Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

friend got job she knew I wanted

833 replies

fcekinghell · 17/02/2021 17:39

It may be my own stupid fault, lesson learned but anyway.

I have an industry mentor. Mentors were being offered to people in my field about 2 years ago and I put myself forward as a means to widen my network, find out about new opportunities etc, especially as I wasn't happy where I was at the time.

I got assigned to a woman I will call Debbie. We had a few Zoom calls, emails etc where she gave me some tips and advice on how to move into employers like her own.

For the record, I am more qualified and experienced than Debbie but wanted a mentor to help me into that kind of employer. Debbie told me to keep her posted on my job hunting. Offered to help with my CV and interview skills if I needed it.

Well I got made redundant in Covid. Debbie still working where she is. Then my dream job came up. I excitedly told Debbie, telling her its my dream job. I did the application and asked Debbie what she thought, was there anything missing. She told me it was 'perfect' and 'good luck'.

Well, I didn't get the job. They said they might recruit later in the year and they'll let me know. I've now heard that Debbie got the job.

It feels like a real kick in the stomach. She was my mentor. She knew this was my dream job and jobs like this don't come up often. In fact, really rarely. She knew I was unemployed whilst she was still working. Plus this job is asking for a particular skill which I do not believe she has.

DH and my DM are telling me I am a fucking idiot for speaking to her. I am aren't I? I probably gave her all the answers too!

I'm so upset Sad Sad Angry Angry

OP posts:
IWentAwayIStayedAway · 18/02/2021 07:41

I wonder is there a way to alert professional bodies re the job and that the employer has recruited someone not on their list? I recruit on a regular basis and if that requirement was an essential on the job description she has lied. She should not have been shortlisted. Or another query to HR re the essential criteria? Or is membership something she could do now and 'rejoin'. Very annoying for you but something better is just around the corner

KatherineJaneway · 18/02/2021 07:20

While Debbie is under no obligation to tell you what jobs she has applied for, she was unprofessional to review your application while applying for the same role.

Either Debbie lied about her skills and experience, which will come out soon enough if the skill was so key to the role that it couldn't be done without it, or she had something else they wanted.

Five67Eight · 18/02/2021 07:20

I’m really sorry @fcekinghell - that all sounds shit.

Posting on here when you’re genuinely upset about something is rarely a good idea.

I hope you haven’t been too upset by some of these uninsightful posts, from people deliberately not getting it. I feel if you had his conversation with real people in real life, you’d’ve had a much kinder response. Flowers

fcekinghell · 18/02/2021 07:12

I didn't sleep too well.
I've always been too trusting and and too nice. I do always try to see the good in people. So this experience really threw me.
Yesterday I was so mad and hurt, it just all came out as a big rant here on Mumsnet as its anonymous here.
Last year was so horrible, it left me suicidal. Covid bereavements, horrible job, health problems, then redundancy.
I confided all of that in her and her role was not just to help me explore other potential jobs / career paths, but to build my confidence.
I really wanted something home based as I do not want to work in a bitchy office environment again. There aren't many home based roles in our industry. In fact this is the only one I've seen in a long time!
If she's no longer a member of our professional body, I can't really report her. Her new employer may not be happy if she's not and maybe I could alert them, but what would be in it for me really?
All I can really do is learn from the experience and continue job searching and keep my mouth shut in future about my job search.

OP posts:
bombastical · 18/02/2021 05:47

Well it’s obvious she’s a)lied about her qualifications b) used your application and improved on it for her own c) thrown you under the bus by saying she’s your mentor

Lodge a complaint with their HR. You have an industry code of conduct. Isn’t it wise to let them know they have a dishonest staff member? If it was me I’d say that you feel she’s been dishonest and breached confidentiality. She shouldn’t have reviewed your application and given advice on it if she was applying for the same role. It’s pretty shitty behaviour. Let them know!

readingismycardio · 18/02/2021 05:30

@Andylion

*Yes it is, and if she had any decency she should have disclosed to you that she was interested too and took a step back from reviewing your application, as it’s a big conflict. I think the replies on here are very harsh.*

I agree with this.

This with bells on!
MyNameIsFiveSpice · 18/02/2021 04:39

@fcekinghell I think you both sounded professional, but you probably feel hurt so you’re misreading her message.

Op, are you 100% sure that the job vacancy was only listed on the company website? The vacancy might have appeared elsewhere on a job site? If not, then more likely then not “Debbie” probably did come across the vacancy after hearing about it from you.

Having said that, aside from not disclosing that she has applied for the same vacancy or told you after viewing your application, in which she should not have reviewed your CV/application, I don’t know what else she’s done wrong. Someone upthread mentioned that “Debbie” could have disclosed that she was mentoring you which will make the interviewer/future employer think she might be somehow better than you if you were mentored by someone not as qualified or experienced as you. Do you think that that can be a remote possibility?

Do be careful because in a niche field word does spread. This can impact you in a profound way so do maintain a professional persona and now you’ve disclosed this matter to two people, and they’ve sympathised so do not speak of it further to anyone else unless they’re a trusted friend who is not part of your chosen field of work and will never work in that sort of field. Also, whilst they might have sympathized about the code of conduct etc, you don’t want to come across as bitter and entitled.

For some reason, it doesn’t effect men as much but when a woman has a lot of knowledge, relevant experience and qualifications etc, it is not always seen as confidence because usually for a woman it is misinterpreted as reeking of entitlement and evokes a a general feeling that you are looking down on others.

Another thing that I’d like to point out is that you are convinced that she has less experience than you or not as many qualifications, but she’s received tips from you and you’ve also sent her helpful links etc over the years. Maybe that also helped her? She might not be as unqualified/inexperienced as you think? It also shows that she’s willing to learn skills and gain qualifications in her own free time for her professional development. Moreover, she might be on a lower end of the pay scale if she doesn’t meet the full criteria which could be an incentive for a prospective employer.

Perhaps, seeing your application may have given her an edge so she could amp up her strengths and any weaknesses on your application/CV, she could use that to her advantage and show how she possesses xyz that you might lack. This might not be lying, some people blag do get a job and then they’re quickly found out in the probationary period or they learn quickly on the job. It’s precisely why she should not have reviewed your application, even if it was just a cursory glance.

Ilady · 18/02/2021 04:32

I can understand why your upset over what happened re Debbie applying for the same job as you. When you asked her to look at your CV or application form she should have told you she could not do this because she was applying for the same job.
I would contact the employer and ask for some feedback re the job your applied for and say if anything was to come up with them in the future you would be interested.
My feeling is that Debbie could have done a great interview but her employer might find out that she is not as good at the job as they thought. I have worked with people like this and given time they can and do fuck up. They will say or do the wrong thing or cause hassle with co workers and have the potential to become a bosses nightmare.
The reality for Debbie now is that she has to perform to a high level from day one of this job. She probably has to join a professional body and possibly catch up cpd courses. She has to get through a probation period also.
You might see the job she has now come up at some time in the future.
I know how you feel as I have been their regarding job rejections. Down the line I found out about the long hours, lack of bonuses, the horrible way staff were treated and more than once companies that rejected me had major staff culls and some closed permanently.
I know since covid came it caused a lot of problems for people but at least now vaccines are here and things will improve.
Sometimes things happen for a reason and you can't see why at the time but in time you realise that your in a better position than you ever thought.
Good luck with the job hunting and be very careful who you tell in the future about your plans.

steff13 · 18/02/2021 04:28

If she had already applied when the OP asked her to review the application, it wouldn't have mattered.

kittycorner · 18/02/2021 04:20

@fcekinghell it sounds so disappointing. I'm sorry this happened, I can see why you are upset.

Having said that, you have to remember it was never your job in the first place. I know it feels like it, but she can't not apply because you have dc and a health condition and she doesn't. You also don't know about her life in detail, who knows what she has on her plate.

Hold your head high. You didn't do anything wrong. Life has strange ways of working out. I had a line manager who was very jealous of me and took opportunities away from me, and then weeks later, I was promoted and she had to report one branch/department of her work to me.

You never know where life will take either of you. Wishing you the best of luck.

whatwherewhywhenhow · 18/02/2021 03:45

She’s not a friend, she was a mentor.

She behaved unethically by not advising you of her conflict and that she couldn’t review your application.

It’s possible she didn’t have a conflict until after she reviewed your application and then decided to apply. But you’ll never know the sequence of events.

It’s disappointing but you have no choice but to get over it, and never trust her again.

RantyAnty · 18/02/2021 03:10

Unfortunately, there is nothing fair or ethical about work.

People you work with aren't your friends, don't gossip, maintain a poker face, and always hold your cards close to your chest.

Five67Eight · 18/02/2021 02:28

@Sapho47

Unless Debbie sabotaged the ops cv though she doesn't have any ability to influence the outcome
Except for the fact that - unlike everyone else who applied - Debbie got a good old squizz at the CV of an applicant who had ideal skills and experience for the role....
Ariela · 18/02/2021 02:17

I would swallow my bitterness for now. If Debbie has not got the right industry experience and memberships, will she flounder in her new post?
If so her new employers might look to replace.
So I'd maybe look at thanking the potential employer for the interview, expressing the fact if a further job opportunity arises you'd love to hear from them and finding out why you were not the best candidate from the employer, and work on that feedback to improve, while continuing to look for other work.

BoomBoomsCousin · 18/02/2021 02:14

@EarringsandLipstick

"But every post is implying (and more) that Debbie got an unfair advantage by seeing the OP's CV, by getting the 'answers', that she hadn't the right qualifications, she's a bitch, she didn't deserve it as she's no children or health conditions."

"That's the part that reflects so badly on OP."

"I'd have said, if I were Debbie, but I'm making the point that she didn't have to and OP is in the wrong to be so vicious about her, instead of examining how she can improve."

I said in my first post (the one you responded to to tell tell me how wrong I'd got it because, in your opinion, Debbie couldn't be called a mentor) that the OP needs to look further afield for the reason she didn't get the job.

At the moment OP is venting about what is, to her, a break in trust and dealing with the huge disappointment of not getting a job she really, really wanted. Which is a raw position to be in and her response is pretty normal. In a few days when the disappointment isn't so sharp she may be able to look more rationally at the situation. If, at that point, she continues to focus the blame for her not getting the job on Debbie, it might reflect badly on her. At the moment the harsh comments to OP just reflect badly those posters.

Sapho47 · 18/02/2021 02:10

Unless Debbie sabotaged the ops cv though she doesn't have any ability to influence the outcome

Five67Eight · 18/02/2021 02:02

Really? If you were mentoring someone and they come in and say "I've found this great new job opening can you help me apply?" You don't think it would be a little demotivating to them to say you had already applied.

It’s far more demotivating to be lied to, and to find out after the event. Confused

Anyone with an ounce of professional sensibility would be upfront about the conflict of interest. ‘I’m applying for the job too - do you still want me to review your application?’

But this is typical Mumsnet - people rushing to try to appear completely objective and detached or something, and throwing the baby out with the bath water.

Would those of you defending Debbie actually do what she did?

Again OP - I hope you find a job soon.

Providora · 18/02/2021 01:52

Really? If you were mentoring someone and they come in and say "I've found this great new job opening can you help me apply?" You don't think it would be a little demotivating to them to say you had already applied.

Well the OP seems pretty demoralised by the 'say nothing' approach!

I would let them know I'd be happy to help, but let them know I'm interested too so they can decide themselves whether or not they want to share details of the job, or their application, with a potential rival. It may be demoralising, but it's the ethical thing to do.

JanuaryJonez · 18/02/2021 01:52

A friend of mine started a company a decade ago coaching people in how to do pitches. He's done amazingly well.

THE most important thing he tells clients is that it's imperative that you just get on with your clients - your pitch might not be perfect but if you have the ability to form a relationship with them then something good may come from that.

Bluenightowl · 18/02/2021 01:04

You don't think it would be a little demotivating to them to say you had already applied.

I wouldn't find it demotivating to be given the heads up and I would be happy to be given the opportunity to refer my application to someone else rather than a fellow applicant.

But beyond that, I really don't think she did anything wrong

Beyond that? Debbie has been completely underhand and unprofessional. Under no circumstances should she have reviewed the OP's application in her capacity as mentor without disclosing that she was also applying for the role.

The number of people on this thread who admire Debbie is mindblowing and says a lot about themselves.

Sapho47 · 18/02/2021 00:45

@Providora

I can't think of any sort of personal or professional relationship where I would agree to read someone's CV without letting them know I was applying for the same job.

Regardless of whether this woman's a real mentor or not, regardless of what professional ethical standards say, etc etc, I think it's off and you are right to be upset about that.

I do think you have to let go of the other stuff, you're making this very personal and it's not a personal issue, it's business.

Really? If you were mentoring someone and they come in and say "I've found this great new job opening can you help me apply?" You don't think it would be a little demotivating to them to say you had already applied.
PumpkinPieAlibi · 18/02/2021 00:42

To add to the above, I do think the ethical thing to do would have been for Debbie to advise that she was also applying for the same role and maybe, decline the opportunity to review the application.

But beyond that, I really don't think she did anything wrong.

miraloma · 18/02/2021 00:42

Yup, many skills can be learned. Self awareness not so much.

PumpkinPieAlibi · 18/02/2021 00:40

The thing is, the CV and application only gets you a seat at the table. How you sell yourself on the day is the bigger issue.

Also, while qualifications and memberships are obviously hugely important, sometimes someone with say, a Bachelors degree and the right personality may be a better fit, for example, than a Chartered postgrad with not quite the attitude the company is looking for (whatever that may be).

It's about the whole picture really and finding the right 'fit'. For whatever reason, that was Debbie.

ConquestEmpireHungerPlague · 18/02/2021 00:36

I'm referring to the people who are coming back to the thread again and again just to pile a bit more hate on to the OP. I think it's weird to be so invested in being repeatedly nasty to someone who was upfront about how shit she's already feeling.

And actually no, @gnashingsalt, it just came out. Wink