Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why marriage before children is so important?

187 replies

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 13:02

Excuse my ignorance on this but time and time again I see comments from people on MN’s telling people not to have a child with somebody before marriage - comments I see are along the lines of ‘it’s so risky’ , ‘leaving yourself open’ ‘asking for disaster’

I might just be really naive but can somebody please explain the risks involved?

Myself and DP are TTC now, and all these comments are making me really uneasy, should I genuinely be worried?
We were due to get married this year and then the plan was to start ttc but we have postpone the wedding due to COVID and didn’t want to postpone having a baby too. Should I genuinely get be worried about this? And get married first?

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 16/02/2021 13:46

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-7334313/amp/I-never-felt-marriage-important-day-Paolo-died.html

Daily mail link but explains reality of situation for lady who was engaged when her boyfriend died leaving her with a toddler.

BlueLionel · 16/02/2021 13:45

I'm about to have a baby, and we aren't married. Partner wants to marry. I don't.

I am financially secure by myself, and have large equity in my house. I don't want to give this up at this stage. In another 5 years or so when he is in a different financial position, we want to buy together, and at this point I might change my mind about marriage as I know it is improper at to him. As it stands he contributes towards bills and food, but I carry the bulk of the financial responsibility, including a car loan we both pay for but in my name. It comes with risks and benefits - if I kicked him out he could technically have no claim on the car, but equally if he walked away, I have a car I cannot afford on my own and would have to surrender.

I don't think anything is ever as black and white as "you are better if you are married"

Elbels · 16/02/2021 13:43

It's an interesting question because we're in a similar position (wedding cancelled / probably need to try and see if we can have children in the meantime as I'm not young). However in our scenario I'm the higher owner, own more of the house and have more savings so potentially it's in my interest not to get married!

HeidiHaughton · 16/02/2021 13:43

Maybe if we were like France, with one standard secular state mandated ceremony for all to get married, people would be more willing to do it? And then the expectation of a 'big day' would be reduced as everyone would be married rather than having 'a wedding' no matter what they did after the ceremony. Only people who really wanted a church fuss would have it.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/02/2021 13:42

I would never have children unmarried.
All you can do is know the differences and make decision that best fits you.
There’s a good link about differences on CAB website.
A married woman’s husband is assumed to be father and has parental rights from birth. Your boyfriend won’t have parental responsibility for baby unless you name him on birth certificate. Not usually an issue but if you die in childbirth or before birth registered he’d have to go to court to be child’s father. I personally wouldn’t like not to be legal parent of my child with no right to consent to treatment for them etc but lots of men seem happy with this.
You die or become ill you are not each other’s next of kin. Families can be odd - you’d have no recourse if next of kin wanted to arrange funeral, exclude you etc.
No entitlement to bereavement support payments - not a huge amount but would pay for funeral and give you income whilst you get back on your feet (only widows/widowers qualify)
Unmarried partners are best viewed as a flat mate - so no obligation to support each other financially. That obviously suits some people. Where is usually goes wrong is woman gives up job/goes part time, lives in his house and then when split up is entitled to nothing.

mum2bin2021 · 16/02/2021 13:41

Having grown up around carnage (mum had me very young and subsequently got into a DV relationship with someone else for many years) I swore I'd be married before having kids. This is an extra level of security for me and shows me that my partner has no commitment issues before taking the biggest step there is and having a baby. Without marriage, there's no real security there with you and your child and as harsh as this is, relationships are a lot easier to get out of than marriages. I wanted to be 100% sure that I had done everything within my power to give my child the most secure possible start as that's what I craved as a kid. I don't understand why women are so blasé about getting pregnant without marriage/a serious long term relationship first. A child is the biggest commitment there is and should be absolutely considered as such.

2bazookas · 16/02/2021 13:39

Having as baby together is, or should be, a huge mutual commitment . That for the next 20 years, you will both be parenting and emotionally and financially supporting that child. To take that on you need to know the other person inside out, know what their values and ambitions are, trust them.

 "The wedding" has nothing whatever to do with what marriage (and parenthood) is really about.
1990shopefulftm · 16/02/2021 13:38

For me it was that dad died when I was a kid and them not being married made probate and getting his medical records harder as they weren't married. I m going to be a stay at home mum once my mat leaves over and us being married means we can get marriage tax allowance and our will covers most things but it would make it easier if something happened although I would say you need a will and life insurance regardless of being married or not.

iguanadonna · 16/02/2021 13:33

A lot of the above doesn't apply to you. You're not slipping into cohabitation and parenting without talking about plans, commitment, a shared sense of the future. You're planning to get a legal contract securing your rights as soon as restrictions allow a celebration at the same time.

Hankunamatata · 16/02/2021 13:32

If not married then protect yourself legally. Make sure you have name on deeds of a house. Dont share bank accounts - I'm not a fan anyway of this even after 18 years married. Make sure you have a private pension if not working or working pt that has decent contributions going in each months. Get wills written. Have clear plans if one or both of you pass away.

BridgertonBunkUp · 16/02/2021 13:30

Marriage affords some degree of financial security and a cushion against the blow your earning potential may take due to maternity leave/being the main carer etc.

No, that won’t be a problem for some women, but for many it will.

Equally important is to make sure you are both on the mortgage if you own a property and to keep your foot in the world of work.

I have seen SO many women I know left in vulnerable positions through not being married (especially when they’ve been SAHM or had low paid, part time jobs) when they break up with their ‘lovely’ DP years down the line and realise they don’t have any rights to property, pensions, assets etc.

Merryoldgoat · 16/02/2021 13:27

you’ll only be entitled to a share of the family home if you’re married

I meant to say IF you’re not on the deeds.

MissingLinker · 16/02/2021 13:26

@ThatDoesntBelongInAIBU

I was going to say it’s beneficial for a child to grow up seeing a stable and committed relationship, but apparently it’s all about money.
Marriage does not ensure that couples stay together. It does ensure that those two people have financial obligations and legal protections.
Merryoldgoat · 16/02/2021 13:26

@ThatDoesntBelongInAIBU

I was going to say it’s beneficial for a child to grow up seeing a stable and committed relationship, but apparently it’s all about money.
Stable and committed relationships happen outside of marriage.

I like being married and I’m happy to be married but I might not have bothered if I didn’t want children because all of the compromises that having children bring make the security of marriage essential, but those compromises obviously aren’t present if you don’t have children.

Tippexy · 16/02/2021 13:24

Because the stats are something like 90% of parents who are unmarried when the baby is born will have split up by the time the child is 16.

HeidiHaughton · 16/02/2021 13:22

All other things being equal, money does provide stability. Poverty is a huge cause of unstable housing and access to food, etc.

VinylDetective · 16/02/2021 13:22

Marriage is something that doesn’t matter in the slightest until a relationship ends either by death or separation.

If your spouse dies you automatically inherit their assets tax free and qualify for any death in service benefits. If you separate, marriage means a more or less fair division of assets. It’s a very cheap and easy way of providing financial security.

Merryoldgoat · 16/02/2021 13:22

The reality is women are nearly always the primary caregivers when children are born. This includes going part-time, not seeing promotion or giving up work because their partner earns so much more.

You’re not entitled to spousal support if you split unmarried. You’ll only be entitled to a share of the family home if you’re married, you cannot make any decisions about care if your partner is incapacitated. The man can fuck off with zero legal recourse.

Personally I wouldn’t have children without marriage and I wouldn’t manny anyone until I was confident they were a decent person. Yes, people change, but I think it’s actually rare for such a volt face character-wise.

My DH isn’t perfect but his actual character is one of decency. It has been every day we’ve been together. We might split one day but he’d see his children provided for no matter what.

My DH wasn’t fussed about getting married but I wanted to. The conversation was wonderfully bland.

‘I’m not really fussed’
‘Well I want to be married and I won’t have children outside marriage’
‘Oh fine, well we best get married then as I definitely want children’
‘Ok great’

ThatDoesntBelongInAIBU · 16/02/2021 13:21

I was going to say it’s beneficial for a child to grow up seeing a stable and committed relationship, but apparently it’s all about money.

FanSpamTastic · 16/02/2021 13:20

The issue is not so much marriage as the financial imbalance that arises if you give up your career after having a baby and do not have a partner that values the contribution of a stay at home parent.

Many couples choose jointly to have a family but then do not consider how family finances will work afterwards. Childcare is very expensive and it often happens that the woman stays home to bring up young children or if she returns to work that the cost of childcare comes out of her salary. A woman may be expected to continue to pay half of household costs while having reduced income and to deplete her savings to do this.

Years out of the workplace impact career prospects and pension savings for a woman. Men tend not to have the same impact.

Unmarried couples have no automatic rights to receive any financial provision from a partner if they split up. A divorce has at least some financial provisions and things like pensions etc need to be taken into account.

Have you and your partner discussed how things would work eg who pays what while you are on maternity leave? Does he see childcare as a joint cost or only your cost? How will household bills be split when you are not working? Are savings joint or do you have yours and he has his? How much life insurance do you each need to maintain your lifestyle if something happens to you or to him? Many guys would be shocked at how much it would cost them to have a full time nanny, cleaner and PA but expect their partners to do it all for love!

HollyGoLoudly1 · 16/02/2021 13:19

I wasn't married when I had my DC. Didn't feel at risk: I have more assets, a better pension, earn slightly more and it didn't affect my career. If anything, it is riskier for me now that we're married as I brought more financially to the table.

Imo the risk is all about the finances. And it's not the 1950's, I know plenty of couples where the woman is the breadwinner and the men benefit more from the security of marriage.

Laila747 · 16/02/2021 13:18

I think the biggest issue for me was giving DD his last name with the promise that we’d get married and all have the same last name....
That never happened (he slept with my best friend) so I’ve never had the same last name as my DD and it really used to bother her that her younger siblings all had the same last name as me and she didn’t. Her dad wouldn’t let her change it or double barrel it Sad That bothered me much more than getting half of anything the scabby ditch pig had.

PurpleFlower1983 · 16/02/2021 13:18

@Idontgiveagriffindamn

It depends on your own personal circumstances:
  • individual assets / joint assets
  • work plans after children - are you giving up work to be a SAHM or working full time in a high salary job (or everything in between)
  • whether you both have will’s sorted
It’s not a given that you’re in a vulnerable position if you’re unmarried and have children.
I agree it’s down to individuals. When I met my DH I was in a much stronger financial position but due to a fairly large inheritance we are more evenly matched now. The tax benefits etc. are still better for married people though.
YouLikeTheBadOnesToo · 16/02/2021 13:18

extreme example, but I used to work with someone who’s partner decided he didn’t want to be a dad, and left while she was 8 months pregnant. They weren’t married, so she couldn’t put his name on the birth certificate. In order to claim child support she had to go to the courts to get ‘assumed parentage’. He refused a DNA test, and was eventually forced to pay (the minimum) in child support. He still refuses to be named on the child’s birth certificate.

Of course a married man can leave at anytime too, but the fact that they weren’t married certainly made an already very stressful situation much worse.

GreenWillow · 16/02/2021 13:17

Unmarried couples are significantly more likely to split up than married ones.

Outcomes for DC of separated parents are significantly worse across the board than those for the DC of married parents.

Therefore, taken at population level, DC are going to be worse off if you are unmarried, than if you are married.

Obviously life gets in the way, and there are always families that buck this trend, but the trend nevertheless exists.