Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why marriage before children is so important?

187 replies

Eaststreet · 16/02/2021 13:02

Excuse my ignorance on this but time and time again I see comments from people on MN’s telling people not to have a child with somebody before marriage - comments I see are along the lines of ‘it’s so risky’ , ‘leaving yourself open’ ‘asking for disaster’

I might just be really naive but can somebody please explain the risks involved?

Myself and DP are TTC now, and all these comments are making me really uneasy, should I genuinely be worried?
We were due to get married this year and then the plan was to start ttc but we have postpone the wedding due to COVID and didn’t want to postpone having a baby too. Should I genuinely get be worried about this? And get married first?

OP posts:
Pyewhacket · 16/02/2021 14:11

There's more to marriage than just money, IMHO.

littlepattilou · 16/02/2021 14:11

@HeidiHaughton

My work contract is a 'piece of paper', yet how many people would want to work without one? As are the deeds to our house, our insurance polices, life insurance polices and so on. Paper is terribly important!
THIS! ^
minipie · 16/02/2021 14:08

It’s not marriage before children. It’s marriage before reducing your hours/earning capability to look after kids (including maternity leave), unless your DP does the same.

canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 14:08

Laws and rights have also moved on and it was extremely important for the woman to get married other than social norms.

Remember at some point we weren't allowed to own property in our own right, hence the introduction of the women's property act. We weren't allowed independent control of our finances.

HeidiHaughton · 16/02/2021 14:07

My work contract is a 'piece of paper', yet how many people would want to work without one? As are the deeds to our house, our insurance polices, life insurance polices and so on. Paper is terribly important!

NYCDreaming · 16/02/2021 14:07

It will protect you in the event of your relationship ending or your partner dying.

It's all very well saying that you plan on going back to work and your income won't be affected but you don't know what life has in store. What if you end up with twins and can't afford childcare for two babies? What if you have a child with a disability and you have to spend your life going to medical appointments and meetings with their school which makes having a job impractical? What if you have a child whose needs can't be met by non-specialist childcare? It might sound farfetched but it does happen. All of those things apply to me!

If you aren't married then you are in a much more vulnerable position. As a woman it's statistically likely that it will be your career and earning potential that are affected by having children, not your partner's. Marriage isn't all about the wedding, can you get married now but postpone the wedding until later?

TakeTheCuntOutOfScunthorpe · 16/02/2021 14:07

Having children is a much bigger commitment than marriage. That is why marriage should come first, because if you can't commit to marrying the person how on earth will you be able to raise a child together? If you don't see yourself staying with the person for at least the next couple of decades you shouldn't be having kids with them.

littlepattilou · 16/02/2021 14:05

@Eaststreet

I can't believe some people are so clueless on this matter..... I can't be bothered to put a new response, so am copying and pasting my post from similar thread from earlier.

----------------------------------
You'd have to have rocks in your head to have children with a man, if you're not married to him. You have NO rights whatsoever, and you can bet he will keep HIS money mostly to himself.

And, as most people have said, it's almost ALWAYS the woman in the relationship who sacrifices her career, and her income... And subsequently, it's the woman who will suffer if/when they split, or he dies...

The 'it's only a piece of paper' brigade are so clueless and obtuse. It's very much NOT only a piece of paper. It's an important legal document that gives you a lot of rights, and a lot of protection.

Any man that wanted me to have children with him, but refused to get married to me, could fuck right off.

I said this on another thread the other day. Watch FINDING ALICE on itv hub. That highlights what a shitstorm is left behind when the man you've shared your life with (and had children with.) dies, and you're not married to him.....

You have no more legal rights than the neighbour's dog.

Brefugee · 16/02/2021 14:04

I earn about the same as my DH, we are married but not being married wouldn't leave me super vulnerable.
Some of my friends out earn their husbands and are hot advantaged at all

Since the majority of those who lose out financially (in terms of salary, pensions, job progression etc) are women most of this thread concerns the women. But it equally applies to the lower earner in the relationship (male or female) and while threads are usually "marry him for the security" it really should be "marry your partner for the security". It is in the less financially endowed's interest to get married, and it is not in the more financially endowed's interest not to get married. Male or female.

People who had babies first then married, had babies and never married and didn't suffer financially if their partner left, or who are still together are the lucky ones. But you never know what the future holds so if you get married, you have at least that much legal protection, even if on paper it's more benefit than the reality reflects.

blueleonburger · 16/02/2021 14:04

Op why not go get married at the registry and have the big wedding post-lockdown?

Lockheart · 16/02/2021 14:03

You don't have to get married. If you're the one in the relationship with the better job and the assets then there isn't much need for you to seek the protection it gives, although if you're planning to give up work to look after the baby then you'd be disadvantaging yourself.

Being married does not mean one party won't fuck off and leave the other. It does mean that they can't fuck off without consequences.

If you're one of the women who fall into the majority where you earn less than your partner, or if you're the one who the bulk of childrearing and housekeeping will fall on because you'll be losing or heavily curtailing your career, then you should certainly get married first.

Personally speaking, I would not have children unless I was married.

Streamlinerose · 16/02/2021 14:02

I personally think some of these reasons are a load of shit, like ‘leaving the woman vulnerable’.

My DP pays for DC to go to nursery three days a week whilst I study full time on maternity leave.. I am actively improving my life prospects whilst ‘off on maternity leave’.

We’re not married.
Both have equal personal assets in addition to an equal share of the equity in the property.
If we split we’d have DC 50/50 so the time for study/work does not change.

When I return to work I’d have graduated and will be looking for a nice swanky grad job with both experience and education under my belt.

If you’re vulnerable then quite frankly that’s on you and the dynamic in your relationship.

If you have babies without savings, without a plan then that makes you vulnerable. Not the lack of marriage. You can’t then turn around after falling pregnant and choosing to go ahead with it without a safety net and blame the man for not putting a ring on it.

CrapDogOwner · 16/02/2021 14:02

Wills.

Make sure you are both on the deeds of any property

If you go part time/ become a SAHM, make sure you have some sort of provision in place to compensate you for the fact that your career has gone down the pan in the event of a split.

Medical power of attorney for each other to cover the medical decision making issues.

Most of the protections marriage affords can be replicated with enough time and effort. There may even be situations where you wouldn't want the financial implications of marriage (my situation as a house owner in my 50s).

The one big thing you can't replicate any other way than through marriage is avoiding inheritance tax.

Themostwonderfultimeoftheyear · 16/02/2021 14:00

I think that if you are going to have a child with someone you should be happy to give the security of marriage also. Situations can change so fast.

When DH and I got married he was earning minimum wage in a call centre and I was on a prestigious graduate management programme. I also had wealthy parents so likelihood of a big inheritance at some point.

However 7 years along and one DC later DH is earning £110000 a year and I am a SAHM because of a mental health breakdown. No chance of inheritance anymore as went NC with parents as they were causing the mental health issues.

I gave financial security to DH when we first married and now he gives it to me.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/02/2021 13:59

Heidi What stuck me and there’s a similar Daily Mail one I can’t just find where she was a teacher, that these were older educated women and they were so ignorant about their legal position.
Your idea about one type of legal wedding for all then anything else ‘ceremony/celebration’ optional is an interesting one would certainly stop a registry office wedding being seen as poor relation.

JustLyra · 16/02/2021 13:59

Inheritance and financial assistance if one of you dies are two big reasons.

If your DH or DW dies, under pension age, and you have children then the government will give you a £3500 lump sum and £350 a month for 18 months. This is not means tested.

You'll also have automatic inheritance rights and inheritance tax benefits.

While everything is going well marriage makes no difference at all. However, when if the shit hits the fan marriage can offer massive protection.

canigooutyet · 16/02/2021 13:58

It's down to individuals.

If you're daft enough to give up your financial freedom to become a skivvy, marriage or not you will be impacted both long and short term. Yes should you seperate you might get a chunk of their pension, why put yourself in a situation of being financially reliant on another person?

Married people can still individually change their wills and screw over their significant other. Happened to a mate and fighting it was very long and expensive, they'd been married over 30 years. She'd even changed things like who the pension would be paid to directly with her employer, and things like this were clarified in that will.

They can still walk away from their child. Mine did and trying to track him was impossible.

Property, if you invest your money into something with another person, you protect your ass legally and ensure you are on all documents. Relationship dissolves, either sell or buy the other person out. Being married to someone doesn't alter this, if there's not enough money to pay the mortgage it has to go. If you already own property, you never add them on anything, buy somewhere together if you must. Just because you are married doesn't mean you keep the house.

I would say living with someone first is more important. If things aren't equal a piece of paper isn't going to magically solve this. What are the expectations of both when it comes to raising any children and proper chats about finances. You read on here many mums in relationships and are both working, yet all the child expenses are paid for by her and never discussed as a joint expense.

Muskox · 16/02/2021 13:56

It's mainly if you're planning to become a SAHM or work part time. If you will carry on working full time, it's less of an issue.

ginghamtablecloths · 16/02/2021 13:56

I was told by a school teacher that traditionally marriage was for the protection of women. If a marriage ends it doesn't guarantee that he'll do the right thing by providing care or financial help for the children but the law is there to help. The wedding doesn't have to be expensive. Modern expectations are to have a champagne wedding even if you've got a beer income.

In the 1960s 'let it all hang out/marriage is just a piece of paper' etc came along. My mum used to say that it was 'all right for the rich and intellectual' but it wasn't really the case for ordinary folk.

It can work both ways. My sister divorced her lazy arse of a husband and she lost half her stuff to him even though she'd contributed more so the 50/50 thing went against her but in a way it was worth it to be rid of him. We could argue the toss all day about this subject but both sides will never agree.

MrsToadlike · 16/02/2021 13:55

I am happily married but just the briefest of glances on here shows that lots of marriages end. And some of them end acrimoniously. Also unfortunately sometimes partners die sadly before their time.

So I think it makes sense to ensure you're protected financially, but I would always give that advice to any mother or woman planning to become a mother, regardless of whether she's married or single or maybe planning marriage in the future but not right now, or adament she'll never get married, etc etc.

A previous poster summed up best how to protect yourself financially: pay into a pension, ensure your career isn't downplayed in favour of his (especially important if there's a perception that he's the 'breadwinner'), ensure any assets are joint with your name on deeds as well as his, etc.

Good luck ttc OP Flowers

TolpuddleFarter · 16/02/2021 13:54

I'm sure this won't go down well, but...

When me and my DP (now DH) decided we wanted children, we decided to go for it. From my point of view, if there was fertility issues, I wanted them flagged up before we got married. And then we both would then have the choice as to whether to stick with each other or find someone where it would work. Sounds dispassionate, I know.

My DP became my DH after our first child was born. Because of the reasons stated above.

We love each other a lot, but we are also both rational people.

SummerHouse · 16/02/2021 13:52

I am unmarried. Eldest child is 11. Been with DP for 19 years. I don't want to get married. Nothing I have read on Mumsnet has made me feel I should (and there are many people with very strong views on it.) Suits us fine.

Watchingbehindmyhands · 16/02/2021 13:52

but I used to work with someone who’s partner decided he didn’t want to be a dad, and left while she was 8 months pregnant. They weren’t married, so she couldn’t put his name on the birth certificate. In order to claim child support she had to go to the courts to get ‘assumed parentage’. He refused a DNA test, and was eventually forced to pay (the minimum) in child support

This is not how it works in England. Any woman can name any man the father of her child as far as the CMS is concerned. It would be up to the man to prove he wasn't the father by denying it in the first instance and then taking a DNA test which he would also be expected to pay for. If he refuses to take a test, then paternity is assumed and the person concerned assessed for maintenance as they would be if they were on the birth certificate.

HeidiHaughton · 16/02/2021 13:50

@Dixiechickonhols

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-7334313/amp/I-never-felt-marriage-important-day-Paolo-died.html

Daily mail link but explains reality of situation for lady who was engaged when her boyfriend died leaving her with a toddler.

My goodness. How do two adults have a child and assume they are 'as good as' married. One is either married or not. A cautionary tale.