Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

friend got job she knew I wanted

833 replies

fcekinghell · 17/02/2021 17:39

It may be my own stupid fault, lesson learned but anyway.

I have an industry mentor. Mentors were being offered to people in my field about 2 years ago and I put myself forward as a means to widen my network, find out about new opportunities etc, especially as I wasn't happy where I was at the time.

I got assigned to a woman I will call Debbie. We had a few Zoom calls, emails etc where she gave me some tips and advice on how to move into employers like her own.

For the record, I am more qualified and experienced than Debbie but wanted a mentor to help me into that kind of employer. Debbie told me to keep her posted on my job hunting. Offered to help with my CV and interview skills if I needed it.

Well I got made redundant in Covid. Debbie still working where she is. Then my dream job came up. I excitedly told Debbie, telling her its my dream job. I did the application and asked Debbie what she thought, was there anything missing. She told me it was 'perfect' and 'good luck'.

Well, I didn't get the job. They said they might recruit later in the year and they'll let me know. I've now heard that Debbie got the job.

It feels like a real kick in the stomach. She was my mentor. She knew this was my dream job and jobs like this don't come up often. In fact, really rarely. She knew I was unemployed whilst she was still working. Plus this job is asking for a particular skill which I do not believe she has.

DH and my DM are telling me I am a fucking idiot for speaking to her. I am aren't I? I probably gave her all the answers too!

I'm so upset Sad Sad Angry Angry

OP posts:
SchrodingersImmigrant · 17/02/2021 22:40

I really wish Debbie appeared tbh. I would be very curious to hear what arrangements these actually were.

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 17/02/2021 22:39

No conflict of interest. Only op expectation and entitlement

10KaDay · 17/02/2021 22:38

@fcekinghell

I know she got the job cause she updated her LinkedIn

I sent her a LinkedIn message saying "well done, I didn't know you were also applying" to which she replied "thanks, good luck in your continued job hunt"

No acknowledgement that she looked over my application, no acknowledgement that she never told me, no apology, just kind of rubbing it in that I am still looking.

I tried to be professional in my reply but I think she's being even more of a bitch. AIBU?

I would be more accepting of her getting the role if she'd just been honest. Okay I may be unfair on the qualifications and experience aspect but my anger and upset is probably getting the better of me.

@fcekinghell: I think she’s a bitch! She absolutely should have told you there was a conflict of interest...

That said, play it cool, you never know she may still be a useful contact in future in a small industry/make no enemies . I’ve competed against friends/colleagues and ALWAYS cross paths with old colleagues when I move roles so you need to (eventually) pick yourself up and slap a smile on

I would never, if employed, tell someone in my industry I was applying for a job (apart from 1-2 really trusted friends including my 1st boss who really is a mentor), so I understand her not telling you that, but she should have made an excuse not to see your application

This is also why mentors/mentees should have a difference in level, not be competing

Having been unemployed a couple of years ago, I personally wish you luck in your job search - and damn well contact this (underhand) woman next time you see something that interests you (unless she would tell friends?). She is unlikely to be looking now, and owes you one! Be all innocent when the time comes ...

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 22:38

@HappyHallie

When recruiting for a small team I have, and have known others to, choose to give the job to an applicant who was second best technically but who we felt would get on better with the team.

So there's one of the many reasons they could have chosen her instead of you.

Good point.
HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 17/02/2021 22:38

Op you fundamentally misunderstood what a mentor is
And it’s confusing all the fangirls who are bumming on about girl code,ethics,morality. Because they don’t understand either

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 22:37

@BoomBoomsCousin

I think she behaved appallingly to let you talk to her about your application without letting you know you were in competition with her. She is not your friend and not much of a mentor - a relationship that needs trust.

But, you can't expect someone in your industry to sit back and not go for a job they want once they've heard about it. It's a risk with a mentor who isn't rungs higher up the food chain you. Even if she hears about the job through you it's unreasonable to expect her to put her career ambitions on hold just because she's volunteered to help you out. She's probably mentoring in part to increase her network too.

It sucks, OP. And I'm sorry you lost out on your dream job. Try and pick yourself up and dust yourself down and get back in there. Maybe finding someone different to mentor you.

Also, while assuming she lied about her experience isn't totally unreasonable given she was happy to lie by omission to you, it's probably not the healthiest assumption to make about why you didn't get the job. When everything smarts a little less (but don't leave it too long), asking for feedback or a chat from someone on the interviewing panel might be constructive, if they'll give it.

Debbie wasn't her mentor. OP is using that word but that's not what happened

A conversation about clients in Debbie's field is not mentoring. It was just a contact in a related area.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 22:36

Looking at her CV and wishing her well without disclosing that she is also going for the job, is also not ethical.

I disagree.

I have said that, personally, I'd have told OP.

But Debbie isn't wrong. It's absolutely her choice.

She had no informal or formal mentoring arrangement with OP, whatever OP thinks. She absolutely was under no obligation, ethical or otherwise, to tell OP.

BoomBoomsCousin · 17/02/2021 22:35

I think she behaved appallingly to let you talk to her about your application without letting you know you were in competition with her. She is not your friend and not much of a mentor - a relationship that needs trust.

But, you can't expect someone in your industry to sit back and not go for a job they want once they've heard about it. It's a risk with a mentor who isn't rungs higher up the food chain you. Even if she hears about the job through you it's unreasonable to expect her to put her career ambitions on hold just because she's volunteered to help you out. She's probably mentoring in part to increase her network too.

It sucks, OP. And I'm sorry you lost out on your dream job. Try and pick yourself up and dust yourself down and get back in there. Maybe finding someone different to mentor you.

Also, while assuming she lied about her experience isn't totally unreasonable given she was happy to lie by omission to you, it's probably not the healthiest assumption to make about why you didn't get the job. When everything smarts a little less (but don't leave it too long), asking for feedback or a chat from someone on the interviewing panel might be constructive, if they'll give it.

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 17/02/2021 22:34

You reek of entitlement op.If you’re that much a shoe in,you’d have got the job.
You didn’t. The other candidate clearly has what the employer wants
Stop all the griping,crack on and stop being a sore loser

Don’t be jollied along by the mn fan girls. It’s platitudes and misplaced ire

You need to move on now

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 22:34

She was advising me on her customer group really as it was one of the options for future career paths for me

And again, if this is what she was doing, she was not a mentor.

Not in any way, shape or form.

If you had such superior experience & qualifications to her, surely you would have been the preferred candidate.

ScreamingBeans · 17/02/2021 22:33

@EarringsandLipstick

But I don't know how anyone can think Debbie behaved ethically in continuing to mentor the OP around a situation in which she had a personal conflict of interest.

She didn't mentor OP. OP is using that term v v loosely, and it doesn't fit any recognised definition of mentoring.

She looked at her CV and wished her well. There was no continuation - she wasn't mentoring her at all to start with.

Looking at her CV and wishing her well without disclosing that she is also going for the job, is also not ethical.

Having a technical reason why you haven't done anything wrong, isn't the same as having an ethical approach to relationships and professional behaviour.

HappyHallie · 17/02/2021 22:33

When recruiting for a small team I have, and have known others to, choose to give the job to an applicant who was second best technically but who we felt would get on better with the team.

So there's one of the many reasons they could have chosen her instead of you.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 22:32

OP my sympathy is really waning now.

I simply do not believe she was hired with none of the relevant qualifications or experience. It's not plausible.

And now talking about how you've a greater entitlement due to your health conditions & having children. C'mon! That's not relevant at all.

For sure, you might have liked the job, it would have been helpful.

But you are sounding like a nightmare employee. I've come across applicants & employees like this, unbelievably entitled, with no idea of how they come across.

Lorw · 17/02/2021 22:30

Maybe they just liked her more OP. Can’t be helped unfortunately and you sound bitter. I say everything happens for a reason and so just wasn’t meant to be.

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 17/02/2021 22:30

Yet she still got the job

fcekinghell · 17/02/2021 22:27

@blitzen

That does sound gutting, OP. There's been a couple of times I've been wary of a similar situation panning out that way for me, at which point I made the decision never to discuss opportunities with anyone. Ever. Apart from dh, who takes the same approach in his career. However, I think your mentor did a shitty thing morally, by looking over your application. She could have said she was too busy even, if she didn't want to say she had gone for it. Have you heard from them since?

Also, just to say, I am a mentor for someone who almost has the same level of qualification but who has about 15 years + more experience than me. Luckily our paths are sufficiently divergent so we won't ever go for the same role, although we are broadly in a similar sector. So it is possible to have a mentor who is not necessarily more senior, for the pps who have assumed so.

yes this is kind of what our mentoring relationship is like.

we work in the same industry with similar qualifications but with different customers.

I have 20 years experience with this customer group. She has none. She was advising me on her customer group really as it was one of the options for future career paths for me.

The job we both went for was asking for qualifications, industry body membership and experience with this client group. I have all of this, she does not. She has the minimum qualification,I have the highest.

The job was home based. She does not have any children or health conditions. I have both children and health conditions.

So there are lots of reasons why I am so pissed off really.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 22:21

@WineIsMyMainVice

OP has said that Debbie's job is filled but in any case, is nowhere near where OP lives.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 22:20

@Mrsmadevans

I was always under the impression that employers prefer giving the post to employed applicants .
That's daft.

OP had been employed till recently. Any decent employer will give the job to the candidate that performs best on the day.

WineIsMyMainVice · 17/02/2021 22:19

@Wearywithteens

On a positive note - Debbie’s old job will be up for grabs?
Could this maybe an opportunity op?

This situation must feel awful.

Good luck

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2021 22:19

But I don't know how anyone can think Debbie behaved ethically in continuing to mentor the OP around a situation in which she had a personal conflict of interest.

She didn't mentor OP. OP is using that term v v loosely, and it doesn't fit any recognised definition of mentoring.

She looked at her CV and wished her well. There was no continuation - she wasn't mentoring her at all to start with.

SoulofanAggron · 17/02/2021 22:19

The discussions they had about this job would have helped Debbie

@SixesAndEights ot necessarily. If she 'is' OP's mentor she presumably knows a bit about relevant stuff (although of course OP is far superior.)

It's entirely possible this role was advertised other places OP doesn't know about. Its possible Debbie was approached by an agency on the company's behalf because they found her cv online/linkedin/she is known in the industry/ word of mouth

Good points.

@fcekinghell You could ask her, but I wouldn't trust her again. As you excel above her in every way, you don't need her as a mentor anymore.

I tried to be professional in my reply but I think she's being even more of a bitch. AIBU?

YABU. I think she was just being polite. But I wouldn't bother with her anymore. You thought she was a friend (so you said at first) but she isn't particularly. She anwered you very formally.

blitzen · 17/02/2021 22:17

That does sound gutting, OP. There's been a couple of times I've been wary of a similar situation panning out that way for me, at which point I made the decision never to discuss opportunities with anyone. Ever. Apart from dh, who takes the same approach in his career. However, I think your mentor did a shitty thing morally, by looking over your application. She could have said she was too busy even, if she didn't want to say she had gone for it. Have you heard from them since?

Also, just to say, I am a mentor for someone who almost has the same level of qualification but who has about 15 years + more experience than me. Luckily our paths are sufficiently divergent so we won't ever go for the same role, although we are broadly in a similar sector. So it is possible to have a mentor who is not necessarily more senior, for the pps who have assumed so.

Mrsmadevans · 17/02/2021 22:15

I was always under the impression that employers prefer giving the post to employed applicants .

ScreamingBeans · 17/02/2021 22:13

YABU about Debbie getting the job.

But I don't know how anyone can think Debbie behaved ethically in continuing to mentor the OP around a situation in which she had a personal conflict of interest.

Astonishing that so many people think this is acceptable, it really isn't.

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 17/02/2021 22:13

Utter rot

Swipe left for the next trending thread