sufficiently to find out if they are a good fit.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 20:50

I don't know why she got it over me but she definitely does not have a key essential skill they asked for (and I do).

The employer told me they wanted someone with the relevant qualifications and memberships so on the latter point she definitely lied.

OP, YABmassivelyU.

I get your disappointment on a personal level.

However I have to say you sound both immature & far less experienced than you claim.

You appear to have no understanding of the nature of the job market & I've included the above quotes as an illustration.

The employers met both of you & decided they wanted her. Undoubtedly you had skills she didn't, and vice versa. Ultimately on balance, she was the stronger candidate.

You are so unreasonable - and quite unpleasant - to accuse her of lying. You cannot know this. Even if the employer said that, they met her in an interview situation, and she performed better there. Otherwise they wouldn't have hired her.

You also were considered a strong candidate, hence why you got called to interview.

Also regarding feedback that's very slight feedback to get. Did you ask for your scores? You are entitled to those firstly, and then most interview board chairs would be open to debriefing you afterwards on specific areas of strength & areas to work on.

It's very surprising to me if you are relatively senior & not had that feedback.

I think you need to move on. You are unfairly focused on Debbie. There isn't just one dream job. There will be other roles, tho I know that's still no help when you are unemployed at the moment.

IthinkIm · 17/02/2021 20:50

Have you answered how you know she got it yet?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 17/02/2021 20:48

@SteveBrexit

but in that case she shouldn't have fucking let the OP tell her all her answers.

I am not sure some posters have a clue how recruitment actually works. Grin It's not high school anymore!

I run my own company and employ over 100 people. I'm still capable of not being a complete cunt to someone I am mentoring.
expat101 · 17/02/2021 20:44

Was she being paid to be your mentor? Do you have some sort of legal recourse with that? Who matched you both together to start with? What do they have to say about this?

Could the Employer have picked her as she was the ''cheaper package''? If she doesn't have the relevant industry membership and the like, perhaps she is one of those people who come across they can do the same job, for a lot less.

In these crazy times, that has a lot of sway and perhaps the Employer thought they could make up the lack of professional support with their own in house training?

Whatever the reason is, I doubt they are going to tell you anymore and if Debbie finds out you are digging about it, assuming she was sneaky about this, she will cover her tracks with the Employer. It's probably better if you don't end up working together down the track.

Frustrating for you all the same.!

Obimumkinobi · 17/02/2021 20:44

I think Debbie had a clear conflict of interest, which she did not declare. This is unethical and inappropriate behaviour for a mentor.

Sure, it's not OP's job to exclusively apply for but she should have been made aware her so-called mentor had, or was going to apply for it.

I have to say, I do think all the PPs criticising OP's 'attitude' need to be a bit more compassionate. She's come her to sound off and it's a forum not a job interview.

SoulofanAggron · 17/02/2021 20:44

@fcekinghell If you are so superior a candidate than you need to ask them for feedback.

And I still think after 2 years she was no longer your mentor. I assume the mentoring would have a set beginning and end or be routinely reassessed and resumed. Unless it's a more informal arrangement I guess, informally giving hints and tips. If she genuinely is still officially your mentor (you originally pretty much claimed she was just a friend now) then you should report it to whoever organizes the mentoring scheme, as it was a conflict of interest in a way for her to look over your application for something she was already applying for.

If she is really your mentor, why were you calling her a friend on here? Confused I think you have issues with relating to people. This maybe came across at interview. I have ASD traits so I understand what it can be like...that might be something that's worth you looking into, to give a generous explanation.

(I still think she did find out about the job via you BTW maybe.)

You don't know that she 'lied' on the application about being in the professional bodies etc. It could be that for some reason her listing isn't up but she is a member. Some sites let you keep it confidential in case you don't want it listed for whatever reason.

I don't think she copied your work, I'm sure she's capable of making her own application.

How do you know Debbie didn't review the OPs application and then a few days or a week later look at the job advert again and decided to go for it?

@Buccanarab That's a good point.