Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

friend got job she knew I wanted

833 replies

fcekinghell · 17/02/2021 17:39

It may be my own stupid fault, lesson learned but anyway.

I have an industry mentor. Mentors were being offered to people in my field about 2 years ago and I put myself forward as a means to widen my network, find out about new opportunities etc, especially as I wasn't happy where I was at the time.

I got assigned to a woman I will call Debbie. We had a few Zoom calls, emails etc where she gave me some tips and advice on how to move into employers like her own.

For the record, I am more qualified and experienced than Debbie but wanted a mentor to help me into that kind of employer. Debbie told me to keep her posted on my job hunting. Offered to help with my CV and interview skills if I needed it.

Well I got made redundant in Covid. Debbie still working where she is. Then my dream job came up. I excitedly told Debbie, telling her its my dream job. I did the application and asked Debbie what she thought, was there anything missing. She told me it was 'perfect' and 'good luck'.

Well, I didn't get the job. They said they might recruit later in the year and they'll let me know. I've now heard that Debbie got the job.

It feels like a real kick in the stomach. She was my mentor. She knew this was my dream job and jobs like this don't come up often. In fact, really rarely. She knew I was unemployed whilst she was still working. Plus this job is asking for a particular skill which I do not believe she has.

DH and my DM are telling me I am a fucking idiot for speaking to her. I am aren't I? I probably gave her all the answers too!

I'm so upset Sad Sad Angry Angry

OP posts:
PumpkinPieAlibi · 18/02/2021 11:20

@Belladonna12 - I think you lack an understanding of how recruitment works in many industries. In my industry, someone who works in HR wouldn't have a clue whether a potential employee has the required skills. Obviously there would be people on the panel who do that even then it's not always that easy to work out who's lying.

I'm sorry the people in your industry are seemingly inefficient but I can guarantee you that the people in my workplace are very much aware of what is required. One of my colleagues has sat in an average of 20 interviews per week for over 10 years. I think she has a sense of what she's looking for. And if she doesn't, the subject matter experts with over 30 years experience in their specific fields certainly do.

And if someone has lied, it really isn't that difficult to work out if you know what you're looking. If someone applying for a job in Project Controls can't tell you what VOWD stands for, for eg, of course all the fancy stuff on their resume starts to look questionable.

It's actually quite insulting that you would suggest that people who have gained decades of experience in their fields would be unable to figure out if someone else is knowledgeable on the matter.

SteveBrexit · 18/02/2021 11:14

I confided all of that in her and her role was not just to help me explore other potential jobs / career paths, but to build my confidence.
I really wanted something home based as I do not want to work in a bitchy office environment again. There aren't many home based roles in our industry. In fact this is the only one I've seen in a long time

You might not have realised it, but this probably came across in your interview somehow.

Employers are not interested by what YOU bring to the job, not what the job brings to you. So Debbie probably just came across better, being more relax about the whole thing.

Belladonna12 · 18/02/2021 11:13

I agree with @SurvivalIsInsufficient that a lot of posters don't seem to understand how recruitment works. I worked in recruitment for over 6 years (I'm still in HR) and you can steal someone else's CV and lie about anything on your application but all it will do is get you to the interview stage as you would have ticked the right boxes. The real test is the interview and any recruiter with a brain WILL question you on the details on the CV as well as the Line manager.

I think you lack an understanding of how recruitment works in many industries. In my industry, someone who works in HR wouldn't have a clue whether a potential employee has the required skills. Obviously there would be people on the panel who do that even then it's not always that easy to work out who's lying.

SteveBrexit · 18/02/2021 11:03

If she's no longer a member of our professional body, I can't really report her. Her new employer may not be happy if she's not and maybe I could alert them, but what would be in it for me really?

why do you obsess over this?

You don't know what was said in the first place, and why do you insist the employers is unaware anyway?

I get you are making yourself feel better if you think Debbie got the job because she lied, but it's very likely she simply was a better fit.

I work in recruitment. I promise you a "sore loser" attitude is not something remotely attractive for employers. So feel free to rant with your partner and best friend for a couple of days, but then let it go and move on.

PumpkinPieAlibi · 18/02/2021 10:58

I agree with @SurvivalIsInsufficient that a lot of posters don't seem to understand how recruitment works. I worked in recruitment for over 6 years (I'm still in HR) and you can steal someone else's CV and lie about anything on your application but all it will do is get you to the interview stage as you would have ticked the right boxes. The real test is the interview and any recruiter with a brain WILL question you on the details on the CV as well as the Line manager. Having been in some very technical interviews (engineering and construction in the Energy industry), it becomes obvious very, very quickly when someone cannot back up what they wrote on their resume and is not technically sound. Additionally, while you may be technically proficient, under pressure certain aspects of your personality may come out. I have seen people who started the interview all smiles becomes very snappy and defensive if they feel insecure while being questioned. This is certainly picked up on by the interview panel

There are SO many reasons why it could not have worked out. Let's just say Debbie stole every word from OP's CV, she still had to prove herself in multiple interviews. If she's lacking all the things OP thinks she is, something would have come out somewhere. Recruiters and line managers do hundreds of interviews - they instinctively have a good sense of what they are looking for and the right fit for the role.

And what about references? For all we know, this could have been where OP's application feel down. We''ll never really know, will we? We just have to assume that the professionals know how to do their job and picked who they feel was the right match for the job, their company and the company culture.

Cas112 · 18/02/2021 10:56

You also need to remember the other factors employers take on board such as confidence, whether they will fit into the team/company, willingness to learn, strong work ethic, positive attitude, adaptability and motivation to grow and learn ect. They obviously think she's capable or they may have liked her that much that if she doesn't have this particular key skill you have talked about, they do think this is something she can develop whilst at the company. Their is so much more to interviewing and getting a job than just having the exact key skills they request, which is why interviews are needed. Just take it as this isn't the job for you and your perfect job is on the way.

AryaStarkWolf · 18/02/2021 10:49

She's not unreasonable for going for the job but she should have told you and not taken your CV etc, that was sneaky

fellrunner85 · 18/02/2021 10:46

I think a lot of people are placing too much emphasis on the application form.

The application form is essentially just your ticket to the interview. Then, at interview stage, candidates are judged on their performance and appointed accordingly.
Debbie seeing the OPs form will have had next to no impact on the recruitment process, in my experience, as the interview is what matters. These references to the OP "showing your hand" therefore demonstrate a pretty poor knowledge of how recruitment works. Debbie will have had to demonstrate her own abilities in interview, using examples from her own career. She can't have cribbed those from the OP's form.

I also think that, if the gulf in experience is as great as the OP believes, the panel went for Debbie based on her "soft" skills - strategic vision, negotiating skills, teamwork, influence, ability to see the bigger picture, blah blah blah. These are all skills the OP suggests she herself did not demonstrate, based on her absolute focus on the technical qualifications for the job.

I would always rather appoint the person who comes across as flexible, motivated and a good team player in interview - even if they might require some training - over the person who comes in, says "I can do this and I've done this for 20 years" and expects to be appointed on that alone.

SurvivalIsInsufficient · 18/02/2021 10:41

I've always been too trusting and and too nice. I do always try to see the good in people

Your posts very much suggest otherwise

Plutoh · 18/02/2021 10:40

@Belladonna12

n which case there'd be no conflict of interest. Debbie helped the OP with their application for a job she'd no idea about (and cleary Debbie's input didn't cause any problems as the OP got to the final interview) and then decided later she'd also like to apply to the post. Is she supposed to not apply for new opportunities because someone she knows is?

Yes she shouldn't apply for new opportunities if she only knows about them because she is a mentor. She is not supposed to use information from her mentees to their disadvantage which is what happened in this case. Not only did she only hear about the job from the OP but she also probably use the CV. It's easier to improve upon someone's else's draft than to start from scratch. Her behaviour was very unethical.

There is literally zero indication that Debbie used OPs CV, and it's unfair on OP to put them into her mind. Employers aren't stupid, they will know if a CV has been copied, plus, a lot is relating to previous jobs, I doubt Debbie copied those.
SurvivalIsInsufficient · 18/02/2021 10:39

Not only did she only hear about the job from the OP but she also probably use the CV.

You don't know where she heard about the job (neither does OP) and its highly unlikely she used the CV of someone unemployed who she was mentoring. What use would it be to her?

I don't think some of you know how recruitment works. Debbie did nothing wrong here. OP, on the other hand....

Washimal · 18/02/2021 10:37

Not only did she only hear about the job from the OP but she also probably use the CV.

There is no evidence for this! These are things OP believes, not facts.

Washimal · 18/02/2021 10:35

I certainly wouldn’t contact the employer - they would think the OP is nuts!

Completely agree with this.

Those egging OP on, agreeing that Debbie is a "bitch" and making claims about "discrimination" etc are not helping by fueling the fire. OP has described her industry as being very niche, but she has already admitted to sounding off to a couple of colleagues about Debbie and will be lucky if this doesn't get back to her. If she goes round kicking up a fuss, making formal complaints, claiming that Debbie only found out about the job from her (she has no proof of this), used her application to improve her own (no proof of this either) and that she is more qualified and a better fit for the role than Debbie (this is OP's opinion, which was clearly not shared by the panel at interview) then she risks embarrassing herself and damaging her future prospects in the industry.

We have no idea why Debbie got the job and OP didn't. OP's assessment of her own skills and experience being far superior may or may not be accurate. There are a lot of inconsistencies and things that don't really add up but one thing that is very clear is OP's has had a difficult time and holding onto her anger at Debbie isn't going to do her any good. It also isn't going to help her secure another job as there are few things more off-putting to recruiters than when people come across as resentful of the success of others and unwilling to admit that they may have areas for improvement.

Belladonna12 · 18/02/2021 10:28

n which case there'd be no conflict of interest. Debbie helped the OP with their application for a job she'd no idea about (and cleary Debbie's input didn't cause any problems as the OP got to the final interview) and then decided later she'd also like to apply to the post. Is she supposed to not apply for new opportunities because someone she knows is?

Yes she shouldn't apply for new opportunities if she only knows about them because she is a mentor. She is not supposed to use information from her mentees to their disadvantage which is what happened in this case. Not only did she only hear about the job from the OP but she also probably use the CV. It's easier to improve upon someone's else's draft than to start from scratch. Her behaviour was very unethical.

flyingant · 18/02/2021 10:26

It's fair enough that she went for the same job as you and and got it. She obviously ticked more boxes than you. It doesn't seem very underhand that she looked at your application without telling you though. You were basically unknowingly showing your hand to the opposition, and I get that must hurt.

Bluenightowl · 18/02/2021 10:24

It was fair game

Are you routinely given fellow applicant’s application forms before you are interviewed?
It absolutely was not fair game. Give your head a wobble!

LadyCatStark · 18/02/2021 10:13

It was fair game. You both had an interview and she came our top. Plus she’s not really a friend, she’s a mentor.

IrmaFayLear · 18/02/2021 10:02

I certainly wouldn’t contact the employer - they would think the OP is nuts!

I feel for OP and the term “snake” which a pp used seems very apt for Debbie. It’s a salutary lesson in keeping one’s cards close to one’s chest.

However, they chose Debbie. On a banal level, it’s like confessing to a mate you fancy Dave. You talk all about Dave. You plot together to get Dave to ask you out. And then you find that your mate has snuck in there and is now going out with Dave. But, when all’s said and done, Dave preferred your mate. Tant pis.

Buccanarab · 18/02/2021 09:57

There's absolutely no evidence to suggest Debbie had already applied for the job before reviewing the OPs application. In fact the OP was quite adamant that Debbie had no idea about the job until the OP had mentioned it to her.

In which case there'd be no conflict of interest. Debbie helped the OP with their application for a job she'd no idea about (and cleary Debbie's input didn't cause any problems as the OP got to the final interview) and then decided later she'd also like to apply to the post. Is she supposed to not apply for new opportunities because someone she knows is?

The OPs quite clear she only made contact with Debbie at the beginning to broaded her own career options by learning about Debbie's area of work. It's a bit two faced to have no issue gleaning as much information as you can from someone to help your career but then moaning that they learn about a job from you.

TheKeatingFive · 18/02/2021 09:56

Plus side of this you may get the job instead.

Honestly, this is stupid advice. They’re not going to give her the job because she shops their chosen candidate.

There is so much the OP doesn’t know about how the team came to the decision they did. She risks looking like an utter tit going down this road.

If Debbie IS as terrible a fit for the job as the OP believes, it’ll come out in the wash eventually and she’ll get another crack at it.

fellrunner85 · 18/02/2021 09:54

OP, I deal with senior recruitment a lot, and all your posts have illustrated to me exactly why you didn't get the job.

You need to be thinking what Debbie has that you don't, and how you can work on that before your next interview, rather than focusing on your own assumptions about her experience compared to yours.

GinAndTonicOnIt · 18/02/2021 09:47

It does sound like Debbie was ethically very much in the wrong Sad

I'm so sorry OP. I think you've learnt a (very painful) lesson here. BUT Debbie is a dick, and I do think it will all come out in the end. I think you have two options:

  1. You could try to let the employer of the new role know what happened. This will only really work if you have your correspondence in writing and she has actually broken ethical protocol.
Plus side of this you may get the job instead. Downside you may not get the job and they may think you sound bitter/hard work.
  1. Accept Debbie has the role, and hope that further roles come up in the future and apply for those. She may be crap at the role because she may have twisted the truth in her interview...
Plus side: you remain squeaky clean and the bigger person in all respects Down side is another post may not come up.

I'd be tempted to do no.1 if these posts are so rare to come up...

BrownEyedBlonde · 18/02/2021 09:43

My only thought is that Debbie should have disclosed to you that she was applying for the same job. I think it’s wrong that she was able to look over your application while going for it herself. Sneaky!

Belladonna12 · 18/02/2021 09:38

I think that people encouraging OP to report to profession bodies/HR/The Pope/whoever are not doing OP any favours
Debbie got the job and anything OP tries to do now will reflect badly on her even if Debbie gets the fall out as well. OP will not get this job now no matter what she does and that’s a real shame but she needs to move on and keep looking for a job. That’s not her job, never was.

I agree that when there is no point reporting to HR or a professional body. Whoever is organising the mentor scheme should probably know about it though as it sounds like things need to be tightened up so this kind of thing doesn't happen again.

Belladonna12 · 18/02/2021 09:37

I think that people encouraging OP to report to profession bodies/HR/The Pope/whoever are not doing OP any favours
Debbie got the job and anything OP tries to do now will reflect badly on her even if Debbie gets the fall out as well. OP will not get this job now no matter what she does and that’s a real shame but she needs to move on and keep looking for a job. That’s not her job, never was.

I agree that when there is no point reporting to HR or a professional body. Whoever is organising the mentor scheme should probably know about it though as it sounds like things need to be tightened up so this kind of thing doesn't happen again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread